Google’s Gangland Case: Shooting The Messenger Or Should Digital Platforms Be Liable As A Publisher?
Google has again come into the firing line in a recent defamation case, revealing that Australian courts are prepared to hold digital platforms to task. As the power and influence of digital platforms grows, so has the controversy around just how liable Google, Twitter, Facebook and other online intermediaries should be for the content they share. In this piece, advertising and media legal experts Heidi Bruce, principal, and Winnie Lok, solicitor, of Anisimoff Legal, join B&T to discuss these developments and the broader media impact.
Pressure has been mounting in Australia for digital platforms to be held to higher standards of accountability as shown by the ACCC Digital Platforms Inquiry and the regulatory outcomes of that Inquiry which are now unfolding. This issue has hit the headlines in a big way with the US President Trump recently commencing a war on Twitter and pushing for stronger regulation of Twitter and other social media platforms.
Google was recently ordered by the High Court to pay $40,000 in damages to Melbourne lawyer George Defteros for publishing results that associated him with gangland figures and defamed him.
Bruce told B&T: “The Google and Defteros decision is controversial as it shows this legal trend in Australia, towards stronger liability for digital platforms. The court had to consider whether Google was simply an innocent messenger, or whether it was liable as a publisher.
“The High Court decided here that Google is liable. There is a push towards evening up the balance between digital platforms on the one hand and traditional publishers like news outlets and broadcasters on the other. Our laws are out of step with the influence and reach of these technologies, but our courts are willing to stretch them to hold these parties accountable.”
Lok added: “The case stretches beyond the social media giants, it has broader impacts for other online providers, including businesses that operate forums, online tools or comparison services, or Facebook pages. They can’t simply continue to view themselves as if they are innocent bystanders.”
In the early 2000s, Defteros ran a criminal law firm in Melbourne whose clients included many prominent gangland figures. In 2004, Defteros was charged with conspiracy to murder Carl Williams, his father and bodyguard. Defteros denied the charges and the charges were withdrawn.
In 2016, Defteros became aware that when searching his name on Google, the search results produced an article published by The Age in 2004 in relation to his charges, headed ‘Underworld loses valued friend at court’.
Defteros notified Google and requested that the article be removed from the search results. After Google’s failure to remove the article, Defteros sued Google for defamation, as the search results would lead readers to think that he was more than just a lawyer, he had become a confidant and friend of criminals.
The big issue in the Defteros case was whether Google could be liable as a publisher for the content that appears in its search results. At first glance, this may seem outlandish. How could Google be responsible for automated results of third-party content that depend on keywords entered by users?
The court found Google was liable for the publication by way of omission. Google’s failure to remove the article after being notified by Defteros meant that Google was responsible for the continued publication of the defamatory content. The court importantly held that, even though Google’s search engine was fully automated, Google was still considered a “publisher” on the basis that with human intervention, objectionable content could be identified and removed.
Google tried to rely on the defence of ‘innocent dissemination’ under section 32 of Defamation Act 2005 (Vic), that as a secondary publisher exercising reasonable care, they did not or would not have known that the material was defamatory. However, the court found that innocent dissemination was not available to Google as they were aware of the material after being notified by Defteros.
The court found that the defence had lapsed seven days after Google had been put on notice. Lok says, “So in a nutshell, as Google had the ability to remove content, and it was aware of the defamation and did nothing, it was liable. They were no longer an ‘innocent messenger’. You could say that once Google is put on notice it has at the most, 7 days to remove the content before it loses its defence.”
This is not Google’s first brush with a defamation lawsuit. In a similar scenario in 2016, Milorad Trkulja was successful in claiming that Google was responsible for search results and auto-completions that were defamatory as it linked Trkulja’s name and image to Melbourne’s criminal underworld. The High Court ruled that Google’s participation in showing the results to users made it the publisher.
Google has also been sued by the ACCC for misleading or deceptive conduct, for displaying sponsored ads that were generated through its AdWords by advertisers in its search results. The High Court here decided that Google was not liable. In publishing the sponsored ads, Google was simply carrying out the advertiser’s instructions, and Google was not endorsing the information displayed in the advertisement. The Court considered that consumers would understand that the ‘sponsored’ links are ads that have been paid for by businesses to appear on search results pages.
Google successfully relied here on an “innocent messenger” defence, in Section 251 of the Australian Consumer Law. This defence provides that a party is not liable for breaching the Australian Consumer Law if they a) publish or arrange for the publication of advertisements; b) received the advertisement for publication in the ordinary course of business; and c) did not know or had no reason to suspect that the publication of the advertisement would breach the Australian Consumer Law.
Bruce commented: “Unlike in Defteros, the ‘sponsored links’ case was favourable for Google and digital platforms. However, if Google had been notified that the sponsored ads contained misleading claims and failed to remove it, Google may very well have been liable. The current thinking of the courts as we have now seen is, once Google knows about a breach and does nothing, it is no longer an innocent messenger. This could leave digital platforms in uncomfortable situations where they receive complaints on content that look fine on the surface, but they take a risk by turning a blind eye.”
The Defteros case has broader implications on digital platforms, but also operators of online forums, Facebook pages or review platforms. This is strengthened by a very recent NSW Court of Appeals decision, holding media companies (ie Fairfax Media, Nationwide News and Australian News Channel), liable for allegedly defamatory comments made on their Facebook pages. These comments were written by third party users, under stories on the media companies’ Facebook pages. They were not pre-vetted. However as they allowed people to post comments, and had the means to delete posts when they became aware they were defamatory, they were liable as a publisher.
These cases show that a business does not need to be the original publisher to be liable for defamation law. Even if the content is written by a third party user on a Facebook page, or shared on Facebook, or comes up on a Google search, an online business may not be merely an innocent messenger, free from liability. Once it is notified that material is potentially defamatory or misleading, it then risks being liable if it does nothing. The Australian Government has flagged a major overhaul to defamation laws, and also set up a road map for changes to the regulation of digital platforms.
Bruce said: “We are seeing a move towards stronger liability for digital platforms. The regulators and the courts are seeing that the freedoms enjoyed by digital platforms in their formative years are now out of date. We still have traditional news publishers and broadcasters very heavily regulated, but a much lighter set of rules for digital platforms. In Australia the future looks to be heading towards evening up that balance.”
To discuss a related media or advertising legal issue with one of the experts at Anisimoff Legal please contact us here or email us at enquiries@anisimoff.com.au
Latest News
Scroll Media Recruits Costa Panagos From Twitch
Digital publisher network Scroll Media has employed ex-Amazon Twitch gaming executive Costa Panagos (lead image) to strengthen its Scroll Gaming capability. Panagos is highly experienced in game advertising and media sales professional with two years in account management at Twitch and three years in media sales at News Corp, so will bring his extensive media agency […]
Year13, Microsoft & KPMG Australia Launch AI Course For Gen Zs
School-leaver service Year13 has launched a new Artificial Intelligence course to upskill young people in AI, made in collaboration with Microsoft and KPMG, at an event to rally industry support behind youth AI fluency. The free online course AI Amplified which is part of Year13’s Academy aims to provide all young people with the opportunity […]
General Motors Snares Heath Walker From Scania
General Motors has announced the appointment of Heath Walker (lead image) as the new marketing director for GM Australia and New Zealand, effective April 23, 2024. Walker brings a wealth of marketing and communications experience gained from working across various industries, including IT, sporting, and auto – notably Tesla, Nissan and most recently, Scania in […]
VML Launches New “Envoyage” Brand For Flight Centre
VML unveils new brand for travel operator Flight Centre. Alas, no sign of those paid actors pretending to be pilots.
Subaru Places Media Account Up For Review
Subaru puts media up for review, as adland journos get set for mandatory "agency drives off with..." headline.
TV Ratings (17/04/2024): Contestants Faced With Harsh Realities As Alone Australia Heats Up (Or Cools Down)
Alone still doing the business for SBS. Overly long train journeys not doing the business, but they persist anyway.
Ben Fordham Loses Number One Spot As Ray Hadley Celebrates 156th Ratings Win
The radio numbers are in! Discover who's off for a boozy lunch today & who's waiting for the dreaded HR death knock.
Gourmet Ice Cream Brand Connoisseur Launches New “Thrill Your Senses” Iteration, Via SICKDOGWOLFMAN
Rattling the old "truth in advertising" adage comes this ice-cream spot full of noticeably thin people.
Paramount’s Global Sales Boss: ‘Australia’s Converged Model Is A Blueprint For How I’d Like All Of Our Markets To Be’
Paramount's global sales boss gives local sales ops the thumbs up. Didn't weigh-in on the Lisa Wilkinson debacle.
TikTok Starts Testing Its Instagram Rival In Australia
In exciting news for piano playing cats & brattish pranks in shopping centres, TikTok unveils its Insta rival plans.
Man Wrongly Named By Seven As Bondi Killer Hires Lawyers
Struggling to save for a house deposit? Why not get wrongly identified by Sunrise!
Smartsheet Appoints Indie Agency Sandbox Media To Its Media Account
Can't stand your colleagues? Like to dob them in when they miss a deadline? These work management platforms are ideal.
Boss Not Letting You Come To Cannes In Cairns? Use This Business Case To Convince Them!
Stingy boss won't spring for a ticket to Cairns? Add this to your persuasive argument repertoire. Or grovel.
Alt/shift/ Brisbane Builds Portfolio With Ausbuild Creative, PR, Content & Social Account Win
The Brisbane comms/PR agency lands constructor Ausbuild. Also hoping for a discount on its new glass conservatory.
Young Guns Versus The Old Guard: Who Adds More Value to Our Industry?
Cannes In Cairns poking this hornet's nest in a lively debate. Just so long as the oldies can get up the stairs.
70% Of Aussies Don’t Have Green Power Plans ENGIE Says In Major Brand Campaign Via HERO
Are you the notorious "light leaver on-er" in your flatshare? Quell any infighting with this green energy news.
PrettyGood Launches Offering Brand & Media Solutions For Australasian SMEs
B&T applauds the charitable nature of this new agency. Although we'd hate to see it impact any Chrissie present sends.
A Blunt End: Dolphins Medicinal Cannabis Sponsorship At Risk
Yes, it's another NRL drug story. Yet, thankfully it doesn't involve coke in Kuta during the off-season.
Slew Of New Creative Hires At Leo Burnett Australia
Ahhh, all black! The outfit of choice for agency creatives, David Jones staff and everyone in Melbourne.
Under Armour Unveils Local “Live in UA” Campaign
American apparel brand set for yet another tilt at the Aussie market, as Nike declares "we'll see about that".
Pepsi Launches New Look, Refreshing Classic Fashion Staples Via Special PR
Are you always the bridesmaid, never the bride, as the old saying goes? How do you think Pepsi feels?
Pure Blonde Returns To A Place Purer Than Yours In New Campaign Via The Monkeys
B&T's always been a huge fan of the 'drink yourself thinner' diet plan. So big thanks to Pure blonde, vodka & tequila.
Spotlight On Sponsors: Carsales Strikes With Another Storm-Based Team
Think our hacks are living their sports journalist dreams vicariously through B&T? Confirm it with this reporting.
Commission Factory & AGL Energy Ignite Strategic Partnership To Empower Australian Energy Consumers
Concerned by global warming yet ran the fans non-stop over summer? Add to the guilt with this read.
Allied Nabs Nicola Gold From Pico International Dubai
Seasoned marketer relocates from Dubai to Sydney. Says the shopping's not as good but at least you can get a drink.
Nine’s Push For Gold, Silver & Bronze Ad Opportunities Could Break New Ground In Broadcasting
Nine insists that AI won't dominate its Olympics coverage. And not merely because Bruce McAvaney doesn't understand it.
TV Ratings (16/04/2024): Toxic City Girls Too Much For Farmer Bert
Fans calling out toxic behaviour on Farmer Wants A Wife, seemingly unaware that's the very premise of any dating show.
Kaimera Wins Afterpay ANZ Media Account
Have couriers even started to mention you're overdoing the online shopping? Probably best to avoid this Afterpay news.
Industry Reacts: Stuff Group Swoops In To Save 6pm News After Newshub Closure
As you'll read here, New Zealand's media's in a right state of flux. And nor have they forgotten 1981's underarm.
a2 Milk Launches “Only a2 Will Do’ Brand Platform In First Work From BMF
A2 milk drinkers tend not to bother everyone with their gut health issues & it's a lesson for vegans & the gluten-free.
Can You Recite It In Under 4 Seconds? Maccas Relaunches Iconic Competition With Modern Twist
Do you know what would make a fantastic ad? Drunk people at 3am trying to recite the ”two all-beef patties"
‘Liar, Liar’: Lehrmann Exposed As High Profile Defamation Case Comes To A Close
Having exhausted all avenues in his defamation case, is there only one option left for Bruce - reality television?
MECCA & Fendi Among Premium Advertisers For oOh!media Woollahra OOH Network Launch
If you've not been to the snooty suburb of Woollahra, the locals would like to thank you again for staying well away.
Yahoo Academy Announces Class Of 2024
This academy is strictly for "emerging leaders". Courses don't include 'sleeping at your desk' or 'bunking off early'.
Top 35 Media Leaders Announced For 2024 TikTok Agency Accelerator Program
Despite the ban threats, TikTok keeps marching on. Cementing its reputation as the Julian Assange of the tech.
AiMCO Announces First-Ever Diversity Webinar To Explore Inclusion In Influencer Marketing
Think influencer marketing's a little on the white side? This free webinar's for you. Sadly, it's not given TV ideas.