In this guest post, freelance strategist Dan Machen (pictured below), says the battle of man and machine (technology) is fast heating up in agency and marketing land, but he argues, it needs to be a partnership not a war…
Noah Yuval Harari’s books Sapiens and Homo Deus explore humankind’s growth in tandem with our use of technology. Harari says that Sapiens shows us where we have come from, and Homo Deus shows us where we are going. But he skipped the tricky bit. There is a missing link – ‘Techno Sapiens’ – or where we are now.
As the UK’s Institute of Practitioners in Advertising (IPA) today calls for a moratorium on micro-targeted political ads, agencies and brands worldwide are wrestling with the issues of humankind meets machines. Marketers must get hold of technology now, to use it empathetically, ethically and effectively in future.
As a job-hunting Brit, new to Sydney, I’ve been struck by similarities even though I’m supposedly a world away from the UK. They include:
- A sense of decency and a fair go that dominates UK and Aussie culture and successful creative campaigns.
- A real sense that agencies and brands need to build brand value ‘top to bottom’ and ‘bottom to top.’
- A serious concern that our current use of technology respects little of what we value above.
We need to get hold of technology for sure, but where is the root of the problem? Cambridge Analytica? Facebook? That’s a start but we need to look deeper – it’s a people problem.
In Sapiens, Noah Yuval Harari perfectly predicts the tug-of-war we are witnessing between man and machine. Talking about biological possibilities versus cultural permissions he says: “Biology enables, culture forbids.’ Biology is willing accommodate a very wide spectrum of possibilities. It’s culture that obliges people to realise some possibilities while forbidding others.”
Swop the word ‘biology’ for ‘technology’ and it perfectly reflects the murky creek we find ourselves up. The Cambridge Analytica shocker that rocked people around the world is a perfect example of ‘technology enables, culture forbids.’ (Or more realistically in this case, technology enables, culture turns a blind eye, culture sh*ts itself, culture forbids.)
But let’s cut the crap and be adult about this for a minute.
Just as humankind explored every facet of what’s possible in biology, so it will be with technology. Yesterday’s NSA scandal, becomes today’s Facebook Scandal, and will no doubt be tomorrow’s Amazon Echo scandal.
In thrall of all our tech toys, it’s inevitable humankind’s grasp will exceed its reach. But we will reach. It’s human nature. It’s also entirely right and appropriate that collective culture obliges us to realise some possibilities, while forbidding others in future.
While CA was found guilty with Facebook a henchman by association, we are all complicit in being too free with our data online. We sweep permissions aside – ironically to get to that psychology quiz to find out how well balanced we are. It’s what is then done with that data that is the critical point for collective debate and action.
I’d argue the Cambridge Analytica scandal actually has some positives. It was significant and serious enough to wake up the world on the need to look at where we are. With the great power of ‘Techno Sapiens’ comes great responsibility.
The challenge now is what do we do about it?
In global terms, this means redressing how culture permits the use of the data people share online by intermediaries and companies. In marketing terms, we’ve equally got to get to grips with how this big stuff impacts what we do day-to-day.
It’s great to see thought-leaders like the IPA get out in front of this this debate with a call to ban micro-targeted political ads. They are also grown up enough to not make this a backlash on micro-targeting per se.
The IPA’s lead to move beyond the malaise and get to the ‘magic in machines,’ echoes what I recently saw at South by Southwest (SXSW). Simply put, this can be distilled into 3 Es – Empathy, Ethics and Effectiveness. I think these three areas are good rules of thumb for how we can start to approach the challenge of where we are, in practice:
If where we have been is human vs. machine, we now need to consider humane + machine. Empathy is a critical mind-set to change to get to where we need to be. Or to paraphrase that wellspring of philosophical wisdom – Jurassic Park – ‘just because we could, doesn’t mean that we should.’ As Zuckerberg recently said from his Congressional naughty step, ‘we have to start about thinking about how we can use these technological tools for good’. We need to move beyond dark patterns of triggering a knee-jerk response and look at how we can use tools to optimise choices. This is key to long-term brand value verus short-term spikes.
The world has had two serious wake up calls on data exploitation. Unethical use of audience data can seriously erode shareholder value. These two words are the language of proper corporate response. Smart brands and agencies will move ahead of what’s required and step up to new regulatory benchmarks such as Europe’s GDPR. GDPR could well be adopted further afield to give people better protection and allow them to make more informed choices about how their data is and isn’t used in particular.
There needs to be a wholesale move away from murky digital practices. Based on what I am hearing across Sydney, agencies and brands are sensitive to increased transparency and genuine qual versus quant measures on digital activation. Unilever’s Keith Weed recently describing social media as “little better than a swamp” particularly underscores this. It’s great to see the likes of Havas moving towards greater transparency in the programmatic buying space and also new media contender Truth using block chain to give complete understanding of budget allocation versus digital media spend.
Overall, we while where we have been and where we are going next is all very educational and exciting, but we must deal with the missing link – where we are now. If we can move beyond the distraction of today’s headlines and see this as a wider function of humanity’s maturation with tech we can start to make progress.
Ultimately, finding the magic in the machines tomorrow, hinges on our ability to really get to grips with this today. This comes down to changing practice and refocusing on empathy, ethics and effectiveness. Only then will we start to realise technology’s value bottom to top in marketing and more importantly for humankind.
Hayley Fisher [pictured] is the AUNZ Country Manager at Adyen. In this op-ed, she discusses the upcoming holidays sales season and explains marketers can help drive sales. Over the 18-months the pace of ecommerce has accelerated to new heights. According to latest figures from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS), a record $44.2 billion was […]
TPG Telecom has announced it will hold a creative pitch to further develop the Vodafone brand here in Australia. Last year’s merger between Vodafone and TPG brought together a family of brands under the TPG Telecom group, with the creative shift to position Vodafone for the future. While Vodafone’s long-standing relationship with WPP will continue, […]
Following 18 months of intermittent lockdowns across Australia, shopping centre giant Westfield is launching a new service that will tap into the ecommerce boom. The new service, named Westfield Direct, will take on the likes of Australia Post by providing shipping directly to customers. Shoppers will also be able to select items from an online […]
SBS has been recognised as one of Australia and New Zealand’s Most Innovative Companies, in the prestigious annual list published by the Australian Financial Review and Boss Magazine, from over 700 nominated organisations. Ranked third on the Media and Marketing list, SBS was the only media company to make the list, recognised for its growing and evolving multilingual digital services, exemplifying SBS’s innovative culture and strategy. SBS provides multiplatform services in more than […]
Twitter has confirmed it is experimenting with a new ad format which will see ads placed within conversation threads for the first time. The company’s Revenue Product Lead Bruce Falck made the announcement on Thursday. “Starting today, we’re trying something different and testing a new ad format in Tweet conversations,” he posted on Twitter. “If […]
In exciting news today, Mushroom Group is thrilled to announce much lauded Aussie music program The Sound will return to the ABC this November! Celebrating some of our best musical talents since its launch in 2020, The Sound Season 3 will debut on Sunday 7 November at 5.30pm (local time). Viewers can watch The Sound on ABC TV each Sunday afternoon or catch up with the latest episodes via ABC iview. Across Season […]
Strategic design and innovation company AKQA has received the top industry ranking in the 2021 AFR Boss Most Innovative Companies List. This is the third consecutive year the company has been acknowledged by the AFR for its commitment to innovation in the media and marketing category. The Most Innovative Companies Awards were presented via a […]
National news brand, The Australian, has launched a new podcast from Hedley Thomas, Shandee’s Story. Shandee’s Story is the culmination of six months’ work by Thomas, the award-winning investigative journalist behind The Teacher’s Pet and The Night Driver podcasts. The podcast investigates a harrowing cold case. Shandee Blackburn was left to die after a frenzied knife attack as she walked […]
Greater Bank has won a Silver Award at the 2021 Step Two Intranet & Digital Workplace Awards with its Intranet Built on the Elcom Digital Employee Experience Platform. The global awards recognise outstanding contributions to the fields of intranets and digital workplaces, honouring remarkable solutions that deliver business value to their organisations and then share […]
Two new research reports have revealed key drivers for ‘commerce content’ and the massive revenue opportunity it presents for digital publishers and brands. Published by independent media organisations, commerce content allows readers to understand the goods and services promoted by an editorial team. It’s now a major part of the partnership ecosystem, and a way […]