“Couldn’t Have Been Worse”: Branding Guru Slams CA’s Handling Of Ball-Tampering Scandal

“Couldn’t Have Been Worse”: Branding Guru Slams CA’s Handling Of Ball-Tampering Scandal
SHARE
THIS



One of Australia’s leading experts on branding has severely criticised the response by Cricket Australia (CA) to the ball-tampering scandal that has rocked the sporting body.

Karl Treacher, CEO of The Brand Institute, told B&T that if he was rating the sporting body on its handling of the scandal, his score would be a zero out of 100.

“Whoever is managing the media strategy on this is demonstrating exactly zero knowledge and skill,” he said.

“If Steve Smith gets banned – which he has to – whoever is advising on reputation strategy should be walking straight out the door with him.

“I’ve never seen a sports media crisis handled worse than this. It just shows how out of touch the administration is with today’s audiences.”

CA chief executive James Sutherland (pictured above) announced late yesterday morning that Australia’s men’s Test team captain Steve Smith, vice captain David Warner and batsman Cameron Bancroft have been officially reported for breaching the organisation’s Code of Conduct and dumped from the squad that is currently touring South Africa.

“The preliminary findings have confirmed that prior knowledge of the incident in Cape Town was confined to only the three players reported,” he said.

“Sanctions are expected to be announced within the next 24 hours.”

Treacher said while it is hard to predict the long-term impact of the incident, he believes the damage will be significant in global cricket circles for some time.

“As far as implications locally with fans, this will pan out to be a drop in the ocean – an ocean made up of 150 years of world-class sportsmen behaving (relatively) appropriately,” he said.

“You only need to look at Matt Johns admitting to group sex as part of a NRL footy trip while married to realise that fan loyalty runs deep and even the biggest indiscretions will probably be forgiven. He even got his own footy show after that incident.”

Karl Treacher

Karl Treacher

A variety of well-publicised sports brand issues have now created something of reliable social precedent that predicts “supporter leniency”, according to Treacher.

“When many people become supporters of a national cricket team or whatever, they assume some the team’s identity so as to ‘go on the journey’ with them. So, to give that up means giving up something more than just their replica baggy green, it becomes very personal,” he explained.

A number of cricket sponsors including Magellan, Commonwealth Bank, Qantas, XXXX Gold, Sanitarium, Accenture, and Skins have issued powerful statements on the incident, with many of them seemingly adopting a ‘wait and see’ approach.

However, Sanitarium appears to be the first sponsor that’s taken decisive action, removing any mention of Smith in its online assets.

Steve Smith in Sanitarium ad

Treacher said the right course of action for team sponsors is different to player sponsors.

“The sponsors of teams support the dreams of children and the social structure of large subcultures that cross so many diverse societal territories,” he told B&T.

“They have little to gain by ditching the Australian cricket team and run the risk of being viewed as popularity groupies instead of brands dedicated to supporting teams through the good and tough times.

“That said, if CA continues to suggest that this is a team issue, then it would be reasonable for sponsors to pull back sponsorship until the team has been re-established under new leadership.”

Please login with linkedin to comment

ball tampering CA cricket Cricket Australia Karl Treacher The Brand Institute

Latest News

AAP Sale Formalised, Confirms Name To Be Retained
  • Media

AAP Sale Formalised, Confirms Name To Be Retained

The sale of Australian Associated Press (AAP) to a consortium of impact investors and philanthropists has been formally completed, ending 85 years of ownership by Australia’s major publishing groups. The national news agency will continue to provide a trusted breaking news service with a team of journalists and photographers, most of whom have joined the […]

Aussie Success Story Afterpay Unveils New Brand Identity
  • Marketing

Aussie Success Story Afterpay Unveils New Brand Identity

Aussie retail payments platform Afterpay has launched a new global look, feel and positioning with a fresh brand identity. Founded out of Bondi, Sydney, Australia five years ago, Afterpay has skyrocketed to infinite heights, with almost 10 million customers and 55,000-plus merchants now using the platform globally across Australia, US, UK (where it is called […]

Women in Media’s Doris Li: “Listen To Your Heart And Go For It, Then Settle For Extraordinary”
  • Media

Women in Media’s Doris Li: “Listen To Your Heart And Go For It, Then Settle For Extraordinary”

How Communications’ China marketing director, Doris Li, believes ad-land professionals must be courageous enough “to be abnormal”, and listen to their hearts, to be fearless in times of change. During this year’s B&T Women in Media Awards, presented by Bauer Media, we’ll be recognising exceptional people who have achieved success in their professional arenas, celebrating […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Study: New Business Wins Still Resilient, But Creative Finding It Tougher Going Than Media
  • Advertising
  • Media

Study: New Business Wins Still Resilient, But Creative Finding It Tougher Going Than Media

The holding companies might be losing as much as 23 per cent of their revenue year-on-year, but new business has remained relatively resilient through 2020, the lastest research from R3 has revealed. In the first half of 2020 total new business revenue decreased 10 per cent globally – but creative agencies are having to find […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
I’m Not Loving ‘Karens’, For What They Highlight About Our Society
  • Opinion

I’m Not Loving ‘Karens’, For What They Highlight About Our Society

In this guest post, the CEO of PR/comms agency Extollo, Katy Denis, examines the social phenomenon of our time – the entitled ‘Karens’ amongst us & why they can be such a danger… Until last week, I had no idea who or what a “Karen” is. Thanks to (and I use that term very lightly, […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
The Mint Partners Wins Pernod Ricard, Cemoy & Little National
  • Advertising

The Mint Partners Wins Pernod Ricard, Cemoy & Little National

Independent communications consultancy The Mint Partners has bolstered its integrated client roster and signed a number of premium lifestyle brands to kick start the new financial year. With an array of new products, services, and a focus on insight-led and creative integrated communications, MINT has enjoyed recent success with an expanded portfolio across new categories including fintech, […]

opr Adds DocuSign To Client Roster
  • Media

opr Adds DocuSign To Client Roster

Sure, it might not be a Coke or a Qantas, but opr think this win significant enough to send well-meaning press release.

Stan Acquires Heckler Co-Produced Biopic On F1 champion Sir Jack Brabham
  • Media

Stan Acquires Heckler Co-Produced Biopic On F1 champion Sir Jack Brabham

A feature length documentary on the extraordinary racing career of Australia’s first Formula 1 champion, Sir Jack Brabham, co-produced by design, animation and visual effects house Heckler, will be available on Stan exclusively from this Friday – 7 August. Directed by Ákos Armont (Aurora Films) in association with Heckler, whose co-founder Will Alexander served as […]

Would TikTok Be Missed?
  • Opinion

Would TikTok Be Missed?

Columnist poses the question - would TikTok be missed? B&T says not as much as vanilla Paddle-Pops or Best Of Red Faces.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Jamie Whincup And A Host Of Aussie Personalities Star In Club Marine Series
  • Media

Jamie Whincup And A Host Of Aussie Personalities Star In Club Marine Series

In a first for the Australian insurance market, Club Marine, Australia’s largest provider of boat and pleasure-craft insurance, has released a new series of videos to help explain insurance cover. With a few familiar Aussie personalities to help out, Club Marine is helping its members, as well as the broader boating community, to understand the […]