“This Is Not About A Gay Journalist And His Hurt Feelings”: Sky News Panellist Fires Back At Guardian Journo

“This Is Not About A Gay Journalist And His Hurt Feelings”: Sky News Panellist Fires Back At Guardian Journo
SHARE
THIS



Radio presenter Julia Hartley-Brewer has hit back at abusive tweeters complaining about the Sky News segment on the Orlando shooting that saw Guardian journalist Owen Jones leave the set in anger.

The Guardian’s Jones appeared on Sky News to discuss the newspaper coverage of the tragic shooting in Orlando, Florida at LGBT nightclub Pulse. The attack tragically killed 49 people and injured many others. Hartley-Brewer from radio company talkRADIO was a panelist on the show along with Sky News host Mark Longhurst.

Throughout the segment, Jones said it was a homophobic attack on the LGBT community, to which Longhurst responded it was an attack on all humans and their freedom in having fun.

While Jones repeatedly stated his belief it was a homophobic attack and that Longhurst couldn’t understand “because he wasn’t gay”, the debate got more heated with Hartley-Brewer jumping in too.

In a piece penned for The Telegraph in the UK, Hartley-Brewer said this was not about Jones, it was about the horrific shooting and people should remember that.

“It is not about one gay journalist and his apparently hurt feelings,” she wrote.

She said she’d received “thousands of abusive tweets” over the weekend about the segment, and called out Jones’ piece in The Guardian that said he was amazed at the lengths people would go to ignore homophobia.

“I have now watched the full exchange three times and I am still at a loss as to what Owen Jones found so disgusting,” wrote Hartley-Brewer. “And, no, that’s not because I am ignorant or stupid or a bigoted homophobe, as Owen’s delightful Twitter followers seem to think, but because nothing was said that could remotely have caused such a scene.

“Neither the Sky presenter Mark Longhurst nor I said anything that was offensive, wrong or bigoted in any way.”

During the exchange, Jones noted the others couldn’t understand the horror of the attack “because you’re not gay”.

To which Hartley-Brewer responded with in writing in The Telegraph piece: “While I can understand that someone who feels a particular affinity with victims of a violent crime may feel the pain more acutely, it’s a very worrying state of affairs if straight people aren’t allowed to be horrified by crimes against gay people.

“I’m not French or a rock music fan and yet I was horrified by what happened in the Bataclan in Paris last November. I’m not Jewish but I am disgusted by the wave of antisemitic attacks sweeping Britain and the rest of Europe. I’m not black but I am just as appalled by the murder of black people as I am those with white skin.”

Sky News’ Longhurst has reportedly apologised for the segment, saying there was never an intention to offend anyone.

In a piece on The Guardian, Longhurst’s statement reads: “As the presenter responsible for chairing the conversation, I regret that the segment ended as it did. I absolutely accept the atrocity in Florida was, of course, an attack on LGBT people, but I was also trying to reflect what was on the newspaper front pages.

“It was never my intention to offend Owen Jones and I very much look forward to working with him again in future.”

The Guardian also claims nearly 60 complaints were received by OfCom, industry regulatory body in the UK, with many of them complaining about the apparent dismissive nature of the Sky News hosts towards Jones.

In Jones’ piece about his appearance, he reiterated it wasn’t about him, however was amazed at people ignoring homophobia.

“In sum, I walked off in disgust during a discussion about the massacre: it was an instinctive reaction to an unpleasant and untenable situation,” he wrote.

“The presenter continually and repeatedly refused to accept that this was an attack on LGBT people. This was an attack ‘against human beings’, he said, and ‘the freedom of all people to try to enjoy themselves’. He not only refused to accept it as an attack on LGBT people, but was increasingly agitated that I – as a gay man – would claim it as such.

“If a terrorist with a track record of expressing hatred of and disgust at Jewish people had walked into a synagogue and murdered 50 Jewish people, we would rightly describe it as both terrorism and an antisemitic attack. If a Jewish guest on television had tried to describe it as such, it would be disgraceful if they were not only contradicted, but shouted down as they did so. But this is what happened on Sky News with a gay man talking about the mass murder of LGBT people.”

B&T has contacted Jones, Sky News, OfCom and talkRADIO for further comment but had not heard back at the time of publication.

Read Owen Jones’ full piece here.

Read Julia Hartley-Brewer’s piece here.

Read Sky News’ apology piece here.

Lead image: Screenshot via YouTube user Raheem Kassam.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Advertising Standards Bureau julia hartley-brewer mark longhurst Mobile Advertising orlando shooting owen jones PartnerReach talkradio

Latest News

Omnicom Agencies Move Beyond The Binary To Mark International Pronouns Day
  • Advertising

Omnicom Agencies Move Beyond The Binary To Mark International Pronouns Day

Omnicom agencies are committing to move beyond the binary to mark International Pronouns Day as part of Open Pride, a global employee resource group committed to inclusion and diversity. As part of the initiative, Omnicom agencies, including DDB, PHD and Clemenger Group, have committed to ensuring all policies promote gender-inclusive language and have encouraged staff […]

Lions Live Set To Launch Second Young Lions Live Award Brief
  • Advertising

Lions Live Set To Launch Second Young Lions Live Award Brief

As part of Lions Live in June, Lions Live challenged under 30s with a brief in partnership with the World Food Programme. It was free to enter, and nearly 1,000 young adlanders entered. It was such a success, Lions Live plan to run a second competition during Lions Live this week. This time the brief […]

Pause Fest To Return In 2021 As Online Event
  • Media

Pause Fest To Return In 2021 As Online Event

Festival for business and creativity, Pause Fest, has confirmed the event will run in 2021 – and will be its biggest to date. The 11th Pause Fest – named Changes – will migrate from its Melbourne home to the online world for the first time, running 1-12 March 2021. “Pause Fest has always been at […]

Shutterstock Adds Editorial Video Service
  • Media

Shutterstock Adds Editorial Video Service

Shutterstock today announced the highly anticipated addition of Editorial Video, a new premium, full-service editorial video offering that is now available for license. Critical Past, Celebrity Footage and Viral Hog are just a few of the new partners who will distribute their engaging video content worldwide through Shutterstock’s Editorial Video. In addition, current partners’ epa […]

Adobe Unveils A Host Of New Innovations As Part Of Adobe Max 2020
  • Technology

Adobe Unveils A Host Of New Innovations As Part Of Adobe Max 2020

Today at Adobe MAX, Adobe unveiled significant innovation across its Creative Cloud applications and services. In addition to ground-breaking new features like Neural Filters in Photoshop, the company released major updates to its flagship applications including Lightroom, Premiere Pro and Illustrator. Adobe also underscored its commitment to accelerating the development of mobile and multi-surface apps, with […]

Timboon Fine Ice Cream Celebrates 21 Wears With Rebrand Via Squad Ink
  • Campaigns

Timboon Fine Ice Cream Celebrates 21 Wears With Rebrand Via Squad Ink

To mark a twenty-one year milestone the iconic Victorian ice cream brand, Timboon Fine Ice Cream, has revealed a modernised new look for their take home tubs.  Tim Marwood, third generation farmer and founder of Timboon Fine Ice Cream, explains why the anniversary provoked the upgrade.  “There’s not too many small family rural based ice […]

Bendigo TAFE And Kangan Institute Launch Latest Advertising Campaign – Our Heroes
  • Campaigns

Bendigo TAFE And Kangan Institute Launch Latest Advertising Campaign – Our Heroes

Bendigo TAFE and Kangan Institute have launched their latest advertising campaign titled, Our Heroes, which is a celebration of the role their students play in the community. “Within a few short years, our students are building our houses, nursing our sick, fixing our cars, caring for our children and pets, designing our clothes – all […]