Mumbrella Bows To Industry Pressure & Switches Off Comments

Shh! Women's secrets. Cropped shot of female with finger in mouth. Closeup portrait of young woman is showing a sign of silence with shhh written on the finger.
SHARE
THIS



Mumbrella has made the bold call to turn off comments on its articles, a move that will undoubtedly have a big impact for the publishing site.

Mumbrella head of content Damian Francis made the announcement Friday afternoon, penning an opinion piece which will be the last article on Mumbrella to have comments.

Francis wrote: “From today, Mumbrella will no longer publish reader comments. This policy will be for all of the content we publish, regardless of what it is.

“The ethos behind Mumbrella’s long-held stance on publishing comments has shifted as the brand has developed and today’s announcement is a continuation of that shift.

“Making the decision to scrap comments altogether just eight months on from the new policy may seem more like one giant leap rather than one small step, but I feel it’s an important leap to make for Mumbrella, its staff and the industry. And now is as good a time as ever to do that – when we can make that decision clearly, analytically, and without emotion or pressure.”

It follows Mumbrella‘s decision to change its comment moderation policy in January this year, with the new policy of “only publishing comments that [Mumbrella believed was] worth [its] audience seeing.”

Francis stepped into the head of content role in mid August after Mumbrella announced a restructure of its team, which saw editor Vivienne Kelly depart. It is essentially the role Tim Burrows had filled since founding Mumbrella.

Francis wrote that prior to moving into the role, all he could do was “observe from the sidelines” as the debate around comments ranged on.

He wrote: “In my mind, there are solid arguments for both sides. An open channel of communications for the industry, particularly those without a big voice, versus a poisonous well of uneducated opinion and name calling. That’s an overly basic assessment, of course – the arguments on both sides run substantially deeper than that.

“I found that I didn’t side wholly with one party or the other. And I kept out of the debate. I did not participate in the now infamous meeting of the minds called by WPP AUNZ chairman, John Steedman – which followed his open letter to the industry – or join the round table that we ran at one of our industry retreats in Tasmania, despite the fact I was there. As head of event content, it simply wasn’t my race to run.”

In his new role, however, and with a “lull in commentary around comments” on trade press, Francis said it was an “ideal time to reasses the situation”.

Francis added there are many reasons Mumbrella has chosen to turn off its comments, one being that the publishign site wantes to “foster a community”.

“That means opening the communication channels with as much of the industry as possible. That doesn’t gel so well when the history of the comments has been, at times, vicious, rather than supportive. Nor does it gel when there is such significant debate around the value of comments,” wrote Francis.

It’s a huge move for Mumbrella, as the comments section was arguably one of the most popular aspects of the website. However, it was also a place where plenty of hatred and vitriol was served.

There have been plenty of calls over the years for Mumbrella to better moderate or turn off comments all together, including a callout form industry veteran John Steedman in June last year.

In a statement issued to media last year, Steedman called the increasing problem of divisive and anonymous reader comments “the coward punches of public debate” before adding that he had witnessed a “concerning decline in the quality of online comment in our media industry”.

Steedman added: “People are being attacked for their sexuality or appearance, for their perceived ability or public statements.

“Anonymous comments are a cheap laugh for the people behind these posts, and those who trawl through them, but it often causes real and lasting damage to those on the receiving end.

“People who are going about their daily business, striving to deliver results like the rest of us and share honestly held opinions on important topics of discussion.

“This is another grubby example of the lack of respect in public discourse – a cancerous trend that now pervades politics, business, the media and the workplace,” he said.

B&T has long argued against the practice too.

It will prove an interesting move in terms of advertising revenue for the publisher, with time spent on page and site visits potentially decreasing with no comments to trawl through.

B&T reached out to Mumbrella for further comment.

 

 

Please login with linkedin to comment

    Latest comments
  • Glenn Hampson 1 month ago

    Sorry to read this and sorry the decent majority have to pay for the idiot minority

mumbrella

Latest News

We Need To Talk About B2B Events
  • Opinion

We Need To Talk About B2B Events

This columnist asks is it the end for B2B events? And if so, where will B&T journalists take afternoon naps now?

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
WPP’s Acquisition Shopping List Revealed
  • Advertising
  • Media

WPP’s Acquisition Shopping List Revealed

This article contains a hint of speculation, a spot of fabrication, but hopefully not a dollop of defamation.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
The Recipe For Return On Investment (ROI)
  • Partner Content

The Recipe For Return On Investment (ROI)

The recipe for ROI is revealed here! And thankfully it doesn't include caciocavallo podolico or white alba truffles.

Partner Content

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Viztrade Launches Facebook Style Self-Serve Solution
  • Technology

Viztrade Launches Facebook Style Self-Serve Solution

Independent programmatic platform Viztrade has launched a self-serve solution for publishers to generate digital advertising revenue directly from their own websites. Viztrade Connect is to be launched through the Viztrade platform and enables advertisers to purchase advertising from publisher websites with no friction and full visibility into the cost of the media. The solution is […]

Google Launches YouTube Select In Australia
  • Technology

Google Launches YouTube Select In Australia

On the upside, reading B&T's tech news isn't as nerdy as reading it on tech sites. On the downside, it's not as good.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Blank bus stop advertising poster shot in Germany near Rostock at a bus stop. Perfect for visualising design or advertising concepts
  • Media

BIG Outdoor Launches Programmatic With Vistar Media

BIG Outdoor has announced the launch of programmatic capabilities powered by Vistar Media. BIG Outdoor is leveraging Vistar’s supply-side platform (SSP) to make their inventory available for purchase programmatically via open exchange or private marketplace deals. “Our mission is to stay at the forefront of improving the value proposition of digital billboard advertising,” said Richard […]

Why Purpose is Needed Now More Than Ever
  • Opinion

Why Purpose is Needed Now More Than Ever

Has a bad back all but ruled you out of catching falling colleagues for motivation? Try this hernia-free read instead.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
New normal trendy,stay home,work from home,social distancing concepts on covid-19 outbreak situation.safety and health care ideas
  • Marketing
  • Opinion

Five Aces To Overcoming The Pandemic For CMOs

This is the only thing any CMO should be reading today. Well, this and maybe Riston's latest rants or Marketing Week.

Opinion

by Christos Tzortzis

Christos Tzortzis
NSW Government Launches Maths Trains Brains Campaign Via Bastion Banjo
  • Campaigns

NSW Government Launches Maths Trains Brains Campaign Via Bastion Banjo

The NSW Government and the Department of Education have today launched a major campaign titled ‘Maths Trains Brains’ which is aimed at changing the perception of maths and encouraging more engagement towards the subject for students from pre-kindy to Year 10. The campaign was developed by creative and digital agency Bastion Banjo with production by […]

Debunking The Myths: The Environmental Cred Of Print Media
  • Opinion

Debunking The Myths: The Environmental Cred Of Print Media

In this guest post, Dr Phillip Lawrence of Edith Cowan University debunks the myths of the environmental impact of printing… The environmental credentials of printing have been in the spotlight for a while with brands and marketers as well as large corporates regularly proposing they would reduce or eliminate paper and printing from their business as […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Mindshare Snares Kayo’s & Binge’s Media
  • Media

Mindshare Snares Kayo’s & Binge’s Media

The WPP-owned agency Mindshare has revealed it has won the media business for both Kayo and Binge. Both Kayo and Binge form part of Foxtel’s Steamotion’s streaming services and have seen significant boosts to the subscription numbers in recent times, primarily during lockdown. Commenting on the win, Mindshare CEO Katie Rigg-Smith said the win would […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Aussie Tech Firm Launches App To Help Media Owners Find Local Advertisers In Any Location
  • Media

Aussie Tech Firm Launches App To Help Media Owners Find Local Advertisers In Any Location

Realworld, an Australian location-based technology company, today launched adfindr.co, a leads platform for media owners. Adfindr finds the contact details of hundreds of local businesses around any location. Adfindr offers all media owners a database of local advertising leads. Simply type in a location and extract advertising leads in that area. David Sanderson, Director at […]