ShEqual Report Shows That Advertisers Are Too Scared To Talk About Sexist Content

Australia’s adland is silencing a third (30 percent) of people concerned by potentially sexist content in advertising, such as dangerous female stereotypes, according to new research. In November 2021, Australian advertising equality movement shEqual surveyed 598 advertising professionals.
It found that almost one in three (30 percent) reported hesitating to call out gender equality issues in ad content due to fears of negative consequences. Other reasons for not speaking up included feeling it wasn’t their place (30 percent), they weren’t senior enough (29 percent) and a lack of experience (27 percent).
Conversely, the research also showed that depictions of women that were respectful (93 percent), realistic (88 percent) and diverse (89 percent) were extremely, or very important to respondents.
“Our data shows a disconnect between the intentions and actions of the industry in depicting women,” says Dianne Hill, CEO of Women’s Health Victoria, the organisation leading the shEqual movement. “It’s encouraging that the motivation is there, but the missing piece is an open dialogue on what representation looks like in 2022.”
To help advertisers discuss the depiction of women shEqual has launched a new resource to help creatives, strategists, and brands identify and erase problematic stereotypes. The guide, Female Stereotypes in Advertising, lays out some common stereotypes currently in use in advertising and the real-world harm these shallow depictions can have. The purpose for the guide, along with upcoming video and social content created by Icon Agency, is to drive much-needed conversations about the representation of women in creative content.
“The average Australian sees 5,000 adverts a day, so it’s hard to overestimate the power they have to influence peoples’ views,” says Dianne Hill. “It’s vital for the health and wellbeing of women that ads don’t reinforce harmful expectations and social norms. A good starting point is removing caricatures of women in advertising and replacing them with more realistic and diverse representations of women.”
The report highlights seven recurring stereotypes in depictions of women:
- The Model Mother: Women are disproportionately shown as the primary caretakers of both home and children – caring, dressing, cooking and cleaning.
- The Passive Little Girl: Ads show boys engaging in active play and girls sitting passively, often with one another, playing with dolls and house appliances and everything is pink.
- The Observed Woman: The observed woman loses her agency and authority in the male gaze.
- The Sexualised Woman: This stereotype demonstrates that a woman’s value comes only from her sex appeal.
- The Pretty Face: This stereotype can be more subtle but shows women as secondary and “just a pretty face” without much intelligence or independence.
- The Magical Grandmother: Older women are generally missing from ads, but when they are shown they are often in the kitchen serving food, smiling and supporting younger characters, with few spoken lines.
- The Ticked Box: Characters included to check diversity boxes, but commonly limited to the background.
Many other women were broadly absent from ads, including women with disabilities, women with larger bodies, queer women, older women, and women of colour – especially First Nations women.
shEqual warns that the pervasiveness of shallow stereotypes in Australian advertising has damaging real world effects – and their work is supported by United Nations research that shows that gender stereotypes can perpetuate inequality and limit women’s autonomy and freedom.
“Sexist ads fuel a culture of gender inequity that perpetuates violence against women, with one in three* reporting having experienced physical or sexual violence.
“Our data shows that two-thirds* of the industry agree that gender stereotypes are a contributing factor to this issue. It’s time that these demeaning conventions are dispelled to help prevent further harm to women,” Ms Hill added.
The launch of the Female Stereotypes in Advertising guide is supported with a series of videos that capture a panel of leading industry voices discussing female stereotypes and how the industry can combat them.
The panel event will be hosted by comedian and TV presenter Alex Lee and features Dhivia Pilai (senior strategist, TBWA), Sarah Vincenzini (associate creative director, M&C Saatchi), Niall Hughes (group account director, Icon Agency), Anathea Ruys (CEO, UM Australia), Irene Joshy (head of creative, Insights, Kantar Asia & Australia) and Fiona Le Brocq (senior executive, Brand, Marketing & CX, Medibank).
“Involving leading industry professionals in this discussion is vital to ensure that this message reaches all corners of the advertising and communications sector,” said Dianne Hill.
“We need a richer discussion on what actions the industry can take to banish stereotypes of women, which is why we’re thrilled to start this dialogue with respected industry heavyweights and emerging talent.” Icon Agency will host the panel at The Content Garden, Victoria’s newest video production and studio complex.
The panel is being hosted by Icon Agency at its recently launched digital production studio, The Content Garden, in the Cremorne Innovation Precinct.
Icon Agency managing director and co-founder, Joanne Painter, said: “Challenging inequality through advertising, storytelling and communications starts with the people working in the industry. Gender and cultural diversity are deeply ingrained in Icon’s DNA; they are a source of pride. At Icon, we’re committed to ensuring the work we create offers realistic depictions of Australia’s complexity and diversity.”
Icon was last year awarded a prestigious B&T diversity award, along with three Agency of the Year recognitions.
“As a female and co-founded agency, we’re proud to lend our support to shEqual by hosting this event. We hope this panel facilitates insightful discussion and combat harmful stereotypes in advertising,” said Joanne.
“The conversation on depictions of women must build momentum,” says Dianne Hill. “We’re hoping the entire industry can leverage this event, the videos and the guide to spark meaningful conversations in the places that matter. We don’t have all the answers, but if we work together, we can support a true shifting of standards and dismantle these stereotypes.”.
For more information about shEqual and to view the Female Stereotypes in Advertising guide, click here.
Latest News

Study: 37% Of Aussies Admit To Reading Gossip Mags; With Adelaide Women Their Biggest Fans
A new survey conducted by magazine and newspaper subscription service Readly found that celebrity gossip mags are a popular guilty pleasure with more than a third of Australians (37 per cent) indulging in the habit. Perhaps unsurprisingly the biggest cohort of gossip and entertainment magazine readers were women (41 per cent) aged 30-39 followed by […]

Fabulate Names Marie Galinsky As National Sales Director
Market leading Australian content marketing platform Fabulate has named Marie Galinsky (pictured) to oversee its rapidly expanding national sales operation in the role of national sales director. Galinsky’s promotion will see her lead Fabulate’s growing sales team and comes just six months after she joined the content marketing startup to lead its Melbourne sales operation. […]

adidas And Indigenous Football Australia Team Up To Give Opportunities To Indigenous Children
A new partnership between adidas and Indigenous Football Australia, which oversees the strategy and expansion of Australia’s most successful and longest-running Indigenous football initiative, John Moriarty Football, will ensure more Indigenous children in remote and regional communities benefit from the power of football. The partnership will see adidas and Indigenous Football Australia (IFA) work together […]

The Advertising Council Releases Statement On Industry Bullying & Harassment
The Advertising Council releases some tough talk on bullying & harassment. Nothing on whether the beard's had its day.

Clementine Ford On Joining Nova And Finding A Woman Friendly Space In Media
The one & only Clementine Ford drops by B&T for an insightful chat. Office beer bong competition rescheduled to Friday.

Australian Studio Start Beyond Appoints Angus Stevens As Chief Executive Officer
Start Beyond, Australia’s leading producer and distributor of VR and AR immersive learning solutions, today announces the internal promotion of Angus Stevens (pictured) to CEO. Stevens, who joined the business in 2016 as one of the founding members, is moving on from his current position of managing director effective immediately. In his new role, Stevens […]

Nine Apologies After Journo Shares Contentious Abortion Post
Another day & it's yet another apology coming out of Nine's head office. Karl just thankful it wasn't him for a change.

FORWARD Agency Announced As PR Agency For Social Enterprise World Forum 2022
PR agency Forward announces exciting new win. Local BWS soon wiped out of Stoli and Moët piccolos.

Indie Agency Hardhat Boosts Its Senior Team With Hires & Promotions
Hardhat riddled with first day nerves & possible loose bowel or two as agency announces a string of new recruits.

Tuesday TV Wrap: MasterChef Sizzles But Nine Brings Home The Bacon
It has to be said that Ninja Warrior is off to a slow start. And who can ever tire of watching perfect specimens fail?

Sir Patrick ‘Star Trek’ Stewart Skewers The Staff Farewell In Witty Work For Yorkshire Tea
Yorkshire Tea's the tea of choice at B&T. Although it's often overshadowed by alcohol, which is the drink of choice.

Men With Large Penises Sought For New TV Doco ‘Too Large To Love’
Ever encountered a todger so extraordinarily large your eyes have watered? Get set to pat the pupils again on this news.

IAB Report Shows Brands Are Using Game Advertising To Extend Ad Reach
In exciting news for the sale of Red Bull & marijuana, new report shows gaming set to be adland's next big opportunity.

Triple M Comes Out On Top Amongst Footy Shows In Survey 4 Results
Triple M has recorded the largest commercial AFL and NRL metro footy audience, delivering almost double the listeners of any other commercial competitor, according to today’s Survey 4 radio ratings results. Triple M’s AFL coverage across Melbourne, Adelaide and Perth reported a cumulative audience of 679,000, while Triple M’s NRL coverage has an audience of […]

VMG Appoints Brendan Harper As Frontier Media Queensland GM
Independent Australian-owned media company VMG has announced the appointment of Brendan Harper (pictured) as general manager and group business director to lead media planning & buying agency, Frontier Media in Queensland. His appointment follows the departure of Queensland director Alexandra Paton, who has been with Frontier Media for more than 15 years. Harper holds extensive […]

Havas Australia Appoints OIS As Third-Party Verification Partner
Havas Australia has appointed OIS, leaders in out-of-home (OOH) verification, as its independent, third-party verification partner across digital, programmatic, and classic out-of-home client campaigns following a competitive review. Australia is among the top 10 global out-of-home markets by size and one of the most advanced, highlighted by leading adoption rates of digital and more recently, […]

Virtue APAC Appoints Fiona Knight As Head Of Account Management
Vice's Virtue appoints Fiona Knight as head of account management. A role, you'd say, would need a proficiency in Excel.

BetterBriefs Unveils New Best Practice Guide Addressing Industry Shortcomings
BetterBriefs will today unveil a new best practice guide, The best way for a client to brief an agency, co-authored by Mark Ritson and in partnership with the IPA, at the IPA Business Growth Conference. After shocking the world of advertising last October with the painful and alarming truths about the enormous misalignment between marketers […]

Dentsu’s Merkle Names Simon Doukas As Inaugural Chief Experience Officer
Adland continuing to see rise of the chief experience officer. Yet no correlation in the rise of anyone wearing linen.

No Better Time To Eat Macca’s Than Winter Proposes New Work From DDB Sydney
Macca's says it's the winter food of choice in new work from DDB. Arguably also the destroyer of the summer bikini body.

Report: Out Of Home Spends Up Almost 15% For Q2
Australia's outdoor industry continues its post-COVID purple patch. Camping, however, remains as shitful as ever.

oOh!media Strikes Deals With 10 Queensland Shopping Centres
oOh!media likes what it sees in Queensland shopping centres. Still can't find a decent park, however.

KPMG Launches End-To End Customer Business, KPMG Customer
KPMG unveils new customer-centric offering, KPMG Customer. Confirms shoplifters and wonky trolleys not its remit.

TABOO Launches Innovation & Design Division, TABOO Labs
TABOO announces the launch of TABOO Labs. Which kinda sounds like tabouli just without the bulgur wheat.

Uber ANZ Announces In-House Ad Division Headed By LinkedIn’s Michael Levine
Uber announces creation of its in-house ad division. No news of its drivers overdoing it with the air freshener.

Red Havas Boosts Health Team With Three New Hires
Red Havas unveils new health team recruits. All of which achieved 90% or above in Operation during interview process.

Big Red Group Nabs Naked Wines’ Paul Connell For CMO Role
Naked Wines' Paul Connell quits for new role. Also thankful he no longer has to explain what herbaceous means at BBQs.

Bank Of Queensland Drops OMD, Hands Media To Initiative & Performics
If there was ever a bank that could pull off the muumuu or the Hawaiian shirt it has to be the Bank Of Queensland.

Why A Federal Election Is A Treasure Trove Of Data For Strategists & Marketers
This columnist argues that elections shine a light on the zeitgeist of a nation. And insane billionaire candidates.

“Don’t Read The Comments, Darling!” Richard Wilkins On Helping Son Christian Navigate Logies Dress Backlash
Proof the red carpet's about the only interesting part of the Logies comes this story from B&T's Christian obsessive.

Why Trust, Not Crypto, Is Today’s Most Valuable Online Currency
In uncertain times, trusted sources become even more significant in the world of media. Elise Bennett (pictured), head of account management (APAC) at Outbrain, reveals what advertisers need to know about the new trust exchange. Instability breeds uncertainty. From bushfires to the pandemic and war, there’s been plenty of both to go around in recent […]

Monday TV Wrap: MasterChef Cooks Up Solid Numbers For 10
MasterChef continues to prove it's like a proverbial Thai red curry left in the fridge overnight - it just gets tastier.

Radio Ratings: Kyle & Jackie O Are Hot On Ben Fordham’s Winning Trail
Sure, B&T's radio ratings aren't always first or aren't particularly thorough, but we guarantee a Media Watch-free read.

Nine’s Radio Stations Bag Best Ever Survey 4 Results
GfK Survey 4 of 2022 reveals that Nine’s talk stations achieved a cumulative audience of 1.873 million – up 9.1 per cent on Survey 4 of 2021. It’s the highest ever Survey 4 audience for the network, and comes off the back of record audiences in Surveys 1, 2 and 3. Sydney’s 2GB is a […]

“Absolutely Disgusting & Racist!” Adlander Slammed For Age/SMH Column Calling For Nick Kyrgios To Be Deported
There is nothing more divisive than tennis ace Nick Kyrgios. Save for hot or cold custard or Nicole in 'Eyes Wide Shut'.

British Drag Queen Busted Sniffing Amyl Nitrate During Live Pride TV Show
B&T never condones the use of drugs in any manner. Except for crappy dance music, where they're almost a necessity.