It’s Time For Some Honesty About (Online) Advertising

It’s Time For Some Honesty About (Online) Advertising
SHARE
THIS



In this guest post, Visit Victoria’s head of consumer insights, Julian Major (pictured below), argues it’s time for a closer look at online advertising’s effectiveness…

Judging by the various responses to Jesse Frederik and Maurits Martijn’s recent article, few are surprised by the findings around online advertising and perhaps, some are just glad someone else is talking some common sense in the marketing world.

0

Some cliff notes for those who do not have the time to fully digest the article (though I do recommend it). Online advertising often appears effective through ‘selection’ effects. Access to more data means we know who is most likely to buy whatever it is we are selling. And so we end up buying ads to people who were going to buy anyway. This produces metrics which makes our marketing look effective, but it is the equivalent of saying coupons are effective if you hand them out to shoppers already in line at a store. Or, a clear modern example; eBay paying for search ads for the search term ‘eBay’.

What has likely cut through about the article is not just the finding itself but how easy it is to come to these conclusions. In the era of everyone in marketing confidently talking about ‘A/B tests’ and experimental design, it appears we don’t use these methods for questions actually worth answering. It also cuts right to the heart of why we accept this when we know better. ‘Bad methodology makes everyone happy’. Proving marketing effectiveness is difficult. And we have an ever-increasing demand to prove ‘ROI’. Online advertising produces nice immediate metrics that can make us look good, much more than any channel before it. It’s not the case of consultants conning us, but everyone coming along for the ride. It’s also a great article to remind ourselves about some basic principles of how advertising works.

“If people were easier to manipulate with images and videos they don’t really want to see, economists would have a much easier task. Realistically, advertising does something, but only a small something
– and at any rate it does far less than most advertisers believe”

While that quote is great, it is nothing new and should not surprise any person that has studied marketing. It’s also nothing unique to online advertising. Advertising is simply a weak force. Andrew Ehrenberg summarised this well a long time ago by describing advertising as creative publicity, rather than persuasion. Advertising does not con us into buying things we ultimately do not want through mind-altering techniques. And as Ehrenberg points out, it rarely even tries. The world of long copy advertising is long gone. Rather, advertising works by creating awareness and building brand salience, which increases the chance of the brand being recalled when the consumer is in a buying situation. Advertising gives us a nudge rather than a push.

Screen shot 2019-11-18 at 6.56.22 AM

The ever trending Les Binet describes it quite well in this nice graphic from adam&eveDDB; advertising slightly increases the chance that people will choose your brand. And often, it ends up just maintaining sales.

Screen shot 2019-11-18 at 6.57.15 AM

Mark Ritson recently wrote in amusement over modern marketer’s obsession with the Promotion P when you could argue it is the least important in the mix. It’s hard to disagree. Compared with immediate effects that come through changes in price and product distribution, advertising effects are small and often slow (And sometimes non-existent).

The fact that an ever-increasing chunk of our lives are played out online means that advertisers now have incredibly detailed behavioural data on us (Though it is not always accurate). But this has not fundamentally changed how advertising works. It has not turned advertising from a weak force into a strong one. As ex-Yahoo employee Garrett Johnson states in the article, ‘It’s very hard to change behaviour by showing people pictures and movies that they don’t want to look at’.

Plenty of research does exist to show that advertising works, including online advertising. But proving advertising effectiveness is not as easy as some say, particularly for individual brands and campaigns. So while we have new tools to play with and new channels to operate in, we still face the exact same challenges as before. And we’d all be better off if we were more honest about that.

Please login with linkedin to comment

visit victoria

Latest News

Agent99 Hooks New Clients In FishMe! And Donna McGeorge
  • Media

Agent99 Hooks New Clients In FishMe! And Donna McGeorge

Award-winning independent PR Agency, Agent99, has hooked new clients in online seafood delivery service, FishMe!, as well as productivity specialist and author, Donna McGeorge (main photo). Since launching earlier this year, Sydney’s FishMe! has cut out the middleman and bricks-and-mortar overheads to ensure customers get great quality at competitive prices. The business was founded by […]

Menulog Celebrates The Best In Food Delivery With The ‘Menulogies’
  • Campaigns

Menulog Celebrates The Best In Food Delivery With The ‘Menulogies’

Menulog has teamed with creative agency, Poem, and social agency, Connecting Plots, to launch the ‘Menulogies’, a rebrand of its 10th annual restaurant awards. Building on the success of previous years, the awards have returned with updated categories to reflect the latest culinary and social media trends, as well as loads of glitz and glamour […]

Yahoo Appoints Julia Edwards To NSW Sales Director
  • Media

Yahoo Appoints Julia Edwards To NSW Sales Director

Yahoo has announced it has promoted Julia Edwards to NSW sales director. Since joining Yahoo 18-months ago, Edwards (main photo) has been instrumental in building the commercial success of Yahoo Creative Studios (formerly RYOT Studios) in her role as head of strategic solutions. She has been behind a number of industry-first campaigns using cutting-edge technology, […]

Jack Dorsey Quits, Parag Agrawal Named New Twitter CEO
  • Media
  • Technology

Jack Dorsey Quits, Parag Agrawal Named New Twitter CEO

Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey has stepped with immediate effect, replacing him, the company board unanimously appointed distinguished Chief Technology Officer (CTO) Parag Agrawal. After almost 16 years Jack Dorsey has decided it’s finally time to leave Twitter. Though, he will remain a member of the board until his term expires at the 2022 meeting of […]

Bob Gallagher Hangs Up His Mic & Bids Farewell To Breaky Radio
  • Media

Bob Gallagher Hangs Up His Mic & Bids Farewell To Breaky Radio

ARN has announced that Bob Gallagher from Brisbane’s 97.3FM’s Robin, Terry & Bob, has resigned from the popular breakfast show. After an extraordinary 19 years of working breakfast radio hours, Gallagher will turn off his early morning mic this Friday.  Gallagher said: “I leave the show in great shape and I’m looking forward to a sleep-in after so many years of early morning […]

History Will Be Kind Wins Wins The Access Group’s Comms
  • Marketing

History Will Be Kind Wins Wins The Access Group’s Comms

Independent communications agency History Will Be Kind (HWBK) is taking its tech portfolio to the next level following a competitive pitch which has seen it win new client partner and leading business software provider, The Access Group. A significant global player in business software technology with a track record of impressive growth including the acquisition […]

CUB & TBWA\Melbourne Launch “Woody & Cola” Campaign That’s Bang On For The Demographic
  • Campaigns

CUB & TBWA\Melbourne Launch “Woody & Cola” Campaign That’s Bang On For The Demographic

CUB has launched a new “Woody & Cola” campaign via TBWA\Melbourne. Set to the well-known Escape (The Pina Colada Song), the campaign introduces characters ‘Woody’ and ‘Cola’, who are completely different, yet completely complimentary at the same time – much like Woodstock’s smooth oak-aged, blended Kentucky bourbon with sweet refreshing cola. Following their journey, Woody […]

Podium Announces Australia’s ‘Most Loved Local Businesses’
  • Campaigns

Podium Announces Australia’s ‘Most Loved Local Businesses’

Local businesses communication and payments platform, Podium, and Council of Small Businesses Organisations of Australia (COSBOA) has today announced the winners of Australia’s Most Loved Local Businesses, which includes a specialised biking store and a stigma-busting dental practice. The campaign aimed to shine the spotlight on a handful of vibrant, dynamic and innovative Australian businesses following an […]

Monday TV Wrap: Nine’s Snackmasters Debuts & Wins Entertainment
  • Media

Monday TV Wrap: Nine’s Snackmasters Debuts & Wins Entertainment

Nine’s Snackmasters wins the night in entertainment pulling in 603,000 viewers – if you can watch this without snacking, as far as I’m concerned you are superhuman! In news, news – Seven News hit 949,000 viewers while Nine News had 872,000 viewers. Nine’s A Current Affair snagged the second entertainment spot with 696,000 viewers – Do you […]

Lorraine Jokovic: What We Don’t Know About Diversity & Inclusion In Adland & How That’s About To Change
  • Opinion

Lorraine Jokovic: What We Don’t Know About Diversity & Inclusion In Adland & How That’s About To Change

Lorraine Jokovic (main photo) is the CEO of LOUD Communications, ACA board member and chair of ACA’s diversity and inclusion committee. Ahead of the launch of ACA’s Create Space diversity and inclusion census, Jokovic says adland often talks a good diversity and inclusion talk but its actions not words that are required… As an industry […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Lawrence Mooney’s Clash With Triple M Goes Nuclear
  • Media

Lawrence Mooney’s Clash With Triple M Goes Nuclear

Departed Triple M star Lawrence ‘Moonman’ Mooney would have lawyers salivating as he chases after a $1million-plus damages claim against his former employers. Mooney still had over a year remaining on his contract with SCA before an internal issue led to the popular personality’s abrupt departure from the airwaves. It’s believed his salary for 2021 […]

Decoding Creativity And Effectiveness
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns
  • Media

Decoding Creativity And Effectiveness

Spikes Asia talks with chief creative officer at Performance Art, Ian Mackenzie (main photo), about his Spike award winning campaign, ‘Publicly Traded’… When creativity is effective and effective work is creative, it has even greater power to positively impact people, brands and the world. Spikes Asia brings weekly insights from award winning creators of inspiring […]

How Twitter Is Raising The Bar On Brand Safety 
  • Partner Content
  • Technology

How Twitter Is Raising The Bar On Brand Safety 

People are at the centre of Twitter’s brand safety policies. By putting people first, Twitter is creating a safer space for brands to engage with the right audiences, at the right time, with the right conversations.  As a platform where people come to participate in conversations, connect with others, and get information they can trust, […]

Ethical Cosmetics Company Lush Closes All Social Media Accounts
  • Media
  • Technology

Ethical Cosmetics Company Lush Closes All Social Media Accounts

Ethical cosmetics chain Lush has boycotted social media over concerns it is having a negative impact on teenagers’ mental health. The cosmetics company closed down all it’s social media accounts last week, consisting of Instagram, Facebook and Snapchat. It’s a pretty big deal considering The Guardian, reported that Lush has amassed over 10 million followers […]

UnLtd Announces Open Applications For 2022 ‘Ambassador For Good’ Program
  • Media

UnLtd Announces Open Applications For 2022 ‘Ambassador For Good’ Program

UnLtd and Yahoo’s inaugural Ambassador for Good program has come to a close for 2021, with the call for applications being sent out for next year. From over 80 applicants, 16 individuals from across the industry were selected into the launch initiative to use their skills and networks for good. Over the past year, the […]

Celeste Barber Teams Up With Bras N Things For A Relatable Lingerie Collection
  • Marketing

Celeste Barber Teams Up With Bras N Things For A Relatable Lingerie Collection

Comedian and social media star, Celeste Barber has collaborated with lingerie brand Bras N Things for a relatable and wearable lingerie collection. Barber’s collaboration with Bras N Things is bright, vibrant and fun. It’s relaxed and comfortable but there is also plenty of drama and sass. Barber worked closely with the Bras N Things team […]

Creator Company Jellysmack Expands ANZ Team
  • Media
  • Technology

Creator Company Jellysmack Expands ANZ Team

Global creator company Jellysmack has announced its latest Australia and New Zealand team members as the company accelerates its growth plans in the region. Last month, Jellysmack launched its popular creator program in Australia and New Zealand and prioritised the region as a key growth market within the $US100 billion creator economy. The VC-backed technology […]

Mix 94.5 Partner With Starcom For Masters ‘Milk Carton’ Regatta
  • Marketing
  • Media

Mix 94.5 Partner With Starcom For Masters ‘Milk Carton’ Regatta

Bega’s flavoured milk brand, Masters, saw the return of its iconic Western Australian event over the weekend, with locals taking to the water at Hillary’s Boat Harbour in Perth, to race watercrafts made from Masters milk cartons. The ‘Masters Milk Regatta’ this year partnered with SCA’s Mix 94.5 station – with Starcom overseeing media strategy, […]

Love Island Australia Dumpees Join Tinder For One Night Of Swipes
  • Marketing

Love Island Australia Dumpees Join Tinder For One Night Of Swipes

Three dumped islanders from the Love Island Australia Villa will be joining Tinder for an exclusive in-app experience, ‘Swipe Island’, looking for another chance to find their lucky match. Between 6pm-11pm tonight, Aussie Tinder members will have the final chance to participate in the virtual ‘Swipe Island’ experience and match with ex Villa babes including […]

Nestlé Australia Announces Switch To 100 Per Cent Renewable Energy
  • Marketing

Nestlé Australia Announces Switch To 100 Per Cent Renewable Energy

Nestlé Australia has announced it is switching to renewable energy, meaning Aussie favourites, KitKat, Milo, Allen’s, Uncle Toby’s and Purina will now be made at 100 per cent renewable energy-powered factories. Nestlé Australia’s announcement comes four years ahead of its original global target of 2025. The company partnered with CWP Renewables to make its first renewable power […]

Why We Need More I In Team
  • Disruption
  • Media
  • Opinion

Why We Need More I In Team

Here's a top piece by the Ad Council's Hannah Sturrock that deserves your attention. Well, more than a passing glance.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine