Myer, Time To Take Off The Rear-vision Mirrors

Myer, Time To Take Off The Rear-vision Mirrors

In this guest column, behavioural analyst and group CEO of The Brand Institute of Australia, Karl Treacher (pictured below), runs his expert eye over beleaguered retailer Myer and, he says, if things don’t change and fast, it’ll be epitaphs next…

Without knowing it, humans default to replicating behaviour that served us in the past. It’s like a built-in safety device that works in so many cases. Myer, and the way it needs to be led is not one of those cases. In fact, by looking back to move forward, Myer will come to a complete stop.

Screen Shot 2017-10-25 at 12.17.24 pm

Myer has struggled for a long time to find a brand position that is worthy, and that marries with the established brand image of yesteryear. And that’s just it, we’re not in yesteryear (somewhat obviously), we’re in an age that swiftly and often publicly executes brands that fail to remain relevant day in day out. With the latest high-profile media spat involving major shareholder Solomon Lew having its way with Myer’s faltering reputation, the business and brand are approaching a crucial fork in the road.

The upcoming strategy update address by CEO Richard Umbers needs to be something straight out of Steve Jobs’ magic bag. The approach to date, as part of Myer’s five-year strategy is far too conventional, relying on proven, conventional retailing practices that worked…in the past. Proven in the past. The genius of Jobs or any visionary leader is in building strategy that speaks to future needs, not stated observed needs of today – as these all too quickly become hygiene tickets to play.

When it comes to Myer’s reputation, things aren’t great. So many attributes of their reputation are currently in question – not the least being their financial performance, as highlighted by their major shareholder demanding Q1 reporting immediately.

Of the many roads facing the Myer board, there is only one that will begin to rescue the brand and make in-roads into repairing its reputation. Forget the past. There is nothing that we’ve researched across the Australian retail landscape that suggests Myer can continue to operate using existing business and customer experience principles. That includes directional assets used over the past two years, which have shown Myer’s hand regarding it’s lack lustre penchant for disruptive innovation…and disruptive innovation is exactly what it needs.

However before Myer begins engaging in demonstrative change, it needs to do one thing first. The thing it’s needed to do for over 15 years – find a position and own it. We audited Myer in 2003 and the issues it had then remain today. Australian retail doesn’t have room for two large department stores occupying the same (or very similar) market position.

At least not enough room for them both to do well, and satisfy shareholder expectations. Before the internet sure, now – no way and we all know this. However Myer’s behaviour and actions suggest it’s a slow learner. DJ’s has won that battle; it owns it. Interestingly (and importantly for the Myer board), there is a market position for Myer that will work. A position that would rescue them, but from what we see at present it may never be realised.

The writing is clearly on the wall for Myer should it remain committed to it’s current strategy and rate of change. What happens with regard to the ongoing feud with Solomon Lew and Premier, Myer’s major investor will be interesting to watch but not the main event.

The main event will be one of two things : (i) the extraordinary story of Myer and how it evolved into the hearts and minds of its diverse customer base (and Australians in general) or (ii) the great disappearing act of one of Australia’s iconic retail brands and a story of risk-led transformation that failed to move this iconic brand into the current day success it could and needs to be.




Please login with linkedin to comment

    Latest comments
    1. Fear of Change v. Fear of Failure! Change in business is non-negotiable, inevitable and relentless and for those who do not change…. will FAIL simple as that!. As a Global Change Agent I’m damn frustrated at this loved retail giant doing the same old same old! Im also an ex employee from mid 90’s and had the same view then as Karl does now! How can Myer not see this, are you all frightened to take the risk … to position yourselves and own your space? Change, fear of change and denial of change.. Kodak did that and look what happened to them. Face and Embrace it Myer. @jen_trethewey @bandt @myer

David Jones Karl Treacher Myer The Brand Institute of Australia

Latest News

Meta Launches Instagram Creator Marketplace To Australia & New Zealand
  • Technology

Meta Launches Instagram Creator Marketplace To Australia & New Zealand

Meta has launched its Instagram Creator Marketplace to creators and brands based in Canada, Australia, New Zealand, United Kingdom, Japan, India and Brazil. Meta began testing the tool in 2022 in the US as a tool for brands and creators to connect and collaborate around partnership opportunities. The Marketplace allows brands to find creators to […]

Man of Many Partners With NBC Universal For Red Carpet ‘Argylle’ Premiere
  • Campaigns

Man of Many Partners With NBC Universal For Red Carpet ‘Argylle’ Premiere

Man of Many in partnership with NBC Universal, stages an atmosphere of elegance for Sydney premiere of ‘Argylle’ film. Independent lifestyle publication digital publication, Man of Many, has shown its innovative approach to event management in the premiere of ‘Argylle’ at Hoyts Cinema in Sydney’s entertainment quatre. Over 400 guests were included in the films […]

Next & Co Takes On The U.S. In Global Expansion
  • Advertising

Next & Co Takes On The U.S. In Global Expansion

Independent performance agency, Next&Co, has revealed its plans to extend its operation across the pacific ocean to the United States. The Melbourne-based agency specialises in strategy, media buying, creative and tech and has been servicing global clients for over a decade, with plans for its first international office coming into fruition. Next&Co’s platform, Prometheus, is […]

Cronulla Sharks Check-in At Quest Apartment Hotel For A Two Year Partnership
  • Marketing

Cronulla Sharks Check-in At Quest Apartment Hotel For A Two Year Partnership

Quest Apartment Hotel announced a two-year deal with the Cronulla Sharks NRL Club, motivated by the critical work of the ‘Sharks Have Heart’ program in championing inclusivity. As official community partner the Quest group have vowed to incorporate the Sharks initiative for inclusivity into their practises, landing them advertising space on the Cronulla Sharks jersey […]

The New Age Of Advertising: Persuasion & Craftmanship Rise In The Wake Of The Death Of The Cookie
  • Opinion

The New Age Of Advertising: Persuasion & Craftmanship Rise In The Wake Of The Death Of The Cookie

In this Op-Ed, Dave Jensen (pictured below), co-founder and partner at Connecting Plots, unpacks why it’s time to reignite the flames of persuasion and craftsmanship in advertising for longevity rather than the quick fix. On a bleak, chilly and rain-soaked morning in late 2024, a funeral service is being held in a cemetery somewhere on […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Vevo Partners With PubMatic To Expand Programmatic Buying Across Its Global CTV Network
  • Technology

Vevo Partners With PubMatic To Expand Programmatic Buying Across Its Global CTV Network

PubMatic has announced its partnership with Vevo, the world’s leading music video network. The collaboration will allow for an accelerated phase of programmatic CTV growth for Vevo, allowing advertisers to drive scaled reach across its premium library. Vevo’s global network spans more than 800,000 videos, boasting a total monthly average of 25 billion views. Partnering […]

Ash Barty Fronts New AIA Campaign From Bullfrog
  • Campaigns

Ash Barty Fronts New AIA Campaign From Bullfrog

AIA Australia has unveiled its new brand campaign, encouraging Australians to go ‘all in on something’ in an extension of its successful ‘All or Something’ brand platform. The new campaign comes as AIA Australia this year celebrates the 10-year anniversary of its science backed health and wellbeing program, AIA Vitality. The campaign sees AIA continue […]

Heckler Appoints New Creative Director Piotr Stopniak
  • Advertising

Heckler Appoints New Creative Director Piotr Stopniak

Heckler has announced the appointment of award-winning creative director Piotr Stopniak. With a celebrated career in motion graphics and design, Stopniak has enjoyed success in his field, first establishing studio Toby & Pete with friend Toby Pike back in 2009. Starting with typography design and moving into interactive and installation work led Stopniak into show […]

Former SCA Exec Bolsters Elevate Communications Media Power
  • Marketing

Former SCA Exec Bolsters Elevate Communications Media Power

Established industry leader in the Australian marketing and communications space, Elevate Communication has added experienced news executive Tash Jobson (lead image) to its already impressive team of practitioners. Jobson joins Elevate as a media specialist after more than two decades as a journalist and editorial leader, most recently as head of news operations at Southern […]

Apple: Child Safety Standards Would Jeopardise User Privacy & Turn Companies Into “Arms Of The State”
  • Technology

Apple: Child Safety Standards Would Jeopardise User Privacy & Turn Companies Into “Arms Of The State”

Apple has warned that the eSafety Commissioner’s proposed standards to tackle online child abuse would threaten user privacy and turn private companies into “arms of the state” by forcing them to comb through private user communications. The tech giant said that child exploitation is “abhorrent” but that it had serious concerns over the proposed new […]

PHD Kick Starts The Year Winning The AFL Media Account
  • Marketing

PHD Kick Starts The Year Winning The AFL Media Account

PHD Australia has announced that it has renewed its relationship with the Australian Football League (AFL) to manage their media account. PHD will be responsible for the media planning and buying across the AFL account, which includes the AFLW competition, Game Development programs and Marvel Stadium. The account will be run out of Melbourne and […]

Kargo Powers Cross-Channel Performance For APAC Advertisers With CORE
  • Advertising

Kargo Powers Cross-Channel Performance For APAC Advertisers With CORE

Kargo, a leading provider of full-funnel advertising solutions across mobile, desktop, and TV screens, is excited to announce the launch of CORE (Create Once, Run Everywhere) in APAC. CORE is built on creative science and empowers advertisers to easily use their creative assets across screens for seamless campaign performance at scale. A combination of creativity […]

Nunn Media Wins Global Independent Agency Of The Year At Local Planet 2024 Global Conference
  • Marketing

Nunn Media Wins Global Independent Agency Of The Year At Local Planet 2024 Global Conference

Australia’s largest independent media agency, Nunn Media, has taken out two major awards at Local Planet’s 2024 Global Conference, including the evening’s top honour of Global Independent Agency of the Year. Rising above more than 75 independent media agencies from 125 markets around the world, Nunn Media was recognised as Global Independent Agency of the […]

Gravity Media & Supercars Media Drive 400 Hours Of All-Screens Coverage Of This Year’s Repco Supercars Championship
  • Media

Gravity Media & Supercars Media Drive 400 Hours Of All-Screens Coverage Of This Year’s Repco Supercars Championship

Supercars Media and Gravity Media, a world-leading global provider of complex live creative production and media services, today confirmed the broadcast and technology partnership to deliver coverage of this year’s Repco Supercars Championship across Australia and multiple international territories. This year, Gravity Media Australia and Supercars Media will travel more than 40,000 kilometres to deliver […]

“There Are So Many Things I Wish I Could Ask Him”: Robert Irwin Opens Up About Losing His Dad As He Fronts The March Edition Of The Australian Women’s Weekly
  • Media

“There Are So Many Things I Wish I Could Ask Him”: Robert Irwin Opens Up About Losing His Dad As He Fronts The March Edition Of The Australian Women’s Weekly

Are Media, Australia’s leading omnichannel content company for women, today published the March edition of The Australian Women’s Weekly – with Robert Irwin on the cover. The Wildlife Warrior and I’m A Celebrity… Get Me Out Of Here! host is only the third solo man in modern times to grace the magazine’s cover (the others […]

DDB Sydney Nabs Monkeys Creatives Emmalie Narathipakorn & Seamus McAlary
  • Advertising

DDB Sydney Nabs Monkeys Creatives Emmalie Narathipakorn & Seamus McAlary

DDB executive creative director Matt Chandler has announced the appointment of creative team Emmalie Narathipakorn and Seamus McAlary from The Monkeys, building on the success of its existing creative team. Lead Image: L-R – Emmalie Narathipakorn and Seamus McAlary Narathipakorn, who was an art director at The Monkeys, joins DDB as senior art director, while […]

Slew Of New Promotions & Hires As Thrive Announces Melbourne Leadership Team
  • Marketing

Slew Of New Promotions & Hires As Thrive Announces Melbourne Leadership Team

Thrive PR Melbourne has kicked off the year with new appointments, promotions and a new leadership team, marking the delivery of a transformation strategy that’s seen the agency diversify and strengthen its corporate, consumer and integrated digital service offering in Victoria. Lead image:  (L-R) – Sophie Maguire, Melanie Campbell, Nathan McGregor, Zoe Raknes, Erika Rutledge, […]