During his time at Telstra, Brent Smart flipped the script on its performance-heavy marketing towards a brand-led approach. You’ve heard that one before. But you might not have heard the hard results.
During a talk at Mutinex’s Marketers & Money conference in Melbourne yesterday, Smart took listeners behind the scenes to reveal the impact of his work.
Smart is one of the country’s most celebrated marketers. He’s been on the B&T CMO Power List five times, once with NRMA Insurance and four times with Telstra. And for good reason.
When he and CEO Vicki Brady joined the telco, everything appeared to many internally that things were ticking along quite nicely.
“Inside Telstra, everyone was really convinced that things were going really well. Its NPS was at record highs, it spent billions and billions of dollars on the network. It clearly had the best network, winning on every single network measure. Our customers were pretty happy,” Smart told the crowd.
“Except when you looked at the reputation data, I’ve never seen a bigger delta between customers and non-customers. The thing we have to remember, these digital transformations, all this CX stuff we’re doing, only customers experience it. If you want your brand to grow, you need non-customers to think differently about the brand.”
While these are important, Smart, a self-confessed disciple of Binet and Field, believes the first job of any marketer is to create future demand – working for the 95 per cent of customers who are not currently in the market to buy and not existing customers.
But with a reputation problem, that 95 per cent of customers are unlikely to switch, hampering incremental growth.
To, literally, illustrate the gap between customers and non-customers, Smart commissioned a small ethnographic study with non-customers and asked them to draw how the Telstra brand made them feel. The results proved a turning point.
“One really made everyone have a sharp inhalation of breath when they saw it: you’re a bully. That’s how people really felt about this brand. I could have presented decks on decks and all the data in the world from the brand tracker. They’re free drawings,” smart said.
“We’ve got to think about creative storytelling, not just in advertising and communications and content but how we present internally as marketers. We’re storytellers and they way you demonstrate a problem is critical if you want to get support to change that problem.”
At the time, Telstra, Smart said, was spending around 80 per cent of its marketing budget on performance marketing. Ostensibly it was working well. Performance, he said, was driving $388 million of revenue and brand about $269 million.
To prove his belief that brand-focused marketing would prove more effective, Smart told the crowd that he ran a small test in Adelaide, moving half of his budget away from performance for four months.
“It probably isn’t long enough, we’d have liked longer… I banned the team from looking at any of the results until four months was up because you’ve got to be patient with brand.
“I remember presenting the results thinking ‘Please, store traffic and ecommerce hold’. I thought everything was going to fall off. We got the results back from Adelaide and it had outperformed the national average. Sales are up 14 per cent in Adelaide over a four-month period. Now I’ve got a data point that says when you spend more on brand, you don’t lose anything in terms of current demand. In fact, sales performance is going to increase,” said Smart.

“Now we’ve got conviction and data… the other thing, which I think is massively underrated in great marketers is patience. Most marketers have no patience. We change the work just when people are getting used to the work. We’re bored of it,” he added.
At the time, Telstra had not yet launched its new ‘Wherever We Go’ brand campaign created by Bear Meets Eagle on Fire and Omnicom bespoke agency +61, that would come in September 2024, nearly a full two years after he joined.
Again, conviction and patience would play key roles in its success.
“When we launched this thing, it was not good,” said Smart, quoting online reactions to the brand campaign.
The ad particularly irked NRL fans (Telstra is a major sponsor of the league) when it played straight after half time.
“People who tell you pre-testing is this very valuable, no pre-testing would have told you that when we run this ad and people’s rugby league team is losing, they have this incredibly angry reaction,” he said.
“I get the call from corporate comms… and sentiment for the ad on social is the most negative we’ve ever seen… Then Gruen say it’s the ad TikTokers love to hate. The early tracking was super polarising. A lot of people hated it, but a lot of people loved it.”
The rest, of course, you know. Social media users began to start parodying and mimicking the walk.
“It’s very tempting as a marketer to say, ‘OK, we’re going to pour fire on this, amplify i, do our versions of it, get in there’. That’s the worst thing you can do, especially if you’re a brand like Telstra. They don’t want you in there, this is their thing,” he said.
When half time during State of Origin, the most expensive TV spot on Telstra’s plan, rolled around, it made social media users the star. The results were, again, impressive for a polarising brand campaign. Smart said Telstra had 90 per cent of all telco category searches on TikTok and it achieved 30 million views.”[It] had 30 million organic views on TikTok that I didn’t pay a cent for… They say share of search is a great lead indicator of effectiveness,” Smart added.
All taken together, Telstra’s switch to 50-50 performance-brand advertising generated $500 million of nw connection revenue driven by marketing.
“The thing that no one thinks works is actually driving half a billion dollars of new connection revenue. But here’s the kicker, even though we’re spending way less on performance, our performance marketing has gone up… because we’ve spent three years building future demand and stronger brands convert better,” he said.
During his time at Telstra, the company even fell out of Nielsen’s top 20 list of Australia’s biggest advertisers.
Allianz, he said, is also proving the switch to brand advertising works. According to Nielsen, the insurer is outspent on media by several rivals. But, according to YouGov, it ranks highest among brand consideration for all insurers.
“Brand and creativity are not this sort of indulgent, award-winning, colouring-in thing. They are the most critical thing you can do as a marketer if you want to drive commercial impact. Start there. Most marketers start in the wrong place. They start with small, short-term tactics that look real good now, but you are leaving so much money on the table,” Smart said.
“I encourage everyone to rethink about branding creativity. Brand does have a branding problem. Let’s think about it differently, because I think it’s a commercial thing, not a colouring in thing.”


