Carat Sydney’s Head Of Strategy On Serena Williams Cartoon: “It’s Right For Brands To React”

Carat Sydney’s Head Of Strategy On Serena Williams Cartoon: “It’s Right For Brands To React”
SHARE
THIS



The recent Mark Knight caricature depicting tennis player Serena Williams published in Herald Sun has caused worldwide furore, with many condemning its racist and sexist undertones.

As the uproar over the caricature continues, it is also important to address how the cartoon, and News’ reaction to it, may influence brands looking to advertise with the publisher.

Speaking to B&T, Carat’s head of strategy for Sydney, Danni Wright, questioned, “What is the impact and what potential negative halo will it have?”

“I think it’s right for brands to react, I wouldn’t be surprised if a brand said, ‘we don’t want to appear in that publication’.

 “While brands cannot and should not pertain to control where they appear down to the level of editorial coverage, there will be brands who have a strong steer on their identity and what they stand for, who find themselves at odds with the publication given its response to it.”

“If I was having a conversation with clients about it I would be open with my views,” Wright added.

While social media users were quick to criticise Knight and Herald Sun, News Corp was equally as quick to defend Knight, with Herald Sun editor Damon Johnston stating: “A champion tennis player had a mega tantrum on the world stage, and Mark’s cartoon depicted that. It had nothing to do with gender or race.”

Meanwhile, News executive chairman Michael Miller posted on LinkedIn: “Criticism of Mark Knight’s Serena Williams cartoon shows the world has gone too PC & misunderstands the role of news media cartoons and satire.

“Poor behaviour in any sport needs to be called out,” he added.

However for Wright, “The way they’ve reacted and then doubled down says a lot about their ethos.”

Speaking on the criticism, Wright said the most problematic issue with the cartoon is how Williams has been portrayed next to her Haitian-Japanese opponent, Naomi Osaka.

“In this day and age, it’s inexcusable how they depicted Serena and the opponent.

“A caricature dials up something that’s already there, but as they’ve done that in comparison to her competitor, they’ve changed Osaka’s race and stature and made her look very feminine.

“It’s the polarity of the comparison.

“It becomes really stark that if you’re permissive and the victim in the situation then you’re white and feminine whereas, Serena is depicted as the polar opposite,” Wright added.

B&T has approached News Corp for comment.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Carat mark knight News Corp serena williams

Latest News

M&C Saatchi Still Tops For New Business Wins, But Newcomer It’s Friday Off To A Flyer
  • Advertising

M&C Saatchi Still Tops For New Business Wins, But Newcomer It’s Friday Off To A Flyer

It might be a little more than six months old but indie creative agency It’s Friday, headed by former Leos and Saatchi boss Pete Bosilkovski, is off to an impressive start judging by R3’s monthly review of new business wins. It’s Friday posted an impressive third spot on June’s new business wins after the agency […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Ryvalmedia Retains Top Spot For New Media Wins For June
  • Media

Ryvalmedia Retains Top Spot For New Media Wins For June

Indie agency Ryvalmedia continues its impressive run, topping R3’s June list for new business wins for the third consecutive month. It’s been an impressive 2022 for the (lead image) Simon Ryan-steered agency after it announced the opening of its Sydney office in mid-July.  Ryvalmedia was again R3’s pick of the media agencies with wins that […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
CRA Chief Ford Ennals Announces Refresher For Radio Company
  • Media

CRA Chief Ford Ennals Announces Refresher For Radio Company

CRA chief executive officer Ford Ennals (pictured) announced today a renewed strategic direction for the peak radio industry body, with a greater emphasis on the digital audio market along with supporting its members to grow commercial radio advertising revenue. “We are experiencing strong growth in digital audio so it’s timely for CRA to have a […]

AWS’s Curiosity Kid Campaign Is A Heartwarming Tribute To Small-Scale Success
  • Campaigns

AWS’s Curiosity Kid Campaign Is A Heartwarming Tribute To Small-Scale Success

Amazon Web Services (AWS) has launched its first Above the Line (ATL) brand campaign after a decade of being in Australia, with the feel-good ‘Curiosity Kid’ ad series showcasing the many brands using its services. The campaign, which launched on August 7, highlights how AWS can be used for innovation by local businesses, demonstrating a […]

What Aussie Brands Can Learn From Global Lessons In Sustainability Engagement
  • Opinion

What Aussie Brands Can Learn From Global Lessons In Sustainability Engagement

In this guest post, Stu Wragg (lead image), chief strategy officer at Herd MSL, takes a look at global brands getting the sustainability message right and the lessons Aussie brands can learn along the way… The need to address increased consumer and employee interest in the environmental and social action of business is clear to […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
SOCA Welcomes Two New Senior Hires In Farah Alias And Neil Martin
  • Marketing

SOCA Welcomes Two New Senior Hires In Farah Alias And Neil Martin

Significant Other Creative Agency (SOCA) has brought on two senior hires, with Farah Alias joining as partnerships director and Neil ‘Marty’ Martin jumping into a dual head of art role. Alias (pictured, right) brings with her a wealth of senior international experience and knowledge from DDB & BBDO Singapore, Wunderman Thompson, and most recently Rare. […]

Ogilvy NZ Lands Partnership With Breast Cancer Foundation NZ
  • Marketing

Ogilvy NZ Lands Partnership With Breast Cancer Foundation NZ

Ogilvy NZ has been appointed as the new creative and strategy agency for Breast Cancer Foundation NZ. BCFNZ chief executive Ah-Leen Rayner said the Ogilvy team presented a new direction for the foundation with a strong focus on reaching Maori and Pasifika women who were over-represented in breast cancer statistics. “Ogilvy’s approach acknowledged our current […]

Claxon Bags CarExpert Partnership For Creative And Media
  • Marketing

Claxon Bags CarExpert Partnership For Creative And Media

Australian new car website, CarExpert.com.au has appointed independent growth agency Claxon as its creative and media agency after pitches from a slew of other agencies that included HERO and DDB. Claxon will be handling the creation of a new national TVC campaign and the associated media account working closely with shareholder, Seven West Media to […]

InsideOut PR Wins Prestige InHome Care Account
  • Media

InsideOut PR Wins Prestige InHome Care Account

Sydney PR agency InsideOut PR has been appointed for Prestige InHome Care, an in-home aged care service with a focus on media relations. InsideOut PR worked with Prestige Inhome Care back in 2013 and again in 2017 launching their public relations and advertising program; and supporting their growing profile in the market. Founder and CEO […]