What Soured The Milkshake? A Filmmaker’s Guide To Avoiding International Embarrassment

In this opinion piece, filmmaker and co-founder of purpose-led film production company Taste Creative and Bus Stop Films, Genevieve Clay-Smith, reflects on what the government’s Milkshake Consent Video can teach us about tackling tough social topics.
The talk of the town and the overwhelming topic for opinion pieces over the last two weeks has been, you guessed it, the Milkshake Consent Video. It’s goal? To educate young Australians about the issue of sexual assault and consent.
The result? A major national backlash for a confusing and very strange set of videos that used metaphor, comedy and heightened realism to address a very serious issue.
Using storytelling in order to raise awareness about important social issues is not new and when done right is incredibly impactful.
So, when we looked at the ill-fated Milkshake Consent video, we were really curious to dissect and explore why it failed. And we have some ideas to help others try not to make the same mistakes in the future.
Message and Audience
Every piece of communications must start with the two ‘W’s: Why and Who? Why does this message need to be told (what’s its purpose) and who is it for (the audience)?
These two very important questions will make for a successful video or not. These two questions will guide the creative, the tone and entire approach to how a film is made.
So, when we look at the message of the MCV, and what its purpose was, straight away we can see it’s serious. Sexual assault and consent is in the zeitgeist right now. It’s a major issue even infiltrating the inner-workings of Parliament. Using comedy could be an option, but we need to take into consideration a few things before we explore that approach; namely, the audience. Who are these films targeted at? Teenagers.
What do we know about teenagers? They process information differently to adults. According to the University of Rochester Medical Center, “The rational part of a teen’s brain isn’t fully developed and won’t be until age 25 or so.” And, when we are teenagers, we process information with the amygdala which is the emotional centre of the brain. It means that the connection between the emotional part of the brain and the decision-making centre are still developing.
So… how should we communicate with teenagers on a sensitive, serious and important subject like sexual assault and consent? Clear, direct messaging. Use of real stories over metaphors.
Real stories are a proven way to engage the hearts and minds of people no matter the age. What if we were to do this campaign all over again, and use someone like Grace Tame, our current Australian of the Year and sexual assault survivor, to host the videos and interview other survivors as well as convicted perpetrators of sexual assault?
Whilst this might sound heavy, being real about a serious issue like sexual assault and consent is an effective way to communicate with and engage teenagers, who use their amygdala to process information.
Inclusive filmmaking
For over a decade, us folks at Taste Creative have been pioneering inclusive filmmaking with our sister company Bus Stop Films. Taste incubated Bus Stop from a fledgling idea into a fully sustainable social enterprise over ten years and has prided itself on developing an inclusive filmmaking model that involves people with disability and other underrepresented groups in creating films and content that authentically voice their experiences.
These videos needed to be co-created with experts and survivors of sexual assault. If it had been, I doubt it would have taken on the creative skin it did. Putting the people who have lived experience of a social justice issue at the centre of making content about that same social justice issue is the only way to ensure the content is authentic.
The MCV videos are not authentic; they are produced in a studio, with caricatures, within a heightened, highly designed world that feels removed from reality.
We define inclusive filmmaking as the involvement of people from a marginalised or underrepresented community group in all stages of content creation. Consulting does not meet that need. Consulting can often be tokenistic and we recommend against it. It just isn’t enough in our opinion.
It doesn’t give the person with lived experience enough authority. We need a diverse and authentic creative team to input into the creative, through involving writers and directors with lived experience in the process, both in front of the camera and behind the scenes.
You can check out and download the Inclusive Filmmaking Toolkit we created with Bus Stop Films.
Understanding filmmaking techniques and their impact on audiences
When we identify the audience and the message for the content we are going to create, we think about how the way in which we produce the creative will impact the audience. The techniques employed in MCV are;
Heightened realism – we are in a studio, the colours are vibrant and pastel, the world feels heavily constructed. When we opt to create content in a heightened world, we need to understand what the impact of this will be on the audience. Usually when filmmakers create a heightened world the desired effect is to minimize the sense of reality and increase a sense of escapism into a different universe. Not ideal if you want teenagers to recognise their world in the videos in order to relate to it seriously.
Heightened characters – heightened characters are usually employed as comedic devices to elicit humour. Think of all your favourite comedies; Kath and Kim, Big Bang Theory, New Girl, The Office – all the characters are exaggerated, and because of that, they make us laugh because they subvert our expectations. It dates all the way back to Commedia dell’arte and the use of masks in performing caricatures. The characters in the MCV videos are so over the top, you’d expect to see them on a kids show. They don’t reflect the real experience of teenagers in school and so we miss the opportunity to connect teenagers to the reality of the issue, because it’s virtually impossible for them to imagine themselves in the characters presented.
Slapstick comedy and other comedic devices – comedy has been used very carefully and also very rarely in other government campaigns about serious issues. A fabulous example is of course Dumb Ways to Die. Why did comedy work really well this time? We had a precedent to tell us it would work; the Darwin Awards: a book of strange and bizarre deaths that people laugh at due to the unbelievable ways in which some people, through their own stupidity or bad luck, die.
Whether that is offensive to you or not, doesn’t really matter. The point is, the campaign worked. People find it funny to think about how people might die doing something stupid. We almost roll our eyes; “what were you thinking?”. We’re actually not laughing at injustice when we laugh at the Dumb Ways to Die We’re laughing at people’s choices that have led to dire consequences for themselves. Now, is the sexual assault of teenagers in that same boat? No. There is a major sense of injustice around this issue, and dealing with youth actually heightens the stakes. Because of this, comedy in whatever form was never going to work.
Understanding filmmaking techniques and how they impact audience engagement is incredibly important when devising creative for a campaign.
The final thought
Success has many fathers, and so does failure. We will likely not be privy to the workings of this campaign, but it’s never just one person’s fault. All the stakeholders involved in the creation of content, from the creatives, to the client writing the briefs and signing off on the creative, need to understand first and foremost; what effect do they want to have on their audience?
In this case the effect should have been; a clear understanding of the seriousness of what consent is, and how disregarding it can lead to sexual assault. I think if everyone had been clear on this in the first place, we wouldn’t have been left with an effect of confusion and disconnection.
Please login with linkedin to comment
Latest News

REVEALED: Australia’s Greatest-Ever Ad!!!
You voted and now B&T can reveal Australia's greatest EVER ad! Yes, Ali Baba Kebabs can feel rightly aggrieved.

The Royals & Ryvalmedia Win Big In B&T’s Top-Performing Agencies For November
Which agency chiefs will be collecting their Christmas bonuses? Discover the truth with this 'who's hot' barometer.

George P. Johnson Announces Leadership Changes
Changes at the top at George P. Johnson today. The middle and the bottom given the order to stand down.

Monday TV Ratings: The 1% Club Scores Seven A Win
Game shows continuing to rate well with TV viewers. Yet, that's not to say we need Andrew O'Keefe back anytime soon.

Free TV Comes Out Swinging Over Sports Rights After Amazon Snares The Cricket
Industry body says free TV sports rights are under threat. Meanwhile Wallabies declare they've all but given up.

Westpac Shows Optus How To Apologise
Westpac delivers on its crisis communication. Also see Westpac board trying to save their collective arses.

Triple J Announces Hottest 100 2023 Dates
This year's Hottest 100 deets announced. With B&T predicting big things for Nollsy's KFC ad.

A Professional Cheese Sculptor Stars For Wacky Ads For US University
Hating the job right now? These uni ads could (A) inspire you to new things or (B) give you a laugh, albeit a brief one.

Don’t Be THAT Perfectionist….Enter B&T’s 30 Under 30 Awards, Presented By Vevo, Now!
Work with people who endlessly say "things were better in my day"? Sounds like you're a real contender for 30 Under 30.

We Are Warriors & R/GA To Produce City Of Sydney’s Calling Country & New Year’s Eve Fireworks
Social Indigenous Enterprise We Are Warriors (WAW), supported by creative innovation studio R/GA Australia, has been selected to produce the City of Sydney’s New Year’s Eve Calling Country live performance as part of the 9pm firework show. Lead image L-R: WAW co-founders Ben Miles & Nooky. The performance will feature a special Welcome to Country […]

Data Is King. So How Can Marketers Survive Privacy Reforms?
There's a fine line between proper use of customer data and a $50K fine from the ACCC. Save your cash with this read.

Chery Launches New Tiggo 7 Pro In Australian Market With Creative Campaign Via Chello
Chinese EVs continuing to flood into the Aussie market. Clearly no reciprocal agreement with our wine and barley.

Isuzu UTE Extends A-Leagues Partnership Through To 2026
Isuzu UTE extends its A-Leagues partnership. Also desperately hoping the fans don't behave like dickheads.

Seven Network Unveils New Advanced Advertising Division
Seven unveils its new advanced advertising division. No sign of official scarlet red team tracksuits, however.

“Give An F About the Flags”: Surf Life Saving Australia Launches Summer Campaign Via Banter
Every Australian should know to swim between the flags. That and Bradman's average and most of the words to Khe Sanh.

Toyota & HCLTech To Appear On Aussie Cricketers’ Shirts This Summer
You can almost hear leather on willow with this news. Unless someone's being attacked with a cricket bat in your office.

G Squared Bolsters Paid Media & Search With Key Hires
G Squared announces key hires in its paid search team. Although we appreciate not everyone's a fan of paid search.

“Extinction Greenwashing”: Supermarkets Target Of ACCC Complaint Over Misleading Salmon Claims
Yet again claims about Tasmanian salmon catch watchdog's ire, as chickens declare we're ridgy-didge.

Droga5 London Launches First Campaign For ADV New Motorcycle
Unsure if you're in the throes of a possible midlife crisis? Watch this motorbike ad and learn the horrible truth.

Mediahub Expands Into New Zealand Market
Mediahub unveils its New Zealand plans. And it only took the locals four minutes to mention the rugby.

It Takes A Village: Havas Drives Off With Avis Budget Group’s Media & Earned PR
There are few greater joys in life than flogging the shit out of a rental car, is there?

Amazon Prime Secures Rights To Next Cricket World Cup
Judging by the acrimony, sledging & hatred of last month's Cricket World Cup, the next one's shaping up to be a ripper.

Limited Tickets Still Available For First Ever Industry Pantomime
With just over 24 hours to go until the world premiere of Addy Lala and the Mood Tea Thieves, limited tickets are still available for the pantomime, which will run for one night only at the Everest Theatre in Sydney’s Seymour Centre on December 5th. All in the industry are encouraged to come along to […]

Palin Communications joins GlobalCom PR Network
Specialist Australian health PR agency, Palin Communications, has joined GlobalCom PR Network with a view to delivering meaningful, consistent, impactful, global health campaigns across a range of countries and regions.

Axe-Wielding Eric Andre Stars In Opera GX Campaign, Via Waste Creatives
Irreverent campaign for Opera GX, the browser for gamers, sees actor and comedian Eric Andre confronting people using “boring” browsers

Make it your way at Highpoint Via Cyclone Creative Agency
Highpoint is inviting Melbournians to embrace what makes them different, through their ‘Make it Your Way’ campaign via Cyclone Creative agency.

2045: A New Melbourne-Based Creative Agency Founded by Tim Evans and Nick Auditore
2045, a Melbourne-based creative agency founded by Tim Evans and Nick Auditore has just launched. The agency takes its name from the year futurist Ray Kurzweil predicted organic and artificial intelligence would converge. Lead Image: 2045 Team Evans was formerly a Partner and Executive Strategy Director at DT (now AKQA), before co-founding B.B.E in 2015. […]

Pengu Dances Their Way Through New Film by electriclime°
Production house electriclime° have linked up with Riot Games to create a new film to celebrate the launch of Teamfight Tactics Mobile (“TFT”) in Asia Pacific.

National Breast Cancer Foundation Announced as Charity Partner For NYE Sydney
The National Breast Cancer Foundation has been announced as the Charity Partner for Sydney New Year’s Eve. The Australian not-for-profit organisation is represented by the pink ribbon and raises money to fund world-class research towards its vision of zero deaths from breast cancer. Research that saves lives through a better understanding of how to prevent […]

Sunday TV Ratings: Brits Dominate With Annika, Joanna Lumley And David Attenborough Making Top 10
Sunday night strangely dominated by UK-made content. That said, Piers not getting a heap of love over at Sky.

Emporium Unveils Unique Christmas Campaign: “Every Tradition Starts Somewhere”
This holiday season, Emporium Melbourne has announced its festive creative campaign that celebrates and encourages the Melbourne community to embrace their personal ‘untraditional traditions’ – the unique traditions that make Christmas truly special for them, and their family. The campaign’s tagline, “Every tradition starts somewhere”, reflects Emporium’s commitment to embracing, inspiring and applauding diverse traditions […]

Stop Being A Water Waster! Sydney Schoolboy Urges Everyone To Save Water, Via It’s Friday
Planning a staff dunking booth this Christmas? Not too late to switch to 10-pin bowling with this water save campaign.

Reddit Updates Conversation Placement Ads Formats
Reddit has announced updates to its new ads placement with Carousel Ads and Product Ads. These new units, placed in the heart of Reddit discussions, provide an even more dynamic and compelling way for advertisers to scale to relevant audiences, deliver deeper value to users, and drive stronger, full-funnel performance among the hundreds of thousands […]

Full Throttle Into 2024: Drive.com.au Announces 12 New Products In 2024 Upfronts
Automotive Network Drive has announced its 2024 upfronts, its biggest in more than a decade, with a suite of more than 12 new products that underpin its vision to be the number one automotive network in Australia. Now in its 27th year and with a monthly audience of 2.45 million, Drive is leveraging its reputation […]

Journalist Tegan George Suing Network 10 After Being Left With “Trauma” From Bushfire Reporting
It's been a rocky road for many people & agencies in 2023; however, it's been all sunshine & rainbows for 10's lawyers.

As Big Spenders Flee, X Pivots To SMBs To Fill Ad Dollar Deficit
Elon's halo continues to slip. Joining Albo's, Harry's, Meghan's and Optus' similar downward trajectory.