The ACCC has released submissions from the current digital advertising services inquiry.
First announced in February, the inquiry follows on from the regulator’s landmark Digital Platforms Inquiry and is being carried out by the ACCC’s newly created Digital Platforms Branch.
The inquiry, set to produce an interim report by the end of 2020, investigates the competitiveness of digital advertising, concentration of power, the auction and bidding processes and the distribution of ad spend between publishers and ad tech providers.
There have been calls to increase the viewability into advertising technologies in recent times, after an ISBA/PwC report out of the UK revealed 15 per cent of programmatic ad spend remains unaccounted for.
With vertical integration a key focus of the inquiry, Google acknowledges it is ” one of the ad tech providers that is present at more than one level of the ad tech supply chain”.
However, the search engine giant indicates that this vertical integration can reduce costs for businesses (presumably on advertising spend), with these savings then passed on to the consumer.
Google points to Adobe, Amazon, AT&T/Xandr, and Verizon Media as other ad tech providers that are vertically integrated along multiple parts of the ad tech stack.
And while Google is one – if not the – highest-earning advertising companies in the world, it maintains it is just one piece in the ad tech ecosystem.
“Most ad tech providers, including vertically integrated players, enable advertisers and publishers to use their products in conjunction with other providers’ products. Google is no different,” the company says.
“Our products work well together, but we also enable publishers and advertisers to use them with the ad tech products of other providers, and many advertisers and publishers do so to benefit from the different innovative features offered by various ad tech providers.”
In terms of mergers and acquisitions, which is another area of focus for the inquiry, Google points out that its ad tech acquisitions have occurred “mostly in the 2008-2011 timeframe when ad tech was less developed”.
When it comes to transparency, although it points out the importance of being able to provide accurate metrics to clients, Google recognises the issues that are apparent in the ad tech ecosystem.
Fragmentation is one of the key culprits, says Google.
“Lack of transparency can arise from the variety of services and number of service providers in programmatic ad transactions, rather than the practices of individual ad tech providers,” the company says.
“Advertisers (and in particular ad agencies in Australia) and publishers multi-home among many different vendors and solutions, which contributes to complexity.”
Google also suggests that it is at times limited in the amount of data it can share on digital advertising, given consumer privacy concerns.
As part of its response, Facebook seeks to clarify its role in the digital advertising landscape, which it maintains has been misconstrued in the inquiry.
With the ACCC’s talks so often centring around ‘tech giants’, Facebook indicates that when it comes to ad tech, it is being unfairly bundled in.
“The ACCC’s issues paper in this Inquiry (Issues Paper) inaccurately states that Facebook operates across multiple parts of the Australian advertising ecosystem and is vertically integrated. This is not correct,” the submission states.
“Our role in the ad tech supply chain is—as set out above—limited, and we are not vertically integrated: we do not provide publisher ad servers, we do not run publisher-side auctions and we do not independently offer market-wide analytics.
It is important that, going forward, this Inquiry recognises the limited role we play in the ad tech stack and acknowledges that our advertising business is very different from other more prominent players in the ad tech stack.”
Although Facebook does operate Facebook Audience Network for third-party publishers, the “the vast majority of ads delivered using our advertising solutions are surfaced on our owned and operated platforms”, the company says.
Another ‘tech giant’, Microsoft instead points its finger at Facebook and Google as the most influential players in digital advertising, specifically display.
“Each platform is a gateway to a massive universe of users for digital advertising purposes that cannot be replicated or achieved in any other way,” Microsoft says.
“Their size and user engagement mean that the only way to practically run display advertising campaigns that reach users online in a targeted way is to include those platforms.
“In other words, major brand owners seeking to reach millions of users could not substitute other platforms to achieve advertising campaigns of similar scale to a targeted audience.”
Sheer scale also makes Google and Facebook the market leaders in tracking and measurement, says Microsoft, both through ‘tags’ on websites and mobile data.
“This means that Google and Facebook are better able to track users, demonstrate the effectiveness of any particular advertising efforts, and enable advertisers to adjust campaigns to maximize their effectiveness,” the submission says.
“Given the importance of measured performance in driving advertisers’ decisions on how to allocate expenditure in display advertising, these advantages are likely to create a barrier to entry for potential rivals.”
In its submission, Verizon Media makes mention of perhaps the most pressing issue for the advertising technology industry at the moment – Google Chrome’s discontinuation of third-party cookies.
As Verizon points out, such a change has the potential to impact competitiveness in the space.
“For example, the shift away fromcookies could require competing ad intermediaries (who do not also operate a browser) to adopt different identifiers to continue operating and an identifier acceptable to the browsers,” the company says.
Verizon also adds weight to calls for independent verification to improve pricing transparency in the industry, with blockchain technology floated as a potential solution.
“Verizon Media and others are beginning to test these technologies in some markets and will evaluate the results to identify the outcomes they deliver relative to the engineering costs involved,” Verizon says.
“Such market-led initiatives seek to enhance transparency between parties without the need for forced disclosures.”
Australian owned and operated email and SMS marketing software company, Vision6, announced the launch of its first-ever national brand campaign and new brand platform “Simply Reliable”. Founded in 2001, Vision6 was one of the first email marketing software providers in Australia and has since been relied upon by thousands of Aussie businesses and organisations for […]
Out-of-Home media company JCDecaux New Zealand has appointed business growth specialist Adam McGregor in preparation for its bid to win upcoming local government street furniture tenders across the country. With contracts for the provision of street furniture including bus shelters across New Zealand up for renewal from late 2022, they collectively represent the biggest advertising […]
Fetch TV has announced that ABC iview will soon be available as a dedicated Virtual Playlist Channel on the Fetch platform. Virtual Playlist Channels (VPCs) were developed by Fetch to promote content discovery, and to provide a clear bridge between the traditional world of linear TV and the growing availability of on demand content via […]
Jackie Gillies, businesswoman, psychic medium and cast member of The Real Housewives of Melbourne is bringing her sassy, inspirational and adventurous spirit to her new podcast Shine It Up, With Jackie Gillies, which launches today via Acast. Hosted and distributed by the creator-first podcast company Acast, the show will offer listeners inspiration and motivation to […]
Crowdsourcing platforms DesignCrowd and BrandCrowd are promoting vaccination efforts in a unique way, launching a logo redesign contest among their networks of designers. The initiative saw iconic Australian brands such as Hungry Jack’s, Jetstar, JB Hi-Fi, and Bunnings undergo a redesign. “We thought it would be fun to see some other iconic Australian brands back […]
Jillian Davison has been named editor-in-chief of the recently relaunched Harper’s BAZAAR Australia. She will oversee all content, development and creative direction across the iconic magazine’s digital and brand platforms. Davison (pictured) succeeds Eugenie Kelly, who recently stepped down to pursue other opportunities. The announcement was made by Maureen Jordan, publisher of Harper’s BAZAAR Australia […]
Freedom Foods and 72andSunny Sydney have launched the first advertising campaign for Australia’s Own range of plant-based beverages. The campaign introduces a new visual world and identity for the brand and captures the healthy, positive feeling you get when spending time in nature and when consuming Australia’s Own certified-organic, plant-based beverages. As well as featuring […]