In this guest post, Gerry McCusker (pictured below), author of PR Disasters and founder/principal advisor at Engage ORM, says brand disasters “manufactured” for social media can play everybody as a sucker…
I’ll frame this piece by paraphrasing the old adage; “You can’t give offence but you can certainly take it.”
After retailer Target has decided to withdraw a line of little girl’s t-shirts after some social media sniping from people with opinions, we have to assess the new rules of reputation management.
Lamentably, on social media, anyone can stoke up a PR disaster by claiming they were insulted/offended by a brand or company. What I call “tough-to-love” brands are especially vulnerable to minor or subjective attacks (often manifested as ‘trivial disputes), which media news are all-too-willing to turn into eyeball-chasing, outrage-provoking audience headlines.
Here’s how Trivial Dispute gets played online…Are you ready?
Customers make online statements about brand experiences, products or service. Your tough-to-love brand is expected to respond in real time. So you try a dry, operations-oriented response. BUT…”Don’t treat me like a number,” they wail.
So, be warned, you’ll be penalised for cut ‘n’ paste replies!
You’re tempted to be more empathetic or personal. You try that. BUT – Whap-WHAAA! The customer was a psychic mind-reader! They sussed your attempt to empathise and relate to them, as a stick-on insult.
You try to clarify. You try to justify. You to to pacify. But you’re a tough-to-love company so no-one cares. Oops! They now chide you online and whip up a ‘social storm’ of faux-indignation. Whap-WHAAAR!
Then a journalist thinks that subjective social slating is a real news story. Whap-Whap-WHAA! They interview ‘the insulteds’ , giving them free PR and a fat SEO boost: And your brand gets slammed again. Ouch!
Now more people see – and wanna play – ‘Trivial Dispute’ online. Got the hang of it yet?
The key is understanding that the online reputation game can be as rigged as a pellet-gun stall at a bent fairground. But if it’s a set-up, “who wins?” you ask.
- The self-interests of the complainant scores the attention it seeks
- Online lurkers, neurotics and worriers savour the savaging of the tough-to-love brand
- The churnalist gets the headline that draws ‘eyeballs’ (The eyeball-quotient helps justify advertising and keeps them in employment).
- Social networks stream the fake f racas into their feeds (which keeps content fresh)
- And the tough-to-love brand …?
Well, they get to play the game over and over. Until they figure out a better engagement model where they can wrest better control of the SEO , narrative and content findability agenda.
The SingularityU Australia Executive Program will take place this may, celebrating leadership at the intersection of the values of humanity and the value of technology. The Elon Musks, Apples and Xeros of the world are taking risks for humanity and creating new technologies that streamline and beautify business operations. They simplify life by providing basic […]
Brisbane media professional and former OMD Australia Account Director Taylor Fielding (pictured) has officially launched TFM Digital. TFM Digital is a specialist media agency based in Newstead which primarily provides media buying services, and strategy development, to businesses chiefly, but not exclusively, within the franchise sector. Prior to the launch of TFM Digital, Fielding spent […]
Judging by the hangovers in the B&T office today you can count yourself damn lucky we even managed this photo thingy.
Launch marketing specialists Five by Five Global have been appointed by FutureFeed to develop their brand, international certification trademark and go to market strategy. The innovative livestock feed ingredient developed by CSIRO, Meat and Livestock Australian and James Cook University uses a specific genus of seaweed, Asparagopsis, which significantly reduces methane emissions in ruminant livestock. […]
Andrew Knowles, partner and co-founder of the corporate communications consultancy Shoebridge Knowles Media Group (SKMG), has won the PR category in the 2021 B&T 30 Under 30 Awards. Knowles received the award at a ceremony in Sydney last night, claiming victory in a highly competitive field that included leading executives from some of Australia’s biggest […]
The AFL is delighted to welcome Therabody as its Official Recovery Partner of the 2021 Toyota AFL Premiership Season. Therabody’s industry-leading devices and research will be integrated into pre-match training and post-match recovery routines to help prevent injuries and help improve overall athletic performance. Therabody will also become the naming partner for the end-of-season AFL […]