Ehrenberg-Bass Institute: Why Public Health Campaigns Often Neglect The Simple Rules Of Advertising

Ehrenberg-Bass Institute: Why Public Health Campaigns Often Neglect The Simple Rules Of Advertising

In this guest post, Amy Wilson and Nick Danenberg, senior marketing scientists at Adelaide’s Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, take a look at Australian public health campaigns to find out what flies and what flops…

Done well, public health campaigns can encourage healthier behaviours and reduce the growing burden that health is putting on the pockets of individuals and the government. Done badly, they waste a lot of money with no benefit. We need to look to evidence-based advertising research for some clear guidelines to making campaigns more effective.

How does advertising work?

In the commercial world advertising largely works by increasing a brand’s Mental Availability – the chance of the brand being thought of or noticed in buying situations (Romaniuk and Sharp 2004).

Commercial marketers use campaigns to build mental availability for their brands by informing potential buyers that a brand exists, and then regularly reminding them. It works the same way for public health campaigns, however rather than increasing mental availability for a brand, the aim is to remind the target audience (often the entire general public) about a beneficial behavioural change (e.g. being sun smart or consuming more fruit and vegetables).

In general, the public health discipline is centred around behaviour change theories that focus on the role of information to educate consumers and affect a change in behaviour. As such, public health campaigns have overly relied on information and persuasion, an approach which has been supplanted by the evidence-based approach to advertising which seeks to remind, reinforce and nudge behaviours consistently over time.

Some rules for building Mental Availability

The Ehrenberg-Bass Institute’s research into advertising effectiveness provides some evidence-based insights for building mental availability that can be applied to public health campaigns. While there are many aspects to consider, including media choice, scheduling and reach, this article focuses on some of the creative aspects of advertising.

  • Use Distinctive assets – Distinctive Assets are creative devices (like logos, slogans, fonts or characters) that are non brand-name elements that act as mental triggers to remind people of the brand (Romaniuk, 2018).

Distinctive Assets ensure that campaigns look unique, help the ad’s message to stand out and, when used over time, create a mental link between a number of stand-alone campaigns. This ensures that they are seen as a single, cohesive, ongoing initiative which improves mental availability and the likelihood of behaviour change over time.

Distinctive Assets also help to make sure that ads look different from the competition. This is crucial, as if an ad looks like it is for another brand (or is somewhat ambiguous), it can affect sales. The same holds for campaigns that promote behaviour change. If they look like one another, people may  become confused about the health message being communicated to them. Campaigns need to stand out and cut through visual clutter so that it is easy for the public to recognise the campaign and the behaviour change it is promoting.

By campaigns we mean a single campaign which runs for a few weeks to a couple of years (e.g. ‘Go for 2 & 5’) and which may or may not be part of a broader public health initiative (e.g. to promote healthier diets).

 

We recommend using a range of distinctive assets to allow for creative flexibility across different media (e.g. radio, TV, print etc).

Examples of distinctive assets that have been used in public health campaigns in Australia include:

Screen Shot 2018-02-26 at 4.06.16 pm

  • Be Consistent – Applying distinctive assets repeatedly across all forms of communication, regardless of media choice (TV, radio, print media, online etc.) is important for building mental availability. This can build the fame of your distinctive assets, ensuring they are known and recognised by more people. 

NB: to increase the chance of your campaign reaching more people, we recommend using more than one type of media.

  • Be Engaging – People are busy and distracted. Campaigns that can cut through the advertising clutter and are engaging and likeable have a better chance of getting attention. Engaging ads are more likely to refresh and remind people about the behaviour change they are promoting. This reinforcement of the mental structures (including distinctive assets) can increase the likelihood of behavioural change.
  • Be relevantIt’s important that campaigns reflect the broad range of scenarios where people could benefit from changing their behaviour. This helps campaigns to appeal to a wider range of people and their various needs, experiences and motivations. For example, in a sun smart campaign you would want to show examples of people being sun smart at the beach, but also a range of other less obvious situations such as walking to work, out shopping, standing at the bus stop etc.

Who does it well?

It is easy to think of brands that do a great job of being distinctive, consistent, engaging and relevant, such as Coca-Cola, Cadbury, McDonald’s. However, finding good examples of public health campaigns is more challenging. Most campaigns in the public health space have, unfortunately, fallen short on at least one of the rules.

One exception is the Cancer Council’s ‘Slip Slop Slap’ campaign which launched in 1981. Sid the seagull has informed and reminded Australians to ‘Slip, Slop, Slap’ for over 30 years. Aside from the addition of ‘Seek and Slide’ in 2007, Sid the Seagull, the simple, catchy reminder to ‘Slip, Slop, Slap’ and the general look of the campaign have been consistent. Sid has also demonstrated being sun smart across various outdoor activities. Each new campaign has built on the previous one and The Cancer Council has developed strong distinctive assets and built mental availability. Importantly, the campaign has contributed to the prevention of skin cancer.

Room for improvement

In contrast, recent federally funded national campaigns aimed at promoting a healthy diet have missed the opportunity to build mental availability.

Campaigns such as ‘Be Active’, ‘Swap It Don’t Stop It’, ‘How Do You Measure Up’ and ‘Go For 2&5’ all aim to encourage Australians to adopt a healthier diet. However each of these relatively short campaigns (each on-air for less than a year) used different distinctive assets and messaging. By creating entirely new creative for each campaign the advertisers missed the opportunity to build mental availability which diminishes the likelihood of a sustained influence on behaviour. Plus, developing new creative for each new campaign is very costly.

As marketers interested in promoting health and wellbeing, we hope that our insights about advertising effectiveness can help public health campaigns achieve their goals. We encourage people working in public health promotion to use an evidence-based approach (see Romaniuk, 2018) to executing their campaigns so they get better value for money on their marketing spend and have a greater influence on behaviour change.




Please login with linkedin to comment

Ad campaigns Ehrenberg-Bass Institute

Latest News

Multicultural Comms Agency Ethnolink Announces AI-Enhanced Multilingual Campaigns
  • Technology

Multicultural Comms Agency Ethnolink Announces AI-Enhanced Multilingual Campaigns

Multicultural communications agency Ethnolink has unveiled Ethnolink Edge, a bespoke technology platform designed to streamline the initiation, planning and execution of multilingual campaigns across Australia. This system aims to boost operational efficiency in the creation of in-language campaigns, with future enhancements set to include artificial intelligence. Costa Vasili, CEO of Ethnolink and recently recognised as […]

Gate 7 Bolsters Visit California & Brand USA Teams
  • Marketing

Gate 7 Bolsters Visit California & Brand USA Teams

Integrated tourism marketing agency Gate 7 has announced the newest addition to their team, Daniel Gervais, as director for Visit California. With an extensive background in strategic marketing and communications, Gervais brings a wealth of experience to his new role. He had a notable stint as head of marketing at Airbnb, where he played a […]

Mediahub Snares Linda Fagerlund From Carat
  • Advertising

Mediahub Snares Linda Fagerlund From Carat

Full-service agency Mediahub has appointed renowned strategist Linda Fagerlund to the newly created role of chief strategy officer in Australia and New Zealand. She will be responsible for delivering Mediahub’s trans-Tasman strategic support for key clients and will also join Mediahub’s senior leadership team. Fagerlund brings 15+ years of diverse strategy experience to the new […]

BMF’s Tom Hoskins & Dave Roberts Promoted To Group Creative Directors
  • Advertising

BMF’s Tom Hoskins & Dave Roberts Promoted To Group Creative Directors

BMF has made a series of promotions, including Dave Roberts and Tom Hoskins, to the role of group creative directors. Lead image: BMF Team Hoskins joined BMF as an award-winning creative director in 2021 with a wealth of industry experience, having worked in the UK, US, Asia, and Australia. During his time at BMF, Hoskins […]

QMS Secures Toyota, Stan, Allianz and Patties Food As Paris 2024 Launch Partners
  • Media

QMS Secures Toyota, Stan, Allianz and Patties Food As Paris 2024 Launch Partners

The digital outdoor media company, which launches it Paris 2024 network today, says it will bring Olympic and Paralympic content to 80 per cent of Australian adults. Lead image: A QMS City of Sydney digital billboard on Pitt Street, Sydney. QMS secured the rights as the official outdoor partner of the Australian Olympic and Paralympic […]

Publicis Groupe APAC Strengthens Its Senior Leadership Team With Key Appointments
  • Advertising

Publicis Groupe APAC Strengthens Its Senior Leadership Team With Key Appointments

Publicis Groupe Asia Pacific has announced four key appointments as part of its efforts to strengthen its senior leadership team to power growth in the region. Lead Image:  L-R – Jessica Farrell; Pauly Grant; Anushka Methananda These appointments are promotions from within the group, reflecting the organisation’s stance on talent recognition and its success in […]

Slew Of Promotions & A New Hire At History Will Be Kind
  • Marketing

Slew Of Promotions & A New Hire At History Will Be Kind

Award-winning creative communications agency History Will Be Kind (HWBK) has built a successful first quarter with two senior promotions and a new hire. Lead image: L-R – Lizzy Chadwick, Group Account Director; Rachael Gadgil, Group Account Director, Brooke Gascoigne, Senior Account Executive  Talented senior leads Lizzy Chadwick and Rachael Gadgil kick off the year strong […]

Latto “Talks Snack” With Menulog Via Thinkerbell
  • Campaigns

Latto “Talks Snack” With Menulog Via Thinkerbell

Australian-born on-demand delivery platform Menulog has today launched a brand new social series with US rapper Latto titled ‘Talking Snack with Latto’. Created via Thinkerbell, the social series was shot when Latto was in Australia for the first time ever, shortly after Menulog introduced the next chapter of the ‘Did Somebody Say’ Brand platform starring […]

ING Invests In Finance Partnership With Seven
  • Media

ING Invests In Finance Partnership With Seven

ING has launched a finance partnership with the Seven Network. ING’s head of consumer and market insights, Matt Bowen, will feature on daily and monthly Sunrise segments and, in weeks to come, join 7NEWS. Matt will provide viewers with expert insights into the day’s top money stories and deep dives into key finance topics to […]

Gregory Jewellers Elevates eCommerce Experience With Digital Transformation Platform Via Wonderful
  • Advertising

Gregory Jewellers Elevates eCommerce Experience With Digital Transformation Platform Via Wonderful

Jewellery brand Gregory Jewellers has launched a comprehensive digital platform with integrated eCommerce and enhanced search and discovery capabilities to deliver a more seamless experience for customers. Developed by independent digital agency Wonderful, the new platform has been optimised for mobile-first and features simplified navigation across Gregory Jewellers’ extensive product catalogue. This enables customers to […]

Carsales.com.au: We Are The Kings Of Intent
  • Media

Carsales.com.au: We Are The Kings Of Intent

With around 12 million addressable, opted-in, privacy-compliant emails of Australians, carsales doesn’t see itself as competing with other online auto classifieds businesses, instead it sees itself as in the fight with Meta, TikTok and the other global tech giants. Davor Vilusic, executive general manager – media carsales, and Stephen Kyefulumya, general manager – media product […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine