We’re still waiting on a result from the Federal Election, but in this piece from The Conversation David Waller from the University of Technology, Sydney, argues negative campaigning, particularly around Medicare, has had an impact.
Advertising can be a powerful tool for political parties, though it’s just one of several factors that can influence a voter’s behaviour at election time. Following the 2013 federal election, I wrote:
Generally, advertising does not appear to play a significant role in the final result of the election; rather the leaders, events, and the nature of the election are more important. If the mood is for change, then no amount of advertising can stop it.
In 2016, despite the result still not yet being known, we can say the role advertising played was very different. The 2016 election has shown that when there is a close result, negative advertising can be a powerful campaign tool. This is particularly evident in the Labor Party and its supporters’ campaign around the future of Medicare under a re-elected Turnbull government.
However, in a tight race, these ads can also point to policy differences, impact on attitudes towards a candidate, stir emotions, question policies, add doubt, and stay in the memory longer than positive political ads.
The trend to negative
The 2016 federal election campaign began with largely positive ads. However, it seemed to take a significant change with one advertisement in which former Labor prime minister Bob Hawke warned of the privatisation of Medicare if the Liberal Party was returned to government.
Until this point, Medicare was not perceived as a major issue.
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull responded by describing the ad as a “disgraceful scare campaign”:
It is an absurd falsehood and he [Labor leader Bill Shorten] should stop misleading people.
But over the following weeks, advertising and other communications continued to spread doubts about Turnbull and the Coalition’s commitment to Medicare. One Labor ad even pointed out that he has “never relied on these services”, which made him “seriously out of touch”.
While not everyone has children or school-aged children, everyone wants a strong, universal health system, even the young. The Medicare campaign was a perfect uniting issue that was mentioned in speeches, advertisements, leaflets, on posters, and on the “Medicare bus”, with the words:
Bill Shorten and Labor. We’ll save Medicare.
This left the Liberals without a clear response, other than to say that it was a “Mediscare” campaign and they would not privatise Medicare:
Third-party election advertising
It wasn’t just the parties that advertised during the election. Many ads were run by third parties, such as unions, business groups, and trade associations.
There is a saying that “election time is the only time politicians will listen to you”. These groups use election campaigns to present and promote their view in the hope that voters and politicians will listen to their message.
Union ads generally advocate their positions on key issues such as workers’ rights, health care and education. They can support a party or attack the other, such as the ACTU’s “Put the Liberals Last” campaign, which also supported saving Medicare.
Being “independent” of the Labor Party, these ads can be more direct, more critical, and sometimes more creative than those from the official party.
However, it can be risky for business associations and individuals to take a public stance on an issue, or against a party. This may be interpreted as a partisan opinion which could affect relationships with shareholders, suppliers, distributors, customers, and the new government, if they openly supported the wrong party.
Social media was another channel of negative election communication, particularly via memes. These are images with funny, derogatory, or humiliating captions or titles, which are spread online.
During this election, many anti-Liberal, anti-Turnbull, and Save Medicare memes were posted and tweeted by the unions, such as the Australian Manufacturing Workers Union.
The ACTU also handed out fake Medicare cards, more than one million Medicare leaflets, and made over 46,000 telephone calls.
Labor’s Queensland branch also sent a fake text from “Medicare”, although a spokesperson later claimed the sender information was supposed to indicate the subject rather than the sender.
These more creative techniques are not only another touchpoint for the message to get to the voter, but the use of humour or something unusual is better at grabbing a person’s attention than traditional ads.
Exit polls found that 72 per cent of voters rated health and Medicare as important issues in deciding their vote. This is extraordinary, given Medicare was not a major issue at the start of the campaign.
So when the competition is tight, negative advertising can be a very powerful campaign tool.
Lead image via Australian Medical Association.
Two Australian-born technology providers have joined forces to bring more power and choice to marketers in Australia and New Zealand with mobile messaging that is more local, cost-effective, and integrated. It’s a partnership that sees two Australian software companies come together to deliver a world-class mobile-first solution for marketers building data-driven, personalised, omnichannel campaigns. While […]
PubMatic, Inc. has announced the appointment of Luke Smith as senior director of CTV and online video, APAC. Smith will start his role in the new year, working closely with the APAC and global leadership teams to define and execute the strategy for CTV, OTT, and online video across the region. Smith joins PubMatic from […]
Snap Inc., the technology company that brings the world Snapchat, has announced a host of new appointments to its local team. Lead image: L to R – Dina Bailey, Bethany Rao-Davies, Sarah Ding, Rob Fitzpatrick, Tony, Daniel King, Elise Keeling The new hires include Dina Bailey, ANZ Agency Lead; Daniel King, Senior Client Partner; and […]
Respected broadcaster Michael McLaren (lead image) has been confirmed as the new host of 2GB Afternoons, commencing in January 2024. A long-time listener favourite, McLaren started his radio career at 2GB in 2006 as a program producer. His on-air career kicked off in 2011, first hosting 2GB’s Weekend Overnight program before taking on Australia Overnights […]
Reddit has received a playful brand refresh with a new, more lifelike rendering of its Snoo mascot and two sharper typefaces. It’s the first time the platform has had a lick of paint since 2017, when it first launched its mobile app. The biggest change comes to the platform’s typefaces with Reddit Display and Reddit […]
Amidst shimmering tinsel and dazzling LED Christmas trees, World Square unwraps its gift to Sydney tomorrow, 1st December, when a giant interactive present and advent calendar installation comes to life and becomes an iconic centrepiece of the Square and the entire city. The heart of Sydney’s entertainment, dining and shopping district, World Square is gifting […]
Zitcha and Broadsign have teamed up to integrate the Broadsign out-of-home (OOH) advertising platform with Zitcha’s retail media platform. The collaboration empowers retailers to maximise and monetise in-store digital display networks and enables advertising partners to easily view and book available in-store inventory and review campaign performance alongside the retailer’s other media channels. With the […]
Australia’s National Drag Racing Championship (NDRC) has launched its latest media campaign aimed at engaging fans and building excitement ahead of the summer championship series, via Murmur-Group. The campaign is the first to market since Murmur was appointed to the business earlier this year. Spread across OOH, Radio, Programmatic, Youtube, Meta and BVOD, the campaign […]
Today, 7-Eleven has announced a one-of-a-kind collaboration with the popular Sydney-based anti-resort wear label Double Rainbouu. Dropping tomorrow, December 1, just in time for summer, this limited-edition capsule will infuse the fashion brand’s rebellious spirit with a distinctly iconic 7-Eleven flavour. The unisex collection features five must-have styles comprising two signature Hawaiian shirts, a peaked cap, a bucket hat […]
Free passes to Cannes in Cairns you say? That’s right, calling all editors, producers and journalists — apply for your accreditation now! Cannes in Cairns brings the greatest creative and marketing minds together from across APAC, making it a must-attend event for any and all business, advertising and marketing journalists from Perth to Phuket, from […]
The In-House Agency Council (IHAC) has partnered with Kantar to publish its ‘2023 In-House Agency Landscape Report’, APAC’s only research report focussed on the state of the in-house agency model. The new research follows on from the IHAC’s first study released in August 2021 and aims to provide a current take on the country’s in-housing […]
The Outdoor Media Association (OMA) has announced the winners of the Quarter Three Creative Collection competition for 2023. OMA members submitted 31 entries, including campaigns by JCDecaux, oOh!media, QMS, Scentre Group Brandspace, Cartology, TorchMedia, goa and Val Morgan Outdoor (VMO). Guest judges: Abigail Holmes, Head of Client Strategy & Campaign Solutions, JCDecaux Christine Le Maitre, […]
JOLT, Australia’s third-party verified, sustainable digital-out-of-home and electric vehicle charging network, today announced the launch of a first-to-market product that enables brands to further engage with high-value audiences with its new in-app advertising solution. The first of its kind in Australia’s media industry, this solution provides an unparalleled one-to-one connection with customers, whilst charging their […]
Customer insights platform, Ideally, has expanded its regional footprint as part of its ambitious growth strategy, announcing the appointment of Simon Gawn to lead Australian operations. Ideally appoints Gawn on the back of exponential growth since launching in August this year, already boasting a strong and established Australian-based client roster. Gawn’s immediate remit is to capitalise on Ideally’s significant growth opportunities in Australia, a market five times larger than New Zealand.
Aussie coastal lifestyle brand SurfStitch has announced a bold repositioning with a new brand identity and campaign, “Ready for Everywhere”. Reflecting the brand’s commitment to inspiring people to embrace their lifestyle, whatever it may be, the strategic shift reflects a commitment to facilitating style that adapts to the life its customers lead across a broad […]
Man of Many has Announced Key Hires Amidst a Year of Extraordinary Achievement Lead image: Naman Singh & Alex Martinez Man of Many, recently crowned B&T media platform of the year, Australia’s premier men’s lifestyle digital publication. Announces the addition of two crucial members to its team – Naman Singh as SEO Content Specialist and […]
Australian property site realestate.com.au has announced the extension of its partnership with the Sydney Swans for two further seasons. Lead image: Tom Harley, Owen Wilson and Tom McCartin realestate.com.au has partnered with the Swans since 2016 and has called the back of the club’s iconic guernsey home since becoming a major partner in 2020. This […]
Leading independent media agency, Avenue C, is thrilled to announce the appointment of Paula Lopes as Digital Director. Paula, a seasoned professional with over 17 years experience in the media industry, joins Avenue C from her role as Chief Operations Manager of KINESSO (merger of Reprise, Matterkind, and Kinesso specialities).
oOh!media brought together more than 260 of its sales, operations, commercial, marketing, finance and leadership teams last week for its national annual revenue and growth conference. Held over two days at the picturesque Rydges Resort in Hunter Valley, the event ‘Fusing people and performance’ focussed on how to build a high-performance mindset and how it […]
Free TV has welcomed the federal government’s ongoing commitment to ensuring that all Australians can access their local free television services on connected TVs through the introduction of legislation to implement a prominence framework in coming days. Free TV CEO Bridget Fair (lead image) said: “Right now, Australian viewers are being steered in the direction […]