Men Do All The Talking In Publications’ Comments Sections

Closeup portrait of nervous, stressed young woman, girl, employee student biting fingernails looking anxiously, craving for something isolated on green background. Human emotions expressions, feelings
SHARE
THIS



The ability for readers and journalists to engage in conversation online is often touted as a key achievement of the digital media revolution, but when it comes to the comments section it’s men who are doing most of the talking.

New University of Sydney research has found male or pseudonymous voices dominate the comment sections of news stories on 15 news sites internationally including The Guardian, Washington Post and Sydney Morning Herald. Female identified commenters make up as little as three percent of participant voices, and at most 35 percent, based on a sample of news services from Australia, the United States and Britain.

Dr Fiona Martin, senior lecturer in convergent and online media at the University of Sydney, said her findings tally with other research that shows that men dominate conversations in meetings, seminars and other public gatherings, unless those events are organised and run by women.

“Comments can influence opinion. Research suggests negative comments reduce readers’ opinion of an article, so it’s also plausible that an absence of views from women, or migrants or young people could also affect how people interpret online news,” said Martin.

Major international news websites such as the BBC, ABC, Daily Mail and New York Times were included in the study of in-house news comments sections.

Martin said the findings of gender bias in the study should make publishers and policymakers pause to investigate the commercial and diversity implications of this marginalisation of women from the digital public sphere.

“Comments increase user engagement and therefore revenue,” she said. “They also provide extra content, production feedback and quality control. Given there’s significant moderation cost to providing a commenting service it’s important to make sure its appealing to as many users as possible.”

Martin said major news websites not only need to improve moderation to reduce abusive or aggressive commenting, but also explore more interventionist approaches that support conversational interaction. They could also encourage journalists to interact with users more often – particularly to address questions and suggestions.

“Involving more people in the comments, more productively, and making sure the quality of the interaction is civil and rewarding can only have benefits,” she said.

Please login with linkedin to comment

hillary clinton Talent

Latest News

Asics Australia Launches First Women’s Cricket Shoe
  • Marketing

Asics Australia Launches First Women’s Cricket Shoe

ASICS Australia has released the world’s first cricket shoe, specifically designed for females – developed locally in conjunction with Cricket Australia’s (CA) Women’s Team Physiotherapists and Athletes. In recognition of the incredible growth of women’s cricket in Australia, ASICS has launched the 350 NOT OUT FF to the market alongside a fresh ‘Made For Me’ […]

Tourism Tropical North Queensland Appoints Marketing Manager
  • Marketing

Tourism Tropical North Queensland Appoints Marketing Manager

Tourism Tropical North Queensland has appointed Marketing Manager Lani Strathearn to spearhead the rollout of the Cairns & Great Barrier Reef brand. TTNQ Chief Executive Officer (CEO) Mark Olsen said Ms Strathearn had a solid career in tourism marketing having worked in agencies in Melbourne and Adelaide for the past four years with clients including […]

Omnicom’s Resolution Digital Named As Google Honours Agency Of The Quarter
  • Advertising

Omnicom’s Resolution Digital Named As Google Honours Agency Of The Quarter

Resolution Digital has been awarded the Australia’s Agency of the Quarter award in the prestigious Google Honours program. The Honours program for 2020 recognises the achievements of the very best performance marketing agencies and providers across Australia and New Zealand. The program consists of 3 quarters, 43 agencies and over 500 individuals; measured on account […]

SCA Launches New Media Research & Insights Division
  • Media

SCA Launches New Media Research & Insights Division

SCA today announced that its award-winning Research & Insights and Strategy & Insights divisions have come together to form SCA iQ, one of Australia’s largest media research and insights offerings.   SCA iQ fuses the research, insights and strategy functions together, to better power insightful solutions for SCA’s Sales and Content teams and advertising partners and is underpinned […]

Audi Pulls Ad, Apologises For Dangerous, “Phallic” Campaign
  • Campaigns

Audi Pulls Ad, Apologises For Dangerous, “Phallic” Campaign

German carmaker Audi has been forced to pull its latest campaign and issue the usual round of apologies after a rather tone-deaf launch over the weekend. On Saturday, the carmaker shared an ad for its snazzy looking Audi RS4 with the caption “Lets your heart beat faster – in every aspect”. The ad featured a […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Audiences Are Coming Back, Says Global Out Of Home Industry Leaders
  • Advertising

Audiences Are Coming Back, Says Global Out Of Home Industry Leaders

World Out of Home industry leaders from Australia, the UK, US and Germany have revealed that audiences are returning to public spaces despite ongoing challenges from COVID-19, and that they anticipate improved market fundamentals in coming months. In an interview for a podcast being released today, leaders including oOh!media CEO Brendon Cook, President of the […]

Perth Agency Firefly Adds Six New Accounts & Launches New Media Arm
  • Advertising

Perth Agency Firefly Adds Six New Accounts & Launches New Media Arm

Firefly has brought on six major new clients as it continues to expand, adding new media planning and buying arm to its business. Managing Director Andrew Mathwin (pictured) said the independent agency, known for clients such as Air New Zealand, Buy West Eat Best, West Coast Eagles and Mrs Mac’s Pies, had a strong year […]

Media33 Announces Two Senior Promotions
  • Advertising

Media33 Announces Two Senior Promotions

Boutique communications agency, Media33, have made two senior appointments with Ashlee Crawford appointed to General Manager and Mick Bradley appointed to Agency Director. Both Ashlee & Mick have been part of the management team at Media33 since it was launched in early 2013 and have played a key role in the agencies ongoing cultural strength […]

Independent Brewer Wingman Cancels All Sales For A Month In Support Of Dry July
  • Marketing

Independent Brewer Wingman Cancels All Sales For A Month In Support Of Dry July

In possibly a first for the category, independent brewer Wingman decided to cancel all sales of Wingman beer during the month of July, in support of Dry July. This bold initiative went live at midnight June 30 and ran throughout July. Wingman Beer’s general manager Will Chambers explained: “We have noticed a dramatic spike in […]

AAP Sale Formalised, Confirms Name To Be Retained
  • Media

AAP Sale Formalised, Confirms Name To Be Retained

The sale of Australian Associated Press (AAP) to a consortium of impact investors and philanthropists has been formally completed, ending 85 years of ownership by Australia’s major publishing groups. The national news agency will continue to provide a trusted breaking news service with a team of journalists and photographers, most of whom have joined the […]

Aussie Success Story Afterpay Unveils New Brand Identity
  • Marketing

Aussie Success Story Afterpay Unveils New Brand Identity

Aussie retail payments platform Afterpay has launched a new global look, feel and positioning with a fresh brand identity. Founded out of Bondi, Sydney, Australia five years ago, Afterpay has skyrocketed to infinite heights, with almost 10 million customers and 55,000-plus merchants now using the platform globally across Australia, US, UK (where it is called […]

Women in Media’s Doris Li: “Listen To Your Heart And Go For It, Then Settle For Extraordinary”
  • Media

Women in Media’s Doris Li: “Listen To Your Heart And Go For It, Then Settle For Extraordinary”

How Communications’ China marketing director, Doris Li, believes ad-land professionals must be courageous enough “to be abnormal”, and listen to their hearts, to be fearless in times of change. During this year’s B&T Women in Media Awards, presented by Bauer Media, we’ll be recognising exceptional people who have achieved success in their professional arenas, celebrating […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Study: New Business Wins Still Resilient, But Creative Finding It Tougher Going Than Media
  • Advertising
  • Media

Study: New Business Wins Still Resilient, But Creative Finding It Tougher Going Than Media

The holding companies might be losing as much as 23 per cent of their revenue year-on-year, but new business has remained relatively resilient through 2020, the lastest research from R3 has revealed. In the first half of 2020 total new business revenue decreased 10 per cent globally – but creative agencies are having to find […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
I’m Not Loving ‘Karens’, For What They Highlight About Our Society
  • Opinion

I’m Not Loving ‘Karens’, For What They Highlight About Our Society

In this guest post, the CEO of PR/comms agency Extollo, Katy Denis, examines the social phenomenon of our time – the entitled ‘Karens’ amongst us & why they can be such a danger… Until last week, I had no idea who or what a “Karen” is. Thanks to (and I use that term very lightly, […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
The Mint Partners Wins Pernod Ricard, Cemoy & Little National
  • Advertising

The Mint Partners Wins Pernod Ricard, Cemoy & Little National

Independent communications consultancy The Mint Partners has bolstered its integrated client roster and signed a number of premium lifestyle brands to kick start the new financial year. With an array of new products, services, and a focus on insight-led and creative integrated communications, MINT has enjoyed recent success with an expanded portfolio across new categories including fintech, […]

opr Adds DocuSign To Client Roster
  • Media

opr Adds DocuSign To Client Roster

Sure, it might not be a Coke or a Qantas, but opr think this win significant enough to send well-meaning press release.

Stan Acquires Heckler Co-Produced Biopic On F1 champion Sir Jack Brabham
  • Media

Stan Acquires Heckler Co-Produced Biopic On F1 champion Sir Jack Brabham

A feature length documentary on the extraordinary racing career of Australia’s first Formula 1 champion, Sir Jack Brabham, co-produced by design, animation and visual effects house Heckler, will be available on Stan exclusively from this Friday – 7 August. Directed by Ákos Armont (Aurora Films) in association with Heckler, whose co-founder Will Alexander served as […]