In this guest post, Facebook’s head of marketing science, Andy Ford (pictured below), dives deep into the social media giant’s recent research on TV ad viewability, and offers some tips for brands on how to keep consumers’ attention.
A lot of my time is spent comparing the performance of channels, formats, metrics and more. It’s the thing I’m asked to do most by marketers, who are grappling with measuring their media in a meaningful way.
But when I’m asked about how viewability compares across digital publishers, I push back and ask how they measure viewability across non-digital channels. No-one has ever said they have.
So, I was delighted to read Dr Karen Nelson-Field’s latest piece where she quite rightly points out that attention is the way people build connections with brands through memory associations. As she succinctly puts it: “If you’re not paying any attention, you won’t process (or act upon) what is right in front of your face!”
Understanding what captivates people will help us plan media campaigns to optimise the delivery of a message and measure markers which directly influence outcomes.
To start to get a handle on this we conducted a study with international research institute Eye Square, starting with the most ingrained media behavior: a night in front of the television. According to a recent Global Web Index report, 74 per cent of Australians have their mobile phone within arm’s reach whilst watching TV, but we wanted to understand where they are focusing their attention in that time, and how much they take in.
We recruited TV viewers with a mixture of single, couple, co-habiting households, as well as a number containing ‘natural’ distractions (children, pets etc.). Respondents wore eye-tracking glasses during their prime-time viewing, which recorded how much time their eyes were on their TV screen, their mobile screen, and ‘other’ (e.g. looking at a clock, partner, pet). They were watching a linear TV feed, so were not able to fast-forward ad breaks but could change channel. As well as Australia, the research has run in six other countries including the UK and US, giving us robust samples (over 760 people) which provided consistent global themes and Australian nuances).
Firstly, Australians really like their TV. Aussies are one of the more engaged audiences with programming across the global markets we studied, with 71 per cent of attention from participants on the tele, compared to 23 per cent on the phone. The other 6 per cent split between staring at the room or other people.
But when it came to ad breaks, there was a clear change in behavior and attention as people tuned out. Attention focused on TV amongst those studied dropped from 71 per cent to 43 per cent, whilst mobile grew from 23 per cent to 47 per cent.
A breakdown by age also gives a glimpse into emerging future behaviours. Our study showed under 35s ad viewing time dropped to 38 per cent, with their mobile attention increasing to over 50 per cent. This younger cohort is likely to represent the future total average in Australia as mobile use continues to become ingrained in behaviour.
We also delved into individual ad attention, measuring the amount of time participants in the study spent watching more than 1,700 15-second ads. It showed:
- 36 per cent of all 15-second ads received no attention at all.
- 58 per cent of all 15-second ads received attention for two seconds or more.
- The smartphone was the top distraction (85 per cent of the time).
- On average, just 23 per cent of people viewed 15-second ads to completion.
- The channel was changed in 33 per cent of the ad breaks measured.
What impact does it have on consumers?
At the IAB Measure Up conference recently, I heard someone glibly dismiss the idea that people don’t always watch TV ad breaks by saying, ‘There have always been cups of tea’.
Whilst TV measurement does account for this, statements like that don’t help in understanding the impact of the increased number of distractions in a modern home for viewers, where mobile phones are ever-present.
It also got me thinking about why we accept an ‘allowable’ view on wastage – or a lack of viewability – for ‘traditional’ media, but not for digital?
Maybe there is a need to rethink how we are executing this creative to be more aligned to attention, delivering key messages early, succinctly and more impactfully in all channels – not just digital?
A lot of this is probably unsurprising to you if you have taken a moment to think about how you behave. And the purpose of this study is not to run down TV advertising – as we’ve said before, it’s a powerful and valuable medium.
But as Binet and Field’s recent work found, it needs to be complemented by a strong social and digital element to be truly effective – it’s understanding how that works together now that is important.
That is also backed up by the work of independent consultants Analytic Partners, whose research into digital and social ROI shows “the synergy of using two different tools resulted in an average increase in ROI of 19 per cent over campaigns using just one channel”.
Attention is a useful metric and much more aligned to outcomes, but it’s currently hard to recreate in an ongoing, sustainable way. So what can we do in the meantime? Here are a few suggestions:
- Understand people’s attention and then plan your reach to be exhaustive across a range of channels instead of siloed. Utilise digital channels that can offer incremental reach.
- With attention moving between screens, creative must be designed to have impact from the start. Do not assume an audience will watch all of your ad in every environment.
- Push for comparisons across all channels. One of the first steps as we shift towards measuring attention and outcomes is to move from an opportunity to see on separate channels, to actual exposure across all channels.
All of this shows a clear need for the industry to push towards a single, comparable measurement currency which at the very least correlates with sales and/or brand outcomes, if not drives them.
If we can get away from the vanity metrics which come with a traditional media mentality to have something which shows how good integrated marketing can move the needle for businesses, the better it will be for everyone.
LinkedIn, the world’s largest professional network, has today released its 2021 LinkedIn Top Australian Startups List revealing the top 25 most sought-after startups to work for by Australian professionals. The annual ranking highlights startups that are growing and recruiting top talent, informed by the billions of actions taken on LinkedIn by more than 774 million professionals. This […]
72andSunny have strengthened their team in Australia with four super senior hires in strategy and creative roles. “72andSunny’s vision has always been to drive growth by impacting culture. We’re stoked to add this world class talent to the team to help deliver this,” said Ross Berthinussen, 72andSunny Sydney president. “It’s rad to have such superstars […]
Seismic has announced an expanded New Zealand (NZ) presence to support the transformation of sales and marketing teams, and enable the nation’s employers to focus on upskilling their workforces to overcome a digital skills shortage. The company has also signed NZ-based specialist consultancies, Fresh Perspective Sales (FPS) and Jumping Fox Interactive, as its first two […]
A magnitude six earthquake hit Melbourne/Naarm and areas of regional Victoria today, causing damage to some buildings. The earthquake hit at approximately 9.15am AEST – while the ABC News Breakfast team were still at their desks. Presenters Michael Rowland and Tony Armstrong were sat in the News Breakfast set discussing the program after broadcast had ended […]
The Inspired Unemployed are launching a Spotify Original podcast, giving Australians even more insight into the larrikin’s unexpected fame and adventures. Commissioned by and only available on Spotify, the first ever podcast from the duo will bring a whole new dimension to the adventures of Matt and Jack, two best mates who still can’t quite […]
In this guest post, Garth Williamson (main photo), country manager ANZ at Shutterstock, says all the evidence is in for a more inclusive workplace, but asks why are so many still shunning the idea? The evidence is clear; inclusive marketing increases brand reach, consumer engagement and drives customer brand advocacy. And yet, few brands are […]
The Masked Singer’s big reveal saw a slight drop off in audience from its Monday night episode, netting an average of 654,000 viewers. That’s a decrease of 49,000 from the previous night where, as you are sure to remember, the dancing pinata was revealed to be Lote Tuqiri. Last night was the reveal of a […]
Australasia’s largest real estate agency has released its biggest brand campaign ever that was all done in-house. The spring campaign, “Proudly Ray White”, was created to help service the more than 730 Australian offices under the leading group’s umbrella. Spearheaded by Ray White marketing manager Todd Alexander and brand manager David Williamson, the campaign was […]
American beer brand Pabst Blue Ribbon wants to pay drinkers to plaster their homes with ads for the brew. The oddball campaign is called “In home advertising” and, despite the fun, works more as a clever piss-take of the advertising game. Apparently the idea for the ad came about when the client complained of the […]
JCDecaux has announces the successful outcome of one of the largest Out-of-Home advertising contracts in Australia, as Sydney Trains appoints the company as its main advertising partner across the concourses and platforms of train stations for a term of up to ten years. The company, still smarting from relinquishing the City of Sydney contract to […]
Leading cultural insights and strategy company The Lab today announced the promotion of three senior staff members to executive positions in its Melbourne and Sydney offices. The promotions follow strong growth for The Lab, with the addition of new clients and the launch of its innovative new artificial intelligence and machine learning division, Lab AI, […]
Alex Huntley, Booktopia’s head of customer experience, recently appeared at software company Freshworks’ recent digital CX summit RE:SOLVE. During the summit, Huntley shared his thoughts on future-proofing customer service architecture.Huntley sat down with B&T to discuss Booktopia’s partnership with Freshworks and how it has helped their platform develop. B&T: Why did Booktopia first decide to partner […]
The Edison Agency has made four new appointments in its Sydney office to service the continued growth across key account The Arnott’s Group and the recent appointment to Nestlé Oceania’s strategic packaging design roster. Over the past 12 months, the culmination of strategic and creative work across the Uncle Toby’s brand and continued growth of […]
SCA has announced a new smart speaker experience for the Hit Network, with Tom and Olly’s Guide to Lockdown. A voice-activated way to get inspiration and information on fun activities that can be done at home, the guide is curated to appeal to a wide audience. Smart speaker users will find a range of ideas […]