Meta has won a landmark antitrust case brought by the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC).
The regulator had alleged that Meta has an illegal monopoly in social media and sought to unwind Instagram and WhatsApp from Meta ownership.
US District Judge James Boasberg ruled that the FTC failed to prove Meta’s acquisitions of Instagram (2012) and WhatsApp (2014) allowed it to operate an unlawful social media monopoly.
During the six week trial, the commission’s case was built around trying to prove that people used Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp for “personal social networking”, and were different in how people used rivals YouTube and TikTok, which the commission argued were more for entertainment.
Judge Boasberg did not find the FTC’s case compelling, arguing that in the time the antitrust case went to trial—five years–the social media landscape had shifted dramatically, diluting Meta’s dominance.
“Believing that the only constant in the world was change, the Greek philosopher Heraclitus posited that no man can ever step into the same river twice. In the online world of social media, the current runs fast, too,” Boasberg wrote in an 86-page decision.
“The landscape that existed only five years ago when the Federal Trade Commission brought this antitrust suit has changed markedly. While it once might have made sense to partition apps into separate markets of social networking and social media, that wall has since broken down.”
The decision highlights the challenges regulators face in trying to enforce monopoly laws during years-long antitrust cases in the fast-moving technology sector where new players can rapidly disrupt the shape and concentration of markets.
“We are deeply disappointed in this decision,” said FTC spokesperson Joe Simonson, adding, “we are reviewing all our options.”
A Meta spokesperson said: “The Court’s decision today recognises that Meta faces fierce competition. Our products are beneficial for people and businesses and exemplify American innovation and economic growth. We look forward to continuing to partner with the Administration and to invest in America.”
In his ruling, Boasberg cites examples of how Instagram and Facebook reels are similar to TikTok videos and YouTube Shorts, inferring that Meta’s apps are increasingly in competition with rivals (see image below).
He noted that the launch of TikTok in the US pushed Meta to prioritise short-form video over posts from friends in order to prevent users switching to TikTok.
“Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube have thus evolved to have nearly identical main features. On all four, users spend most of their time watching videos,” Boasberg wrote.
“All four use algorithms to recommend those videos to users. And if someone finds content that she likes, all four apps let her tap a button to send it to friends — whether via a direct message on Facebook, Instagram, or TikTok, or using a text message.”
The Meta case is part of a larger antitrust crackdown on US Big Tech. The FTC is battling Amazon over alleged anti-competitive tactics for its online marketplace, Google is battling the Department of Justice (DoJ), avoiding a breakup of its Chrome browser and Android operating system, while Apple is also under fire from the DoJ about restrictions it has placed on app makers and third party devices.


