Aussie Ad Regulators Are Being Left Behind By The Greening Sector

In this opinion piece, Belinda Noble, founder of Comms Declare, discusses why the Ad Standards Environmental Codes is useless at stopping greenwashing.
Pretty much every poll shows that Australians overwhelmingly support renewables and climate action.
A recent YouGov poll of 15,000 Australians found 71 per cent per cent do not see coal or gas as part of our future energy mix and 61 per cent support cutting greenhouse gas emissions by half by 2030.
Some of Australia’s biggest advertisers are on board, Coles and Woolworths are desperately trying to ‘out green’ each other, but our advertising and marketing associations are oddly mute.
The Australian Association of Australian Advertisers (AANA) is a member of the World Federation of Advertisers (WFA).
The WFA has just launched a Planet Pledge which seeks to find “a clear role for marketing as a positive force for environmental change”.
This is a fair call from an industry that has long created demand for products that aren’t doing the environment any favours.
Thirteen multinationals including Ikea, Unilever and Mastercard have joined, as have 22 national associations, including from France, the UK and Japan. But not the AANA.
Why is this?
A clue is last year’s AANA review of its code of ethics that governs the self-regulation of our advertising. Polling and surveys found most people object to sexism and violence in advertising. So, they focused on those issues and left their Code of Environmental Claims unchanged, even though climate change is one of the most important issues for Australians overall.
The AANA and its regulator arm, Ad Standards, work with the rationale that their only job is to uphold community standards in advertising. Therefore, greenwashing ads that are completely misleading aren’t in breach of the code, if the average consumer is fooled by them.
This is explained in a practice note: “It is not intended that legal tests be applied to determine whether advertisements are misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive, in the areas of concern to this Code. Instead, consideration will be given as to whether the average consumer in the target market would be likely to be misled or deceived by the material.”
This is clearly insufficient when it comes to coal and gas, where the biggest miners and retailers have spent squillions over decades to successfully persuade people that their products are clean and green and totally necessary for BBQs and hot showers.
Most people think AGL is a gas company, but its main energy source is coal. Most people think gas is clean, not realising its main component, methane, heats the atmosphere 87 times more than carbon dioxide.
The proof that the rules are too weak to be useful is that Ad Standards has only ever upheld one complaint on false environmental claims. One.
Ads that have passed muster under the current regime include one form Santos that claims “to build a better future, the natural choice is natural gas.” And an Origin Energy ad that states: “Origin. Good energy”.
Origin and Santos are some of Australia’s biggest greenhouse gas polluters. Compare this to overseas, where ads for fossil fuels, SUVs and airlines are being banned as a measure to cut demand for products with high amounts of greenhouse gases.
Comms Declare’s industry survey last year found 57 per cent of marketing, PR and ad agencies were aligning business strategy with the need to reduce emissions and 67 per cent were aiming for net zero by 2040. This year we’re asking under 30s in the sector to tell us their views on climate, and we hope the results will be a wake up call for the industry.
The AANA and other Australian associations like them are rapidly being overtaken by this issue. There is no doubt they will soon be trying to stave off tobacco-style bans for fossil fuel advertising. They should take a leadership role on climate now, to protect self-regulation and remain relevant.
Please login with linkedin to comment
adland responsibility belinda noble climate change comms declare corporate responsibilityLatest News

Meta Says There Are ‘Serious Times Ahead’ For Its Workers
Everyone's CFO says the exact same thing after he finally finishes shredding tax documents.

“Call Me Bruh!” Kanye West Threatens Legal Action Against Aussie Burger Joint
The temptation to make a gold digger joke here is strong, but thankfully we aren't witty enough to think of one.

Your Wish Is Our Command! More Time To Enter Best Of The Best Presented By Finecast
Think your better then everyone? But, it's awkward to bring up in meetings! We have the outlet for you.

The Growth Activists Help Bassike Reach B Corp Status
In exchange for helping bassike reach B Corp, TGA expects free invites to the inevitable party celebrating the status.

Enero Announces Two Key Acquisitions In ROI DNA And GetIT
It's very challenging to take Enero group seriously when their ASX tag is literally just 'EGG'.

Seven Moves To Terminate Broadcasting Partnership With Cricket Australia
Imagine not wanting to show a full season of cricket where each game can easily go on for around four hours!

New Study From Redcat And Impact Data Finds Customer Marketing Sweet Spot
The study makes no mention of how many times you can drunk dial a customer before they start blocking your number.

Thursday TV Wrap: Leigh Sales Farewells 7.30 With 572,000 Eyeballs Watching
With Sales signing off, Tracey Grimshaw might now be the offical Queen of blazers and looking slightly concerned.

Charlie Short Appointed As Head of Growth At Revolut Australia
Revolut appears to have gotten most of the way through revolution and then given up right at the conclusion.

Transforming C-Suite Leaders into Empathy Officers Can Deliver Unmatched Business Success
If your management style is modelled after Cruella de Vil. You can keep your coats, but you should try being nicer.

News Corp Australia Increases Its Investment In Medium Rare Content Agency
Much like betting on horses, News Corp realises that since they're in for eighty, they may as well be in for a hundred.

“Bittersweet!” Nelson Aspen Hands In His Two Week Notice To Sunrise
Aspen now calling in sick, stealing office pens and finally telling the cash cow what he really thinks of him.

Non-Alcoholic Brand Lyre’s Goes Live With ‘Make It A Lyre’s’ Campaign Via The Kinetic Agency
Non-alcoholic is a term guaranteed to cause moans in the B&T team, but the animals in the ad are cute, so this one's ok.

Social Motive Gives Tangle Teezer Australia A Fresh New Do On Social Media
Social Motive could have been the name for a new branch of the climate change awareness movement. Missed opportunity.

InMobi Integrates Mobile Supply With Yahoo’s Demand-Side Platform For Direct Advertiser Access
It seems like the good people at InMobi have finally decided to go all Yahoo on us.

From “Little Things” Big Change Happens; NSW Government’s Multi-Partner Media Campaign Via UM
Here at B&T we like our medical advice from our footy stars and our spiritual advice from our reality stars.

“Very Proud!” Neighbours’ EP Jason Herbison On Saying Goodbye To Ramsay St
Neighbours will be there for one another! Until someone makes a noise complaint then Grimshaw gets a call.

First-Ever D&AD Shift With Google In Sydney Ends With Showcase By Google, Adidas And Kua
We can only assume the Sick Bay mural is more Banksy inspired than Pepper Pig. Though the pig has more cache than Banksy

It’s Not Too Late To Apply For The Shopping Category At The Australian Impact Awards Powered By Wavia!
Think you've missed your chance at fame, glory and Linkedin bragging rights. Think again.

Dynata’s Latest Economic Crossroads Report Shows Consumer Trends From Around The Globe
Across the world, rising costs are causing anxiety and financial struggles for consumers. The worldwide impact of inflation is affecting their outlook and behaviour. More than half of consumers globally are struggling financially because of inflation and the increasing price of fuel, housing and everyday goods. Russia’s war on Ukraine intensifies their concerns around supply-chain […]

InMoment Bring Major Updates To Their XI Platform For Greater Customer Experiences
Making people's lives easier one update at a time. Because nowadays it's all about accessibility, right?

US FCC Commissioner Wants Apple And Google To Take Down TikTok From Their Stores
Anyone who wants to ban TikTok clearly doesn't understand how cool Anna Paul is.

Fullbright Scholar Teams Up With CQUniversity For New Opportunities In Queensland
It's nice to know the Sunshine State might finally be using said sunshine for something productive.

“Talk About Soft!” Mark Levy Blasts The Project Over Interview With Climate Change Activist
The world is actually burning, but sure let's be mad at the protestors.

Best Of The Best Judge, Ben Pellow Nabs Group Sales Director Role At Forbes Australia
Here at B&T, we love to remind you about all the fancy friends we have. Mainly because they never cop to it in public.

Visit Victoria And Endemol Shine Australia Announce New Partnership
The new series will allow Sydneysiders to appreciate Melbourne from their couches, just the way we like it.

Sydney Set To Host South By Southwest Festival For 2023
This comes as part of a wider plan to steal Texan culture, with Sydney set to take on plentiful Cowboy boots and rodeos.

Nine’s Big Dog Mike Sneesby Announces EOFY2022 Bonuses For Permanent Staff
Bonuses were decided after staff declined MAFS merch as a thank you.

Tony Armstrong Reveals The ABC’s Reaction To His OnlyFans Account
Armstrong proving that even a Logie can't save you from boring meetings with your bosses.

Wednesday TV Wrap: MasterChef Owns Demos But Nine Dines Out On The Night
Thank you MasterChef for normalising cooking while crying.

FutureBrand Australia Grows, Makes Two Senior Appointments
Bringing the "future" to Australia's business industry.

Sedona Lands Cinnamon Darvall As Executive Producer
If Sedona can acquire some Milk, Eggs and Flour as well, they'd be on their way to a nice crepe recipe in the C suite.

Jaywing And Frank Digital Nab Rai Campbell For Commercial Director Role
Campbell will be called to drive the Jaywing to success. That's not a phrase out of a sci-fi series by the way.

Are Media Launch Body Positivity Initiative ‘BODFest’ With OGX Haircare
Cause there's nothing that will make you feel better about yourself than seeing Em Rata on stage.

Quantcast Launches New Advertising Solutions For Marketers
With the rate at which Quantcast is attempting to solve problems, Ariana Grande and Iggy Azalea may need to get in touch

Nielsen To Publish Global Annual Environmental, Social And Governance Report
Nielsen is releasing its global annual environmental, social and governance (ESG) report to share information in six key ESG topic areas including diversity, equity and inclusion, human capital, governance, data privacy and security, environment, and communities. The report is designed to demonstrate how Nielsen does what it does with responsibly and with integrity—and how that […]