“Dangerous, Irresponsible, Unethical”: Young Adlanders Are Having Their Say About Climate Change In Comms Declare’s Future Leaders Survey

“Dangerous, Irresponsible, Unethical”: Young Adlanders Are Having Their Say About Climate Change In Comms Declare’s Future Leaders Survey

It’s unquestionable that the world is currently in the grips of a climate crisis – and organisation Comms Declare wants Australia’s advertising industry to take responsibility for its role.

To do this, it has set up the Future Leaders survey, calling for people under 30 in the industry to have their say.

Belinda Noble, Comms Declare’s founder, said, “We’re absolutely hearing that young people want to work for agencies that take an ethical stand, and increasingly that excludes larger agencies with big energy clients.”

“Our agency survey last year found 87 per cent agreed that climate action is important to attract employees, but there’s still a disconnect between what agencies say and what clients they are willing to take. We say fossil fuels are the new tobacco, you can’t proclaim to be ethical while enabling their business.”

The ethical and moral questions for agencies abound: is there ever a justification for continuing to market companies that actively harm the earth?

B&T spoke to two young adlanders about the industry’s relationship to the climate, and what we can do better.

Maya Halilovic is a senior creative at 303MullenLowe. From her perspective, agencies have a significant responsibility what it comes to climate action.

“I think agencies should play a massive role in confronting climate change, if only because we are part of the reason that it exists. It’s kind of a difficult one to stomach, because if you think about it, BP and Shell Oil and Chevron and whatnot – the sort of giant polluters of the world – have and will continue to rely on agencies to lift their profile, and to talk about a ‘cleaner and greener’ future that is increasingly just a vaguer and vaguer concept,” she said.

“We have a massive role in reversing that, because we are directly contributing to it.”

Ultimately, any business or agency has a moral or ethical responsibility when it comes to taking on clients.

“If you don’t, you’re just kind of contributing to the existing problem,” she reflected. “I just feel in 2021,  I don’t really know how to continue to market something like a BP or Shell. I’m not sure what you can begin to say.”

“For all the rural the events that we host, and all the panels that we host, and all the Zoom talks that we give on a sustainable future in advertising, the first thing you need to do is to not take on clients that are digging up the earth.”

She reflected on a business and ethics class she took at university where they discussed mining. One of her fellow classmates said something that has stuck with her.

“He went: that company exists because it digs holes in the ground. So if you want those holes to stop happening, if you want to stop digging, that company has to shut down.”

“This company can’t exist.”

Sian Henderson, a senior account manager at The Bravery, shared similar reflections. She believes that, as communicators, agencies have a responsibility to lead the conversation on the climate.

“There’s many things in terms of advertising agencies and communication agencies and their roles to play. They’re literally the communicators between clients or businesses and the consumer audience, and other industry players, depending on who your client is. So there’s a huge responsibility there to make sure that we are communicating and educating and driving that awareness around climate change,” she explained.

“In another sense, it’s just a fantastic opportunity: you’ve got the biggest issue of our time happening, and as communicators that sit in the middle, we are in a position where we can really be those people to educate our clients, and people on the other side, and consumers, to understand the issues around climate change, and how people can get involved.”

Capitalising on drive and passion around the climate, she said, is a powerful tension point.

It’s clear that the climate is a priority for young people. Indeed, Henderson pointed to The Power and the Passion report published by The Bravery in collaboration with Republic of Everyone and Mobium Group this year.

It found that 36 per cent of both Gen Zs and Millennials were ‘extremely concerned’ about climate change. 82 per cent of Gen Z and 80 per cent of Millenials were also overall concerned about climate change.

This is something employers must recognise.

Lauren Piro, Quiip Brands’ human resource director said, “we know that millennials are much more values-driven and want to work for organisations with a social purpose. We find that we have applications coming to us rather than needing to advertise as people appreciate our commitment to climate change action and ethical business practice”.

Ethics are something Henderson has prioritised in her career.

“When I first went to transition into a more career oriented role, I was only looking at ethical job searches because I only wanted to work for a company that aligned with my values. That was for two really strong reasons,” she explained.

“One was, I only wanted to contribute to a positive future. We work five days a week, the majority of our lives. So, therefore, the best way to do that is to make sure that I’m aligning with a company that also does that, and we can work together to do that. Secondly, I think another interesting point is that being younger and being under 30, we have more flexibility to make those choices of who we work for, and why.”

“When you go into a workplace, or you go to school, to do something, anything that doesn’t align with who you are, there’s so much disassociation around it. I think people – especially with the pandemic – are kind of like: I’m done with that. I want to live the life that I want, I want to live, I want to feel present, I want to make sure I’m pushing for that change.”

Both Henderson and Halilovic felt the importance of agencies taking an active stance against fossil fuel-producing and climate change-enabling clients.

“If we’re not working towards a future that is sustainable, what are we doing? Where are we going? What’s the point? It’s dangerous, it’s irresponsible, it’s unethical.  I understand that not everyone feels that way, and there’s probably education that needs to be had around certain areas. But really, where we’re at now is pretty crucial,” Henderson reflected.

“We do need to start really pushing for some of those harder action items, such as saying, ‘no, I won’t work with you, you know, I’m not going to do it. I don’t want to support that’.”

But to do this, agencies need to be committed to giving young people a voice – and actively choosing to listen to it.

“Agencies hire young people because they want a youthful perspective, they don’t want to be out of touch…they want people that have their finger on the pulse,” Halilovic said.

“But sometimes they also just don’t want to hear what young people have to say. I think the opportunity is there, but you need to be empowered to do it. You need your agency to support how you feel about climate change. It is difficult to oppose it and then do work for Shell Oil or Chevron.”

Henderson explained that often, young people don’t realise the power they have. However, “in terms of actually making change, I think it really just comes down to the employer.”

She is hopeful, though, about the potentials of young people using their voices.

“What I really realized is that we have so much more power than we think we have as an individual. Then that feeds into the collective power that we have in these workplaces: just to tap into that, and see how that goes.”

You can find the Future Leaders survey here.




Latest News

Senior Appointments Expand Hatched Sydney Team
  • Advertising

Senior Appointments Expand Hatched Sydney Team

Following a raft of new business wins, Hatched Sydney has announced the expansion of its team with two new senior appointments. Lead image: Laura Comber and Berlian Ayudya. With more than a decade of media experience in Ireland, Laura Comber joined as business director alongside Berlian Ayudya who stepped into the role of strategy director […]

History Will Be Kind Builds Client Portfolio With Appointment Of Koskela
  • Advertising

History Will Be Kind Builds Client Portfolio With Appointment Of Koskela

History Will Be Kind (HWBK) has been appointed as the agency of record by Koskela, Australia’s leading furniture and design sustainability practitioner. The appointment follows a competitive pitch by the B Corp-certified business, with services to be delivered under HWBK’s impact and reputation specialism, History Matters. Working across creative brand strategy, public relations, social media, […]

JCDecaux Launches Dominion Road SMARTFRAME
  • Advertising

JCDecaux Launches Dominion Road SMARTFRAME

JCDecaux New Zealand’s latest addition to the high-impact ‘SMARTFRAME’ network arrived on Auckland’s Dominion Road. This new installation extended the SMARTFRAME network to 27 screens across Auckland, Wellington, and Christchurch. Dominion Road was the 18th frame in Auckland. It strengthened SMARTFRAME reach into city fringe suburbs, as part of the network in locations including Mount […]

Innocean Australia Announces Giorgia Butler As New Chief Strategy Officer
  • Advertising

Innocean Australia Announces Giorgia Butler As New Chief Strategy Officer

Innocean Australia CEO, Jasmin Bedir announced the appointment of senior strategist Giorgia Butler as its new Chief Strategy Officer, as the agency strengthens its full-service, connected creative and media strategy offering for clients. Lead image: left to right, Giorgia Butler, Matt Morgan, Kathryn Funari, Wez Hawes, Jasmin Bedir. Butler will be responsible for leading strategy […]

INVNT Appointed Creative Experiential Partner For SXSW 2024
  • Advertising

INVNT Appointed Creative Experiential Partner For SXSW 2024

INVNT has been announced as the Creative Experiential Partner for SXSW and sponsor and co-producer of the SXSW Sydney 2024 Discovery Stage after a successful collaboration at last year’s inaugural event. As a Creative Experiential Partner for SXSW Sydney 2024, the agency will be inviting brands and official partners of the 2024 event to collaborate […]

The Media Store Wins Melbourne Royal Show Media Account
  • Advertising

The Media Store Wins Melbourne Royal Show Media Account

The Media Store has won the Melbourne Royal Show media account following a competitive pitch process. Lead image: Stephen Leeds and Jacquie Alley. The Melbourne Royal Show is Victoria’s largest annual community event celebrating agriculture and regional life. It is held over 11 days during September and October at the Melbourne Showgrounds and has been […]

Toby Jenner: ‘The Power And Energy Of Our Good Teams Will Get Us Through Tough Times’
  • Advertising

Toby Jenner: ‘The Power And Energy Of Our Good Teams Will Get Us Through Tough Times’

Toby Jenner, global CEO of Wavemaker and now the global president of GroupM clients, said that the “power of people and teams” make the good times good, and will see the holding company’s agencies and clients through tough times. Speaking to B&T’s Greg ‘Sparrow’ Graham, Jenner explained what his new role will entail and what his […]

Foxcatcher & InMobi Partner To Enhance Media Planning And Activation
  • Advertising

Foxcatcher & InMobi Partner To Enhance Media Planning And Activation

RyanCap’s data and technology specialist, Foxcatcher, unveiled a new partnership with InMobi. This collaboration aims to refine media planning and activation with an SPO and audience match integration. The collaboration leverages extensive strategic data alliances and first-party audience data powered by Foxcatcher proprietary tools, FoxID & Worldview, supported by InMobi’s always-on audience segments. Lead image: […]

VALE Dennis Merchant – A Giant Of The Media Industry
  • Advertising

VALE Dennis Merchant – A Giant Of The Media Industry

Dennis Merchant OAM, a pioneer of Australian independent media buying, passed away yesterday at age 82. Truly ahead of his time, Merchant started the first independent media buying agency in Australia in 1974. Merchant and Partners was a powerhouse media business initially representing smaller indies that didn’t have the media scale or clout of some […]

Gravity Media Australia To Deliver Crankworx Cairns For Red Bull TV
  • Advertising

Gravity Media Australia To Deliver Crankworx Cairns For Red Bull TV

Gravity Media confirmed details for the global coverage of this year’s Crankworx Cairns. Gravity Media Australia will deliver the international broadcast technology and production outcome for Crankworx Cairns, the world’s largest mountain bike festival, from 22 to 26 May. Coverage of Crankworx Cairns will be delivered across Red Bull TV. Crankworx, a four-day festival of […]

Connecting Plots Nabs Former Saatchi & Saatchi Leader Craig Page
  • Advertising

Connecting Plots Nabs Former Saatchi & Saatchi Leader Craig Page

connecting plots has announced Craig Page as the new Strategy Partner as Tim Collier departs to pursue new opportunities. Lead image: Craig Page, strategy partner, Connecting Plots. Craig Page, esteemed integrated strategist and founder of strategic consultancy WeirdWorks, joined Connecting Plots as a strategy partner to lead the company’s strategic services. Page, who founded WeirdWorks […]

Roger Federer & Rafael Nadal Revive Core Values Campaign For Louis Vuitton
  • Campaigns

Roger Federer & Rafael Nadal Revive Core Values Campaign For Louis Vuitton

Louis Vuitton launched a new iteration of its storied ‘Core Values’ campaigns, captured by Annie Leibovitz. The campaign featured Roger Federer and Rafael Nadal as they ascended to the summit of Italy’s Dolomites mountain range. The tagline reads, “There are journeys that turn into legends”. 3,000m high, Nadal and Federer are seen not as competitors […]

One Year Later, Is BAR Ogilvy’s Livingfont Making A Difference?
  • Advertising

One Year Later, Is BAR Ogilvy’s Livingfont Making A Difference?

This International Biodiversity Day, ANP| WWF and BAR Ogilvy are reinforcing the importance of ‘The Endangered Typeface’ campaign to “protect all animal life”. When talking about the 6th mass extinction, can you really tell the difference a year makes? With the endangered typeface, a living font created in 2023 in a partnership with Associação Natureza […]

“These Issues Aren’t Unique To Our Industry”: Rose Herceg Chats To B&T Ahead Of Create Space Census Results
  • Advertising

“These Issues Aren’t Unique To Our Industry”: Rose Herceg Chats To B&T Ahead Of Create Space Census Results

On Tuesday, 21 May, the Advertising Council Australia (ACA) will host an all-industry webinar to reveal the findings of the second Create Space census. Close to 2,500 professionals from advertising, media, and marketing participated in the anonymous census in November 2023, providing an updated picture of the industry’s demographics and experiences of diversity, equity, and inclusion. […]

Kieran Moore: ‘No Client Has Ever Asked For More Junior People On Their Account’
  • Advertising

Kieran Moore: ‘No Client Has Ever Asked For More Junior People On Their Account’

Kieran Moore is one of Australia’s most experienced public relations leaders, having most recently served as the CEO of public relations, government relations, experiential and design for WPP AUNZ, following a six-year stint as the CEO of Ogilvy PR. Now as the director and principal at comms and reputation management consultancy Brangwin and Moore, which […]

Zitcha appoints Josh Forsyth as sales lead to drive retail media growth across APAC
  • Advertising

Zitcha appoints Josh Forsyth as sales lead to drive retail media growth across APAC

Following global expansion and continued strong local demand Zitcha appointed Josh Forsyth as APAC sales lead. Lead image: Josh Forsyth, sales lead, Zitcha. Australian-headquartered Zitcha, which operates across four continents in countries including the US, UK, Canada, New Zealand and South Africa, is looking to Asia as the next major emerging retail media market. In […]

Moët Hennessy NZ Adds Special PR To Agency Roster
  • Advertising

Moët Hennessy NZ Adds Special PR To Agency Roster

Special PR has been added to Moët Hennessy’s roster of communications agencies in New Zealand following a competitive pitch. Special PR will be responsible for integrated communications for Moët Hennessy across its luxury brands, including Cloudy Bay, Whispering Angel, Veuve Clicquot and Glenmorangie. The scope of work includes media relations, influencer marketing, content creation, events […]