They’re Not Gonna Take It! Clive Palmer Must Pay $1.2 Million Over Twisted Sister Copyright Claim

They’re Not Gonna Take It! Clive Palmer Must Pay $1.2 Million Over Twisted Sister Copyright Claim
B&T Magazine
Edited by B&T Magazine



Ex-politician Clive Palmer has been ordered to pay band Twisted Sister $1.5 million over his use of their anthem We’re Not Gonna Take It in a campaign video.

Universal Music sued Palmer (pictured above in a campaign poster) after he rewrote lyrics to the song in advertising for the United Australia Party back in 2019.

Back in October, Palmer was accused of giving false evidence to the court over the song. He claimed to have written the lyrics in 2018 while he was “deep in contemplation”, and also said the lyrics were inspired by Network, a 1976 film.

In the film, there is the line “I’m not going to take this anymore.”

The court also heard that Palmer’s team had ended negotiations over a license to use We’re Not Gonna Take It in a campaign video due to issues over the cost.

Dee Snider, Twisted Sister’s frontman, told the court in October that Palmer’s use of the song “was not good for [his] heavy metal image.”

Where the original song’s chorus says, “we’re not gonna take it, no we’re not gonna take it”, the United Australia Party’s chorus sings, “Australia’s not gonna cop it, no Australia’s not gonna cop it.”

On Friday, Federal Court Justice Anna Katzmann ruled that Palmer did in fact infringe on copyright to the song. She did not accept the argument that he had used the melody of hymn O Come, All Ye Faithful, and written his own lyrics to the song.

In an interview with Goldmine magazine, Snider said that a friend had pointed out that the song “had borrowed some of its melody from O Come, All Ye Faithful,” citing his years of performing in church choir.

According to court statements made by Palmer, copyright payments were deserved by “the poor monk who wrote the melody [to the hymn]”.

In her ruling, Justice Katzmann wrote that Palmer “was an unimpressive witness. In significant respects his evidence was inconsistent with the contemporaneous records and the evidence of both Mr Wright and Mr McDonald.”

“It is sufficient to observe at this point that he was an unreliable witness whose evidence was at times incredible.”

She also wrote that “there could be no doubt that Mr Palmer intended to, and did, derive a political benefit from the unauthorised use of the copyright works.”

Palmer must now pay $500,000 damages and $1 million damages due to the flagrancy of the infringement. He will also have to pay legal costs.

Snider has tweeted in celebration since the ruling.

Palmer recently had his proposal for a coal mine near the Great Barrier Reef turned down by the Queensland government. In October 2020, the Australian Financial Review named him the eighth richest Australian.




Please login with linkedin to comment

Clive Palmer twister sister

Latest News

Readers Are Looking To Books For Escape – Should They Look To Adverts, Too?
  • Advertising

Readers Are Looking To Books For Escape – Should They Look To Adverts, Too?

Now in its 27th year, the Sydney Writer’s Festival (SWF) has long provided a creative respite but this year, its selection of award-winning wordsmiths is concerned with offering the public an escape from the real world. To find out quite how the public is looking to escape from the real world through words, and what […]

Photographed by Dominic Loneragan. Please Credit Dominic Loneragan.
  • Media

Sky New Zealand Initiates Process For Advertising Sales Representation In Australia

Sky New Zealand launched a process for its advertising sales representation in Australia. Lead image: Lauren Quaintance, Sky chief media and data officer. With around 1 million paid customer relationships throughout New Zealand, Sky is home to a broad variety of content across live sport, entertainment, news, movies and kids’ content, reaching four out of […]

Opinion: Queer & Present Danger – Australia’s Battle For LGBTQ+ Recognition Through Communication
  • Opinion

Opinion: Queer & Present Danger – Australia’s Battle For LGBTQ+ Recognition Through Communication

In this op-ed, Blake Mason (pictured above), group account director at Think HQ, explains why the job of advocating for the rights of the LGBTQ+ community is not and never will be done. In today’s world, the LGBTQ+ community faces a paradoxical reality. While strides toward equality have been made globally, discrimination persists, often intensifying […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Val Morgan Digital Partners With Audigent To Connect Brands With Passionate Audiences At Scale
  • Advertising

Val Morgan Digital Partners With Audigent To Connect Brands With Passionate Audiences At Scale

Val Morgan Digital has partnered with Audigent, a data platform that unlocks the power of first-party data to maximise cookie-less addressability for advertisers. The partnership provided Val Morgan Digital with a suite of tools and data management platform (DMP) capabilities for collecting and activating audience insights across its portfolio of passion-based community websites. Val Morgan […]

International Olympic Committee Launches “The First Effect” Campaign, Via Deloitte Digital
  • Campaigns

International Olympic Committee Launches “The First Effect” Campaign, Via Deloitte Digital

Deloitte and the International Olympic Committee (IOC) have launched ‘The First Effect’, a cobranded campaign that sets out to create a new metric for success beyond the podium – measuring the transformative impact of humanity’s firsts on the world’s greatest stage. ‘The First Effect’ launch marked 100 days until the Olympic and Paralympic Games Paris […]

Nine Promotes Nikki Rooke To Replace Richard Hunwick As Director Of Sales – Total TV
  • Advertising

Nine Promotes Nikki Rooke To Replace Richard Hunwick As Director Of Sales – Total TV

Nine has promoted Nikki Rooke to director of sales – total television, to replace Richard Hunwick. Currently director of sales – Sydney, with commercial responsibility for Nine’s TV, streaming, audio and publishing assets, Rooke will lead Nine’s national total television sales team overseeing Metro TV, Regional TV and BVOD. Working alongside Jo Clasby (director of […]

Thinkerbell Wants To Make Every Day A “Lovely Day For A Guinness”
  • Campaigns

Thinkerbell Wants To Make Every Day A “Lovely Day For A Guinness”

In new work from Thinkerbell and Lion, the iconic Guinness endline — “Lovely Day For A Guinness” — has been reimagined for winter in the southern hemisphere, revealing the iconic pint motif where you least expect it. “Winter is the season that Aussies can enjoy Guinness while taking in the best bits of the season. […]

The Unexpected Guest Wins oOh!media’s Inaugural Indigenous Business Grant
  • Advertising

The Unexpected Guest Wins oOh!media’s Inaugural Indigenous Business Grant

The Unexpected Guest, an Australian-made and owned breakfast food products company has been named as the inaugural winner of oOh!media’s Indigenous business grant. Lead image: Jenny Khan and Sarah Young. Launched to support Indigenous small businesses with pro-bono and significantly discounted out-of-home media packages, The Unexpected Guest was one of 63 submissions received from a […]

Indie Creative Agency Dig Wins Bendigo Bank, Launches New Campaign
  • Campaigns

Indie Creative Agency Dig Wins Bendigo Bank, Launches New Campaign

Bendigo Bank has partnered with independent creative agency Dig to launch a new campaign, its first new brand campaign in years, designed to evolve the ‘better big bank’ and reinforce Bendigo Bank as a challenger brand. Dig was appointed as the lead creative agency after a competitive pitch in 2023. Paul Rhodes, founder of Dig, […]

Made This Launches Mercedes-Benz Van’s New Online Store Through Massive LED Show
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Made This Launches Mercedes-Benz Van’s New Online Store Through Massive LED Show

To launch Mercedes-Benz Van’s online-store, specialist production company, MADE THIS, in collaboration with Team X Australia, developed the “Your Van, Your Way” campaign to highlight the new options for purchasing and customising your Mercedes-Benz Van, online or in-store. The campaign showcased the unique flexibility Mercedes-Benz Vans provides. The shoot took place in Melbourne, at NANT […]

News Corp Launches Indigenous Sport Week Editorial Campaign
  • Advertising

News Corp Launches Indigenous Sport Week Editorial Campaign

News Corp Australia’s annual Indigenous Sport Week has kicked off. Running from May 20-26, the editorial campaign celebrated the rich history, and future, of Indigenous Sport in Australia through storytelling. Each year, News’ sport newsrooms across the country prioritise supporting the AFL and NRL Indigenous rounds and super netball first nations round. The coverage is […]

New “Population: Unexpected” Boomtown Brand Positioning Celebrates Regional Australia, Via Thinkerbell
  • Campaigns

New “Population: Unexpected” Boomtown Brand Positioning Celebrates Regional Australia, Via Thinkerbell

Boomtown, the media collective representing the benefits of advertising to 9.8 million regional Australians unveiled a new multi-channel campaign featuring the brand positioning of Population: unexpected. The new campaign was designed to celebrate and reinforce the exponential opportunity that advertising in regional Australia offers businesses. The campaign shone a spotlight on how the burgeoning regional […]

Cairns Crocodiles, Presented by Pinterest: The Most-Shortlisted Agencies
  • B&T Exclusive

Cairns Crocodiles, Presented by Pinterest: The Most-Shortlisted Agencies

The shortlist for the inaugural Cairns Crocodiles Awards, Presented by Pinterest, was revealed at the start of the month, featuring work for brands as storied as FIFA, Adidas, KFC, Unilever and Netflix created by agencies from New Zealand, Singapore, Japan and, of course, Australia. But which agencies have picked up the most nominations? Here, we […]

Image lead story Samsung Ads’ “Behind The Screens” Event: Showcasing Market Leadership In Connected TV
  • Partner Content

Samsung Ads’ “Behind The Screens” Event: Showcasing Market Leadership In Connected TV

On a crisp afternoon at Hinchcliff House in Sydney, Samsung Ads hosted its “Behind The Screens” industry event, inviting key decision-makers from the media and advertising sectors to discuss how TV plays a role in their screens approach. The event focused on how the rise of streaming and technology is influencing viewing behaviours. Throughout the […]

Partner Content

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
UM Hires Former Carat Client Partnerships Head To Lead Optus Account
  • Advertising

UM Hires Former Carat Client Partnerships Head To Lead Optus Account

Matt Evans has joined the IPG Mediabrands agency UM as managing partner of its Optus account. Based in Sydney, he is responsible for evolving UM’s strategic media approach for Optus, working closely with its account team to “deliver and create market leading value, innovation and opportunity geared for sustainable growth”. Evans begins his new role […]

Roy Morgan: Written News Reaches 97% Of Aussies
  • Media

Roy Morgan: Written News Reaches 97% Of Aussies

Written news reaches 21.5 million Australians over 14 years of age every month, equivalent to 97 per cent of the population according to Total News Publishing data from ThinkNewsBrands and Roy Morgan. The data also shows readers across all demographics are actively leaning into news, with 67 million interactions per week. Australian news readers are […]