Can Facebook Learn from Myspace Mishaps?

Can Facebook Learn from Myspace Mishaps?
SHARE
THIS



Back in the noughties it was the pinnacle of social media. It was knocked down by a young upstart. It tried to get back up again, many times, eventually settling on a music focus in order to differentiate itself from the other challengers.

The story of Myspace is famous on the interwebs. Relegated to just an unused browser bookmark when Facebook barged into the scene, Myspace has since changed hands and revealed another in its long list of makeovers in June last year.

While Facebook may have stolen the social media crown, there’s a lot of chatter around the internet that Mark Zuckerberg’s baby, said to be worth $192 billion, is headed in the same direction as the once great Myspace.

“The biggest learning from Myspace and its demise was that corporisation is what ultimately killed the platform,” says Sam Snowden, account director at social media agency Thinktank Social.

“The irony of Myspace’s demise is that Facebook has shifted from a platform that allowed us to connect with people from all stages of our lives into a marketplace that controls the news we see in our feed from our friends, family and the brands we choose to interact with.”

Logging onto Myspace today, the old look isn’t gone entirely but the platform is very much music focused, with songs still playing automatically when visiting the site. The revamp even saw the ‘S’ in MySpace getting a lower case down grade to Myspace.

Bought for $580 million in 2005 by Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp, the platform was sold in 2011 for $35 million. Forbes writer Adam Hartung wrote at the time: “News Corp tried to guide Myspace, to add planning, and to use ‘professional management’ to determine the business’s future.  That was fatally flawed when competing with Facebook which was managed in White Space, letting the marketplace decide where the business should go.”

Strategist and program manager Jason Olive at content marketing and social media agency Kamber, says there’s a lot of talk around Facebook mimicking Myspace’s story. Sensis’ Yellow Pages social media reports provide insight into what’s happening in the social media realm.

“When you look at the annual Yellow Pages social media reports, 2014 especially, you’ll see that the decline of usage in Australia is in fact miniscule,” Olive says.

“Yes, more under 25s are turning to Snapchat and Instagram, but they’re still using Facebook as their ‘central activity hub’.”

Thinktank’s Snowden says more recent social media players such as Snapchat and Instagram have embraced the population’s penchant for personalised content.

“Yet Facebook has chosen to remove this control from its users, choosing to let the highest bidder’s content influence what we see on the platform,” he says.

It’s this removal of user control and the monetisation of Facebook that now, a decade later, is ultimately leading to the platform’s demise.

Ex-Myspace communications strategist Paul Armstrong has some words of warning for the social media giant.

He writes in The Guardian: “As a rule, Facebook pushes away from content whereas Myspace devoured it. Facebook is more a tool than Myspace ever was. Both had similar features but at its core Myspace was about self-expression.

“Once you stop looking at both companies purely as social networks and consider the ways in which Facebook is similarly vulnerable, it becomes clear how it could fail in the same way – or even more spectacularly – than Myspace.”

Armstrong says Facebook needs to make sure it’s not overly focused on advertising, it needs to stop keeping its users dumb and must make sure it doesn’t lose sight of the fundamentals.

Suz Koch, account director from social media agency We Are Social says there’s little value in comparing the two platforms as they are not equal products.

“It’s not an apples to apples situation,” she says. “I do agree that there could be a negative outcome if Facebook play too much with the news feed and don’t let you see enough stuff from the actual people you care about which is why you’re on there in the first place.

“There wasn’t the same uptake on Myspace as there has been with Facebook. I do think there is a bit of scepticism now about what’s happening in the news feed and that could potentially have an effect on the number of people who use the platform or how it’s used.

“That’s probably how it’s going to change. The interaction with the news feed will change the expectations that we have of what Facebook does. But because it’s reached that critical mass I think people will always have a Facebook account because it connects you with the people you care about and does it in an easy way.”

Still, Thinktank’s Snowden says Facebook hasn’t learnt from Myspace’s mistake.

“The platform’s longevity may have outlived Myspace, but its executives certainly haven’t learnt from the platform’s biggest mistake, prohibiting its users’ personality from controlling the platform’s longevity.”

Please login with linkedin to comment

Advertising Standards Bureau Affiniti Google Play Lenovo Nine Online ads PartnerReach StorageCraft The Smith Family

Latest News

Switch Digital Nabs Simonds Homes Account
  • Advertising

Switch Digital Nabs Simonds Homes Account

Digital media agency, Switch Digital, has been appointed to handle the Simonds Homes account. Their remit covers digital media, including strategy, technology and real-time performance and investment reporting. Previously Simonds Homes has used multiple agencies to service its account but felt they needed a single view of their buyers and the entire buyer journey. Several […]

Stuff You Should Know Podcast Remains As Most Listened To Show
  • Media

Stuff You Should Know Podcast Remains As Most Listened To Show

ARN and iHeartPodcast Network’s Stuff You Should Know podcast has topped the list for most listened to podcast shows in July, according to Triton Digital’s Australian Podcast Ranker. Meanwhile, seven new shows appear in the Top 100 Podcast Ranker this reporting period, including Guru: The Dark Side of Enlightenment (Wondery), She’s On The Money (ARN/iHeartMedia), SCA Victoria News (SCA-Triple M), and WTF […]

Out Of Home Industry Half Year Revenue Dives 35.4%
  • Media

Out Of Home Industry Half Year Revenue Dives 35.4%

The Out of Home (OOH) industry today announced its half year net media revenue results, posting a 35.4% dip compared to this time last year. Roadside billboards posted $129.7 million in 2020, compared to $176.8 million in 2019. The roadside other category (street furniture, bus/tram externals, small format), saw $78 million in revenue, down from […]

Media Agencies To Pilot RadioMATRIX, A World-First Virtual Workspace
  • Media

Media Agencies To Pilot RadioMATRIX, A World-First Virtual Workspace

Australian radio broadcasters are working with major media agencies on the development of a world-leading virtual workspace that will be a key component of the industry-wide ad buying platform, RadioMATRIX. Nineteen agencies will participate in the pilot program, which provides them with a single interface to connect with 370 radio stations and collaborate on media […]

One Daydream Expands Into Alcohol Category
  • Marketing

One Daydream Expands Into Alcohol Category

Sydney and Melbourne based PR, Talent & Digital agency One Daydream has extended its client portfolio to include alcohol. The category expansion comes as One Daydream joins the agency roster of Pernod Ricard, working on a project basis to manage strategic PR and digital campaigns. The global drinks group boasts one of the most comprehensive and prestigious […]

Growth Tank Launches First Virtual Youth Marketing Australia Conference For Free
  • Marketing

Growth Tank Launches First Virtual Youth Marketing Australia Conference For Free

This year due to COVID-19 restrictions, Growth Tank will host the first ever Youth Marketing Australia (YMA) event virtually on 3rd & 4th September 2020 with complimentary tickets available for Australian marketers joining from the comfort and safety of their living rooms. Youth Marketing Australia (YMA) 2020 is a two day, thoughtfully curated event designed […]

Modern interior with furniture and creative business sketch on wall. Success and solution concept. 3D Rendering
  • Media

Commtract Appoints New Business Development GM

Commtract today expanded its marketing, advertising and digital offering in response to a growing number of CEOs outsourcing to ‘gig-workers’ amid COVID-19. According to new research, 40 per cent of Australian CEOs are planning on outsourcing to freelancers in the contingent workforce. Commtract, which launched in 2016,  has more than 4,000 communications experts on its platform, and has already placed over 800 roles. […]

10 Play Boasts Platform Boost With 23% Increase In Monthly Unique Views
  • Media

10 Play Boasts Platform Boost With 23% Increase In Monthly Unique Views

Network 10’s broadcast video on-demand (BVOD) platform, 10 Play, is having its biggest year ever achieving significant audience milestones. Some of this includes: A 29 per cent lift in minutes viewed across the year-to-date. A 23 per cent increase in monthly unique viewers year-to-date. Its biggest three weeks ever. Six of the top 15 commercial […]

TAC Unveils Its Annual ‘Split Second’ Film Competition For Budding Young Industry Creatives
  • Advertising

TAC Unveils Its Annual ‘Split Second’ Film Competition For Budding Young Industry Creatives

Now in its third consecutive year, Victoria’s Transport Accident Commission (TAC) Split Second film competition is back for 2020. Conceived by TABOO in 2018 for the TAC, the film competition calls on budding young filmmakers aged 18 to 25 to develop their own 45-second film idea highlighting mobile phone related driver distraction. This year’s exciting […]

Digital marketing. Businessman touching darts aiming at the target center with icon network connection. Business goal and technology concept
  • Media

Publift And LiveRamp Launch Partnership For Small And Mid-Sized Publishers

Publift today announced its endorsement of LiveRamp’s cookieless Authenticated Traffic Solution (ATS), positioning it as Australia’s first publisher monetisation platform to offer addressable, programmatic marketing without the use of third-party cookies. With ATS, Publift delivers a cookieless marketing solution directly to small and medium-sized publishers on its platform, enabling publishers to seamlessly connect their first-party data with marketer demand. […]

WPP Acquires Perth-Based Digital Creative Agency Meerkats
  • Advertising
  • Technology

WPP Acquires Perth-Based Digital Creative Agency Meerkats

WPP AUNZ has acquired leading WA digital and creative business solutions company Meerkats, as part of the company’s strategy to boost client capabilities announced earlier this year. As part of the agreement Meerkats will merge with Wunderman Thompson in WA, building the brand’s Perth capability to more than 50 employees and creating a specific Experience […]

303 MullenLowe Sydney Confirms Bart Pawlak As New ECD
  • Advertising

303 MullenLowe Sydney Confirms Bart Pawlak As New ECD

303 MullenLowe Sydney has appointed accomplished creative leader Bart Pawlak, as its new ECD. Pawlak has been working with the agency over the last four months, leading the department over this period. Pawlak is an awarded creative director and writer with two decades of experience working within the major advertising networks, most recently as executive […]

Oakley Reprises Bob Marley’s ‘One Love’ In Powerful Ode To Sport
  • Campaigns

Oakley Reprises Bob Marley’s ‘One Love’ In Powerful Ode To Sport

Oakley has unveiled a powerful remake of Bob Marley’s iconic anthem One Love as part of the brand’s 2020 For the Love of Sport Campaign. The official release aims to inspire hope and positivity during a time of uncertainty by celebrating sport and how it can enlighten and uplift. The reworked verses were co-written by […]

“We’ve Seen Lots Of Doggers!” Weather Reporter Hilariously Muddles Dogs & Joggers
  • Media

“We’ve Seen Lots Of Doggers!” Weather Reporter Hilariously Muddles Dogs & Joggers

The perils of live TV were once again on show on the venerable BBC yesterday when a weather reporter managed to mangle joggers with dog walkers and came up with doggers. BBC weather reporter Carol Kirkwood was reporting live from the beautiful Greenwich Park in London yesterday when she managed the red-faced clanger. “Good morning […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Women in Media: A Look Back At The Best Ads Championing Equality
  • Campaigns
  • Media

Women in Media: A Look Back At The Best Ads Championing Equality

The B&T Women in Media Awards, presented by Bauer Media, has always been about recognising the power of individuals. But the awards also shines a light on the best use of creativity and advertising to champion the promotion of women. It’s a relatively new category, ‘Best Ad Campaign – Championing the Equality Cause’, but its perhaps […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine