Publishers, Social Networks, And The Loss Of News Identity

Publishers, Social Networks, And The Loss Of News Identity
SHARE
THIS



The publishing world is being dominated by social media companies, leaving the traditional publishers floundering. In this opinion piece, Jordan Kretchmer, CEO and founder of Livefyre argues what publishers need to do now.

It’s time that publishers got a wakeup call. Our digital-first world is being appropriated by social giants Apple, Facebook and Snapchat. This appropriation has changed the way we access news. Facebook Instant Articles, Apple News and Snapchat Discover are all muscling in on publishers’ most valuable asset – their content. Although these platforms are yet to partner with any Australian outlets, it’s only a matter of time before the industry here follows in the footsteps of the US market.

The way we consume news has changed. Recent Roy Morgan figures paint a bleak picture of declining readership in Australian publications in print and online. This is likely due in part to the rise of social sites – a third of Australians accessed news at least once a day from social networks in 2014.

Facebook Instant Articles, Apple News and Snapchat Discover are all platforms that poach publisher-owned content to house on their properties, and they’re offering no remuneration for that content. When did a publisher’s content become a commodity?

There are precedents for the fair monetisation of digital content. Spotify has paid over $2 billion in royalties to music labels and artists in order to stream their services. Amazon Prime spent $1.3 billion on Prime Instant Video, an amount including both funding for original productions and licensing for third-party content. And yet, the social giants of Facebook, Apple and Snapchat are offering publishers nothing to use their content inside the walls of their platform.

So where did publishers go wrong? They’ve made a series of bad decisions that have led to this state of affairs — most remarkably, handing over the keys to their content distribution, which means outsourcing their commercial and intellectual property to leased platforms.

A fine line between an illusion and reality

Although these more integrated, commercial social news channels are yet to hit Australian shores, there’s been a great deal of buzz surrounding this potential shift in the landscape, and when it might happen here. Within this discourse, however, publishers are forgetting the most important aspect of these new products: that no matter what the platform, or what the deal, they all take control, content and identity away from publishers.There are other implications of passing over your content to social channels, including:

  • Enjoying a temporary audience: Social platforms may give publishers access to a broad audience, but the problem is that it’s the platform’s audience, not the publisher’s. The role of the publisher is continually downplayed until they’re no longer a significant factor. The news becomes Facebook’s or Apple’s news. Creating and investing in an audience on a third-party platform means that ultimately, those individuals are devoted to the platform, not the publisher.
  • Loss of identity: Providing content straight to these external platforms means that they hold the power to decide what content people see, and how they see it. Think about this: what happens when every publisher is optimising its content for the same audience on the same platform, with the same advertisers? You end up with generic material. Suddenly a consumer is targeted with similar articles at the same time, from publishers as previously varied as The Australian Financial Review and Buzzfeed.
  • Their platform, their terms: Say goodbye to brand loyalty. Each one of these platforms, just like publishers, has its own distinct personality. In order to publish content within their walls, there’s a certain level of assimilation that publishers have to succumb to. Whether it’s a custom layout or targeted content — this is where a publisher’s content becomes a commodity rather than a valued piece of collateral.

The light at the end of the tunnel

Right now, publishers are sitting at a historical crossroads. Take back their identity, or hand it over completely. Imagine a world where social giants have absorbed every ounce of a publisher’s identity. Say goodbye to The Australian. No more Sydney Morning Herald.

Content is a publisher’s bread and butter. It is the ultimate goal of a publisher to be the place that readers visit to view content, as it results in loyalty, community, and revenue. A reader who takes the time to visit a publisher on purpose every day is significantly more valuable than the fair-weather readers driven by social channels.

Whilst creating effective content to distribute and developing an audience strategy takes time, money and effort, this crucial investment is how publishers can truly own their content, their audience and their future. Whether you’re talking about Facebook, Snapchat, or Apple, depending on a third party network to distribute and own your content means gambling with a fixed dealer.

Publishers should be serving their own purpose, and creating their own offering; channelling people back to their own websites, rather than outsourcing it for free to third parties. However, the rise of the social giants has taught us that readers want two-way interaction with their news channels. They want to be able to comment on, share, and garner opinions from their peers about the news. Publishers can encourage this debate, build communities, and bring social content onto their website, making it the go-to place for loyal readers’ news, discussions, and content.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Grey Sydney Newsreaders of Sydney

Latest News

Sky News To Investigate ‘Australia’s Cocaine Crisis’
  • Media

Sky News To Investigate ‘Australia’s Cocaine Crisis’

In a major joint investigation with News Corp Australia, Sky News Australia will blow the lid on the escalating cocaine war in an unmissable report, Australia’s Cocaine Crisis, this Sunday at 7:30pm AEST. Following last week’s Australian Federal Police-led sting of the century Operation Ironside, charging more than one hundred organised crime members, Sky News anchor […]

WhatsApp Doubles Down On Privacy In New Campaign
  • Technology

WhatsApp Doubles Down On Privacy In New Campaign

WhatsApp has reaffirmed its commitment to user privacy in a new global campaign, following controversial policy changes earlier this year. The Facebook-owned messaging platform revealed earlier this year it would be sharing certain data with Facebook as a condition of use, with the potential for this data to be used for targeted ads. The changes […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Hospitality Networking Platform Clipboard Launches Equity Crowdfunding Campaign
  • Campaigns
  • Marketing

Hospitality Networking Platform Clipboard Launches Equity Crowdfunding Campaign

Clipboard, a free professional networking platform for the hospitality industry, has announced it will seek to raise its next round of funding via equity crowdfunding platform Birchal. This will power its vision to transform the way the fragmented hospitality industry connects, shares experiences, markets and recruits. With a growing member database of over 24,000 hospitality […]

Planting a Jacaranda Tree in the back yard. Western Australia. Taken on gopro.
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Toys Come To Life With AR In New Big W Campaign Via RYOT Studio

BIG W has joined forces with Verizon Media’s branded content division, RYOT Studio, to give Aussies a new way to shop Australia’s favourite annual toy sale, Toy Mania, using augmented reality (AR). In a first for BIG W, customers can scan a WebAR code to ‘place’ select outdoor toys from the Toy Mania sale virtually […]

Fierce New Campaign Encourages People To Get Angry About Period Poverty
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Fierce New Campaign Encourages People To Get Angry About Period Poverty

The #SeeingRed campaign by Hey Girls UK uses discordance to its advantage, conveying the frustration and disempowerment of period poverty. Hey Girls UK are a period brand seeking to end period poverty in the UK, selling period underwear, cups, pads, and tampons. They run on a ‘Buy One, Give One’ scheme, where for every product […]

Calls To Cancel Christchurch Terror Attack Film ‘They Are Us’ Grow In New Zealand
  • Media

Calls To Cancel Christchurch Terror Attack Film ‘They Are Us’ Grow In New Zealand

An upcoming film about the terrorist attack on a mosque in Christchurch, New Zealand, has been widely criticised for promoting a ‘white saviour’ narrative. Members of the Muslim community have also said it is “too soon” to fictionalise the shooting, which happened in 2019. White supremacist Brenton Tarrant murdered 51 worshippers at Al Noor Mosque, […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Isentia Set To Be Acquired By Access Intelligence
  • Media
  • Technology

Isentia Set To Be Acquired By Access Intelligence

Isentia has announced a takeover offer from Access Intelligence, which is subject to shareholder approval. Under the offer, Isentia shareholders will receive $0.175 per share in cash; this implies an Enterprise value of $67 million. Access Intelligence is a technology-led company delivering SaaS products that address the fundamental business needs of customers in the PR, […]

CHEP Strengthens Tech Offering With New Hires & Promotions
  • Advertising
  • Technology

CHEP Strengthens Tech Offering With New Hires & Promotions

CHEP Tech, CHEP’s technology offering, has strengthened its Sydney team with new hires, including ex-Isobar engineering leaders, Tim Chapman and Kirill Frolov, alongside the promotion of Jacinta Karras to Head of Tech Programs and Charlotte Bruton’s role expansion from Head of Mixed Reality to Head of Innovation Strategy. Mark Gretton, chief technology officer of CHEP […]

Monday TV Wrap: Four Corners QAnon Ep Nets 700,000
  • Media

Monday TV Wrap: Four Corners QAnon Ep Nets 700,000

After it was initially delayed, a Four Corners episode on QAnon, and a link between the conspiracy and PM Scott Morrison, aired last night. The ep – which had 722,000 viewers, as per OzTAM’s metro data – interviewed the family of Australian QAnon followed Tim Stewart. Stewart is a family friend of Morrison, who has publically […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
REMINDER: Time Is Running Out To Enter B&T’s Best Of The Best Awards!
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media
  • Technology

REMINDER: Time Is Running Out To Enter B&T’s Best Of The Best Awards!

With the on-time deadline right around the corner, now is the time to submit your entry for B&T’s newest awards program, Best of the Best. On-time entries for Best of the Best will be accepted until 5pm (AEST) on Friday 25 June. And, while you can submit entries after this date for another week, it’s definitely best […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Commercial Radio Sees Rebound In Ad Revenue
  • Advertising
  • Media

Commercial Radio Sees Rebound In Ad Revenue

New data, compiled by Deloitte and released by industry body Commercial Radio Australia, shows a rebound in radio advertising. According to the data, commercial radio advertising revenue for metropolitan stations jumped by 72.6 per cent in the month of May to reach $59.605 million from $34.534 million a year ago. The rise reflects a strong […]

Swedish Bank Encourages Consumers To Make Smoothies Instead Of Online Shopping
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Swedish Bank Encourages Consumers To Make Smoothies Instead Of Online Shopping

Swedish bank Nordax has created a tool to urge people to buy less online – and to make smoothies instead. How we shop online is constantly evolving, with new ways to pay and get items delivered. Now, with a global pandemic keeping everyone bored at home, online shopping has reached new heights. Nordax Bank, a […]

How To Win A B&T Award With The Leach Partnership Founding Director Sangeeta Leach
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns
  • Media

How To Win A B&T Award With The Leach Partnership Founding Director Sangeeta Leach

It might still be June, but the deadline for entries into this year’s B&T awards is fast approaching (they’re due Monday 19 July at 5 PM, in case you were wondering). This year we’re helping you like never before with our new series, ‘How To Win A B&T Award’, where we speak with a host of judges, […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine