Mike Shaughnessy is the COO at Kargo. here, he looks at how Google has evolved since its inception and discusses what breaking up the tech giant could potentially look like.
When Google first appeared on the scene in 1998, the company and its founders—Larry Page and Sergey Brin—at first seemed a little too idealistic for their roles. The two argued in a paper that year for Stanford University that advertising created “mixed incentives” for a search engine and the two promoted a “competitive search engine that is transparent and in the academic realm.”
Within a short time, of course, Google embraced advertising and won accounts from corporate America. By 2021, with the founders long gone, it came to light that Google had cut back-room deals with big partners like Facebook to ensure they have preferential pricing and winning bids. It also became clear that Google has controls in place to adjust revenue share to guarantee bids clear price floors for key partners. Additionally, Google has a feature called “Reserve Price Optimization” that dynamically adjusts floors based on historical bids.
Those revelations, revealed in a program called Project Bernanke, show that Google has now come full circle from its idealistic inception. A veteran ad industry observer might say that it would be surprising if Google did not have secret deals with other big companies or if it didn’t over-engineer its technology to have complete and total control over which ad is placed where and at what price. In short, it’s clear that Google has too much power across too many parts of digital advertising.
But at this point, such revelations, combined with lawsuits pending against Google, could actually lead to a corporate breakup. If so, our industry needs to have an active hand in dictating what a breakup looks like so the real value of Google’s technologies remain, but Google’s unfair advantage and exclusive black-box insights are diminished.
The Best Break-Up
There are multiple ways to break Google up, but to do so successfully, those overseeing such a breakup would need to understand how everything fits together, or the breakup could end up being meaningless.
One scenario separates Google’s content properties, like YouTube. from its technology business. For the ad tech industry, this idea has a limited impact. YouTube, for instance, operates in a bubble that doesn’t directly affect most programmatic bidding.
Breaking Google’s search business away from its display business is another scenario. Such a move would disrupt a lot of Google’s earning channels since it would make it harder to offer the same AdWords search-plus-display advertising package to the millions of small businesses that are its bread and butter.
Since AdWords is arguably a monopoly, this type of breakup would hit Google hard. But again, it’s not the crux of the issue for the ad tech industry. The issue is that Google serves both marketers (via its Demand-Side Platform) and publishers (via its supply-side platform.) It’s highly probable that Google takes the position that its ad server is the underlying technology that drives buyers and sellers (Doubleclick for Advertisers vs. Doubleclick for Publishers) and if they give that up, they no longer have a direct line into those two businesses.
Make Search Fair for Publishers
In addition to creating a clear argument for how Google’s digital advertising business should be de-monopolized, we can also bring up the many other technologies and processes Google has in place that are hampering fair competition across both advertising.
A lawsuit that the Daily Mail filed against Google notes, “Google makes it difficult for publishers to compare prices among exchanges; reduces the number of exchanges that can submit bids; and uses bids offered by rival exchanges to set its own bids — a de facto bid rigging scheme.”
What’s more, Google’s Chrome browser isn’t just the ruler of all things third-party cookie, but is also able to dictate which ads are shown based on Google’s Heavy Ad Criteria. This includes the ability to block ads from showing, such as a prominently placed ad slot on The Verge that I saw was impacted just a few days ago on my desktop high-speed connection. That’s taking money directly out of publishers’ hands and removing their input.
Now that government entities are taking Google’s monopoly more seriously, we all have a responsibility to create a clear point of view to ensure the outcome is correct. Technically, there are likely to be holes in the case, but the larger issue is Google’s outsized influence on the advertising market overall.
Because of that, Google does need to be split up, and how that happens is the difference between a healthy advertising market and one that continues to be dominated by a monopoly. It’s time to change course.
me&u, Australia’s first and leading mobile ordering and payment platform, has appointed Clementine Churchill as Head of Marketing as they continue to drive rapid growth and expansion in Australia and new international markets. A highly experienced marketing leader and recognised industry thought leader, Churchill joins me&u from My Muscle Chef, one of Australia’s top rated […]
MILO is on the search for Australia’s best made MILO, calling on fans to share their creations for the chance to win #TheMILOCup, via Ogilvy Sydney. This integrated campaign follows on from the success of last year’s ‘Hot v Cold’ campaign, which encouraged Aussies to settle the debate on whether MILO is best enjoyed hot […]
New research from Getty Images, a world leader in visual communications, has found that LGBTQ+ representation in ANZ remains low and stereotypical. It’s 2021 – this needs to change – especially in marketing and advertising. In partnership with GLAAD, the LGBTQ+ media advocacy organisation, Getty Images has launched a full-spectrum Guidebook in direct response to […]
Natural historian Sir David Attenborough is one of the most commanding and respected storytellers in the world and now the iconic series, David Attenborough Life Stories, is available on LiSTNR as part of SCA’s recently announced partnership with the BBC. David Attenborough Life Stories is a series of talks on the natural histories of creatures and […]
Menulog has doubled down on its marketing support for restaurant partners, with the promotion of Senior Marketing Manager, Rami Tamer, to a newly created role of ‘Head of Partner Marketing’, as well as the promotion of former-Blue 449 Performance Manager, Jaryd Buggins. In the new Head of Partner Marketing role, Rami will lead a team […]
ARN has announced Barry Drinkwater will be handing over his content director reins at 97.3FM and 4KQ to respected radio executive, Alisson Longhurst. Drinkwater has had a stellar career in radio spanning more than four decades, and was acknowledged as one of Australia’s Top 20 Content Directors by Radio Today in 2020. He began his radio career […]
Australia’s largest social enterprise is turning 25. On the anniversary of Australia’s first Big Issue magazine being sold on the steps of Melbourne’s Flinders Street Station in June 1996, Town Square has created a campaign to mark the occasion. 25 Years Big is a celebratory statement of pride, rendered in the iconic Big Issue logo […]
The Australian commercial radio industry has joined a global working group of broadcasters, carmakers and tech experts collaborating on the innovation of radio in Android Automotive. Android Automotive is Google’s infotainment operating system which is being built into new connected cars. Industry body Commercial Radio Australia is part of the working group, led by the […]
For the third consecutive year, Triple M’s No Talk Day will return on Thursday July 1 to raise awareness around men’s mental health and encourage courageous conversations on Triple M’s 45 stations across the country with support from partner Beyond Blue. From 6:00am – 6:00pm on July 1, Triple M is encouraging listeners to clear […]
Consumer shifts in how and where people buy products evolved significantly during the COVID-19 pandemic, creating new opportunities for retailers to use new channels, fulfilment strategies and payment options, according to the results of a new survey out today from BigCommerce and PayPal. While a majority of the 3,000 consumers surveyed from the United States, United Kingdom […]
Here is EVERYTHING you need to know about contextual advertising bar the curling wand and the hot pink leg warmers.
The brainchild of co-founders Gina Williams-Folau (main photo) and Greer Bland, the talent agency Liquorice was born out of a desire to make things easier for brand managers. Liquorice offers social talent for brands wanting to hit the sweet spot with Kiwi audiences. Launching with a roster of big names on board including Millie Elder-Holmes, Athena […]