Is This The Worst Government Ad Ever?

Is This The Worst Government Ad Ever?
SHARE
THIS



The federal government has done itself no favours in trying to recruit graduates to work in the Department of Finance, releasing a new ad that is just plain hard to watch.

The video, titled ‘The Game Changers’, is designed to promote the Department of Finance’s graduate program, and features a number of real-life staff who interact awkwardly in some terribly-scripted scenes that would have NIDA graduates doubling over in pain.

Government tenders obtained by Fairfax show the ad cost $37,400 and was created by Together Creative, and agency that describes itself as “famously good” with the ability to develop “head-turning campaigns”.

Speaking to Fairfax, Campaign Edge creative director Dee Madigan described the ad as “truly terrible”.

“I always say real people are terrible at playing real people. No one will watch that to the end,” she said.

“It’s probably one of the worst recruitment videos I’ve ever seen.

“This idea that you have to show the target market to appeal to them is incorrect. Having people in situ having fake conversations has very little cut through. If you actually need real people in an ad, you cast actors.

“Any department that approved that ad, you just wouldn’t want to work for. They should be asking for their money back.”

Cummins & Partners’ Adam Ferrier said the ad was cringeworthy and “unfortunate” given the time and money that went into the campaign.

“This I’m pretty sure would make many people who work in finance cringe,” he told Fairfax.

“People need to realise that everything, everything communicates. From the length of the video, the low production values, the clichéd language – it all communicates.”

Please login with linkedin to comment

Advertising Standards Bureau Department of Finance Together Creative

Latest News

Building New Social Experiences On Facebook Gaming: Play Watch Connect
  • Campaigns
  • Media
  • Technology

Building New Social Experiences On Facebook Gaming: Play Watch Connect

For years, people have been able to play games, watch gaming videos and connect with fellow gamers on Facebook. But what if we could do more? Imagine a world where you didn’t just watch a gaming creator stream their play session, but instead, you could jump in and play with them live without needing to […]

CommBank Report: Aussies Keen To Spend On Travel
  • Media

CommBank Report: Aussies Keen To Spend On Travel

CommBank has today released its Household Spending Intentions (HSI) Index for November 2021, signifying its highest spending level since December 2019 and significant post-pandemic recovery, particularly in travel. The index – which provides an in-depth gauge of Australian consumer spending – rose 2.1 per cent during November to 110.3, driven by solid gains in spending […]

Disability Groups Call For A National Digital Accessibility Roadmap
  • Campaigns
  • Technology

Disability Groups Call For A National Digital Accessibility Roadmap

On International Day of People with a Disability, Infosys (NYSE: INFY) a global leader in next-generation digital services and consulting has released a first of its kind report: Exploring digital accessibility priorities and investments in Australia and New Zealand organisations. The study assessed for the first time, how far 670 organisations across Australia (570) and […]

Affinity Ranks Second At WARC Effective 100
  • Media

Affinity Ranks Second At WARC Effective 100

Independent Australian agency, Affinity has held its own against the world’s best in the prestigious WARC Effective 100, being named the second most effective Digital/Specialist agency in the world, and first across APAC. The recognition follows several wins in 2020 at global and local effectiveness awards across a range of clients, including Effies, New York […]

Tinder: Year In Swipe 2021
  • Campaigns

Tinder: Year In Swipe 2021

2019 had everyone facepalming at the state of the world, 2020 had us shrugging with uncertainty about the future and 2021 is the year we all exchanged and watched the drama unfold. From sharing the collective thought of oh my God when will this end to a common appreciation for simple meet-cutes, Tinder Gen Z […]

GoDaddy Wins Big At Olympic Marketing Awards
  • Media

GoDaddy Wins Big At Olympic Marketing Awards

The Australian Olympic Committee (AOC) announced internet domain registrar, GoDaddy as the winner of the 2021 Inspiration awards for excellence in Olympic marketing in Sydney last Thursday night. GoDaddy’s ‘Dream It. Build It’ campaign earned the top of the podium in a highly competitive field, ahead of Speedo’s ‘Made for Aussies, worn by Olympians’ and […]

Re:act Encourages Young Drivers To Practise Road Safety In New Campaign
  • Campaigns

Re:act Encourages Young Drivers To Practise Road Safety In New Campaign

Road safety behaviour change campaigns, created by local university students to educate young drivers about the risks of driving fatigued, launched nationally across Australia this morning. The campaigns are now featuring across digital assets in metropolitan and regional Victoria, New South Wales, Queensland and Western Australia, and will run for the next two weeks on […]

LEGO® Australia Rebuilds The World One Brick At A Time
  • Campaigns

LEGO® Australia Rebuilds The World One Brick At A Time

This holiday season Lego Australia will be conducting a giant rebuild of the world at the Sydney Opera House. LEGO® Australia will be inspiring children and families once again through their remarkable Christmas Giant builds. Thanks to an exciting partnership with the Sydney Opera House, the activation will take centre stage on the iconic Forecourt. […]