Meta: Privacy Act Reforms Would Force Free Online Services To Find Another Revenue Source
Meta’s privacy policy director, Melinda Claybaugh, has said that the proposed changes to the Privacy Act 1988 would force businesses that rely on ad dollars to find a new revenue model.
Visiting Australia from Washington DC, Claybaugh told journalists that “it’s the fact of the matter that companies that rely on ads to provide free services would be forced to find another revenue source.”
In its submission to the attorney general’s department review of the Privacy Act, Meta said that it supported 106 of the 116 points raised. However, two of the 10 points that it objected to caused particular concern for Claybaugh and her team – the broad definition of targeted advertising that would include even basic targeting of consumers at a postcode or age range level and the ability of consumers to completely opt out of targeted advertising.
Claybaugh explained Meta’s hesitancy on the proposed opt-out provision:
“As it is currently framed in the proposal, it would mean that people could fully opt out of seeing any ads in their personalised experiences. This isn’t just a social media issue. Ads support newspapers, they support all kinds of services.
“Advertising is what allows companies to provide free or reduced-cost services. By allowing people to opt out of that but still having to provide a service to them, which is what is contemplated, you are essentially forcing companies to look at other revenue models.”
Claybaugh did not rule out Meta adapting its business model in Australia and charging users for its services.
“It’s early days in the proposal and we don’t know what it’s ultimately going to look like,” she said.
Meta’s second main bone of contention was the overly broad definition of targeted advertising – something that industry organisations such as the Association for Data-Driven Marketing (ADMA) and the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) have taken exception to, as well.
“We agree generally with the idea that high-risk targeting or targeting to certain populations may carry some risk that warrants mitigation,” explained Claybaugh.
“For example, we don’t currently allow advertisers to target ads to people based on sensitive data. We also don’t allow invasive targeting of kids under 18.
“However, the proposal, as currently framed, frames targeting much more broadly. The concern there is that not just advertising would be implicated but also the content that people see. We tend to think about personalisation just in terms of the ads that we see but targeting and personalisation are also about the content that you see as well.”
Claybaugh explained that by removing the ability of firms to target users for adverts or content, they ran the risk of serving age-inappropriate content to users and risking the ire of Ad Standards and other watchdogs.
“You have to be able to target and personalise content in order to serve age-appropriate content for people under 18 or in order to detect problematic content that you might not want to show people. If you take away or limit the ability to personalise content, you’re taking away the tools that companies have to keep their platform safe,” she said.
Claybaugh said that while she did not know why the overly broad definition of targeting was present in the proposed reforms, it was part of a wider trend.
“What we are seeing globally is an interest in how data is used for targeted advertising and making sure that people understand what ads they’re being served and why, and that they have control over their ad experiences,” she explained.
Of course, personalised advertising and content are fundamental to Meta’s current business model. However, Claybaugh and Josh Machin, Meta’s head of public policy in Australia, were keen to point out that many other small businesses, charities and NGOs also stood to lose out with a ban on targeted advertising.
“Ad-supported free services provide a lot of benefit for consumers, particularly if they’re personalised and they can get content and engage with communities that they are close to,” said Machin.
“It’s good for advertisers, particularly small businesses because it results in more efficient personalised advertising and it’s good for organisations that have tight marketing budgets, like NGOs. We’ve heard through this process about how safety NGOs and some of the other partners that we work with really appreciate personalisation. There are a host of trade-offs with some of these recommendations. It’s not necessarily just the business models of particular online companies, as important as that is, but also what the implications would be for everyone who benefits from the online ecosystem.”
Legislators, consumers and some big names in adland would take exception to Meta’s assessment of the situation. Author and adland veteran Bob Hoffman told the European Union in March that “The KGB, the Gestapo, and the Stasi could only dream of having the depth of information about citizens that Google, Facebook, and other adtech companies have” and has regularly railed against online advertising.
“Advertising can occur if it’s not personalised,” conceded Machin.
“But the conversation that we’re having is to encourage policymakers to think about the trade-offs and benefits that might be lost… The research that the IAB put out last year shows the economic benefits, about $10 billion, that come from improvements in efficiency and advertising. It’s a pretty significant contribution to the economy.”
Claybaugh also added that while contextual, rather than personalised content, worked for “some online services better than others” it would not suit Meta’s range of platforms as contextual advertising was “harder in a fully individualised service.”
“What you and I see on Facebook or Instagram, YouTube or whatever, is specific to us. There is no one context that you can target ads to. The concern is that you’re left with a very broad base of billboard-like advertising where everyone sees, essentially, the same ad,” she explained.
“What we know from our research is that people, if they are going to see ads, they want to see relevant ads. That’s a really bad experience for people to just see random ads. Some people do see contextual ads as maybe a silver bullet and it may be okay for some online services but for many online services, it just won’t work.”
There is, of course, a fair way to go before any of the 116 proposed changes to the Privacy Act become enshrined in law and Meta, for its part, said that it wants to remain a “constructive partner” and get an outcome “that’s good for the Australian economy and Australian small businesses and the broader industry.”
Please login with linkedin to comment
MetaLatest News
‘Blair Is Mr Happy, Beau Is Mr Dopey, I’m Mr Grumpy’ – Top Gear Australia Hosts Reveal What It Was Really Like Filming
Top Gear features the cars you could never afford to drive. It's a bit like the bogan's Gourmet Traveller, really.
Nine’s Total TV Sales Lead Richard Hunwick To Step Down
Nine's Richard Hunwick calls time after 15 years. Hoping for a last trip to the Olympics before getting the gold watch.
Yahoo Academy Culminates With Pitch-Off For Musicians Making A Difference With Trip To Cannes In Cairns On The Line
B&T happy to support the Musicians Making A Difference initiative. Particularly any that encourages more Watusi.
TV Ratings 16/5/24: Nearly 2 Million Tune In To See Sky Blues Win In Women’s State Of Origin
B&T does make jokes about the Budget reply speech but, to his credit, Mr Potato Head rated OK last night.
Binge Launches “Scene:Scents” Sensory Entertainment Campaign, Via Thinkerbell
There's now scented candles to pair with BINGE shows. We're hoping Rex Hunt's Fishing Adventures doesn't hear about it.
Jolt Partners With Veridooh For Verification Of Its EV Charger Placements In UK
Although B&T's an avid supporter of EV cars, we'd definitely miss the smell of petrol and the service station pie.
Nine Ad Manager Named Principal Sponsor Of CommBank SmallBiz Week
CommBank's SmallBiz Week is coming to Melbourne on the 29-30 May. B&T's as confused as you are on how that's a week.
Pet Circle & Seven Communications Partner On “Pawtition” To Get Pets On Public Transport
B&T's concerned about the fleas, urine & faeces on public transport - and that's just from fellow passengers!
‘A Win-Win’ – How The Matildas Helped CommBank Become A ‘Globally Iconic Brand’ For The First Time
CommBank's sponsorship of the Matildas is a sport marketing masterclass. The opposite to Nick Kyrgios & his sponsors.
VML Australia Dominates The One Show With 5 Gold Pencils
VML Australia flying the flag at the One Show Awards in New York. Not that we need more flag waving at the moment.
Social Soup: Consumers Looking For “Informative” Not “Funny” Social Content When Making Buying Decisions
In a further blow to ventriloquism everywhere, new research says consumers prefer information over funny videos.
GIO Unveils New “Protect Precious” Brand Positioning & Campaign, Via Ogilvy
Insurer asks what's precious in our lives in new work. Which is better than asking is this business highly flammable.
Digitas & Heckler Singapore Launch Animated Symphony For Riot Game’s Valorant Champions Tour Pacific
Stony silence between you and the graphic arts team at Friday drinks? This gaming news could be an ice breaker.
Wavemaker Global CEO Toby Jenner Appointed Global President, GroupM Clients
Wavemaker’s Toby Jenner continues his career trajectory. But is it enough to move him up to the first class lounge?
Fast 10: Mindshare Head Honcho Maria Grivas On Her “Resting Smiling Face”
Mindshare is having a very fruitful 2024. Here, CEO Maria Grivas reveals her fertilisers & pruning tips to success.
Real Home Care Clients & Staff Star In New HammondCare Campaign
Aged care commercial uses real life clients & staff. B&T has not contacted the actor's union for comment.
Mutinex’s Henry Innis: “I’m Imperfect As A Leader”
Mutinex is being touted as one of the hottest start-ups in the land. And we don't mean that in an Elizabeth Holmes way.
Slew Of Senior Hires At Sparro by Brainlabs & Jack Nimble
B&T loves to report new hires as it shows the healthy state of the industry. That and cocaine usage at work functions.
Initiative’s Fein, Geer, Colter To Depart For Accenture Song
As you read first in B&T, there are significant comings-and-goings at Initiative. Though mainly goings, if we're honest.
Pizza Hut Fined $2.5m For Spamming Customers
To be honest, if you're going to spam customers, cheap pizza deals is probably on the low side of the dodgy scale.
Jetstar & Qantas Perception Ratings Soar After Bonza Cancelled Flights, YouGov Finds
This poll is further proof nothing builds a positive brand image like your competitor monumentally f@cking up.
Pedigree Launches AI-Powered Ad Initiative To Give All Dogs A Home, Via Colenso BBDO & Nexus Studios
B&T encourages this dog adoption initiative. And that's despite us barely being able to look after our own selves.
Apparent Launches “All Heart, No hassle” Integrated Campaign For Flight Centre’s Corporate Traveller
Apparent charged with Flight Centre's Corporate Traveller creative. Has avoided any gags about stolen hotel bathrobes.
South African Tourism CMO: ‘We Want Consumers To Experience SA Through The Eyes Of A Child’
B&T chats with South African tourism's Aussie CMO. Admittedly, we had to quickly rectify our Barossa Valley questions.
Market Research Firm TRA Names KFC’s “Look On the Fried Side Of Life” As Australia’s Favourite Ad
A poll of everyday Aussies has revealed our favourite ads. And it'll make difficult reading for the Harvey Norman team.
‘A Big, Big Step In The Right Direction’: Media Buyers React To News Corp’s D_Coded
There was a universal thumbs up for News' D_Coded event. Although there were calls for glitter bombs at the finale.
CommBank Announced As Presenting Partner Of Vogue Codes 2024
Vogue Codes is a top initiative encouraging women into STEM-based careers. All while wearing Jimmy Choos, apparently.
Brad Garbutt Joins OMA As Marketing Lead
Seasoned adlander Garbutt joins the outdoor association. Says he's got the DOOH down pat, but working on the PDOOH.
TV Ratings 15/5/24: Gruen Pulls A Crowd For Aunty As It Enters 16th Season
Although B&T typically shuns predictions, we're expecting big numbers for Peter Dutton's Budget reply speech tonight.
D_Coded panel: ‘If You Are A Marketer Handling Data And Haven’t Spoken To Legal, You’re In Trouble’
This fiery panel was a highlight of Tuesday's D_Coded event. Not that it spilled out into the carpark.
SBS Audio Campaign Tells The Stories Of New Australians, With Multilingual Content Offerings To Assist Migrants
SBS Audio has launched a new marketing campaign for its ‘Australia Explained’ service which supports new migrants to successfully navigate life in Australia and achieve a greater sense of belonging and social cohesion. SBS’s flagship service for new migrants, Australia explained, has launched a multi-platform marketing campaign that reaches into the heart of the migrant […]
Tracker App Launches, Promising Consumers A Read On Brand’s & Products Sustainability Chops
Shoppers can now get access to sustainability information at their fingertips through Tracker, a first-of-its-kind mobile app. The Tracker app centralises sustainability data into a single, easy-to-understand format, helping shoppers make informed choices about the brands and products they support. Shoppers can simply scan the barcode of their favourite supermarket, chemist or department store item […]
Channel Factory Expands Team Across Australia & New Zealand By 20%
Social media agency Channel Factory announces a significant lift in staff numbers. Doesn't thank Tuesday's Budget.
Jaywing Extends Strategy Team Appointing Fran Martin As Senior Brand Strategist
As is often said, you can never have too much strategy. Same can't be said of programmatic & AI.
Tourism Tasmania Taps Broadsheet For Latest “Off Season” Campaign Iteration
Do you like to drape yourself in sheepskin, flannelette & weird, wooly hats? Tasmania in winter is for you.
Netball WA Appoints 303 MullenLowe As Brand Strategy partner
Netball WA appoints 303 MullenLowe for its brand strategy. Any mention of Gina also now strictly forbidden.