News Media Bargaining Code “Remains Unworkable” Says Google

Portrait of Google Australia MD Melanie Silva, photographed at the Sydney Google Offices. Tuesday 29th January 2019. Photograph by James Brickwood. SMH NEWS 190129
SHARE
THIS



Google Australia has finally responded to the News Media Bargaining Code legislation, which was introduced to parliament earlier this month.

The tech giant had previously labelled the draft version of the code as “unworkable”, with key concerns including the size of the fines on offer for a breach, data sharing obligations with media companies and the “one-sided” arbitration process that has been proposed.

And while the final version of the code has called for the “two-way value exchange” between tech giants and media companies to be taken into consideration by the arbitrator, Google maintains that the code as it stands is unworkable.

“Unfortunately, while the Government has made some changes, the legislation still falls far short of a workable Code,” said Google Australia & New Zealand VP Mel Silva [feature image].

Silva argued that as it stands now, the code will undermine the open internet.

“No website and no search engine pays to connect people to other websites, yet the Code would force Google to include and pay for links to news websites in the search results you see,” Silva said.

“This sets the groundwork to unravel the key principles of the open internet people use every day—something neither a search engine nor anyone who enjoys the benefits of the free and open web should accept.”

Silva also took aim at the “baseball arbitration” (where if two sides can’t reach an agreement, each puts forward a single final offer and the arbitrator picks one) process that is proposed under the legislation.

“[The code] imposes an unfair and unprecedented baseball arbitration model that considers only publishers’ costs, not Google’s; incentivises publishers to make ambit claims and resort to arbitration rather than good-faith negotiations; assumes that the internet has never required payments for links because of ‘bargaining imbalance’; and requires the decision-maker to choose a single ‘final offer’,” Silva said.

The solution?

Google has previously said it is willing to work with the government to come to an agreement on a code that regulates the relationship between tech giants and media companies.

Silva again maintained that Google will agree to a code, provided certain changes are made.

Instead of the baseball arbitration model, Silva instead argued for a standard model that would factor in comparable transactions.

This arbitration would only apply for deals on the Google News Showcase, which was recently announced as a new initiative in which Google will start to (voluntarily) pay publishers for news content.

“And while the Code professes to recognise the value Google Search provides to publishers, in fact it encourages publishers to argue that arbitrators should disregard that value,” said Silva.

“It does this by allowing the arbitrator to consider a hypothetical scenario in which there is no Google Search and yet publishers receive the same amount of traffic, just from other sources. This scenario… invites unfair outcomes based on speculation rather than evidence.”

Silva also proposed a change to the algorithm notification provisions, which would currently require Google and Facebook to provide media businesses with 14 days notice of any algorithmic changes.

” We make thousands of algorithm updates every year, so providing 14 days’ notice of any significant changes to algorithms or “internal practices” in the way the Code prescribes just isn’t workable. This provision also continues to put every other business that relies on Google Search at a disadvantage, all to benefit one group of businesses—news publishers,” said Silva.

The legislation is set to go to a Senate committee for inquiry in 2021.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Google news media bargaining code

Latest News

TikTok Unveils Second Australian Brand Campaign
  • Media

TikTok Unveils Second Australian Brand Campaign

TikTok has launched its second national brand campaign, “Summer Starts on TikTok”, inviting Australians far and wide to join the platform in celebrating key elements of our local culture in summer-mode. The campaign will showcase key Aussie summer vibes, representing roadtrips, cricket, food, sport, adventure and fashion among others this summer, along with a real-time […]

Integrated Marketing Agency, McCCorkell, Wins Spot In Global Rainfocus Partner Program
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Integrated Marketing Agency, McCCorkell, Wins Spot In Global Rainfocus Partner Program

B2B marketing agency McCorkell has announced that it has been appointed an official Asia-Pacific partner of RainFocus, the next-generation event marketing and management platform. The collaboration will see both companies come together to shake up the end-to-end event service model across APJ. “As the only true integrated event marketing and management platform servicing everything from […]

Oatly Releases Witty Guides, Controversial TV Ad To ‘Help Dads Quit Dairy’
  • Advertising
  • Marketing

Oatly Releases Witty Guides, Controversial TV Ad To ‘Help Dads Quit Dairy’

Challenger brand Oatly has unveiled a new set of creative, including controversial TV ads in the UK, which aims to help kids convince their dads to quit dairy. Dad recipes, witty replies to neutralise arguments, rhetorical judo and four new spots are among the resources Oatly has produced to help win over dads—a market of […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Radio Station 927 Returns To GfK Survey In 2021
  • Media

Radio Station 927 Returns To GfK Survey In 2021

RSN 927, one of Victoria’s longest standing radio stations is re-joining the GfK Radio Survey Ratings in 2021, after a 17 year absence. All of RSN’s flagship programs will be covered in the ratings, with RSN Breakfast Club, RSN Racing Pulse and RSN Central all featuring in the line-up for 2021, along with renowned tipsters […]

Entertainment Appoints FutureBrand Australia To Lead Brand Transformation
  • Marketing

Entertainment Appoints FutureBrand Australia To Lead Brand Transformation

Entertainment has appointed FutureBrand to help deliver its brand and customer experience transformation, as part of a business-wide strategy that will reshape how Entertainment engages with its members, merchants and fundraisers. FutureBrand’s work with Entertainment will inform all areas of the brand, from brand strategy and identity to voice, content and experience. By applying FutureBrand’s ‘sprint’ […]

Established Brands Join Forces To Launch New Comparison And Advice Hub, Compare Club
  • Uncategorised

Established Brands Join Forces To Launch New Comparison And Advice Hub, Compare Club

Some of Australia’s most established and fastest-growing comparison and advice services have joined forces to form Compare Club, a new resource that offers bespoke advice to over one million customer enquiries per year about key financial decisions. Unlike other sites, Compare Club offers a full end-to-end service from customer enquiry and product discovery through to […]

MKTG Australia Unveils New Leadership Team
  • Marketing

MKTG Australia Unveils New Leadership Team

MKTG Sports & Entertainment has announced several senior leadership developments in Australia, including the expansion of the role of current managing director, Matt Connell, to lead MKTG’s efforts across the APAC region; Jarrad Provis’ promotion to general manager, marketing strategy; and Jeremy Francis, as chief operating officer. In addition,  Stephanie Rudnick, former head of PR […]

Marketing strategy on digital mobile platform - cross-device tracking programmatic advertising and multi targeting with laptop and mobile phone gadgets.
  • Technology

SpotX Joins The Trade Desk’s Unified ID 2.0 Initiative

SpotX has announced it is integrating the Unified ID 2.0 solution, an open source and interoperable ID framework designed to improve relevant advertising while protecting consumer privacy and transparency without relying on third-party cookies. The solution upgrades identification standards by using encrypted and hashed email addresses, allowing consumers to easily manage how their personal data […]

Volkswagen Unveils Electric SUV, The ID.4, In Stunning Spot ‘The Wheel’ Via Johannes Leonardo
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Volkswagen Unveils Electric SUV, The ID.4, In Stunning Spot ‘The Wheel’ Via Johannes Leonardo

Zoetropes, a praxinoscope, early projectors, and a phenakistoscope have all been used to channel what is considered a monumental moment for carmaker Volkswagen in a new short by Johannes Leonardo. Directed by Sam Brown, the 90-second film ‘The Wheel’ uses some of the oldest devices of motion in film—the Zoetrope (praxinoscope, early projectors, and phenakistoscope)—as […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine