Facebook Cops Criticism For ‘Safety Check’ Bias After Paris Attacks
Facebook has been left scrambling after being criticised for activating its ‘safety check’ feature for the Paris terrorist attacks, where 129 people died, but turning a blind-eye to bombing in Beirut, where 43 people died and 200 were injured.
The safety check feature is a notification which marks users as ‘safe’ if they are directly affected by natural disasters. This is the first time the safety check has been extended to terrorist attacks.
The decision to focus on Paris but not Beirut was attacked over Twitter and blogs. A Lebanese doctor, Elie Fares, wrote a blog post which has been picked up by publications like The New York Times, The Huffington Post and BBC UK.
“When my people died on the streets of Beirut on November 12th, world leaders did not rise in condemnation,” said Fares.
“There were no statements expressing sympathy with the Lebanese people. There was no global outrage that innocent people whose only fault was being somewhere at the wrong place and time should never have to go that way or that their families should never be broken that way or that someone’s sect or political background should never be a hyphen before feeling horrified at how their corpses burned on cement.”
I must admit that I’m a little confused as to why Safety Check was enabled in Paris and not in Beirut.
— Eleanor Saitta (@Dymaxion) November 14, 2015
And to answer many comments: yes, global outrage is selective. No Facebook safety check or Obama address for #Beirut yesterday.Sad but true.
— Mohamed El Dahshan (@eldahshan) November 14, 2015
#Facebook‘s safety status tool allows you to check on your friends, but ONLY in #Paris not in #Baghdad, #Damascus, #Gaza, or #Beirut.
— Sari al-Khalili (@Sari_AlKhalili) November 14, 2015
Yes, why don’t we? Hey zuckerberg, we are a small country in the med. just next to Palestine and Syria … https://t.co/N21y9QaEaa
— Sonya Sabbah (@SonyaSEtiq) November 14, 2015
Apparently Beirut doesn’t deserve a safety check on Facebook.
— DenniS the menace (@densection) November 15, 2015
Facebook sets up safety check for Paris friends.Thank you #facebook for this great initiative but what about Beirut and Syria…
— Samira Hamana (@SamiraHamana) November 14, 2015
Alex Schultz, vice president of growth at Facebook, posted an explanation of Safety Check in Paris. “People are also asking why we turned on Safety Check in Paris and not other parts of the world, where violence is more common and terrible things happen with distressing frequency. Thursday’s tragedy in Beirut is one recent example.
“We chose to activate Safety Check in Paris because we observed a lot of activity on Facebook as the events were unfolding.
“So we made the decision to try something we’ve never done before: activating Safety Check for something other than a natural disaster. There has to be a first time for trying something new, even in complex and sensitive times, and for us that was Paris.”
Facebook’s CEO and founder Mark Zuckerberg, who liked Schultz’s post, expanded on Facebook’s explanation in his own post:
“Many people have rightfully asked why we turned on Safety Check for Paris but not for bombings in Beirut and other places.
“Until yesterday, our policy was only to activate Safety Check for natural disasters. We just changed this and now plan to activate Safety Check for more human disasters going forward as well.
“Thank you to everyone who has reached out with questions and concerns about this. You are right that there are many other important conflicts in the world.”
Latest News
“Tiny Tech, Mighty Spec” Says Panasonic’s Newest Campaign Via Awaken
Panasonic is launching its newest offering with a charming and cheeky campaign that emphasises the contrast between the camera’s small size and vast capability.’ Using the tagline “Tiny tech. Mighty spec.” the campaign, created for Panasonic by Awaken Media, puts a spotlight on the fact that this impressive new camera is a powerful piece of […]
Mindshare Snares Kayo’s & Binge’s Media
Mindshare staff sent to the basement to dust-off the picnic chairs & trestle table after winning the Kayo & Binge biz.
Aussie Tech Firm Launches App To Help Media Owners Find Local Advertisers In Any Location
Realworld, an Australian location-based technology company, today launched adfindr.co, a leads platform for media owners. Adfindr finds the contact details of hundreds of local businesses around any location. Adfindr offers all media owners a database of local advertising leads. Simply type in a location and extract advertising leads in that area. David Sanderson, Director at […]
Study: Aussies Eye Bricks & Mortar Return This Christmas
Quote Shakespeare when looking for a car spot at Christmas? Ready your "convert to anger; blunt not the hearts" here.
Black Lives Matter Escalates Importance Of Diversity In Just 14% Of Workplaces
We're very diverse & inclusive in the B&T office. Although we do have a good laugh picking on the bloke from Adelaide.
Women In Media’s Elle Bullen: “We Must Get Better At Supporting Our People & Ourselves”
Here's top advice from SDWM’s Elle Bullen. But then when does B&T give bad advice? Those few defamation cases aside.
Monday TV Wrap: SAS Holds Strong In Second Week
SAS has proven good news for Seven and even better news for Tele, Daily Mail and B&T journalists to hang shit on.
Barbie Confronts White Privilege, As Brand Hailed For Its Bravery In Confronting Racism
In a delicious irony, a blonde woman who owns a Malibu mansion, camper and "toy boy" Ken is tackling white privillege.
Time To Fill? Then It’s Time To Will With State Trustees Via Hardhat
The new Online Will from State Trustees has launched with an unexpected campaign via newly appointed creative agency Hardhat, one that aims to turn in between moments into opportunities for action. Having a baby, moving house or exploring some thrilling new hobbies – this colourful, tongue-in-cheek campaign leverages the types of life stages that trigger […]
Destination Gold Coast Appoints In Marketing We Trust As Digital Marketing Agency
The Gold Coast offers world-class attractions all from the comfort of your own double-pluggers & footy training shorts.
Burger King’s Back Trolling Its Competitors In Spooky Halloween Spot
You either love Halloween or you don't. And if you're the latter, don't put carved pumpkins outside or open the door.
Hardie Grant Media Announces Publishing And Sales Partnership With RACT
B&T does actually believe there's a person in this press photo. Admittedly, you do have to strain the old peepers.
WorkSafe & FBC NZ Launch Wild New Campaign Challenging New Zealanders To Take A Fresh Look At Workplace Safety
Worksafe and FCB New Zealand have launched a wild new campaign, challenging New Zealanders to take a fresh look at workplace safety. The launch TVC, hitting screens big and small this week, asks workers to be more vigilant and proactive, by listening to their inner-meerkats. In the last five years, WorkSafe has recorded 363 workplace […]
Campaign To Tackle Macular Disease Brings Impressive Celeb Cachet
B&T's never suffered macular disease but we once had Mackerel disease after a choking incident with the pub's fish pie.
Curtin University Launches Major Brand Campaign Via AnalogFolk
In one of the greater shocks, Curtin University actually doesn't run courses in drapery, rideau or window furnishings.
UnLtd Reports Record $31.2M Industry Social Impact
Here's an industry feel good story. Which B&T likes to think is better than a redundancy story or a police raid story.
Aussies Called To ‘Flex Their True Colours’ In New Lifeblood Campaign Via B.B.E And Cummins&Partners
Lifeblood has joined forces with six Aussie artists, launching a new campaign featuring limited-edition artist-designed bandages in a bid to boost blood and plasma donations over the coming weeks. The integrated campaign, True Colours, will be rolled out nationally over six weeks, encompassing digital, social, OOH, radio, PR, and media partnerships. Donors across the country […]
“Where’s The Craic?” Guinness Goes Booze-Free With Launch Of Guinness 0.0
With Guinness going alcohol-free, how will Bondi police spend their time no there's no drunk backpackers to arrest?
Imagine Room Revolutionises Immersive Content With Australia’s First Microsoft Mixed Reality Capture Studio
Immersive media company Imagine Room has signed an exclusive agreement with Microsoft to build and operate Australia’s first Mixed Reality Capture Studio to drive the next generation of content production. The state-of-the-art studio uses 106 cameras to create holographic and 3D-video performance assets and create immersive and interactive experiences for virtual reality (VR), augmented reality […]
Ex-Isobar CEO Konrad Spilva Launches Creative Consultancy Shadowboxer
Ex-Isobar CEO launches creative consultancy Shadowboxer. Although refutes name was taken from the seminal Angels track.
oOh! Dives Into Data To Support Movember’s 2020 Campaign
Time to look like an Australian 70s fast bowler, adult movie star or SBS' George Donikian as Movember's just about here.
WPP Appoints “Technologist, Scientist & Entrepreneur” Dr Ya-Qin Zhang To Board
WPP appoints Dr Ya-Qin Zhang to the board. And, no, he won't be handing out scripts for Ritalin or methylphenidates.
Study: Why The Australian Made Green & Gold Kangaroo Remains A Winner
The Australian Made logo has confirmed its international appeal, with new Horizon Consumer Science research finding 97 per cent of overseas consumers have a positive first impression of the iconic green and gold kangaroo. The research, which was carried out in six diverse export markets, found that more than two thirds (70 per cent) of […]
DDB Melbourne Wins Dulux’s Creative
DDB Melbourne can't decide if reception should be Avocado Dreaming or Ruby Haemorrhoid after snaring Dulux Paints.
Heckler Collaborates For OnePlus Nord’s Gray Ash Global Launch
Design and visual effects house Heckler has created the international launch video for global technology brand OnePlus’ newest offering: the OnePlus Nord special edition Gray Ash smartphone.
The Bottle-O Goes Musical In New Brand Campaign Via Channel T
Is it just us or is there a surprising number of booze ads on B&T today? You can almost get cirrhosis just reading.
Sapporo Brings Origins To Life In New Manga-Inspired Campaign Via Cummins&Partners
Alongside ironic T-shirts and thick rimmed spectacles, a love of Manga is essential for any budding agency creative.
Women in Media’s Cara Meade: “Find Clarity When There Is Chaos, Inspire Action Where There Is Lethargy”
Looking for a bit of Monday inspiration? Well, this is an essential read. Or, there's always the pub schnitzel.
“You Don’t Need To Be A Star To Have A Voice” Says Nike In New Voting Campaign
When a pair of trainers cost you 250 bucks it's only fair that Nike repays us with a new ad campaign every second day.
Lawyers Called In As Roxy Jacenko And Candice Warner Fight It Out Over Agency Contract
Oh no! The Roxy-Candice stoush has taken a decidedly ugly turn. Here's hoping Candice can keep control of her bowels.
