ACCC Ad Tech Inquiry: Here’s What They’re Saying

The ACCC has released submissions from the current digital advertising services inquiry.
First announced in February, the inquiry follows on from the regulator’s landmark Digital Platforms Inquiry and is being carried out by the ACCC’s newly created Digital Platforms Branch.
The inquiry, set to produce an interim report by the end of 2020, investigates the competitiveness of digital advertising, concentration of power, the auction and bidding processes and the distribution of ad spend between publishers and ad tech providers.
There have been calls to increase the viewability into advertising technologies in recent times, after an ISBA/PwC report out of the UK revealed 15 per cent of programmatic ad spend remains unaccounted for.
With vertical integration a key focus of the inquiry, Google acknowledges it is ” one of the ad tech providers that is present at more than one level of the ad tech supply chain”.
However, the search engine giant indicates that this vertical integration can reduce costs for businesses (presumably on advertising spend), with these savings then passed on to the consumer.
Google points to Adobe, Amazon, AT&T/Xandr, and Verizon Media as other ad tech providers that are vertically integrated along multiple parts of the ad tech stack.
And while Google is one – if not the – highest-earning advertising companies in the world, it maintains it is just one piece in the ad tech ecosystem.
“Most ad tech providers, including vertically integrated players, enable advertisers and publishers to use their products in conjunction with other providers’ products. Google is no different,” the company says.
“Our products work well together, but we also enable publishers and advertisers to use them with the ad tech products of other providers, and many advertisers and publishers do so to benefit from the different innovative features offered by various ad tech providers.”
In terms of mergers and acquisitions, which is another area of focus for the inquiry, Google points out that its ad tech acquisitions have occurred “mostly in the 2008-2011 timeframe when ad tech was less developed”.
When it comes to transparency, although it points out the importance of being able to provide accurate metrics to clients, Google recognises the issues that are apparent in the ad tech ecosystem.
Fragmentation is one of the key culprits, says Google.
“Lack of transparency can arise from the variety of services and number of service providers in programmatic ad transactions, rather than the practices of individual ad tech providers,” the company says.
“Advertisers (and in particular ad agencies in Australia) and publishers multi-home among many different vendors and solutions, which contributes to complexity.”
Google also suggests that it is at times limited in the amount of data it can share on digital advertising, given consumer privacy concerns.
As part of its response, Facebook seeks to clarify its role in the digital advertising landscape, which it maintains has been misconstrued in the inquiry.
With the ACCC’s talks so often centring around ‘tech giants’, Facebook indicates that when it comes to ad tech, it is being unfairly bundled in.
“The ACCC’s issues paper in this Inquiry (Issues Paper) inaccurately states that Facebook operates across multiple parts of the Australian advertising ecosystem and is vertically integrated. This is not correct,” the submission states.
“Our role in the ad tech supply chain is—as set out above—limited, and we are not vertically integrated: we do not provide publisher ad servers, we do not run publisher-side auctions and we do not independently offer market-wide analytics.
It is important that, going forward, this Inquiry recognises the limited role we play in the ad tech stack and acknowledges that our advertising business is very different from other more prominent players in the ad tech stack.”
Although Facebook does operate Facebook Audience Network for third-party publishers, the “the vast majority of ads delivered using our advertising solutions are surfaced on our owned and operated platforms”, the company says.
Microsoft
Another ‘tech giant’, Microsoft instead points its finger at Facebook and Google as the most influential players in digital advertising, specifically display.
“Each platform is a gateway to a massive universe of users for digital advertising purposes that cannot be replicated or achieved in any other way,” Microsoft says.
“Their size and user engagement mean that the only way to practically run display advertising campaigns that reach users online in a targeted way is to include those platforms.
“In other words, major brand owners seeking to reach millions of users could not substitute other platforms to achieve advertising campaigns of similar scale to a targeted audience.”
Sheer scale also makes Google and Facebook the market leaders in tracking and measurement, says Microsoft, both through ‘tags’ on websites and mobile data.
“This means that Google and Facebook are better able to track users, demonstrate the effectiveness of any particular advertising efforts, and enable advertisers to adjust campaigns to maximize their effectiveness,” the submission says.
“Given the importance of measured performance in driving advertisers’ decisions on how to allocate expenditure in display advertising, these advantages are likely to create a barrier to entry for potential rivals.”
verizon media
In its submission, Verizon Media makes mention of perhaps the most pressing issue for the advertising technology industry at the moment – Google Chrome’s discontinuation of third-party cookies.
As Verizon points out, such a change has the potential to impact competitiveness in the space.
“For example, the shift away fromcookies could require competing ad intermediaries (who do not also operate a browser) to adopt different identifiers to continue operating and an identifier acceptable to the browsers,” the company says.
Verizon floats the idea of certain ad ‘intermediaries’ being unable to adapt to the upcoming change in cookie policy, which is scheduled for next year.
Verizon also adds weight to calls for independent verification to improve pricing transparency in the industry, with blockchain technology floated as a potential solution.
“Verizon Media and others are beginning to test these technologies in some markets and will evaluate the results to identify the outcomes they deliver relative to the engineering costs involved,” Verizon says.
“Such market-led initiatives seek to enhance transparency between parties without the need for forced disclosures.”
Latest News

Sex, Sins & Single Source Storytelling
In this guest post, Jen Dobbie (main image), creative director at Hotwire Australia, says ultimately advertising is merely storytelling and offers her expert tips to put more zing in your brand’s tale… The Wicked Bible is a deliciously named, and tempting title for a storied series of mistakes published in 1631. Its pages house the […]

University Of South Australia And KWP! Join Forces To Launch Unstoppable, A New National Brand Campaign
The University of South Australia promptly remembered where they were based and scurried back into a barrel in Fremantle.

William Grant & Sons Australia Announces Partnership With De Kuyper, Two New Roles On Offer
In addition to increasing the nice European booze available in Aus, the acquisition includes some truly strange jobs.

Instagram May Not Be Working Properly For All Users Today
Reports today that Instagram has chucked a bit of a tech wobbly. You don't see print doing that now, do you?

AFR’s Latest Rich List Proves Grim For Media Moguls As Tech & Miners Dominate
Gina Reinhart again tops rich list after inheriting all that cash from Dad. Still proving a rather sour woman to boot.

Triple J To Celebrate Reconciliation Week With Indigenous Takeover
In bad news for lovers of John Farnham's seminal Whispering Jack, triple j reveals plans for Indigenous music takeover.

ABC Journo Goes Viral After A Scarf Is Mistaken For A Dildo During Live Cross
Think it's a quiet day on the B&T news desk today? Confirm it with this nonsensical scarf-not-dildo story here.

The Oz Publishes List Of 100 Game Changers In The Arts
The OZ reveals our hottest art creatives. Yet, the visceral work of Ken Done & the wobble board again cruelly neglected.

Blooms The Chemist Comes Up With Creative New Media Portal To Handle Its Physical And Digital Campaigns
Blooms The Chemist is digitising how it manages owned media, rolling out a dedicated supplier media portal capable of managing in-store and online campaigns across its 110+ pharmacies. The Australian pharmacy sector has seen significant growth, accelerated by the COVID-19 response. At the peak of the country’s pandemic, retail pharmacy sales surpassed $800 million, up […]

Thursday TV Wrap: The Chase & MasterChef Pull Solid Numbers, As Seven Nabs The Night
You'd think B&T's TV reporter never left the house given this thorough precis. Fuelled on Uber Eats & cheap sav blanc.

After Hanging Up Her Yellow Skivvy Former Wiggle Emma Watkins Is Heading To The ABC
Former Wiggle Emma Watkins reveals move to the public broadcaster. Says she's also indifferent to fruit salad.

Agnes Media Appointed By Education Fintech Brand ZeeFi
Independent media agency Agnes Media has been appointed by ZeeFi, Australia’s only ‘buy now pay later’ finance solution designed specifically for the education sector.

Passerby Waves Hand Gun At TV Reporter Doing Live Cross On American Gun Violence!
What is it with Americans? They can put a man on the Moon but decent beer, coffee & gun control is utterly beyond them.

DDB’s Macca’s ‘Australiano’ Coffee Gets Roasted For Appropriating Indigenous Ingredients
US fast food chain in strife for Australian-themed coffee misappropriating Indigenous ingredients. If that makes sense?

Under Armour Returns As Footwear And Apparel Partner For City2Surf
The B&T office is once again enrolled for City2Surf 2022, with grand plans to even attempt it sober this year.

Ellen DeGeneres Closes Out Her Show By Revealing She Couldn’t Say The Word Gay
It's the final curtain for Ellen's chat show. Despite B&T thinking it ended sometime ago after she insulted the staff.

Case Study: How MediaCom’s WHISKAS’ #CatsInBoxes Campaign Saw A 70% Uplift In Sales & Score A Number Of Awards
This WHISKAS case study isn't solely for cat lovers. However, cat haters are well advised to use discretion.

Netflix And Grill’d Team Up For National Burger Day With Stranger Things Inspired Burger
Grill'd are experts in using the word "health" in its marketing, therefore enabling it to charge four times the price.

Dan Astey To Join Triple M Breakfast In Brisbane
Dan Astey joins Triple M Brisbane's brekkie crew. Which, admittedly, isn't as good as Rick Astley joining said crew.

IDC And Data.ai Study Shows Mobile Vs. Console Gamer Gap Is Getting Even Bigger
data.ai (formerly App Annie), the first unified data ai company, today in partnership with IDC, released the Gaming Spotlight 2022 report. Powered by Game IQ, the report reveals that mobile gaming represents 61 percent of the overall gaming market which is set to hit $222 billion in 2022. The report reveals that mobile gaming is […]

Nielsen Teams Up With TikTok To Unleash Greater Potential On Worldwide Marketing Insights
TikTok joins CRM, the boozy long lunch & pretending to have read Dr Byron Sharp's books in every marketer's toolkit.

Emplifi First Quarter Report Shows Investments On Ads Are Up But User Engagement Is Flatlining
Emplifi, the leading unified customer experience (CX) platform, today revealed the findings of its Q1 2022 analysis of social media spend across thousands of brands worldwide including those in Asia Pacific (APAC). While overall social media ad spend decreased in the first quarter following an impressive holiday showing, it remains significantly higher than a year […]

WPP’s Wavemaker Snares Audible’s $700 Million Media In Global Win
Wavemaker staff start Friday pilgrimage to North Sydney's Rag & Famish early after doing not much to secure latest win.

Bohemia Australia Nabs Paul Hutchison From Wavemaker UK For CEO Role
Bohemia looks to the UK for its latest CEO. Yet, no plans to instal a picture of Her Majesty in office reception.

Ogilvy Unveils NSW Government’s Latest COVID PSA “Little Things”
New government PSA urges us all not to be complacent about COVID. You should also eat your vegetables & wear a condom.

Reconciliation Australia Launches National Reconciliation Week Campaign Via Carbon Creative
Reconciliation Australia and Carbon Creative will launch National Reconciliation Week 2022 tomorrow, Friday, 27 May (running through to 3 June) with the theme ‘Be brave. Make change.’ The theme and campaign, developed by social change creative agency Carbon Creative in collaboration with emerging Torres Strait Visual Artist Tori-Jay Mordey, challenges all Australians—individuals, families, communities, organisations, […]

Pearman Media Appoints Tara Lamond As Group Business Director
Tara Lamond clearly startled by large swarm of marauding killer bees outside window during office photography session.

Beyond the Rainbow: How Brands Can Better Connect with LGBTQIA+ Consumers All Year Round
It's tips on how brands can connect with the LGBTQIA+ community. Flannelette & marble wash denim still not resonating.

Wide World Of Sports Radio Will Air Nationally From November
Who needs the visual appeal of watching sports like NRL and AFL when you can listen to them on National radio?

Samsung Launches New Refrigerator Campaign In South Korea, And It’s Wild
Apparently selling fridges wasn't 'cool' enough for Samsung, so now they've got a meme-fueled campaign in South Korea.

Anne Hathaway & Zendaya’s Bulgari Ad Feels More Like A Movie Trailer In The Best Way
Lux brand Bulgari enlists two Hollywood A-listers for latest campaign. Like, who were you expecting? Sharon Strzelecki?

Templafy Lands David Nemes As APAC Regional Director
LinkedIn and Buzzfeed will certainly be lost without Nemes, who is making the leap into the world of online documents.

IAS Signal Will Now Include Total Visibility Dashboard In Latest Update
The news brought so much excitement to the B&T team that we all lifted our heads off our desks and cheered for a minute.

Today Is National Sorry Day
B&T would like to take time out from the usual programming to acknowledge National Sorry Day today.

Wednesday TV Wrap: Charlie Pickering’s The Weekly Delivers, As Nine Snags The Night
If there's one group sad about ScoMo's defeat it has to be ABC comics decrying the lack of material.

‘The Sims 4’ Now Lets You Use Your Own Pronouns For Your Characters
The latest entry in EA and Maxis’ life simulation series, The Sims 4, has released a new update which allows players to customise their character’s pronouns. This new feature is available only in the English version of the game for the time being, with the developers saying that they will soon release it for other […]