In this op-ed, Kenneth Chow, account director at The Fuel Agency, argues that brands need to look beyond imagery to build connection and trust, warning that an over-reliance on photography risks leaving brand identities without substance in an increasingly AI-generated world.
What happens when pictures disappear?
In July, eSafety released an Online Safety Advisory after more than 100 reports in three months of AI face swaps and fake videos built from school photos.
Overnight, the tried-and-true staple of school branding – the smiling student – now represents a potential child safety risk. And so, as schools re-examine their use of student imagery, they’ve leaned on a familiar playbook: workarounds. Cropping heads, shallow depth-of-field, and a suspicious number of candid shots where people conveniently have their faces turned away from the camera.
Now they’ve exposed a different problem.
Imagery is a crutch.
Imagine you suddenly live in a world where food brands have to stop showing pictures of food.
No meticulously styled food photography. No artfully laboured front-of-pack cameos. Just the brand, a plain pack, and miles of clear space where appetite appeal used to be.
That’s fine right? Good brands adapt. You’ll just try other ways to get people craving those chips / cookies / salami snacks / packaged fruit cups. The first thing you’d do is find a workaround. Break an image down into semiotics. What percentage of a strawberry can you show before it counts as food? Is a texture okay? Perhaps you’ll shoot it slightly out of focus, from an angle, and hope that the presence of crumbs is enough to hint at the presence of something delicious.
But eventually, you might come to a realisation: something’s still missing. And then you’ll be in the exact same predicament that schools have now found themselves.
When you remove the smiling student, what’s left?
As it turns out, what’s left is the backs of heads. Close-ups of hands, feet, and stationery. A conspicuous absence of warmth, humanity, or connection.
The problem, of course, is that school brands have become synonymous with pictures of smiling children. Pictures that say “you’re welcome here. You belong here. You’re safe here. You’ll find joy here.” The smiling student is so ubiquitous, so effortlessly easy that it’s hard to imagine school brands without them.
A brand is so much more than pictures. But when pictures do this much heavy lifting, they become the brand.
Showing and telling.
In a post-AI world, a heavy reliance on imagery has consequences well beyond school branding.
It’s never been easier to create a picture; it’s also never been harder to trust one.
Recent ANU research found more people thought AI-generated faces were more human than the faces of real people.
Hence we’ve become conditioned to questioning everything we see. We’ve even replaced “that’s Photoshop” with an even more dismissive epithet: “that’s AI”.
When AI tools can generate almost anything we can imagine, imagery becomes easier to produce, harder to trust, and less reliable as a source of creating distinction or connection.
Brands that have spent years relying on imagery to do the heavy lifting need to develop different ways to tell their stories.
If pictures were the answer, what was the question?
For schools, the question isn’t simply finding a replacement for the smiling student.
Human beings are hardwired to respond to faces. It’s amongst our most primal ways of recognising emotion, building empathy, and establishing human connection. There is no photographic substitute.
But, if a picture is worth a thousand words, taking thousands of pictures doesn’t necessarily tell a better brand story.
The question for brands is the same as it’s always been: how do we tell a brand story, create connection, build trust, and express emotion?
- The advisory asks schools: “Could the same story be told without showing identifiable details?” So start with the story, not the picture. Discussions about brand narratives shouldn’t be reduced to what picture to use on the school website.
- Invest in every part of the brand. Perhaps you’ll hire an illustrator or write a rousing description of canned fruit salad that’ll revive the art of back-of-pack romance copy. Maybe you’ll even bring back the classic advertising jingle or rediscover the lost art of customer service. The more consistent and distinctive these elements become, the less pressure there is on a single photograph to communicate absolutely everything.
- Stop equating better imagery with better brands. There will always be a place for photography, particularly when it’s authentic. Getty Images found 98 per cent of consumers agree authentic images and videos are pivotal in establishing trust. A powerful image can still communicate something words alone cannot. But recognise when we’re building brands that have great brand photography – or brands that are just great photography.
The picture was never the point. Pictures have only ever been a tool. It’s time for brands to (re)explore the others – and stop using imagery as a crutch.

