Purpose Has Become A Tired, “Save The World” Chorus, And It’s Easily Ignored
In this guest post, marketing activist Thomas Kolster (feature image) discusses a study in his new book that shows how purpose fails to motivate and has become a tired “save-the-world” chorus, and easily ignored…
Every ad break these days is packed tight with commercials touting a higher purpose from decrying plastic dumping in our oceans to promoting diversity. I used to believe in purpose, with all my heart. Good Lord, I even wrote a book about it calIed, “Goodvertising” (Thames & Hudson 2012). But I have had to take a hatchet to my earlier held beliefs. Something that wasn’t easy.
Consider this: If you were to kick open the door to a bar and shout, “I’m the world’s best lover!” no one would believe you. So, why would it be any different when brands shout “world saviour”? Take what, outdoor clothing and gear retailers, Patagonia are saying, “We’re in business to save our home planet.” It sounds like self-important navel gazing from a company that essentially sells t-shirts to young men stuck in pokey Brooklyn apartments, wanting to feel outdoorsy.
Patagonia, however, is a rare exception. They can get away with it, because they’re a legacy brand that can break the rules. For almost any other brand, you are setting yourself up for failure and criticism. As I say in my new book, “If you try to fly like superman, you will eventually fall like a can of soup”. Subsequently, I call this concept of self-importance and my new book, “The Hero Trap”. Daily, I witness failures and missteps, and more and more people growing critical towards brands playing heroes.
There are simply too many Mother Teresas or What was wrong with Purpose in the first place?
Purpose can be a very beautiful thing. Having a purpose is supposed to be grounded in having good intent. “So”, you may ask, “why is purpose bad?” Well, brand purpose emerged as a countermovement to a rising mistrust and even hatred towards brands. The thinking was that if brands started caring and acting on issues people cared about, maybe the fragile relationship could be strengthened.
A decade ago, brands like Dove, Ben & Jerry’s, Chipotle and Patagonia made hearts beat faster by simply showing care. But as every brand today is pitching itself as Mother Teresa or Gandhi – who can be believed? Every brand can claim to have a big role to play in your life as their burning “Why”. But if you can’t see or feel the outcome, it’s another broken promise.
Let me ask you this. What brand has changed your life for the better? Taught you something new? Made you healthier? Sparked new thinking? Probably not many. My list was very short, which proves there is plenty of space for brands to play a meaningful role in our lives rather than simply shouting their world-bettering ambitions at us like a Pope on speed.
Less about buying, more about becoming
I’ll argue we’re heading towards a post-purpose marketplace, where people are no longer buying what you make – or why you make it, but instead who you can help them become. It’s all about the difference you can enable in someone’s life. From a positioning point of view, it’s a move from a brand playing a societal difference e.g. a more climate friendly car like a Prius (which my first book Goodvertising described) to a transformational difference e.g. a more conscious traveller.
It’s also a warning to brands who ignore how younger generations are increasingly flirting with a post-consumerist mindset. During the pandemic, we’ve witnessed how people embrace a reality where it’s less about buying and more about realising dreams, goals and ambitions. It’s about guitar lessons, yoga, community work, baking and even knitting. This is a wake-up call for everyone from brands embracing purpose to Non-Profits. People don’t want to hear about your brand’s world-bettering accomplishments or simply buy a halo. Wearing a cap decrying plastic flooding our oceans is the easiest thing in the world. It demands almost no effort. Being generous cannot be bought; it’s something you earn through time and effort.
Patagonia can claim to be “in business to save our home planet,” but compare that to a statement from a Danish organic food box delivery service, Aarstiderne. Their mission is spreading “the joy of organic produce and great tasting meals.” As a customer, I’m improving my cooking and learning how to make great tasting organic vegetarian meals. I’m thankful for the new-found cooking skills, which I can enjoy and share with friends. I don’t actually buy their organic produce. I buy who Aarstiderne helps me become: A better plant-based cook.
The added benefit is that I also want to share my newly discovered skills with my friends and my vegan pie becomes a symbol of accomplishment and status. It’s a world apart from Patagonia’s claim but the resonance on intimate moments of my life is quite profound. Albeit for a similar cause. For this, their brand gets a thankful following.
Change begins with asking: WHO can you help people become?
We don’t need more brands preaching. What we need are coaches who can help us achieve our goals or overcome obstacles. It’s a move from “why” your brand matters to understanding how you can help me achieve “who” I want to be. Very few brands have been able to bridge the purpose gap and get people to move from buying into the purpose to actually buying the product. The intention is there, but action doesn’t follow.
After years of advising leaders and brands on purpose, I finally realised what the missing link was: The very people you are supposed to serve and consequently motivate. I looked to coaching methodologies and psychotherapy to understand how to move people from inaction to action, from unfulfilled to fulfilled. One simple but essential question helped spark the needed change, “Who can you help me become?” It’s moving the relationship from transactional to transformational, helping people be more, do more, see more, experience more!
Your brand’s dreams versus my dreams
I did one commissioned study comparing well-known purposeful commercials like Budweiser’s “Wind Never Felt Better” with transformational commercials like Always’ famous “Like A Girl” commercial. The findings were clear: People are 29.5% more motivated to act on transformational messaging. It’s dangerous to climb the purpose pedestal and put on the hero’s mantle. And it’s even more treacherous to put on a balaclava and behave like an activist.
I realised years ago how difficult it is to create change. We are our own biggest barriers to the change we want to see in our lives – and this is where brands have a truly meaningful role to play. Every brand can claim to be diverse, but the outcome I can feel and appreciate, is a brand that has helped me overcome some of my own biases.
Dear brands, don’t put on that red superhero cape, instead turn people into the activists of their own lives. WHO focuses on the role you can play in people’s lives; enabling their beliefs and dreams, whereas WHY focuses on your organisation’s beliefs and dreams.
Anyone can sell people things, stories or identity, but very few brands can help people achieve their goals. There is no higher accomplishment for a brand or a leader and people will most certainly sing your praise.
Latest News
WARC Names Its Most Awarded Campaigns & Agencies
The WARC Creative 100, Effective 100 and Media 100, a suite of global rankings and the ultimate independent gold standard for marketing communications, are now released featuring the most awarded campaigns, agencies and brands in the world for 2020. Compiled by WARC, the international marketing intelligence company, these annual league tables are produced by combining […]
Agent99 Hooks New Clients In FishMe! And Donna McGeorge
Award-winning independent PR Agency, Agent99, has hooked new clients in online seafood delivery service, FishMe!, as well as productivity specialist and author, Donna McGeorge (main photo). Since launching earlier this year, Sydney’s FishMe! has cut out the middleman and bricks-and-mortar overheads to ensure customers get great quality at competitive prices. The business was founded by […]
What We Don’t Know About Adland’s D&I And How That’s All About To Change
Yes people it's not one, but two censuses (or is that censii?) to complete this year. Antony Green will be pleased.
Menulog Celebrates The Best In Food Delivery With The ‘Menulogies’
Menulog has teamed with creative agency, Poem, and social agency, Connecting Plots, to launch the ‘Menulogies’, a rebrand of its 10th annual restaurant awards. Building on the success of previous years, the awards have returned with updated categories to reflect the latest culinary and social media trends, as well as loads of glitz and glamour […]
Yahoo Appoints Julia Edwards To NSW Sales Director
Yahoo has announced it has promoted Julia Edwards to NSW sales director. Since joining Yahoo 18-months ago, Edwards (main photo) has been instrumental in building the commercial success of Yahoo Creative Studios (formerly RYOT Studios) in her role as head of strategic solutions. She has been behind a number of industry-first campaigns using cutting-edge technology, […]
Jack Dorsey Quits, Parag Agrawal Named New Twitter CEO
Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey has stepped with immediate effect, replacing him, the company board unanimously appointed distinguished Chief Technology Officer (CTO) Parag Agrawal. After almost 16 years Jack Dorsey has decided it’s finally time to leave Twitter. Though, he will remain a member of the board until his term expires at the 2022 meeting of […]
Bob Gallagher Hangs Up His Mic & Bids Farewell To Breaky Radio
ARN has announced that Bob Gallagher from Brisbane’s 97.3FM’s Robin, Terry & Bob, has resigned from the popular breakfast show. After an extraordinary 19 years of working breakfast radio hours, Gallagher will turn off his early morning mic this Friday. Gallagher said: “I leave the show in great shape and I’m looking forward to a sleep-in after so many years of early morning […]
History Will Be Kind Wins Wins The Access Group’s Comms
Independent communications agency History Will Be Kind (HWBK) is taking its tech portfolio to the next level following a competitive pitch which has seen it win new client partner and leading business software provider, The Access Group. A significant global player in business software technology with a track record of impressive growth including the acquisition […]
CUB & TBWA\Melbourne Launch “Woody & Cola” Campaign That’s Bang On For The Demographic
CUB has launched a new “Woody & Cola” campaign via TBWA\Melbourne. Set to the well-known Escape (The Pina Colada Song), the campaign introduces characters ‘Woody’ and ‘Cola’, who are completely different, yet completely complimentary at the same time – much like Woodstock’s smooth oak-aged, blended Kentucky bourbon with sweet refreshing cola. Following their journey, Woody […]
Podium Announces Australia’s ‘Most Loved Local Businesses’
Local businesses communication and payments platform, Podium, and Council of Small Businesses Organisations of Australia (COSBOA) has today announced the winners of Australia’s Most Loved Local Businesses, which includes a specialised biking store and a stigma-busting dental practice. The campaign aimed to shine the spotlight on a handful of vibrant, dynamic and innovative Australian businesses following an […]
Monday TV Wrap: Nine’s Snackmasters Debuts & Wins Entertainment
Nine’s Snackmasters wins the night in entertainment pulling in 603,000 viewers – if you can watch this without snacking, as far as I’m concerned you are superhuman! In news, news – Seven News hit 949,000 viewers while Nine News had 872,000 viewers. Nine’s A Current Affair snagged the second entertainment spot with 696,000 viewers – Do you […]
Lawrence Mooney’s Clash With Triple M Goes Nuclear
Departed Triple M star Lawrence ‘Moonman’ Mooney would have lawyers salivating as he chases after a $1million-plus damages claim against his former employers. Mooney still had over a year remaining on his contract with SCA before an internal issue led to the popular personality’s abrupt departure from the airwaves. It’s believed his salary for 2021 […]
Decoding Creativity And Effectiveness
Spikes Asia talks with chief creative officer at Performance Art, Ian Mackenzie (main photo), about his Spike award winning campaign, ‘Publicly Traded’… When creativity is effective and effective work is creative, it has even greater power to positively impact people, brands and the world. Spikes Asia brings weekly insights from award winning creators of inspiring […]
How Twitter Is Raising The Bar On Brand Safety
People are at the centre of Twitter’s brand safety policies. By putting people first, Twitter is creating a safer space for brands to engage with the right audiences, at the right time, with the right conversations. As a platform where people come to participate in conversations, connect with others, and get information they can trust, […]
“45% Of Adland’s C-Suite Now Female!” MFA Releases Results Of Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Survey
Media agency members of the Media Federation of Australia (MFA) have completed the industry’s second annual DE&I survey, providing a holistic view of progress in the area of diversity, equity and inclusion. The aim of the survey – conducted in partnership with Mediai and completed by 2,203 individuals working in Australian media agencies – is […]
Ethical Cosmetics Company Lush Closes All Social Media Accounts
Ethical cosmetics chain Lush has boycotted social media over concerns it is having a negative impact on teenagers’ mental health. The cosmetics company closed down all it’s social media accounts last week, consisting of Instagram, Facebook and Snapchat. It’s a pretty big deal considering The Guardian, reported that Lush has amassed over 10 million followers […]
Cummins&Partners’ Paul Murphy Joins iProspect As Its Melbourne MD
Oliver Rapson, CEO iProspect Australia, has announced today the appointment of Paul Murphy as Managing Director, iProspect Melbourne, a new position for the office.
UnLtd Announces Open Applications For 2022 ‘Ambassador For Good’ Program
UnLtd and Yahoo’s inaugural Ambassador for Good program has come to a close for 2021, with the call for applications being sent out for next year. From over 80 applicants, 16 individuals from across the industry were selected into the launch initiative to use their skills and networks for good. Over the past year, the […]
Celeste Barber Teams Up With Bras N Things For A Relatable Lingerie Collection
Comedian and social media star, Celeste Barber has collaborated with lingerie brand Bras N Things for a relatable and wearable lingerie collection. Barber’s collaboration with Bras N Things is bright, vibrant and fun. It’s relaxed and comfortable but there is also plenty of drama and sass. Barber worked closely with the Bras N Things team […]
Creator Company Jellysmack Expands ANZ Team
Global creator company Jellysmack has announced its latest Australia and New Zealand team members as the company accelerates its growth plans in the region. Last month, Jellysmack launched its popular creator program in Australia and New Zealand and prioritised the region as a key growth market within the $US100 billion creator economy. The VC-backed technology […]
Exceptional Alien Joins Forces With Tourism NZ Launching Aotearoa Country Special
As this press photo taken in Clovelly, Sydney, will attest, NZ may be the last place on earth we're allowed to enter.
Mix 94.5 Partner With Starcom For Masters ‘Milk Carton’ Regatta
Bega’s flavoured milk brand, Masters, saw the return of its iconic Western Australian event over the weekend, with locals taking to the water at Hillary’s Boat Harbour in Perth, to race watercrafts made from Masters milk cartons. The ‘Masters Milk Regatta’ this year partnered with SCA’s Mix 94.5 station – with Starcom overseeing media strategy, […]
Love Island Australia Dumpees Join Tinder For One Night Of Swipes
Three dumped islanders from the Love Island Australia Villa will be joining Tinder for an exclusive in-app experience, ‘Swipe Island’, looking for another chance to find their lucky match. Between 6pm-11pm tonight, Aussie Tinder members will have the final chance to participate in the virtual ‘Swipe Island’ experience and match with ex Villa babes including […]
Nestlé Australia Announces Switch To 100 Per Cent Renewable Energy
Nestlé Australia has announced it is switching to renewable energy, meaning Aussie favourites, KitKat, Milo, Allen’s, Uncle Toby’s and Purina will now be made at 100 per cent renewable energy-powered factories. Nestlé Australia’s announcement comes four years ahead of its original global target of 2025. The company partnered with CWP Renewables to make its first renewable power […]
“It’s An Important Win For Seven” Seven’s James Warburton On The Networks 2021 Ratings Win
Seven boss chats with B&T on 2021 ratings win. Although we suspect he may have been looking at new Ferraris online.
“We Don’t Create Content For Total People!” Nine’s Michael Stephenson
B&T always loves a chat with Nine's Michael "Stevo" Stephenson. Although he does ask we call him Mr Stephenson.
Cocogun And UTS Announce New Scholarship For Indigenous Creative Students
It may be Australia's ugliest university, but UTS is proving its still has a heart of gold with this top initiative.
Why We Need More I In Team
Here's a top piece by the Ad Council's Hannah Sturrock that deserves your attention. Well, more than a passing glance.
Audience Group Among Several Agencies To Make AFR’s Fast 100 List For 2021
In good news for the industry, a number of agencies make the AFR's Fast 100 list. Still, not as many as tech companies.
TV Ratings Yearly Wrap: Seven Wins Eyeballs & Nine Claims Demos
Seven crowned 2021's ratings winner. Not stopping Nine execs doing their best to get their bonuses by claiming demos.
