YouTube’s content moderation has come under scrutiny after it decided to take no action against a content creator that labelled another YouTuber as a “lispy queer” and “gay Mexican”.
Vox Media writer and video host Carlos Maza received the abuse from conservative YouTuber Steven Crowder.
Since I started working at Vox, Steven Crowder has been making video after video "debunking" Strikethrough. Every single video has included repeated, overt attacks on my sexual orientation and ethnicity. Here's a sample: pic.twitter.com/UReCcQ2Elj
— Carlos Maza (@gaywonk) May 31, 2019
The comments included slurs like describing Maza as a “token Vox gay atheist sprite”, “gay Mexican” and “lispy queer”.
Crowder – whose header image on Twitter is a photo of himself wearing a t-shirt that says ‘Socialism Is For F*gs’ – defended his comments, describing them as a “harmless ribbing”.
And it appears YouTube agreed with Crowder, electing not to remove the videos Maza had flagged.
“Our teams spent the last few days conducting an in-depth review of the videos flagged to us, and while we found language that was clearly hurtful, the videos as posted don’t violate our policies,” YouTube said in a statement on Tuesday.
However, YouTube has slightly changed its stance since electing to temporarily demonetise Crowder’s videos.
Crowder has been told he has to “address all of the issues with his channel”, including removing links to buy his t-shirts, before his account will be monetised again.
But Maza is still unhappy with YouTube’s action, arguing the penalty is insufficient.
He also told The Verge it proves “YouTube’s anti-harassment policies are bullshit”.
“They’re fake policies meant to trick advertisers into believing YouTube actually cares about policing what happens on its platform.”
The saga comes right as YouTube has changed its community guidelines to ban videos promoting the superiority of any group as a justification for discrimination against others based on their age, gender, race, caste, religion, sexual orientation, or veteran status.
“Today, we’re taking another step in our hate speech policy by specifically prohibiting videos alleging that a group is superior in order to justify discrimination,” it said.
It will also remove content that denies well-documented violent events like the Holocaust or the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary, took place.
Free TV Australia today called for changes to the anti-siphoning rules to be fast tracked to protect Australians’ access to live and free sport. It follows yesterday’s news that streaming giant Amazon Prime had has secured the Australian rights to the next cricket World Cup alongside a range of other tournaments run by the International […]
Westpac customers were rendered unable to access their bank accounts online for around eight hours yesterday and its crisis comms strategy should prove instructive for the likes of Optus. The bank began posting regular updates on X (you may know it better as Twitter) around 9pm AEDT yesterday through to around 5.15am this morning. The […]
An American university has launched a trio of ads that take a witty look at eccentric jobs as a backdrop to promoting its courses. Post University in Connecticut launched the national campaign to promote its online courses with the premise being that these are the types of careers not on offer at the University. The […]
We’ve all met that one person who takes great pride in telling the world that they are a perfectionist. “I need things to be just right,” they say as they adjust the vignette settings on an Instagram post of their avocado toast (this rhyme was not intentional). As fabulous as perfection may be – who […]
Social Indigenous Enterprise We Are Warriors (WAW), supported by creative innovation studio R/GA Australia, has been selected to produce the City of Sydney’s New Year’s Eve Calling Country live performance as part of the 9pm firework show. Lead image L-R: WAW co-founders Ben Miles & Nooky. The performance will feature a special Welcome to Country […]
Most marketers, agencies, and brands agree that data is king. Love it or hate it, there is no denying that data is a powerful tool for targeting consumers. Yet the world of data is facing several seismic privacy changes that will have huge consequences for the entire advertising industry. Marketing teams around Australia are now […]
Independent brand and creative agency Chello has created a new integrated campaign ‘I want Tiggo’ to launch automotive giant Chery’s new Tiggo 7 pro into the Australian market. ‘I want Tiggo’ features a short film depicting a young boy who sees his father getting in the car and driving off and shouts “I want to […]
The Australian Professional Leagues (APL) and Isuzu UTE Australia have announced an extension to their partnership, reinforcing Isuzu UTE’s commitment to Australian football. The two-year extension will see Isuzu UTE Australia remain as the Naming Rights Partner of the Isuzu UTE A-League Men and as a Major Partner and Automotive category partner of the Liberty […]
The Seven Network has announced the launch of a new Advanced Advertising division to drive the development and launch of innovative new trading models across Seven’s national converged total TV ecosystem. The team has been set up to lead Phoenix, the world’s most advanced total TV trading system. Phoenix brings together the massive reach and […]
Surf Life Saving Australia has launched a new campaign to fight drownings at the beach, featuring a cheeky approach designed to change behaviour. Every year, over 120 people drown outside the flags on Australian beaches, and that’s too many. So, Surf Life Saving Australia is calling on beachgoers to ‘Give an F About the Flags’ […]
Toyota Australia and HCLTech have upgraded their partnerships with Cricket Australia (CA) to include displaying their global brands on the iconic Australian playing shirts. Toyota will be the men’s front-of-shirt partner and appear on the sleeve of the men’s and women’s playing shirts, while HCLTech will remain on the sleeve of the men’s playing shirt […]