Court Upholds Ruling That Media Companies Are Responsible For Facebook Comments

?stanbul, Turkey - February 10, 2014: Businessman figurines standing in front of Apple iPad monitor  displaying start-up screen of Facebook application. Facebook is one of the most visited social networking website in the world.
SHARE
THIS



The Court of Appeal has upheld a ruling made last year which deems media outlets as legally responsible for any defamatory comments made on their social media pages.

The ruling comes after a consortium of publishers lodged an appeal after it was ruled the companies had “published” defamatory comments about former Northern Territory youth detainee Dylan Voller on various Facebook posts.

The comments were published on the Facebook pages of The Australian, The Centralian Advocate, Sky News Australia’s The Bolt Report, and The Sydney Morning Herald in 2016.

Despite not facing defamation proceedings for the Voller story, Bauer Media, Seven West Media and Daily Mail Australia each attempted to intervene in the appeal, given the potential ramifications of the ruling.

“Each defendant was not merely a conduit of the comment,” said Supreme Court Justice Stephen Rothman in his judgment last year.

“[They] provided the forum for its publication and encouraged, for its own commercial purposes, the publication of comments.

“A defendant cannot escape the likely consequences of its action by turning a blind eye to it.”

In this morning’s judgement, the court ruled that through arrangements with Facebook and by inviting members of the public to comment on news stories, these news outlets had “provided the vehicle for publication”.

“They facilitated the posting of comments on articles published in their newspapers and had sufficient control over the platform to be able to delete postings when they became aware that they were defamatory,” said judge John Basten.

Facebook does not allow the pre-moderation of comments, nor does it give users the ability to turn comments off.

However, the judge argued media companies could have used a filter to get rid of the majority of defamatory comments.

The decision to uphold the ruling carries with it serious ramifications for both media outlets and digital platforms.

In a submission released earlier this year, Facebook argued that by upholding the decision, media outlets would be discouraged from using Facebook altogether.

“If the Voller decision is upheld, all secondary publishers could face disincentives to participate online and enable debate and free expression,” Facebook said.

 

Please login with linkedin to comment

defamation Facebook

Latest News

A-Listers Jessica Alba & Zac Efron Star In Action-Packed, Hyperviolent Ad For Dubai Tourism
  • Campaigns

A-Listers Jessica Alba & Zac Efron Star In Action-Packed, Hyperviolent Ad For Dubai Tourism

Dubai Tourism has enlisted some serious A-list clout and added some serious violence in a new, out-of-character campaign to attract visitors to the Gulf State. The work of London agency Mother, the campaign’s called “A Five-Star Mission” and stars none other than the way-too-attractive duo of Jessica Alba and frequent Byron Bay visitor, Zac Efron. […]

“Video Killed The Radio Star, But Nothing Will Kill Video” : Vevo’s MD Steve Sos
  • Media

“Video Killed The Radio Star, But Nothing Will Kill Video” : Vevo’s MD Steve Sos

This month Vevo is celebrating 40 years of music videos – a medium that has become a cultural touchstone for anyone with ears and eyes. MTV premiered exactly forty years ago this month and changed music forever, offering a visual music medium and music lovers and advertisers have never looked back.  To celebrate such a […]

Nova Launches Live & Unrestricted For The Month Of August
  • Media

Nova Launches Live & Unrestricted For The Month Of August

Nova’s Live & Unrestricted, hosted by Tim Blackwell and Kate Ritchie, will aim to provide listeners with an escape from restrictions, dropping every Saturday morning in August on the Nova Network. Following the overwhelming response to Nova’s Kate, Tim & Joel Live in Lockdown, a one-off special to keep up the spirits of listeners locked down in […]

Spanish KFC Disguises Itself As IKEA To Lure In Customers
  • Marketing

Spanish KFC Disguises Itself As IKEA To Lure In Customers

Every city has a suburb forever laden with the epithet “where the IKEA is”. For Sydney-siders, it’s Tempe (“you know, where the IKEA is”) and in Majorca, Spain, it’s Poligno de Son Malferit (“where the IKEA is”). Granted, it still sounds much more exotic than ‘Tempe’. So, when a branch of KFC opened up in […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
WPP Revenues Back To Pre-COVID Levels, As Digital Ad Spends Soar
  • Advertising
  • Media

WPP Revenues Back To Pre-COVID Levels, As Digital Ad Spends Soar

WPP has revealed its revenues have returned to pre-COVID levels a year earlier than the world’s biggest advertising group had expected after a resurgence in global marketing expenditure fuelled by digital media.  Releasing its half-year update overnight, London head office announced first-half revenues of £6.1 billion ($A11.4 billion), a year-on-year increase of 16 per cent […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
The Misfits Partners With Business Leadership & Culture Experts To Expand Agency Offering
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

The Misfits Partners With Business Leadership & Culture Experts To Expand Agency Offering

Independent experience agency The Misfits has recently announced a strategic partnership with cultural change and leadership experts Nancy Hromin and Kate Chaffer. While the company has for a long time operated in the space of creative services, digital and content marketing, film production and events, The Misfits is now broadening this offering to include business […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
TripleLift Expands Into APAC, Naming The Trade Desk’s Henry Shelley As Managing Director
  • Technology

TripleLift Expands Into APAC, Naming The Trade Desk’s Henry Shelley As Managing Director

TripleLift has today announced an expansion in their Asia Pacific (APAC) operations, with Henry Shelley [featured image] appointed as Managing Director, based in Singapore. Fueling TripleLift‘s expansion in APAC is its success in Australia, where the company works with 70 per cent of the top 50 comScore publishers. “As the home to several of the worlds’ […]

Rob Highett-Smith Joins Fiftyfive5 In Newly Created Role
  • Media

Rob Highett-Smith Joins Fiftyfive5 In Newly Created Role

Rob Highett-Smith joins Fiftyfive5 in the newly created role of head of performance measurement. Performance measurement represents one of the three core offer areas at Fiftyfive5 with tracking programs running across 40 countries; representing our fastest growing capability pillar.  Rob joins to lead this capability, which encompasses brand and comms tracking, multi market monitoring, CX and customer satisfaction, as well as other longitudinal programmatic work.   

Customer Messaging Platform Podium Launches In Australia
  • Technology

Customer Messaging Platform Podium Launches In Australia

Podium has continued its international expansion today announcing its launch in Australia. Podium serves more than 90,000 local businesses in the United States, Canada and Australia, and has seen its customer base in Australia almost quadruple to over 3,000 local businesses since the start of the pandemic. Through its SMS-based platform, Podium helps local businesses receive […]

THE EDGE Welcomes New General Manager Emily Copeland
  • Media

THE EDGE Welcomes New General Manager Emily Copeland

Commercial DAB+ hip hop and RnB station, THE EDGE has appointed Emily Copeland, to the newly created role of General Manager. Copeland brings an awesome mix of skills and experience to THE EDGE, including cross-platform media content experience, partnerships and events (including music festivals – remember those?). Copeland also has a stack of achievements to […]

Sustainability 101 With Brianne West, CEO Of Plastic-Free, Eco-Focused Beauty Brand Ethique
  • Marketing

Sustainability 101 With Brianne West, CEO Of Plastic-Free, Eco-Focused Beauty Brand Ethique

Brianne West is the founder and CEO of Ethique, a New Zealand-based sustainable, plastic free and cruelty free skin and hair care range. West sat down with B&T to explore what genuine environmental sustainability looks like, and how brands can better respond to eco-conscious consumers. B&T: Why are we seeing a rise in eco-conscious consumption?    BW: […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Cities connected with lines on a blue globe.
  • Technology

Blis Unveils New Interactive Dashboard That Tracks Consumer Movement In Australia

Blis has today revealed its new Consumer Confidence Pulse — the most comprehensive tracker of its kind — this interactive dashboard builds on its existing trend data around consumer mood to analyse behaviour during the COVID pandemic. The dashboard also now tracks consumer movement over a rolling 13-month period, across 18 retail and lifestyle sectors […]

Australian Seniors Releases ‘Dare To Date’, Second Series Of ‘Life’s Booming’ Podcast
  • Media

Australian Seniors Releases ‘Dare To Date’, Second Series Of ‘Life’s Booming’ Podcast

Following the success of Series One: Grey Nomads, Australian Seniors has launched the second series of the Life’s Booming podcast – Dare to Date.  Hosted by James Valentine (pictured with guests Liz and Barry), Life’s Booming explores the incredible stories and addresses topics important to Australians over 50. Series two titled Dare to Date is a six-part series that covers real-life love, […]