Lies, Damn Lies And Social Media
In his latest column, B&T regular Robert Strothfeldt from Strothfeldt Consulting, opines if you bother to look at the facts then “new media’s” message often plays with the truth…
“Money doesn’t talk; it swears:” Bob Dylan
I keep reading that the media pendulum is starting to swing back to traditional media and that some (unfortunately not nearly enough) people in our industry are conceding that social media and advertising in it, has been vastly over rated.
To quote Peter Field, the British marketing consultant, “Advertisers have been seduced by a propaganda assault on traditional media spread by an immensely well- funded digital machine”.
Of course, it is the digital revolution and you have to “get digital or get lost”. The fact that TV and radio are digital, newspapers and magazines are increasingly read on tablets/laptops etc. and digital signage is a huge growth area is overlooked.
The Google/Facebook duopoly has been able to both buy and seduce on a level never seen before. I suppose if your stock was over-valued to a point where a correction would be nearly as calamitous as the Wall Street meltdown in 2008, you would do all you can to keep the false value high.
We have lost the art of strategic brand building and rely on short term promotions – because they are what works best on these flaky platforms.
We talk about Big Data, but our media shops don’t seem capable of anything much beyond primary school maths. The measurements to justify ludicrously low CPMs should have been called for what they are – Bullshit, a long time ago.
A report by the Wall Street Journal has estimated Facebook has over- estimated the average time spent watching video by a staggering 80 per cent. FMD! And still, our industry pushes Facebook and Google and lets them measure their own performance, with only a whisper of disapproval.
What do our media “leaders “say about the flaky measurements? “We are not surprised” and it was a “Careless mistake.” (A huge fucking rip-off is more like it) But “After careful review we have determined that this error has no impact on the pricing and audience delivery of our campaigns.”. Of course.
“Here is your campaign performance – plus or minus 80 per cent. But we keep that juicy 20 per cent commission thank you, because the price is not affected”. Have to go, off the lunch/dinner/a show (put favourite past time in here) with Google/Facebook.
In a series of articles recently on Existential Threat to advertising agencies, Credibility and Remuneration were listed as two of the four major threats (Along with Identity and Competition).
When such a significant proportion of a media agencies revenue is linked to commissions, the question of “how objective is the advice and recommendations?” must be asked This is not confined to advertising, but any business whose major stream is derived from commissions.
The financial planning industry was subject to heavy criticism after a number of property financial products failed. Small “Mom & Pop” investors were wiped out. Instead of providing solid, objective advice, these unsophisticated but trusting “investors” had 80 per cent or more of their savings tied up in these products, rather than having their money spread across a number of areas to minimise risk.
A post mortem revealed they were presented to the clients as being almost zero risk, but high return. (Which goes against the basic laws of nature). It was revealed that the financial planners involved were receiving commissions of up to 20 per cnet from these high risk “products”. And to make matter worse, they received their commissions upon the signing up of the poor, unsuspecting client. The planners got their dough. The investors got screwed.
Even if a person believes they are providing objective advice, many studies over many years by psychologists have consistently shown that a person is more likely to believe in something that benefits them. They search for evidence to support their hypothesis i.e. commissions can lead to skewed advice, even if unintentional.
Irrespective of the area of the practise, being “seen to do the right thing is almost equally important as “doing the right thing”.
I have quoted Professor Mark Ritson on a number of occasions. He was the first high profile marketing academic to draw attention to the inadequacies and inaccuracies of social and online media measurements and impact, relative to mainstream. For quite some time he was a lone voice. I have worked with quite a number of marketing academics and they all have one thing in common – their advice is objective. Academic is also somewhat misleading as they all have provided consulting to the both the private and public sector i.e. it is not just theory. They put their thoughts into practice and they are not beholden to a third party for their fees.
His most recent column in The Australian Media section last Monday highlighted how even the biggest and most respected advertisers can become ensnared in the question of conflict of interest.
At a conference at the Hordern Pavilion in Sydney, attended by the cream of the Australian marketing industry, Telstra’s Chief Marketing Officer extolled the virtues of YouTube, detailing the role it played in the outstanding success of their new “Thrive On” campaign. It was described as the most successful in Telstra’s history. (Though I am not quite sure how this was measured).
It received 1.5 million views on YouTube. It was emphasised that 60 per cent of theses viewers did not switch off after three seconds, but saw it through to the end i.e. 900,000 people.
As well as the numbers generated by YouTube, the value was highlighted with a CPM of just $9 compared to $23 for FTA TV.
All sounds great. But Ritson applied a bit of basic maths and looked at the whole picture.
- Getting 900,000 people to look at an advertising video is not to be sneezed at, but this equates to just 5 per cent of Telstra’ 17 million customers all of whom were “invited”, via email, to view it.
- These views were totalled over a two-month period.
- After just one week, Telstra’s ad had 10 million impressions on TV. Over two months that figure was around 90 million
- Most viewers saw it more than the effective 3 times frequency on TV.
- Comparing the two, 98 per cent of the video views were on TV and just over 1 per cent on YouTube
But the role TV played in the campaign was not recognised. To any impressionable person in the audience, YouTube was the hero and TV was yesterday’s hero. It is hard to put an accurate percentage on this, but I would guess that well over half of the audience started their careers in the “digital era” and have fed and believed that online and social as the future believe that time spent understanding traditional media is time wasted – we have a whole generation of marketers who have been brain washed.
As an aside, Senator Dastyari, the Labor Senator who was recently forced to resign for accepting money from Chinese businesses (and by extension, the Chinese government), is the darling of the young progressives. He named his 10 most evil companies – no surprise it was made up of the 4 big banks, the 3 big miners, Coles, Woolworths and Telstra. He did not nominate Apple, Google or Facebook. They are technology companies (well, Facebook and Google really are media companies, but to concede this would seriously cramp their style by having to work within the same constrictive legislative framework as the traditional media companies.). The point – no one in our industry wants to be seen as living in the past. Facebook and Google (outside of their search business) do not come in for anything but the most cursory of scrutiny.
Telstra generates around $9 billion annually from video streaming, of which $1.9 billion comes from YouTube.
So there is a bloody big conflict of interest happening here. But the problem is it is not just “here” but occurring all through the industry.
Is it any wonder so much money has been poured into social and online advertising? One of the largest advertisers in the country is essentially lauding YouTube as the major driver of their most successful campaign ever. And our largest media buyers are shrugging their shoulders and saying “Oh, well, it doesn’t really change anything”, when Facebook is accused of inflating their video watching time by up to 80 per cent. If that figure was say 10 per cent, such a response would be understandable, but 80%?
The old question springs to mind “Is it incompetence, or is it corruption”?
No wonder advisory and management consulting firms are increasingly becoming threats. PwC recently produced research for their clients saying advertising agencies can no longer be relied upon to communicate with a diverse society, as the majority of creative directors are male, white and middle class and hence lack the empathy required.
Twenty years ago it would have been unheard of for a firm, who started out as chartered accountants, to be commenting on our core “product” – creative.
But these guys have the ear of the CEOs and boards. It won’t be long before many start asking, “So if advertising agencies can longer be relied upon to create relevant communications, who can we rely upon”?
And they will smile and say “Us”.
Latest News
The Unapproved Climate Certification Allegedly Causing Mass Greenwashing
Are you left flummoxed in the canned tuna & free range eggs aisle? Just wait till this green certification gets up.
TV Ratings (22/04/2024): Fans Mock “Over The Top” Reaction To New MasterChef Judges
MasterChef returns for its 2024 season. B&T stands by putting peppercorns in Gravox & no one will be any the wiser.
Dentsu Restructure: Muddle, Harvey & Johnston Take Leadership Baton As Bass & Yurisich Exit
A large broom has swept through Dentsu's local ops this morning, taking with it some big names & the air con's cobwebs.
Industry Shares Trends Shaping The Industry This International Creators Day
B&T's asking adland creators to reveal their top trends. And it's not good news for your Jenny Kee cardigan collection.
Mable Extends HOYTS Sensory Screenings Partnership
Mable has extended its HOYTS sensory screening partnership. Vigorously defends its two-star Oppenheimer review.
Orphan Launches ‘They Need Our Help. We Need Yours’ For Children’s Cancer Institute
Anything to do with childhood cancers has B&T's 110% support. That said, we do ignore the red meat & alcohol warnings.
Smile Team Orthodontics & Keep Left Collaborate On Smile-Inducing Campaign
As parents would attest, given the cost of orthodontics you'd expect this campaign to be a lavish production indeed.
Opinion: How Video Calls Neglect Learning Diversity
Need an excuse to duck out of a video call this arvo? Show this to your boss.
DoubleVerify Achieves First-Of-Its-Kind Responsible AI Certification From TrustArc
DoubleVerify receives responsible AI certification. However, not its robotic vacuum that's been seen menacing the cat.
Smile For A Good Cause: The Social Media Campaign Giving Back To The Community
Are you known as the office Austin Powers? More for you teeth than shagability? Get snappy new fangs with this news.
Elon Musk Mocks Albo After ESafety Wins Court Injunction Against X
Albo's 2024 from hell continues - Rabbitohs in crisis, down in the polls and now feuding with world's richest man.
Real Estate Developer In Hot Water Over “Sexually Exploitative” OOH Campaign
Real estate agents again tops in the 'least trusted profession' polls, nudging used car salesmen & ad creatives.
Epsilon’s Shane Hanby: Post-Cookie Era Relies On “Teamwork” Between Brands, Marketers & Tech
This pro predicts more "teamwork" in a post-cookie era. Which spells bad news for the uncooperative or plain stubborn.
Entries For Five Decades Of Advertising Graduates Awards Close On Monday
Entries for the Five Decades of Advertising awards close Monday. And no extensions! Any bribery is open til Wednesday.
Cadbury Extends Commitment To Women’s Sport With Sweet New Wallaroos Deal
Rot your teeth, get fat and support women's sport all at the same time with this sweet new sponsorship arrangement.
Campfire X & Nando’s Partner To Acknowledge Traditional Land Owners Across Australia
Chicken chain unveils important First Nations initiative. The actual chickens more concerned with the Adani coal mine.
Lisa Ronson, Naysla Edwards & Ben Hill Join MFA Awards Signature Judging Panel
MFA Awards adds some serious clout to its judging panel. Still no confirmation Paulini will be performing on the night.
Connect Hearing ‘Sounds Good’ Platform Via Bread Agency
Every office has that one hard of hearing person that's oblivious to the fact. Ramp up their insecurities with this.
Ipsos Iris Data: Australians Prioritise Entertainment & Sports Over Serious News In March
Data shows Aussies prioritising light entertainment over hard news. And who can blame them if you've seen the hard news!
Fur Media Partners With Mad Paws To Support Advertisers
It's never good if your office smells like faeces & brine chunks in aspic. Not if you're pet-friendly agency Fur Media.
MAXIBON Drops Epic Flavour Collaboration Via SICKDOGWOLFMAN
There are few pluses to be had with global warming, except the extension of ice-cream eating season.
Sling & Stone Scrubs Up With Lush Account
Got friends at Sling & Stone? Expect the dreaded loofah and bath bomb for birthdays/Christmas this year.
SBS’s The Cook Up With Adam Liaw Produces ‘Fewer CO2 Emissions Than Industry Average’
SBS could go full vegan for Adam Liaw's seventh season and reduce its TV audience and emissions by 99 per cent.
GumGum & Playground xyz To Merge Media Portfolio, Creating “Powerhouse” Ad Suite
GumGum & Playground xyz tap into consumer mindset. B&T prefers tapping a keg, but whatever works.
All The Winners & Grinners From The TikTok Young Lions Awards Night!
Last week saw every part of the human experience: Exalted, devastated, exhausted & stuffing sausage rolls in the corner.
TV Ratings (21/4/24): Farmer Wants A Wife Wins Sunday Prime Time
Farmer Wants A Wife does make the country life seductive. Apart from the manure stench & the bleating roosters at 5am.
Australia’s Automotive Industry Shifts Gears With CTV
How much was CTV responsible for Australia's record car sales in 2023? Or those horrible oversized American utes?
Australia’s C7EVEN Communications Launches Services In Japan With New Tokyo Office
Aussie comms agency unveils its Tokyo plans. Confirms it's still getting the hang of the toilets over there.
Daniel Goldstein Promoted To Head Of PR At Example
Try as he may to surreptitiously blend in with the wall in his photo, this PR fellow still relatively easy to spot.
Marie Claire & Volvo Partner For The Planet: Nominees For The Inaugural Marie Claire Sustainability Awards Announced
Fashion bible Marie Claire unveils its Sustainability Awards. Yet still refusing to recycle 2023's maxi skirts trend.
Sefiani Unveils A Wave Of Promotions & Appointments
Life's good in PR/comms as Sefiani unveils new hires. Well, bad news for media sites obsessed with redundancy stories.
Yahoo Launches Identity Solutions For CTV
Connected TV just got a whole lot more exciting with this innovation. Bar the incessant Friends re-runs.
Infosum Launches Data Clean Room Solution With Samsung Ads Australia
Infosum & Samsung Ads launch a data clean room solution that's a lot more than a Wettex & squirt of Ajax.
Fast 10: Bread Agency’s Amaury Treguer On Its “Unrivalled” Social Commerce Focus
Bread Agency's Amaury Treguer takes B&T's Fast 10, as he reveals why he won't be sandwiched up against the opposition.
X And Elon Musk To Sue Australia’s eSafety Commissioner Over Sydney Stabbing Takedown Order
If this all wasn't traumatic enough, Elon weighs in to prove he's the world's richest man & world's biggest dickhead.
CRA Siren Award To Be Presented At B&T Awards 2024!
Often attend award nights & think "I wish this night would never end"? Well, B&T's just got that tiny bit longer.