Selling Insurance To The Ys – Hit And Miss, Or Crash And Burn

B&T’s regular marketing to the Ys gurus – How&Y’s Brian and Evan Mitchell – are back with their latest Millennial tale. Here, they argue, tried and true messages for the likes of insurance companies are now way off the mark in attracting 20-somethings…
They love vintage clothing. They search out vintage vinyl. And plaid-wearing hipsters rework the beards and tatts of yesteryear working class men. These bygone styles all have, for Millennials, a reinvigorated trend-soaked cachet.
But they don’t want the services they’re offered to seem recycled from earlier generations.
Gen Y are most engaged when they feel an industry conceives its products and services with their wants most in mind. Telco, tech and digital economy services have been good at giving the strong impression of specific Gen Y relevance (though they have, of course, a walk-up start compared to other service areas).
The flipside is that Gen Y don’t embrace those services they feel are a “hand me down” from other generations. This gives them the dis-empowering sense of being forced to inherit, or even have imposed on them, the way a certain service works, and therefore the way they are made to engage with it.
Yet to date, this has been the consistent approach of the insurance industry – providers and comparison businesses alike.
Whether Life, General or Health, advertising messages here persist with themes derived from earlier generations – oblivious to the reality that Gen Y aspirations and priorities are totally different to those of Gen X and Boomers.
To engage Millennials, a first requirement is to invest in a message that makes it onto their radar – not ones that are irrelevant.
With a few notable exceptions, insurance marketing messages fall into stereotypes.
There’s choose us on price (supposedly playing to the hip pocket – explicit message, “we won’t rip you off”).
There’s choose us on service (the trust and reliability card – implicit message, “we won’t rip you off by denying your claim like our unscrupulous competitors”).
And for those who want to take a funked-up, post-modern approach, there’s the quirk-twerk – playing to Gen Y’s self-styled sense of ironic irreverence (or is that irreverent irony), with messages that are entirely novelty driven, obscuring a lack of authentic substance behind the gauze of “cutesy”.
Like a class of over-eager school kids, advertisers have their hands up calling “pick me, pick me” – without providing an argument that will cut through Gen Y’s preoccupation with Gen Y, and cynicism towards all things NOT Gen Y.
One truism of Millennials that’s overwhelmingly true is they stay younger for longer.
With no previous generation has there been the need or desire to coin terms like “kidult”, “adultlescent” or “rejuvenile”. And even as maturity is forced on them, their models for maturation are no longer parents and authority figures, but their own (real world and digital) peers.
As a consequence, rather than being sensitive to the future – and specifically the future wellbeing of their finances, health, or possessions (the raison d’être of insurance) – they prefer to live in the present.
This is a pretty well-known Millennial characteristic. Why then is its logical implication – that traditional, underlying cautionary messages may not be the way to go – so blithely ignored? Add the fact that onnipotentiality (I can be / do anything) is an intrinsic value for this generation, and it opens up a yawning gap between the assumptions and expectations of marketers and the realities of Gen Y thinking.
The banking industry is another prone to Millennial faux pas in their ad messages.
Reestablishment and invigoration of public trust has been an obsessive theme in recent bank marketing, and no doubt this holds some resonance with the wider community. There are other issues however, more visceral to the Millennial generation than distrust, that are largely responsible for their “generational disconnect” with banks. The first to successfully target these will steal a march on competitors.
So it’s harder than it was in the past, earlier days of recycled messages and warmed up leftovers with a creative modern twist. Generational relevance is now a must. It must be created and then deftly communicated, not simply assumed.
But all this has an upside. Remember, consumer services require an ongoing customer connection. How resilient for this generation would conventional messages be in the face of serious, unconventional attack? How deeply committed is the Gen Y consumer who responds to price, trust, or fake novelty themes, sold as a solution to a need they’ve never been convinced of? And how will they respond when approached in their own backyard, with alternative clever messages that create a need while targeting what’s really important – their values.
It’s always back to values with this generation – and with Gen Z.
And that’s where the upside gets better. Genuine “big ideas”, the holy grail of advertisers, don’t typically fall off the back of a truck, or sit on a shelf waiting to be picked up. They are at a premium. Targeting values, rather than assumed needs, opens up the game to far more creative possibilities. And there is no shortage of Gen Y (and Z) values to target. Our research has identified around twenty aspirational values for this generation, in addition to three intrinsic values. In subsequent articles we’ll look at how these can be harnessed.
A final point on this demographic – Millennials represent your largest market, or the fastest growing, or increasingly the most profitable, or the one promising a competitive advantage, or the one that will drive innovation, or (failing all that) the one your organisation’s future will depend on.
You work a little harder upfront in connecting, so that you can advance that connection over time, and sustain it as an ongoing relationship. QED.
Latest News

The University Of Sydney And Richards Rose Launch Their 2021 Emotions Study: THE INSPIRATION CODE.
New research into inspiration has been undertaken by the University of Sydney Business School and Richards Rose to produce ‘The Inspiration Code’ study. There has always been a need for inspiration. To lift our spirits higher – for a period of time or just for a moment. Given the times we live in, you could […]

Woolworths To Launch Online Market Place After Investing In Start-Up Marketplacer
Do you need more plastic tat, cheap homewares and plastic tubs in your life? There's good news today.

WPP Says Its Entire Supply Chain Will Be Net Zero By 2030
Jens Monsees to put off buying a '71 Ford Falcon V8 GTHO after WPP unveils net zero emission goals.

AFR Apologise For Comments About iSignthis Boss
Memo to the AFR - perhaps a short in-house course in defamation law would prove fruitful to your editorial team?

Jetstar Promotes ‘Limited Time Only’ Sale With Stunning Outdoor Artworks Via Thinkerbell
Who hasn't missed air travel over the past year? Well, the air travel sucks, but the holiday's good at the end of it.

Airbnb Duped Into Listing A Dollhouse In YouTube Prank
This Airbnb dollhouse prank wasn't the least bit funny to the Lilliputians trying to book a weekend away.

GIDDY UP! Nominations for B&T’s CMO Power List Close Monday!
Nominations for B&T's CMO Power List close Monday! Meaning you have all weekend to construct your probability pie chart.

Iconic Aussie Kids Show ‘Round The Twist’ Coming To Netflix
B&T understands this has no relevance to our readership save for the author of said piece loving it when she was a kid.

Apple Perfectly Sums Up The Angst Of Misplaced Keys in First Spot For AirTags
Apple's new AirTag is perfect for the forgetful. Well, it's of little use if you forget to turn it on.

Because Dos Equis’ ‘Most Interesting Man’ Was So Completely Brilliant, Its Efforts Since Have Poured Flat
Dos Equis ads are like The Wiggles, Star Wars and Queen with Freddy - the original was just so much better.

Syrinscape Partners With Croud To Drive Long-Term Sustainable Growth
Syrinscape, the sound design app which brings immersive and dynamic sound effects and music to tabletop games, has teamed up with global digital marketing agency, Croud, to drive sustainable growth via a cross-channel digital strategy.

Big Teddy Bear Leads Cast Of Toys In Fire Safety PSA For American Red Cross Via BBDO NY
Here's a cute fire safety ad. Ideal for kids, cooks who like to flambé or anyone who regularly falls asleep smoking.

InMobi Launches UnifID Identity Solution For App Publishers
InMobi, the world’s leading independent marketing cloud, today announced the launch of UnifID, an industry-first offering designed to simplify and streamline identity resolution for mobile app publishers and developers.

SCA Announces New Head Of Content – Regional, Blair Woodcock
SCA announces new regional head of content who insists he doesn't own K-Tel's Greatest Ever Truckin' Tunes on vinyl.

Lotame Announces 10 Data Partners For Panorama ID
Lotame today announced 10 leading data partners including DTScout and ShareThis will support Lotame Panorama ID, the first global, people-based, privacy-compliant and interoperable identity solution for a cookieless open web. Lotame is providing the industry with privacy-compliant solutions that allow data partners to capture data on the Panorama ID in cookieless environments (Safari, Firefox, and […]

Thursday TV Wrap: MasterChef Ratings Rise As Gogglebox Takes The Cake
Thursday telly threw-up a predictable line-up - football, football, cooking, trains on SBS & something dull on the ABC.

Hyundai, Snapchat Launch AR Experience For New Hyundai Kona
Hyundai has worked with Snapchat to launch an augmented reality (AR) Lens that will allow Snapchatters to explore the Hyundai Kona in the comfort of their own homes.

Study: Golden Retrievers The Most Watched Dogs On TikTok, But A Pomeranian Is The Richest
Golden Retriever tops TikTok rankings for most watched dog. The Papillon wins for licking itself inappropriately.

Audi Australia Premieres ‘Electric Eye’, A Road Trip Into The Future Of Sustainable Travel
The Germans continue to pioneer the electric car alongside weird metal bands, footballers with perms and the strudel.

US Beer Brand, Coors Australia, Appoints This is Flow
Americans lead the world in space exploration, technology, movie making and bonkers politicians. Beer less so.

Oscars Ceremony Sees Rise Of First Time Advertisers Despite Ratings Slump
The Oscars ceremony, streamed by American channel ABC, has officially sold out its commercial time. A number of this year’s advertisers will be new to the event. The commercial interest in the Oscars remains despite decreased yearly viewership, with the 2020 ceremony pulling a historic low of 23.6 million viewers. According to Variety, ABC was seeking US$2 […]

Instagram Is Bringing Ads To Reels
Less than 12 months after launching its short-form vertical video format, Instagram is bringing ads to Reels. In an announcement, Instagram revealed it would be testing ads on Reels in Brazil, Germany, and right here in Australia. The ads will be mobile-first, vertical and full-screen, similar to ads in Stories. As with organic Reels content, […]

72andSunny Appoints Anthony Campagna & Jari Kennedy As Creative Leads
72andSunny Sydney announces two new recruits. Confirms it has no plans to convert from Fahrenheit to Celsius.

opr Report: The Need To Rethink Content In A Post-Pandemic World
Report says we need to rethink content post-COVID. We also need to rethink eating things better suited to a petting zoo.

Are Media Appoints Jane Huxley As CEO, As Brendon Hill Departs
You'd have to say this news came out of left field. When it really came via a well-worded press release in our inbox.

Expedia’s Brand Positioning Takes New Direction
Expedia has announced a new brand direction as the world prepares for the return of travel demand. The online travel giant’s new global positioning is grounded in the understanding that who you travel with matters, and comes after months of customer research. From an updated look and feel to enhanced product offerings, Expedia is looking […]

New Research Says Queen Elizabeth’s Brand Bigger Than Oprah, Beyonce, Kim Kardashian
Study finds the Queen now the biggest celebrity brand in the world. Has still knocked back a guest appearance in Suits.

H&M Launches Free 24-Hour Suit Hire For Men With Job Interviews
H&M launches free suit hire for men with job interviews. Or, you could lie & wear it to a wedding or court appearance.

News Corp Strengthens Audience Data With New Capabilities And Digital Advertising Solutions
News Corp says we're not just appallingly behaved NRL players and Albo bashing, unveiling its latest data initiative.

Domino’s Stores On The Gold Coast To Raise Money For Kelly Wilkinson’s Family
Finally you can eat an entire garlic bread and actually feel good about yourself in this top initiative from Domino's.