“Would Obama Be President?”: Industry Leaders Debate Whether Advertising Leads Culture

“Would Obama Be President?”: Industry Leaders Debate Whether Advertising Leads Culture
B&T Magazine
Edited by B&T Magazine
SHARE
THIS



Powered by Nine’s fortnight of panels and events ended last night with a highly engaging debate on the motion: does advertising lead culture?

While the audience ultimately voted against the proposition – agreeing that advertising is instead led by culture – there were extremely compelling arguments on both sides.

In the affirmative were Rachael Fraser, Head of Strategy at M&C Saatchi, Roshni Hegerman, Executive Strategy Director at McCann Worldgroup, and Toby Boon, Director Strategy, Insight and Effectiveness at Powered (pictured right with Liana DuBois, director of Powered).

Arguing the negative was Andrew Wynne, Principal at JOY, Michele O’Neill, Director of Powered Enterprise, and Camille Gray, Strategist at Rufus, Powered by Initiative (and shortlisted B&T 30 Under 30 award nominee!).
Opening the debate was Rachel Fraser, who questioned where our society would be without the power of advertising.

She began with an image of an advertising-free world: “would Obama ever have become president? Would women still be stuck in the kitchen? Would I have a mum-bob, a side-part, or be aware that my skinny jeans should be replaced by straight ones if I have any chance of not being ‘cheugy’?”

Much of the debate focused on definitions: what is advertising, what is culture and, perhaps most importantly, what does it mean to lead?

The affirmative’s argument largely rested on the idea of leading culture as shaping it. They claimed that “culture is the ship, advertising is the captain”.

All three speakers used the example of smoking – the advertising industry popularised smoking, but is also the reason for its demise in popularity.

However, as pointed out by the negative team’s third speaker Camille Gray, advertising alone was not responsible for the decline in smoking – it was also because the government massively increased the price of tobacco.

“The government actually interviewed and spoke with a massive range of cultures about their relationship with smoking. They used cultural insights to create those ads – the culture lead the ad,” she argued.

For the negative team, advertising does not lead or create culture, rather it amplifies and reflects specific elements of existing culture. In some cases, it does bring niche elements of culture into the mainstream, but it doesn’t truly create.

Andrew Wynne, the negative team’s first speaker, accused the opposition of “[overclaiming] the role of advertising, and [underclaiming] the work of everything else in the world.”

This was emphasised by their second speaker Michelle O’Neil who argued that advertisers sell, rather than lead. The things that actually lead culture are education, war, and design.

While the affirmative team referenced the significance of advertising in our society – with second speaker Roshni Haberman pointing to the ubiquity of slogans like “not happy, Jan” or iconic figures like Rhonda and Ketut – ultimately, the audience was not swayed.

The winning argument of the negative team was perhaps best captured by Camille Gray in her closing remarks, when she made the case that: “A doctor brings a stethoscope to work. What does an advertiser bring? They bring a mirror.”

Please login with linkedin to comment

The Big Ideas Store

Latest News

Aussie Shoe Brand TWOOBS Embraces Anti-Marketing In Push For More Consumer-conscious Shopping
  • Marketing

Aussie Shoe Brand TWOOBS Embraces Anti-Marketing In Push For More Consumer-conscious Shopping

After relaunching in September last year, TWOOBS has become a ‘kinda’ shoe brand by also focusing on making the world a ‘kinder’ place and creating more consumer-conscious shopping. The vegan shoe brand founded by sisters Jess and Stef Dadon changed its marketing approach last year and stopped using social media to push sales the old-fashioned […]

Visit Sunshine Coast Hires New Head Of Marketing
  • Marketing

Visit Sunshine Coast Hires New Head Of Marketing

Highly experienced tourism marketer Kelly Ryan has been appointed to lead the marketing efforts at Visit Sunshine Coast (VSC). During the past 12 years, Ryan has supported Canberra’s tourism industry in senior marketing roles, including as director of strategy and insights as well as director of marketing at VisitCanberra. Most recently, Ryan has been working […]

GHO Sydney And Family Planning NSW Launch ‘Planet Puberty’ Platform
  • Campaigns

GHO Sydney And Family Planning NSW Launch ‘Planet Puberty’ Platform

GHO Sydney has developed a new educational platform for Family Planning NSW to help parents and carers of children with disabilities navigate the changes to their bodies, emotions and social interactions. The project, ‘Planet Puberty’, was made possible through funding from the federal government’s Department of Social Services, and was co-designed with people with disability […]

JCDecaux Announces New Partnership With Bush Heritage Australia
  • Media

JCDecaux Announces New Partnership With Bush Heritage Australia

JCDecaux today announced conservation organisation, Bush Heritage Australia, as its major charity partner for 2021. The partnership is part of a series of ‘social impact’ initiatives the business is launching this year, under the banner of JCDecauxHEART. JCDecauxHEART focuses on three areas of social impact: health and mental health, environmental sustainability, and enriching urban communities. […]

Shameless Duo Michelle Andrews And Zara McDonald Launch New Podcast Exclusive To LiSTNR
  • Media

Shameless Duo Michelle Andrews And Zara McDonald Launch New Podcast Exclusive To LiSTNR

Shameless Media’s Michelle Andrews and Zara McDonald’s latest podcast, The Books That Changed My Life, will launch exclusively on LiSTNR on Tuesday, 15 June. Throughout the series Michelle and Zara will talk with guests including Kevin Kwan, Laura Henshaw, Jock Zonfrillo, Susan Carland, Hamish Blake and Delta Goodrem about the books that have had a profound impact […]

Business and technology concept.
  • Partner Content

Make Your CX Stand Out From The Competition

It's top tips to ensure your CX stands out from the competition. Then again, you could simply plagiarise their stuff.

Partner Content

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Why The Future of Work Is Hybrid
  • Opinion

Why The Future of Work Is Hybrid

This expert argues the future of work is hybrid. Which is sad news, as B&T'd preferred it was rhumba or the bossa nova.

Champion Launches Pride Campaign And Partnership With Queer Sporting Alliance
  • Advertising
  • Marketing

Champion Launches Pride Campaign And Partnership With Queer Sporting Alliance

In celebration of Pride Month, cult streetwear brand Champion has announced an Australia-and New Zealand-first Pride range, Champions of Pride, and ongoing partnership with the Queer Sporting Alliance. Championing a cause, celebrating community, and aiming to create real change, the capsule collection proudly heroes the Pride colours in a selection of signature Champion tees, iconic […]

UK Based BankiFi Expands To Australia
  • Marketing

UK Based BankiFi Expands To Australia

Following the successful deployment of BankiFi’s technology platform at The Co-operative Bank in the UK, BankiFi has appointed Lloyd Parata to lead their expansion into the Australian Financial Services market. BankiFi’s technology platform ensures banks remain relevant by offering SMEs an innovative solution to operate their business, whilst avoiding common challenges like late payment. Parata, […]

5 Gum Announces New Twitch Partnership
  • Media

5 Gum Announces New Twitch Partnership

Mars Wrigley 5 Gum has partnered with Twitch to launch Team CLUTCH, a team of Twitch streamers who will assemble on for three live squad streams tackling popular games like Fortnite while embodying the brand’s ethos of ‘life happens in 5’. This partnership builds on 5 Gum’s 2020 Twitch activation, and is set to create […]