Yesterday, Omnicom’s acquisition of the Interpublic Group of Companies was finalised. Does it mark the start of a new golden age of advertising or a false dawn symptomatic of disturbing trends at place across the industry? Kate Smither, AKA The Tall Planner, opines here.
It’s not quite the dark ages but it is certainly the start of the end of institutional knowledge. Like a perfect storm, redundancies, technological change, operating model change and brands breaking up with holdcos are all pushing the industry towards one inevitable era. One where not knowing will overwhelm legacy and knowledge.
Put simply, the industry is losing its muscle memory. As much as we focus on long term impact for our clients, we are settling for short termism in our industry
In Men in Black the device that did this was called a Neuralyzer, a device used to erase memories of witnessing alien activity. In adland, it is just called 2025.
It seems that breaking up is not that hard to do after all, if you look at the industry trends over the last couple of years. The industry has perfected the cruel art of sudden and mass “it’s not you it’s me” redundancies. Often at the senior level, these brutal “break ups” have created a loss of over 100 years of experience. This experience drain is in turn creating the juniorisation of the industry.
The challenge, of this juniorisation is not how you to manage new thinking and new technologies, or how to accommodate a whole new workforce, it’s how to create defendable value for agencies.
It is redefining what the industry is “selling” as more junior roles get redefined by AI, as the top level of expertise gets stripped out, and as clients look for greater cost and process efficiency. We might just be letting the mission of efficiency replace expertise. Ironic really given that the experts are more likely to be more efficient,
The state of the industry today feels like it is on the brink of something…. question is, is it something good? Or something bad?
What we know is that with everything now up for grabs. With In-housing, AI, the merging or blurring of hold cos and erosion of agency brands, massive change is inevitable, it’s just that success is not guaranteed
Forbes puts it like this, when writing about how you learn, unlearn and relearn “Each time someone leaves their job, a chunk of the organisation’s memory leaves too. How, then, do you run complex systems, see through long-term projects, or avoid past mistakes? Short-term contracts and outsourcing reduce the appetite for learning company or product history. And when job losses land, even more knowledge is lost.”
You can’t really put a financial cost on it, but if you look at our industry now, over 100 years of experience has bled out of the industry, and I am not sure we have time to regain it.
We have definitely done the unlearning Forbes speaks of, but the relearning may just be impossible
Experience drain differs from brain drain. Brain drain is where talent leaves the market often, the country whereas experience drain means not just the loss of talent in this way but also the devaluing of experiences.
In a tough market like this one, experience drain seems to be the result of putting the “short term pain for long term gain” theory into action. Often, it’s the most experienced, the most tenured and the most expensive that are drained from the industry. It’s a financial preservation as much as anything, aimed at getting cost “off the books” so that in a tricky market, the overall numbers look more stable.
In reality though, this short termism is the equivalent of turning up with a knife to the gun fight of agency survival.
So, what is the logic for encouraging, facilitating and allowing this experience drain?
In an atmosphere of crazy change, one hope is that by letting the legacy and experience of a business go, you are free to reinvent yourself and change everything from the position of a clean slate.
Problem is that the idea of a clean slate turns out to be slightly misleading and a long way from the ideal condition for reinvention. Reinvention needs context and that context usually comes with people who have been through change before and know how to win.
Maybe what advertising’s amnesia is doing is simply levelling the playing field. If no one has the history, the context or the experience to win at change, we’re all starting from scratch.
This will go down in history as the week where the merger of Omnicom and IPG was globally green lit, and the acquisition was finalised. I say it will go down in history, but to be honest if the big brands like DDB are “retired” it will be more like a 10-year-old banned from social media until they are 16, the next generation of adlanders just won’t know any different. The future will be whatever it wants, totally untethered from the past. Institutional memory lost.
The loss of institutional muscle memory is creating a period of “great undoing” where the models and structures of the past that developed over time and stood the test of it are being smashed apart. This undoing will liberate specialisms again. Rather than agencies being ‘full service” and able to do everything, you will get new offerings where the client is in charge and can choose who and what they need and when, not to mention where, they buy it from. It is going to be a much scrappier freer marketplace
But this in turn is one definite advantage of the amnesia advertising has created for itself. A lot of expertise and experience is surrounding the industry but not in agencies. It is going to give clients more choice than ever before as it empowers them to build their own brand dream teams of thinking, of creativity and of skills.
It may not be compounding knowledge in the traditional sense but this might just be the new competitive advantage, compounding different experience around a brand and business.
If 2025 was a year of breaking up and undoing, of unlearning and forgetting, maybe 2026 and beyond will be the start of learning once again. The tricky part is that learning is faster and more effective with mentors involved but, the industry’s amnesia may have made that wishful thinking.

