How Did We Miss The Social Media Clues To The US Election Result?

How Did We Miss The Social Media Clues To The US Election Result?

In this episode of CSI Palo Alto, detective Darren Fishman (a Melbourne-based creative director and advertising writer) takes a forensic look at the digital clues that foreshadowed Donald Trump’s win.

It seems the mainstream media and the polls got it all wrong. Without a shadow of a doubt, they told us Hillary Clinton was going to be the first female president of the United States. But that’s not how it turned out, and if you looked carefully around you, there were clues to how it eventually did unfold. These clues were across the social and digital spheres and went beyond what conventional political polling could deliver.

Darren Fishman

Pictured: Darren Fishman

Facebook Live

Both Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump used Facebook live – he far more prolifically then her. Trump was going live up to five times a day in his effort to bypass the mainstream media and get his message out there.

The telling thing here was the number of viewers. While Clinton hovered around the 10,000 mark, Trump was getting five times that number… and more!

Sentiment was also telling, with Trump’s broadcast full of ‘thumbs up’ and ‘heart’ icons, while Clinton was copping the angry face emojis. And while comments on the Trump feed were 99 per cent positive, people were giving her a serve in the comments section of her Facebook Live broadcasts.

Hillary Clinton (Facebook Live)

Donald Trump (Facebook Live)Social Media Followers

Trump had a clear lead when it came to social media followers. On Facebook, his page has 13.5 million likes, with Clinton’s sitting at 9 million. Over on Twitter, the contest was closer, with Trump’s 14 million to Clinton’s 11 million. Overall, that represents a higher reach of around a third more people that are interested in one candidate over the other.

Donald Trump's Twitter page

Hillary Clinton's Twitter page

Rally Attendances

Once again here, Trump held a distinct advantage with massive numbers in the tens of thousands regularly turning out to his events, while Clinton was often lucky to get a few hundred.

Watching mainstream media, you wouldn’t have picked up on the discrepancy in attendances though with their tight shots of the podiums, but on social, people were posting the real story, showing massive stadiums full for Trump, while Clinton had half empty school halls. There were reports on social of her running mate Tim Kaine getting an embarrassing grand total of about 30 people to an outdoor rally in Florida!

US Presidential Election 2016 (rallies).png

The Social Zeitgeist

You need to break out of your own circle of friends to see what is truly the social sentiment in the ‘real world’. Most of us are stuck in our own filter bubble, mixing and interacting largely with people of our own age, same socio-economic groups, same geographical location, etc. They are mostly like you, but there’s a whole world out there!

Trawling public social and digital spaces like news sites and their social pages can be an eye-opener. Reading anecdotes from ordinary Middle Americans in comments sections can be telling.

I read of one person who drove a couple hundred miles from one county to another and saw loads of Trump signs along the way and only a handful of Clinton ones. He was concluding that it had to be an indication on which way people were leaning, and even he was questioning at the time where all these votes were going to come from that the mainstream media was telling us she had in the bag.

Google Trends

Interest in Donald Trump trumped interest in Hillary Clinton by a long way over the past 12 months in the US. A quick search on Google Trends would have told you this and been another indicator that the race was far from over.

US Presidential Election 2016 (Google Trends)

So, as that great philosopher George W. Bush once said, “Fool me once, shame on… shame on you. Fool me… You can’t get fooled again!” In other words, now you’ll know what to look for.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Darren Fishman jonesy & amanda romania sell

Latest News

Bankwest Unveils New Work Via Its Bespoke WPP Agency Union
  • Campaigns

Bankwest Unveils New Work Via Its Bespoke WPP Agency Union

Union, WPP AUNZ’s bespoke national group model created to service Bankwest, has launched a new national brand campaign for the visual-style terms and conditions the financial institution developed with the University of WA in a bid to make T&Cs more engaging for customers. Bankwest has rolled out visual terms and conditions for its Bankwest Easy […]

TikTok To Launch Web Series Supported By Screen Australia And Film Victoria
  • Media

TikTok To Launch Web Series Supported By Screen Australia And Film Victoria

The first ever web series to be funded by both Screen Australia and Film Victoria for TikTok, will launch on May 17. Produced by Hayley Adams and Michelle Melky, and directed by Logan Mucha, Scattered is a new queer drama comprised of 38 x 1-minute daily eps. It follows three best friends, Jules, Sami and […]

Schwartz Media To Launch Osman Faruqi’s The Culture Podcast
  • Media

Schwartz Media To Launch Osman Faruqi’s The Culture Podcast

Schwartz Media will extend its audio offering with a new culture podcast. Building on the success of its flagship daily news podcast 7am, and it’s growing arts and culture coverage, Schwartz Media is launching new podcast The Culture at the end of the month. Award-winning journalist, editor of 7am and pop-culture obsessive Osman Faruqi will […]

Attracting Customers With Horseshoe Magnet
  • Advertising
  • Opinion

How To Nurture Your Online Customers And Turn Them Into ‘Brand Evangelists’

Building a connection with existing customers is just as integral to any marketing strategy as winning new ones, but how do we turn customers into spokespeople for our brands? By Peggy de Lange, VP of international expansion at Fiverr It’s a well-known rule of thumb that it costs 5-times more to get a new customer […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Tooheys, 72andSunny, Vice And Gocsy Collaborate On ‘Proudly Ordinary’
  • Campaigns

Tooheys, 72andSunny, Vice And Gocsy Collaborate On ‘Proudly Ordinary’

In the next instalment of the ‘Proudly Ordinary’ campaign for Tooheys Extra Dry, Lion and 72andSunny continue their partnership with work from Vice and Aaron Gocs (Gocsy). Gocsy is a beloved icon of Australian outsider comedy who creates content for Vice and his own broadcast channels. As part of the highly successful ‘Proudly Ordinary’ brand […]

Have You Seen Trevor?
  • Marketing

Have You Seen Trevor?

Love an opinion piece with a mystery headline? You'll love this. Even more so if you're stuffing your gob with cake.


by Kathleen Farmilo

Kathleen Farmilo