In her latest post for B&T, 3 Phase Marketing’s Marnie Vinall (pictured below) argues that in the digital age, there’s little benefit to be had when the reviews turn sour…
According to Cambridge Dictionary, the saying ‘any publicity is good publicity’ or ‘there’s no such thing as bad publicity’ is said to emphasise that it is better that something receives bad publicity than no publicity at all. But in 2019, is this really still the case?
The phrase is rumoured to have first been said in the 19th century by American showman and circus owner Phineas T.Barnum. The notion also follows sentiment suit of Oscar Wilde’s famous quote, “The only thing worse than being talked about is not being talked about”.
This may have been true in the days where consumer’s options were more limited than they are today. The digital evolution had yet to spiral into the giant it now is and consumers favoured convenience and price-point of a product or service far over its social and environmental values and impact. But the world has changed since then and along with it, how consumers choose where to spend their money and who on.
Today, bad publicity for a brand can put nails in its coffin. Companies can see unrecoverable down falls from PR nightmares where bad publicity really is bad publicity.
Take business partners Kyle Stagoll and Dave Nelson who recently closed their sushi-pizza restaurant in Surry Hills, Sydney, after having the business go into liquidation with debts of $436,000. As reported in The Sydney Morning Herald, the pair blamed the business going bust just three months after opening on high wages, high rents, a slowdown in consumer spending and UberEats.
Stagoll was quoted in the article saying, “Does that mean hospo workers are drastically over paid for the value they produce for a business? Probably.” To this, the pair received a mammoth about of backlash online. There was many news and opinion pieces circulating just hours after the SMH piece went live, slamming the pair for blaming their downfall on having to pay their workers correctly and not on the fact that they sold sushi-pizza. A potentially under researched idea before implementation – at best.
Overnight, the two names which no one outside their friends, family and employees knew, now were being condemned in the public eye and their reputation in the hospitality industry took a massive hit – potentially one they wouldn’t recover from. Now, if they wanted to get a loan to open a new place, or form partnerships to grow their business, they are going to have a lot more trouble than if nobody knew who they were.
Socially conscious consumers
When it comes to products and services, consumers have more choice than ever before, meaning they can buy with their values along with their budgets and preferences. If a brand is slammed in the media for poor working conditions, their customer-base can pretty easily jump ship to their competitors without too much hassle or thought.
In 2017, beauty brand giant Nars saw many of their existing customers boycott the company after it introduced animal testing on its make-up in order to sell in China. After the announce, the brand saw a wave of criticism and an e-petition to see the company stop selling in China, which racked up close to 250,000 signatures.
BBC UK reported that a previous fan wrote online, “Guess I just won’t be buying Nars anymore. Animal lives are more important than reaching another market.”
Consumers could easily make the choice to stop buying Nars because the competition and choice of similar products to what the brand makes is so high. The bad publicity meant that once loyal customers were changing their alliance based on their personal values.
With the rise and spread of information across the web, when brands take a PR hit like this one, they don’t just get increased mentions online and added brand awareness, they lose their customer base.
Nowadays, brands aren’t just competing with the consumer on price point and product, but also the brand and products social, environmental or political impacts.
That’s not say brands or companies can’t turn PR blunders into wins, but the work needs to be done in order to see positive outcomes from bad publicity. It’s no longer going to work for brands to shrug off bad PR and say, “there’s no such thing as bad publicity”. We’re now living in an era where bad publicity not only exists but can also destroy businesses and the people who run them too.
Please login with linkedin to commentMarnie Vinall
10 ViacomCBS today announced the appointment of Nick Bower as Sport Sales Director. With over 20 years’ experience, Bower will bring his extensive proficiency in sport sales and a proven track record developing revenue streams and creating partnership opportunities across television, digital and social platforms in Australia, Asia and Europe, to the newly created role. […]
oOh!media has announced the appointment of Raechel Gavin as the company’s new Chief People & Culture Officer. With over 20 years’ Australian and international experience, Gavin is a highly regarded leader with an impressive track record of achievement in human resources across a range of different businesses, including in the data science and media industries. She […]
Look, we’d love to stop leading with the Olympics in the headline, but with these numbers, it’s hard not too. The success of the Olympics is also leaving very little room for other programming to make its way onto the top 20 most watched programs. That being said, though, the peak numbers for the Games […]
Consumer PR agency, FORWARD has announced a new purpose and sustainability business offering: Communications with Purpose. The internal transformation will see the PR agency achieve B Corporation (B Corp) accreditation. Coinciding with these announcements is the reveal of a new brand identity. FORWARD is introducing Communications with Purpose to complement its existing content-led consumer lifestyle […]
As the saying goes, never put all your eggs in one basket. This is as applicable to programmatic monetisation for app developers as it is for any other aspect of life. Being overly reliant on just one ad tech stack for monetisation can be risky, especially when that ad tech stack isn’t known for offering […]
The only thing better than watching all those athletes sweat it out in Tokyo for a medal is having greasy burger juice run down your chin while you’re prostrate on the couch doing it. Hence, the marked uptick in fast food and home delivery ads since the Olympics began. As regular readers would know, B&T […]
DonateLife is the Australian Government’s program that works to improve organ and tissue donation and transplantation outcomes across Australia. At the heart of DonateLife‘s marketing strategy is DonateLife Week, which runs from 25 July to 1 August. The goal? Encouraging 100,000 Australians to join the Australian Organ Donor Register. This year, DonateLife is support by […]
Octagon, IPG’s global creative agency specialising in sport and entertainment, has announced the promotion of Simone Errey to managing director, Australia, Formerly Octagon’s head of operations, APAC, Errey (Pictured above) will now oversee the agency’s local creative, planning, strategy, commercial consulting, client services and production teams, while also retaining a key position on the APAC […]
Australian furniture brand Koala has launched a campaign to celebrate its new mattress range and has debuted an updated webste. Koala has taken to the soapbox to say ‘sorry’ on behalf of the mattress industry that Koala believes is now awash with confusing lingo, complicating what it takes to get a good night’s sleep. Creative […]
ESPN and the National Basketball League have extended their broadcast partnership for a further three seasons as part of an expanded television rights package. ESPN and the National Basketball League announce a new expanded agreement that will run for three seasons, until the end of the 2023/24 NBL season. The landmark broadcast deal comes with […]
Sydney-based co-working startup, Workit Spaces, announced today the launch of ‘Beyond The Store’, a six-part web series to uncover the smarts and passion behind successful Australian eCommerce businesses. Workit Spaces has gone where no other coworking hub has gone before, by investing over $100,000 to tell the stories of six Australian eCommerce businesses and how […]
In light of the prolonged lockdown occurring throughout New South Wales, Semi Permanent Sydney has announced new dates for this year’s festival. It will now take place between 17-19 November 2021 at Carriageworks. “Our mission, always, is to craft the best and most valuable experience for both our speakers and audience, and to ensure the […]