The traditional agency model is running out of road, according to Jules Hall, founder and chief executive of The Hallway told B&T in an exclusive chat ahead of the agency’s repositioning.
In order to survive, agencies need to rethink what they’re doing in view of what’s coming next. To that end, The Hallway has spent the past 18 months rebuilding its business around CERTNTY OS.
It’s a new proprietary-based AI-powered operating system designed to connect creative, media, data and measurement. Such is its scope, the agency has a new positioning, ‘Calculated Creativity’.
The overhaul comes as agencies contend with a changing competitive landscape, the growing influence of AI and tighter budgets.
For Hall, the pressure to adapt is not a new development, but the pace of change has accelerated considerably since he established The Hallway in 2007.
At that time, the industry was dominated by a handful of large agency groups, operating on a model that Hall believes has become increasingly difficult to sustain. The growth of in-housing, in particular, has taken a significant bite out of agency revenue.
Then came another wave of competition, with established agency leaders launching independent businesses following the pandemic.
“You’ve got this wild situation where the market shrunk 40 per cent and the competitive set has tripled,” Hall told B&T.
Add AI and technological advancements to that equation, and Hall believes agencies have little choice but to reconsider their operating models.
“Two years ago I was intimidated by it all. It’s now undoubtedly the most exciting time for the marketing industry. There’s so much opportunity.”
But taking advantage of that opportunity requires more than introducing new technology.
The Hallway’s transformation was partly prompted by the loss of the GWM account in 2024, which Hall described as a particularly difficult period for the business. Rather than attempt to rebuild around its previous model, he decided to take a longer view of where the industry was heading.
One of the biggest opportunities he identified was helping marketers better understand the commercial case for brand investment.
While marketing science has become more widely understood, Hall believes many businesses still struggle to translate that knowledge into decisions about how much to spend, where to invest and how to demonstrate the return.
That is the thinking behind CERTNTY OS, which brings together three stages of marketing investment: Model, Make and Measure.
The system combines audience and commercial intelligence, creative development and AI-enabled production with ongoing measurement, with the aim of connecting decisions across the entire process.
One of the practical applications of that thinking is The Hallway’s new Amplify product, which is focused on scaling customer experience content through AI.
Rather than rely on teams to manually produce variations of messaging for different audiences and interactions, Amplify uses AI to automate the process. It draws on human-developed strategic inputs to ensure the resulting content remains consistent with a brand’s voice and objectives.
The idea is to make the production of personalised customer communications faster and more efficient, without removing the strategic thinking that informs what a brand says and how it says it.
Hall said the technology could reduce a process that previously took a week or two to complete to just minutes. But he is less convinced that AI is ready to replace the human thinking behind original ideas.
“Creativity is the area where it has the least input, because you still need that human magic to take the inputs and make that leap, and to use that empathy,” Hall said.
The relationship between creative and media is another area Hall believes agencies should reconsider.
While larger advertisers may have the resources to maintain specialist partners, he saw an opportunity for businesses with more modest media budgets to bring the disciplines together.
“You get bigger impact, better outcomes, and you save cost on the way through because you’ve got one set, one point of contact, one strategic team,” Hall said.
The economics of production have also forced agencies to rethink how they charge clients. With AI making certain types of work faster and cheaper to produce, Hall believes agencies need to accept that their pricing structures will have to change.
“Market forces require you to deliver better work in less time at lower cost,” he said.
“You’ve got to charge less. We all aspire to aligning our remuneration to outcomes. It’s actually very hard to do. I think that’s what we should all be aspiring to. The reality is that pricing models have not moved on that much just yet.”
That shift has implications beyond costs. If agencies are expected to deliver more for less, Hall believes they also need to reconsider where they create value for clients and how they demonstrate it.
Hall’s argument is that technology should make agencies better at what they do, rather than become the reason they do it.
And while the operating model may need to change, he believes the fundamentals of effective marketing remain firmly rooted in commercial outcomes.
“There’s a lot of dashboards in the lives of marketers. They don’t want more. They want better,” he said.
“A brand isn’t serving the business. A brand exists to serve a business outcome.”
For an agency approaching two decades in business, Hall’s latest reinvention is an attempt to ensure it is not simply relying on the model that got it here to determine what comes next.

