Social media is often lauded as a must-have for marketers and brands, and yet sometimes advertising on social media isn’t all it’s cracked up to be. John D Morris, a professor of advertising at the University of Florida, explains the phenomenon in this article, which originally appeared on The Conversation.
Social media use has exploded over the past five years, with nearly three-quarters of all online adults using some social media network. Leading social media platform Facebook claims that more than one billion people use its website.
Based on these numbers, advertisers and marketers have used communication philosopher Marshall McLuhan’s aphorism “The Medium is the Message” when approaching this opportunity. McLuhan was talking about television, but social media sites have well outpaced television’s access to the buying public.
Advertisers and marketers are attracted to social media because they have a huge reach, and it’s relatively cheap to place ads on them.
In addition to these benefits, a 2014 study commissioned by Facebook stated that there is “experimental evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through social networks” – meaning users can pass on positive or negative emotions to others through the network.
The study goes on to point out that not only can these reactions be manipulated, but they can also be transferred to a friend subconsciously.
So it makes sense that advertisers would want to exploit these networks to sell their products. But the best advertisements are compelling and engaging; are those used on sites like Twitter and Facebook connecting with users?
In short: no. In the second of two studies conducted at the University of Florida, we found that most Facebook ads are seen as unappealing and not engaging.
Our study measured reactions to the idea of advertising and marketing communications on Facebook, without measuring reaction to specific ads.
Using AdSAM® – the Attitude Self-Assessment Manikin – we were able to measure reactions to five key Facebook marketing vehicles: Banner Ads, Suggested Posts (sometimes referred to as “promoted posts”), two types of newsfeed re-posts – referred to as either “I liked” or “my friends liked” – and Business Pages.
Respondents were then asked to evaluate their impressions of these ads, which appear regularly – in the forms outlined above – on their newsfeeds.
In addition to gathering key emotional response indicators (Appeal, Engagement and Empowerment) to the ads, this study also measured Credibility, Personal Relevance and Intrusiveness to determine the drivers of the emotions among the respondents.
Two hundred twenty-eight undergraduate students – a prime target of advertisers – participated in the online survey.
Although there are significant differences in the Appeal, Engagement and Empowerment results, none of the responses was high or promising. Overall, on a nine-point high scale, the average Appeal was 4.5. Engagement was 4.2, while Empowerment was 5.1. Previous AdSAM studies have shown that television advertising frequently has much higher scores on these dimensions of emotion..
Facebook users do, however, have significantly more positive emotional responses when exposed to ad and marketing messages re-posted by users (“I Liked,” “My Friends Liked” and the “Business Pages”) than ads originating directly from marketers (“Banner Ads” and “Suggested Posts”).
The more positive reactions to the user re-posts (versus the direct advertiser posts) seem to be related to the third dimension of emotion: empowerment. When users feel like they have control, they respond better to the idea of these ads. In addition, ads placed directly by advertisers are seen as less credible, less personally relevant and more intrusive than those re-posted by Facebook users.
Overall, the emotional response to Facebook ads is below the midpoint on appeal and engagement. The only ad format reported to be slightly more positive is the Business Page. This may be due to the fact that this vehicle is more directly beneficial to users, because it comes to users through re-posts and promotions, and seems like it’s less blatantly trying to “sell” users products.
As previously mentioned, this study is a follow-up to a study conducted in 2011. Unfortunately for advertisers, the appeal, engagement and empowerment of these ads have actually fallen since the first study.
Why is this the case?
Social media marketing messages clearly have a different effect on user response than more traditional advertising. In some cases, social media users view sites like Facebook and Twitter as their personal space. Advertising into this space, then, can be perceived as an intrusion. This does not seem to be true for television, newspapers, magazines or radio.
One recommendation from our study is that marketers and advertisers focus more on advertisements that are designed for this medium – ads that actively promote re-posting. Another is to make marketing communications more entertaining and interactive. In other words, advertisers should direct more effort toward the developing engaging content.
Selling products with a content marketing approach is nothing new. Infomercials, native advertising, special advertising sections in news magazines and product-based TV shows have been around since before the middle of last century. John Deere even published an advertising/content-based magazine in 1895. Food products have created and distributed cookbooks for their products for years. And, of course, there’s there Ronco Vegamatic.
To that end, General Electric recently announced that it was hiring film director Ron Howard to develop new content marketing for the National Geographic channel.
And this approach is now making its way into social media. Some companies are providing guidance on how to enhance social media ads with engaging content.
However, in the realm of social media, content-based marketing is a risky venture. The audience is more resistant to sponsored content; if the efforts backfire, users could transfer these negative reactions to the products themselves. On the other hand, if advertisers can make the content seem more personally relevant, the feelings for intrusion may subside and the emotional reaction to the brand become more appealing, engaging and empowering.
Companies considering advertising on Facebook and other social media networks will be most effective if they direct their effort to making an emotional connection with their audience. Building brands is more than presenting facts about a product or conducting giveaways. It means making the benefits come alive for the consumer.
Employing creative strategies that are more entertaining or truly informative may be one method for making these ads appear less intrusive. Ron Howard and other well-known directors may be part of the solution, but they should remember that in the world of social media, they don’t have the luxury of a 90-minute presentation.
CNN is facing backlash after welcoming back legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin only months after he was caught masturbating on Zoom during a working meeting. Toobin went viral around eight months after a video of him being caught masturbating by his coworkers in a Zoom work meeting was leaked to the press. Toobin publically apologised for […]
Aussie construction company Hansen Yuncken has engaged Icon Agency to boost its public relations and communications capabilities nationwide. The new partnership aims to bolster Hansen Yuncken’s corporate profile and raise awareness of its iconic, innovative and sustainable projects across the country. Icon Agency’s managing director, Joanne Painter, said: “Hansen Yuncken is an Australian construction industry […]
The Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case is doing a brilliant job of remaining newsworthy. In the last two days, Roberts-Smith has admitted he hired a private investigator and used burner phones. According to The Guardian, Roberts Smith said in court that he hired a private investigator and commissioned the PI to check his alleged mistress was […]
CondÉ Nast, the publisher of publications such as VOGUE, Vanity fair, Pitchfork and The New Yorker has agreed to raise the minimum wage for employees after a campaign by the New Yorker union. The union had previously organised a protest, which saw New Yorker staff demonstrating outside VOGUE editor-in-chief Anna Wintour’s home. Placards at the protest had […]
GoDaddy has announced it has been named as the official website builder partner of the Australian Olympic team for the Tokyo 2020 Games. GoDaddy has a history of supporting entrepreneurs and small business owners in Australia. Many Australian Olympic athletes are small business owners themselves, running businesses and side hustle to help support the pursuit […]
MDC Partners (NASDAQ: MDCA), the company that owns agencies including 72andSunny, Anomaly and Media Kitchen, has expanded its global footprint in a partnership with This Is Flow. The Australian based indie will become MDC’s affiliate media planning and buying agency across Australia and New Zealand and will help manage global clients and participate on global pitches etc. however This is Flow will still remain 100% independent.
Following recent internal promotions within the editorial team, independent publisher Broadsheet Media has announced the appointment of Emma Joyce in the newly created position of National Assistant Editor. Joyce’s hire will allow Broadsheet to further strengthen its position as Australia’s leading cultural publication. Joyce has more than 10 years experience working in arts and lifestyle […]
After announcing a collaboration with Apple Podcasts Subscriptions, SCA has shared that podcast publishing app LiSTNR will be partnering with BBC. The partnership will see the BBC’s most popular titles and content by globally known personalities available on LiSTNR from 23 June 2021. The partnership is also the first time the majority of the BBC […]
Brazilian football team Ibis Sport Club has achieved cultish status in the country and probably not for the reason you’d expect in the soccer-mad nation. That’s because Ibis has been lumbered with the rather unflattering title of the world’s worst football team. Apparently it all goes back 40 years when, during a period from 1980-1984, […]
DoubleVerify has announced the expansion of a partnership with The Trade Desk to include activation of DV Custom Contextual, which will enable programmatic advertisers using the platform to target relevant audiences in a privacy-safe manner that does not utilize cookies or personally identifiable information. The Trade Desk now supports a comprehensive suite of DV’s pre-bid […]
With the discussion about consent raging and following the Federal Government’s recent campaign comparing sex to milkshakes, Are Media’s marie claire has turned to some of the country’s top advertising agencies to come up with an alternative communication solution. Leading creative agencies, DDB Melbourne, M&C Saatchi, Ogilvy, The Hallway and The Works, were briefed by […]
Jason Barnes [featured image] is the Chief Revenue Officer, APAC at PubMatic. In this piece, he looks at the future of targeted advertising and discusses how the digital advertising ecosystem can correct its course. There is perhaps no bigger disruptor to the digital ecosystem than the changes afoot around addressable advertising. Addressability is a key […]
Swinburne University of Technology has launched a series of Bootcamp Graduate Certificate courses, developed in partnership with FourthRev. The courses, an Australian-first, will upskill career changers and provide students the capabilities required to thrive in the digital economy. They are available on-campus and through its online arm, Swinburne Online. Alongside completing projects which will emulate […]
PayPal has partnered with Welcome to Country, Australia’s first Indigenous-led not-for-profit marketplace, which showcases businesses that support Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities. Welcome to Country launched in 2019, providing an online platform for Indigenous experience providers across tours, day treks, scenic flights, bush food, festivals, art and cultural experiences. When the pandemic hit, the […]
Former liberal politician and female icon Julie Bishop has further cemented her celebrity status by scoring her very own Barbie doll. According to The Sydney Morning Herald, Barbie creators Mattel, created the Barbie doll in Bishop’s likeness to honour her achievements. Unfortunately, the Julie Bishop Barbie won’t be for sale. Instead, the one-off doll was […]
Full-service digital marketing agency Whitehat Agency has launched its new website and branding, with the end-to-end project delivered by its own team of experienced in-house website designers, developers and UX specialists. After a challenging 2020, Whitehat Agency has experienced a very positive 2021 to date, onboarding nine new clients including The Dog Mum, Handpicked Wines, Compost […]