Are You Still Old-School With Your Peoples Strategies?

Are You Still Old-School With Your Peoples Strategies?
SHARE
THIS



In a few weeks we will commence judging for our Employer of the Year at the B&T Awards and Cassie Sacks, managing director at we.people, thought now would be a good time to discuss why performance appraisals are not a good development and retention strategy, unless they have been re-engineered.

Why the process must change?

Well, times have changed. The way we communicate has changed. We no longer have to run home and wait for that important phone call; instead we carry our phone in our pockets and can take that call anywhere at any time. The way we consume media and get our news has also changed, before we use to wait until it was printed on newspaper and then we read about it possibly days after the event. Now we get news through many media channels, on our phones instantly at any time of the day as it happens.

So why do agencies still think the same way when it comes to performance reviews? Why do “HR” experts still insist on using the old set and forget performance reviews as a development and retention strategy? Why do agencies have annual reviews in the first place? They are a remnant from traditional top-down agencies where they “weed out” the bottom performers every year. This approach is based on a philosophy that “we can’t totally trust managers” so we’re going to force them to fit people into these rating scales.

More and more companies like Adobe and recently Accenture have decided to radically change “scrap” or “re-engineer” their performance appraisal process and I strongly believe this is the way forward.

If you have any doubts here is some well publicised research on the effect old performance appraisal:

  • Employees want regular feedback much like how they consume media, so a once-a-year review is not only too late but it’s often a surprise. Regular coaching is the key to alignment and performance.
  • Managers cannot typically “judge” an entire year of work from an individual at one time.
  • Manager-employee relationships are not 1:1 like they used to be. We work with many leaders and peers during the year, so one person cannot adequately rate you without lots of peer input. This is time consuming and to be honest quite frustrating for the employee.
  • While some employees are a poor fit and likely are poor performers, these issues should be addressed immediately, not at the end of the year.
  • Some companies really do have a lot of high performers, so forced ranking eliminates great people and damages the culture.
  • People are inspired and motivated by positive, constructive feedback – and the “appraisal” process almost always works against this.
  • The most valuable part of an appraisal is the “development planning” conversation – what can one do to improve performance and engagement – and this is often left to a small box on the review form.

Well, I’ve probably discussed these issues with what seems like 100 agencies over the last year and our research shows more and more that agencies are ready to let this process go.

Organisation structures have changed and companies need to be more agile. We have a shortage of key talent and the keys to success now focus on regular alignment, coaching, creating passion and engagement, and continuous employee development.

So the moral of the story is, don’t let your “HR” expert convince you that annual performance reviews are a good strategy, because there are many others that have a better outcome.

Please login with linkedin to comment

appa

Latest News

Crater Teams Up With Director Luna Laure For ‘Harry’s Story’, Canteen’s Newest Campaign
  • Campaigns

Crater Teams Up With Director Luna Laure For ‘Harry’s Story’, Canteen’s Newest Campaign

Canteen’s latest campaign features the combined talents of Director Luna Laure and creative agency Crater. The campaign strives to raise awareness for young people affected by cancer. The awareness campaign centres around Harry Barentson, who at 12 years of age found out his pregnant mum had cancer. While his mother fortunately survived, he lost his […]

AFL Legend Kevin Sheedy Narrates ‘A Love Letter To Victoria’ Via Enthral Partners
  • Campaigns

AFL Legend Kevin Sheedy Narrates ‘A Love Letter To Victoria’ Via Enthral Partners

In partnership with storytelling agency Enthral, AFL star Kevin Sheedy has voiced a video ‘Love Letter to Victoria’ using visuals to showcase the state’s natural beauty and culture. Victoria has been hit with the worst of the coronavirus pandemic compared with any other Aussie state experiencing four lockdowns. Sheedy has partnered with Ethral to share […]

Telstra’s Belong Appoints Howatson + White For Strategy & Creative, Retains OMD For Media
  • Advertising

Telstra’s Belong Appoints Howatson + White For Strategy & Creative, Retains OMD For Media

Telstra’s lower-cost telco, Belong, has awarded its strategy and creative account to Howatson + White, and has reappointed OMD to its media buying account, after a competitive pitch process. Howatson + White will handle strategy, planning, creative and CRM, while former agency Clemenger will continue to have a relationship with Belong, managing PR and retail activation. […]

Coke Releases New Campaign, ‘Turn Up Your Break’, Via Ogilvy
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Coke Releases New Campaign, ‘Turn Up Your Break’, Via Ogilvy

Coca-Cola Australia has rolled out its new campaign ‘Turn Up Your Break’. The campaign will be led by a TVC that encourages people to truly pause with a Coke on their break so they can walk away feeling refreshed and uplifted. The TVC features two busy chefs stepping outside for a break, the bustling kitchen […]

Nova 91.9’s Ben And Liam Locked Up In Rundle Mall To Raise Awareness For Mental Health
  • Marketing
  • Media

Nova 91.9’s Ben And Liam Locked Up In Rundle Mall To Raise Awareness For Mental Health

Nova 919’s Ben & Liam breakfast show announced that they’ll be throwing their support behind and raising awareness for a cause very close to their hearts, mental health. On Monday 21 June Ben Harvey and Liam Stapleton will be locked in a purpose-built glass structure, in the middle of Rundle Mall, for an entire week […]

iHeartPodcast Network Australia And The New York Times Agree Podcast Ad Sales Deal
  • Advertising
  • Media

iHeartPodcast Network Australia And The New York Times Agree Podcast Ad Sales Deal

ARN and The New York Times have reached an agreement for ARN to become the advertising sales representative for The New York Times’s podcast portfolio in Australia. The deal will enable Australian brands to connect with Australian listeners to The New York Times’s most popular podcasts, such as The Daily, Serial and This American Life, […]

Verizon Media Academy Ends For 2021 With Youth Charity Pitch-Off
  • Advertising
  • Media

Verizon Media Academy Ends For 2021 With Youth Charity Pitch-Off

Verizon Media’s talent program has come to an end for the third year, closing with a hybrid pitch-off event for Musicians Making A Difference (MMAD). The Verizon Media Academy class of 2021, made up of 44 emerging leaders from across Australia and New Zealand media, advertising and marketing industry, were given just one hour to […]