Advertising “In Structural Decline”: NYU’s Scott Galloway

As new technologies change the way companies interact with customers, NYU Stern marketing professor Scott Galloway has predicted advertising’s death as the value chain upon which brands are built is reshaped, and capital re-allocates from traditional media into product innovation, discovery and distribution.
In arguably the best presentation at Cannes this year, Galloway stated – a belief he has since repeated – that the sun has passed midday on the role of traditional brand as a function of broadcast media.
He said the traditional channel-customer relationship managed by a push approach in communication, where an average product with great advertising was the brand building algorithm, is over.
“Simply put you want to be a builder, not a brander – great products breakthrough,” Galloway said.
“It is not that brands do not matter – it is they just don’t matter as much.”
According to Galloway, traditional brands as we know them are declining in value due to digital “diligence tools”.
He said the tools of product discovery have turned from broadcast to Amazon, TripAdvisor, social media and search, and therefore consumers now no longer need to defer to a brand.
“Their favourite brand is going to be whatever Google tells them at that moment it matches their exact needs,” Galloway said.
In fact, the percentage of consumers that can identify their favourite brand across key categories has declined by somewhere between 30 and 50 per cent, Galloway added.
Consequently, the traditional media industry is on the wrong end of this change in consumer diligence, and TV specifically is ripe for disruption, he said.
Galloway noted that TV has raised its prices faster than inflation but with no underlying increase in productivity, innovation or effectiveness.
“There are going to be more people with Amazon Prime subscriptions than cable in the US in seven years’ time,” he said.
“The people who are cutting cords are young and wealthy, so effectively they are exiting the platforms where they can be exposed to traditional marketing.”
Galloway said innovation, as well as the young and rich, are going to non-ad-supported programming where the storytelling is not interrupted by ads.
He said that these over-the-top platforms are growing 30 per cent year-on-year, while all the ad-supported media is in decline.
“You pay a price to effectively exit the advertising ecosystem,” he said.
“I think advertising has become a tax that only the poor and technologically illiterate pay.
“Anyone with any money is going to have the technology and the ability to start avoiding most advertising out there.
“Advertising is not a great business – it is in structural decline.”
Galloway predicts this will put a strain on advertising industrial complex as capital re-allocates from traditional advertising into product innovation, and also into direct-to-consumer retail.
He noted that Apple spent almost 50 per cent less of its revenue on advertising, compared to Samsung, who dominates digital advertising and has chosen to re-allocate its capital into stores.
“Samsung may come out with a better product in the next few months, but it will take them about ten years to match the brand of Apple,” he said.
“Apple has taken about $4 billion in a year and allocated it into 450 retail stores such that no matter how cool Samsung’s VR is, it is never going to match the brand capital that Apple has invested in their unbelievable purchase temples to the brand that Apple calls their stores.
“But with Samsung, you are still going to have to walk into a Verizon or AT&T store and talk to someone with a name badge on who does not really know how to sell the product.
“Apple’s core competitive killer product is not their iPhone – it is their stores, and they are the most productive retail stores in the world.”
Galloway said retail stores dying and going out of business is a myth.
“That is bullshit,” he said.
“The middle class are dying. Stores in wealthy neighbourhoods are doing just fine.
“Show me a middle-class neighbourhood, and I will show you all businesses are going out of business, including stores.
“General Growth Properties and Simon [Property Group] are the largest mall developers in the US. Moreover, their stocks are at an all-time high. Why? Because they own malls where rich people live.”
Galloway said the brands that are doing well, with the most visibility, are those that re-allocate capital from broadcast advertising into product innovation, innovative product discovery and distribution.
“How much does Tesla spend on traditional advertising? Zero,” he said.
“The big idea in the auto industry 20 to 30 years ago was ‘let’s have Cindy Crawford talk about Cadillac’ or ‘let’s call the Volkswagen a lemon’.
“Now all the big ideas in the auto industry are around product innovation like self-driving cars and self-parking cars.
“It is the reallocation of advertising dollars into R&D.
“If you look at the companies that are winning, they all spend a disproportionate amount of capital on products trying to make a better product, because better products break through the algorithm.”
Galloway said the death of advertising will also hurt companies who have built great businesses on traditional media, specifically consumer packaged goods (CPG) brands.
“CPG is the house that advertising built,” he said.
“Of the top 100 CPG brands in America, 90 per cent lost share and two-thirds of them lost revenue.”
Galloway attributes this to every aspect of CPG being attacked by a well-financed player who is exiting the advertising ecosystem and investing in subscription models.
“If you look at Google Search – a great proxy for brand equity – you will see the Honest Company has more searches than Pampers or Huggies,” he noted.
“Moreover, you will see the same thing with Dollar Shave Club versus Gillette, which used to have an 80 per cent market share.”
Galloway argued that subscription is a better business model because it creates a sufficiently large lifetime value that enables a brand to invest into customer acquisition.
He said recent behavioural research supports the idea people have limited bandwidth to make decisions. Moreover, the more daily decisions people have to make, the greater the likelihood they will make a bad decision.
“I think the reason we are moving towards a subscription-based economy is young people are figuring out if you take every non-critical decision in your life and move it out, you can focus your limited bandwidth on decisions that matter,” he said.
The top advertisers in the world have not changed much in 50 years, and according to Galloway, data analysis reveals the world’s biggest advertisers are losing share of revenue relative to GDP.
In a bid to reverse this trend, some of the largest brands are moving towards new business models to recapture market share.
“P&G are now investing in Amazon dash trying to make CPG products with recurring revenue,” Galloway explained.
“They are reducing their ad spend as a percentage of sales in the last three years.
“The writing is on the wall – the biggest advertisers in the world are reducing their ad budgets and reallocating capital out of traditional marketing.”
Latest News

Eastern Standard Times Hold Launch Event In Deeply Cultural Setting
Global media network Eastern Standard Times had their official launch event on Thursday (23/6) night at the Lucky Kwong restaurant in Sydney’s South Eveleigh, with the focus being placed on how this platform will provide Asian communities in Australia with a greater insight on what they need to know. Editor-in-chief Keshia Hannam, who served as […]

Samsung Slammed With $14M Fine By Federal Court For “Misleading Waterproof Claims”
Thank god we have Korean boy bands because some of the country's leading brands lead a lot to be desired.

Woolworths’ Andrew Hicks Named As One Of The World’s Top 50 CMOs
Woolies' marketing supremo celebrating with an iceberg lettuce or two after being named one of the world's best CMOs.

Nike To Become Latest Big Brand To Officially Abandon Russia
Russians set to queue for bread in their thongs as Nike becomes latest western capitalist dog to exit the country.

Netflix Co-CEO Meets With Reps From Google At Cannes To Strike A Potential Ad Partnership
Ads might soon be coming to Netflix. Although we're quite sure Messrs Warburton, Sneesby etc will be having none of it.

Harrowing Campaign Shows The Last Photos & Videos Of Suicide Victims
Ready the tissues at this incredibly powerful and brave mental health initiative.

Alfi Study Reveals Entertainment & Media Will Be Main Focus Of DOOH Ads Within The Next Year
DOOH continues to prove the hot category in adland. That said, B&T's still got a soft spot for towed plane banner ads.

TV Journo Goes Viral After Mistakenly Drawing Large Penis During Report Into The Capitol Riots
Were your school days full of drawing penises on the blackboard and afternoon detentions? Relive the good times here.

ACT Responsible Awards Wunderman Thompson Australia As One Of This Year’s Champions Of Good
ACT Responsible celebrated 4 Champions for Good from the agency, advertiser, NGO and public sectors who have made an impact in the social and environmental areas and helped improve the world through personal contributions or creative campaigns. “It is not an Award. There is no competition and there is no winner. The goal of this […]

Thursday TV Wrap: Footy Punts Seven To A Big Win
The AFL proved a ratings winner for Seven last night. Just not in Sydney, were no one gives a shit unless the Swans win.

WARC Announce The Winners For Their 2022 Award In Effectiveness
If B&T ever had an award for effectiveness, it would go to our publican for his 5-6pm half-price pints happy hour.

Cannes Lions: VICE Media Win Third Grand Prix For Their ‘Unfiltered History Tour’
On the third day of the 2022 Cannes Lions International Festival of Creativity, the “Unfiltered History Tour” campaign by VICE Media walked away with yet another Grand Prix, this time in the Social & Influencer Lions. The campaign, which was held in partnership with the British Museum by the Dentsu Creative teams of Mumbai, Bengaluru […]

Foodies Unite! Apply For The Food Category At The Australian Impact Awards Powered By Wavia
Is food your business? Well, why not sink your teeth into the Australian Impact Awards' food category.

THE TIME IS NOW: Entries For B&T’s Best Of The Best Close Today!
Do you loathe an overachieving colleague? Completely ruin their afternoon by making them do a Best of the Best entry.

‘Kill Your Advertising’ Documentary Launches At Cannes, Shaking Up The Current Sate Of The Marketing Industry
The state of adland to be laid bare in new doco. Sadly it doesn't have Sir Martin in the lead role of wanton spinster.

SICKDOGWOLFMAN Launches New Campaign For Moro Dubbed ‘Now Add you’ With Sweetshop
Moro is, of course, the olive oil brand & thankfully not the unpleasant chocolate found in the Cadbury's Favourite pack.

Cannes Diary: Atomic 212º’s Asier Carazo Reports
Atomic 212º's Asier Carazo talks the Cannes experience in this diary piece. And not just paying $42 for a baguette.

A Jury Insiders View From Cannes Lions 2022
Bomb again at Cannes this year? Glean some lessons here & be thankful you don't need to fork out for any Brasso Polish.

10 Recruits Natasha Exelby & Lachlan Kennedy To Captain New Breakfast Efforts
Wake-up with 10's Natasha Exelby & Lachlan Kennedy! Which is far better than waking up with that stranger from the pub.

Antipodean Gold Rush At Cannes As The ANZAC Spirit Triumphs
It's a chant of "Aussie, Aussie, Aussie" around Cannes' Pointe Croisette today. There's possibly a bit of vomit too.

Cannes Day Two: Paris Hilton Talks NFTs And What It Means For Brands
B&T’s Nancy Hromin is in Cannes and managed to bag a seat at probably this year’s highlight event – an audience with the one-and-only, Paris Hilton! The socialite took to the stage alongside CEO of VaynerX and Vayner Media, Gary Vaynerchuk, and Swan Sit the board director of Edgewell, Novabay and Far Niente. The trio […]

Five Ways Logos Have Changed Since Lockdowns Lifted
COVID's not merely enhanced our love of toilet paper and Uber Eats, but changed logo design argues this correspondent.

Google Creates New Way For You To Filter Through The News Stories You See
Tech company Google has announced a number of new updates to its News and Search features that will give users greater control and more validated information in the stories they see on their screens. The look of Google News will be changing dramatically, giving way to the side of the screen for a bar that […]

In The Shadow Of Cannes Lions, NFT.NYC Brings Together The World Of Digital Investors
While the marketing industry continues to keep its glaze focused on the South of France and the Cannes Lions International Festival of Creativity, a few thousands of kilometres further away in Manhattan there’s another “festival” going on. NFT.NYC is the biggest conjunction of Web3 artists and investors in the world and by the looks of […]

Contempt Of Court: Lisa Wilkinson Calls In The Lawyers Following Logies Disaster
Lisa Wilkinson joins Lisa McCune and Craig McLachlan in having a Logies win utterly destroy their careers.

Google Adds New Label On Search And Maps For LGBTQI+ Businesses
Mistakenly head out for a coffee only to end up in a gay sex sauna? You've now got this new Google feature to blame.

Brad Pitt Announces Retirement Plans (& Other Things) In Trippy Cover Shoot For GQ
B&T can barely afford to buy GQ let alone anything in it, but all is forgiven when Brad's on the cover.

Adform Unveils PwC Study Showing The Value Of First-Party IDs
You either love first-party IDs or you've never actually heard of them. This one's clearly for the former.

Twitter Will Soon Let You Go Way Beyond the 280 Characters Limit With Its New Notes Feature
Do you avoid Twitter for your anonymous trolling due to its word limits? Get set to be an utter prick with this news.

Wednesday TV Wrap: Gruen Delivers Strong Numbers But Seven Takes The Night
There's only one place to be for any self-respecting adlander on a Wednesday & that's the pub. Ok, maybe watching Gruen.

Reports: Rupert Murdoch Set To Divorce Jerry Hall
It appears the heat's gone out of Rupert and Jerry's love life. Rupert still denying it had to do with climate change.

Mastercard Uses Cannes To Unveil ‘Priceless’ Album To Support Emerging Artists
Mastercard to release an album that sadly won't include ABBA's 'Money, Money, Money' or Joe Dolce's 'Shaddap Your Face'.

Study Shows Aussie Marketers Still Lacking Maturity In Data Privacy Management
Study finds marketers lacking skills in data privacy. Not scared to fire-up the paper shredder if things get really bad.

AKQA Unveils Ten Week Tee As The Winners Of Grand Prix For Future Lions 2022
Now in its 16th year, Future Lions, AKQA’s annual Cannes Lions competition to unearth the next generation of creative talent, has announced the winners and Grand Prix. The awards ceremony is taking place during the iconic Cannes Lions International Festival of Creativity. This year’s Grand Prix winner is Ten Week Tee, the team will now […]

WPP Partners With Ukrainian Government To Support Economic Recovery
Cannes is too often a lot of hot air from entitled, white rich people. But it can also do good, like this initiative.

QMS Promotes Four In The Sales Department
It's promotions galore in the QMS sales team today, as discussions turn to the merits of the Audi over the Golf GTI.