Faking it

Fake PR can lead to tongue-in-cheek tales and blatant sarcasm – but often it’s far from funny. Lucy Clark speaks to PR professionals to discover the ugly side of faking it
When an anti-mining campaigner sent out a press release posing as ANZ, what followed must have exceeded his wildest dreams.
Last month, Front Line Action on Coal protestor Jonathan Moylan saw his hoax press statement published by several media outlets, including Australian Association Press.
Moylan’s statement claimed that ANZ had pulled $1.6bn in funding for a coal mine in New South Wales due to its environmental impact. The big news sent investors into a panic – and prompted them to dump shares.
For Front Line Action on Coal, it was job done. More than $300m was temporarily knocked off the value of the coal mining company in question – Nathan Tinkler’s Whitehaven Coal.
Whitehaven became the third company in the last six months to be hit hard by fake PR notices. David Jones’ shares climbed after false rumours were spread on email of a takeover, and mining services company Macmahon Holdings ended up suspending trading when an email chain circulated that reported a takeover.
Andrew Ure, managing director of OgilvyEarth, suggests: “If this had happened 10 years ago, people would have assumed it was a hoax. The fact that people are willing to believe the press release is really interesting, in terms of what consumers expect these companies to do. Ten years ago, people would not have thought ANZ would worry about this sort of thing.”
But what implications does a bit of (bad) fake PR have, apart from the obvious, short-lived financial ones?
Andrea Kerekes, managing partner at Access PR, says: “This is a wake-up call to companies. Technology is making it easier to do something like this. Staying on top of Twitter and Facebook is one thing, but traditional media is incredibly powerful. A lot of brands over-focus on social media, possibly to the detriment of traditional communications.
“Any company that does not have a really tight media crisis communications plan is making a big mistake.”
Ure states that organisations must be pro-active in their PR and in showing that they are ethical.
“We are in an age of transparency, due to social media,” he says. “Companies have to do what they say and they need to be on the front foot in using PR to build trust with consumers. Once genies are out of the bottle, 90% of the damage has been done. As a company, you can’t just believe in being ethical, you have to communicate it.”
Thrive PR’s managing director, Leilani Abels, wants to see protection for business from hoaxes such as this. She says: “There needs to be guidelines and measures in place. I certainly believe that when it comes to this fake news release, there needs to be accountability. The hoaxer should be held to account. There needs to be measures in place to protect businesses from situations like this.
“PR as an industry has a reputation to uphold. That kind of behaviour doesn’t do anything for the professionals that operate with the highest of standards in our industry. It certainly gives PR a bad name.”
But Kerekes does not agree that such incidents reflect badly on the PR industry.
“I don’t think this gives PR a bad name,” she says. “My initial reaction was that the hoaxer must have done an incredibly good job. PR is always going to suffer from people calling any hoax a PR stunt.”
She also believes that what followed, with the ANZ setting the story straight promptly, and effectively, reflected well on PR.
“I don’t think there is any blame to be laid on anybody,” she suggests. “The ANZ did well – it reacted very quickly and to-the-point, stating immediately that it was a hoax. They didn’t use convoluted language, and they got on the phones, on email and on social media to set the story straight.”
Abels agrees: “The ANZ handled it well. Businesses need to have an issues management and crisis management plan in place. Brands need to be very aware of the potential of this kind of thing happening to them.”
But where does the responsibility lie? With journalists or with brands?
Kerekes argues that fact-checking by journalists is crucial. “I saw two different reports – one said that only one journalist called to check the facts, another said that several did. Either way, that’s not enough to have called to check something so monumental,” she says.
But Abels disagrees: “It’s to the detriment of the industry if media need to check every single press release, it’s just not possible. Accountability needs to be held on the dispatch side of things. When there are serious consequences to a story being reported, there needs to be a certain level of checking – but it’s not feasible for journalists to double check every fact.”
Ure agrees, in part, with both Kerekes and Abels. He says: “There are increasing pressures on journalists’ time, but it’s a journalist’s responsibility to check facts and take reasonable measures. Perhaps the definition of ‘reasonable measures’ is changing.”
Whether big impact or small joke, fake PR is here to stay.
“More and more companies will be the victims of hoaxes,” claims Ure. “People need to believe in your credentials if the hoax is not going to gain traction. The onus is on the brand to show what they are doing to maintain their reputation and to explain their values.”
“Hoaxes like this are not going to stop,” concludes Kerekes. “It will be interesting to see if the hoaxer in this case is charged with anything. The police took away his mobile and laptop, but no-one has ever been charged in Australia over something like this.”
This article first appeared in B&T magazine on February 1.
Please login with linkedin to comment
Latest News

SurfStitch Unveils New Brand Position & Summer Campaign
Aussie coastal lifestyle brand SurfStitch has announced a bold repositioning with a new brand identity and campaign, “Ready for Everywhere”. Reflecting the brand’s commitment to inspiring people to embrace their lifestyle, whatever it may be, the strategic shift reflects a commitment to facilitating style that adapts to the life its customers lead across a broad […]

Man of Many Welcomes Naman Singh & Alex Martinez
Man of Many has Announced Key Hires Amidst a Year of Extraordinary Achievement Lead image: Naman Singh & Alex Martinez Man of Many, recently crowned B&T media platform of the year, Australia’s premier men’s lifestyle digital publication. Announces the addition of two crucial members to its team – Naman Singh as SEO Content Specialist and […]

realestate.com.au Extends Major Partnership With Sydney Swans
Australian property site realestate.com.au has announced the extension of its partnership with the Sydney Swans for two further seasons. Lead image: Tom Harley, Owen Wilson and Tom McCartin realestate.com.au has partnered with the Swans since 2016 and has called the back of the club’s iconic guernsey home since becoming a major partner in 2020. This […]

Tuesday TV Ratings: “There Are Too Few Episodes” – Dessert Masters Finale Leave Viewers Wanting More
Dessert Masters finale reportedly leaves viewers wanting more. Weight Watchers also keeping a keen eye on things.

Avenue C Nabs Paula Lopes From KINESSO
Leading independent media agency, Avenue C, is thrilled to announce the appointment of Paula Lopes as Digital Director. Paula, a seasoned professional with over 17 years experience in the media industry, joins Avenue C from her role as Chief Operations Manager of KINESSO (merger of Reprise, Matterkind, and Kinesso specialities).

Dave ‘Rabbit’ Rabbetts Departs Star 104.5 Breakfast
Dave 'Rabbit' Rabbetts departs Star 104.5 breakfast. Has asked everyone call him Dave for a little bit.

MOO Premium Foods Admits “100% Ocean Plastics” Claims Misled Consumers
Yoghurt brand in strife over green claims. Meanwhile Mars Bars still getting away with "helps you work, rest & play".

IAB Study: Online Advertising Expenditure Hit $3.73B For September Quarter
Digital continuing to be advertising's star performer. Although that's not intended as a slur to the humble catalogue.

More Than 15,000 Watch On YouTube As An Emotional Brittany Higgins Takes The Stand
One of the biggest stories of 2023 looking like it's heading into 2024. Has the legs to even make 2025.

oOh!Media Fuses People & Performance At National Annual Revenue & Growth Conference
oOh!media brought together more than 260 of its sales, operations, commercial, marketing, finance and leadership teams last week for its national annual revenue and growth conference. Held over two days at the picturesque Rydges Resort in Hunter Valley, the event ‘Fusing people and performance’ focussed on how to build a high-performance mindset and how it […]

The End Of An Era: Millionaire Hot Seat Comes To A Close After 25 Years
Eddie McGuire set to become even more annoying after his game show hosting gig comes to an end.

The Good, The Bad & The Ugly: These Are The Moments That Dominated Media Coverage In 2023
It's 2023's biggest news stories counted down! And whoever wrote it clearly didn't miss out out Taylor Swift tickets.

Free-To-Air TV Welcomes Landmark Win Against Streaming Giants
It's a win for the free-to-air networks this morning. However, it's not stopped the incessant squabbling between them.

KFC Spoofs Fragrance Ads With Its Own Unisex Scent Shaped Like A Drumstick
Want stray dogs to follow you home after a night out? This chicken-inspired scent could be just the ticket.

Jimmy Hyett Drops By B&T TV To Talk Christmas Presents, AI & Basketball
Have you ever met a Jimmy you didn't like? Confirm it here with the eminently likeable Jimmy Hyett's B&T TV debut.

Rocket Agency Appoints Samantha Dodson As Creative Director
Rocket serves up the lettuce, nabbing Ex-Ogilvy and DDB creative, Samantha Dodson.

Free TV Welcomes Government’s Prominence & Anti-Siphoning Framework
Free TV has welcomed the federal government’s ongoing commitment to ensuring that all Australians can access their local free television services on connected TVs through the introduction of legislation to implement a prominence framework in coming days. Free TV CEO Bridget Fair (lead image) said: “Right now, Australian viewers are being steered in the direction […]

Watch Out Fifty Shades! Nova’s ‘Wippa’ Publishes His Very Own Erotic Novel
Radio host 'Wippa' has published an erotic novel! Presumably with many of the protagonists whipping it out.

Burger King Wins For Strangest (Anti) Christmas Campaign Of The Year
In exciting news for turkeys & our piggy friends, Burger King attempting to flog burgers as alternative Christmas fare.

Study: Invest In Customer Experience After A Data Breach To Future-Proof Your Brand
Study finds brands should invest in CX after any data breach. Either that or sack your IT department.

“What Do S*x Toys Have To Do With Makeup?” – Sephora Faces Backlash From Parents For Adult Toy Ad
Snag the hard to buy for colleague in this year's office Kris Kringle? This vibrator news may stimulate the thinking.

Kendall’s Infamous Pepsi Ad Tops List Of Most Controversial US Ads Of All Time!
It's the greatest flops in US ad history. Strangely, Hillary's 2016 election campaign conspicuous by its absence.

Pilot Tackles Sex, Shame, and Stigma With New Campaign Challenging Men To Share Their “Shocker Performance Stories”
Men's health campaign shines a light on impotence. And not just the 18 schooners variety.

Guinness Compared To A Cosmic Phenomena As Beer Brand Taps The Chinese Market
Guiness once again ignoring the tagline every drinker wants - "Great going down, even smoother coming out."

The Chaser’s Craig Reucassel To Host ABC Breakfast Radio, Valentine Returns To Afternoons
It's jarmies, hot Milo and bed by nine for Craig Reucassel after he lands new early morning breakfast gig.

Tyreright Appoints 27 Degrees Media
New-generation media agency 27 Degrees Media has been appointed to manage digital media for national tyre retailer Tyreright in one of its first Australian client signings. Lead Image: Loan Morris – 27 Degrees Media CEO Under the partnership, 27 Degrees Media will be responsible for all digital media strategy, planning and buying, along with influencer […]

The Works Distills “Question Everything” For Archie Rose Distilling Co.
Who doesn't love a spicy Archie Rose gin to get you publicly blabbering about an ex or non-existent sex life.

farsiight Unveils New Market Positioning Putting Growth for Good Over Growth At All Costs
Brisbane performance agency farsiight has announced the launch of its new market positioning, Growth for Good, in response to a changing business landscape, marking a departure from a “growth at all costs” mentality that has defined the industry in recent years. Agency founders and brother duo, Josh and Ben Somerville, envision Growth for Good as […]

By Land Or By Sea: GoTransit Offers Options Galore For Transit Advertisers In Newcastle
Australia’s largest privately owned transit media supplier, GoTransit Media Group, now offers unprecedented options for transit advertising in Newcastle – on both land and sea following their successful tender to supply interior advertising inside the popular Stockton Ferries. The national transit media company is already well acquainted with the thriving NSW market, having successfully operated […]

‘People First Bank’ Heritage & People’s Choice Bank Unified
Heritage and People’s Choice have launched People First Bank, the new name for positive change in banking Australia’s largest customer-owned bank has unveiled its new brand, announcing that Heritage and People’s Choice will be unified under the new name of People First Bank. Chairman Michael Cameron said the highly anticipated new brand offered a compelling […]

“Cozzie Livs” Announced Macquarie Dictionary 2023 Word Of The Year
We're not sure how many logophiles read B&T, but this one's for you. That's a lover of words, not a lover of logging.

🏆 Hear From The B&T Awards Winners! 🏆
It's the B&T Award winners all in video form! We're putting the slurring down to their excitedness.

Today The Brave’s Hannah Lawson & Kate Idle On What’s Hot & What’s Not In 2024
Planning your own what's hot/what's not for 2024 list? There's some good ones here if plagiarism is on your what's hot.

Cultural Shift For Australians With ‘The Great Slow Down’
Don't ever really go beyond what's asked? Loathed by colleagues? Bone idle, in fact? The 'great slow down' is calling.

L’Oréal Aus & NZ Partner With Great Barrier Reef Foundation, Announcing Large Investments
L’Oréal Groupe Australia and New Zealand have announced one of the largest investments to the Great Barrier Reef Foundation to pioneer new coral restoration efforts in the region. L’Oréal Groupe Australia and New Zealand have announced today a new partnership with the Great Barrier Reef Foundation (GBRF), to help coral reefs withstand the devastating impacts […]

Fast 10: B&T Chats Marketing & The Future With The Marketing Academy’s Sherilyn Shackell
It's B&T's quick 10 with marketing guru Sherilyn Shackell. And, believe it or not, AI not mentioned once.