Imposing Gender Quotas at Work: Good Or Bad Move?

Women remain divided over whether imposing quotas will fix or frustrate the gender diversity issue within creative agencies a debate held in New York City last week has shown.
Australia’s own Bec Brideson, Venus Comms, and Christina Gliha, Juniper Park\TBWA Canada, argued the case for quotas suggesting on current trends it will take 170 years for women to reach parity without it. Emiliana Torrens CEO of Possible, Buenos Aires, and Jureeporn Thaidumrong, Grey Advertising Thailand, put forward an alternative view.
The debate unfolded at a special event at Google’s NYC headquarters leading up to the 3% Conference, held late last week and over the weekend Australian time. The 3% Conference, now five years old, was started in reaction to the shocking statistic that only 3% of creative directors were women. The number now hovers around 11%.
Moderated by Cecelia Wogan-Silva, global creative agency development director at Google, the views of these high profile ECDs varied greatly. Gliha provided some compelling data on the Nordic experience and the performance benefits of companies who initiated quotas to address the rebalance.
The World Economic Forum research and report on gender gaps conducted in collaboration with Harvard University and the University of California (2013) had Iceland, Finland, Norway and then Sweden come in the top 4. New Zealand ranked seventh, and Australia ranked 24th, well behind other first world countries such as the UK, Canada and the US.
The report concludes countries and companies can be competitive only if they develop, attract and retain the best talent, both male and female. While governments have an important role to play in creating the right policy framework for improving women’s access and opportunities, it is also the imperative for companies to create workplaces where the best talent can flourish. Media and the advertising industry have important roles to play in both empowering women and engaging men in the process.
Brideson offered a holistic view of the systemic patterns needing to be addressed in addition to quotas. One such pattern is women and men’s contributions and behaviours in businesses are different and therefore need to be valued “equally but different” she says. Women bring the female lens and this brings deep knowledge and insight of the most dominant consumer, women.
Other commentators have told B&T that the work life balance required for the primary carer of young children (usually women) is a key stumbling block. Until brand CMOs stop demanding unrealistic turn around on briefs , requiring creatives to work around the clock, quotas alone will not address the issue.
While the room was divided, there was a definite skew towards the imposition of quotas. Notably, two of the panelists were against quotas. Instead they focused on merit in their debate and the notion they were given their roles to make up the numbers rather than on the merit of their work was considered a setback to the cause, in their view.
Vexing and heated at times, but always polite and diplomatic the jury was out with the audience, but not with this author.
The facts speak for themselves. Diversity and inclusion equals better performance. As Cindy Gallop mused in a later talk “you get a bunch of white blokes and you get Superman versus Batman, or you get a diverse group of talented people and you get Hamilton [Broadway’s latest breakthrough hip-hop stage show].”
Pictured above from left to right
- Emiliana Torrens, CEO at POSSIBLE Buenos Aires, Argentina
- Bec Brideson, ECD, Venus Communications, Australia
- Christina Gliha, Group Creative Director, Juniper Park \ TBWA Toronto, Canada
- Jureeporn Thaidumrong, Chief Creative Officer, Grey Advertising, Thailand
- Cecelia Wogan-Silva, global creative agency development director at Google
Please login with linkedin to comment
3% Conference Advertising Standards Bureau american psychological association Dentsu Aegis Global ADMA Forum seven year switchLatest News

Sky News Australia Nabs Ross Greenwood As Business Weekend Anchor
Australian business and finance expert Ross Greenwood has signed exclusively with Sky News Australia as business editor and anchor of Business Weekend. With more than 40 years’ experience covering business news in Australia and around the world, Greenwood brings expertise to the role of Sky News business editor where he will lead the network’s business […]

Christian Wilkins Becomes Pantene’s First Australian Male Brand Ambassador
Christian Wilkins beats out Peter Garrett and Josh Frydenberg to become Pantene's first Australian brand ambassador.

Brands Deploy Mittens Memes After Bernie Sanders Goes Viral
Becoming slightly bored of Bernie Sanders memes clogging your social media? Let B&T add just a little more clog here.

Bumble Goes Public Despite Apple Privacy Change Concerns
The B&T editor's authoritative research confirms Bumble is ahead of Hinge when it comes to getting completely ignored.

Dan Andrews Cracks Top 20 In Hottest 100: “It’s Officially Time To Get On The Beers”
Victorian premier now referring to himself as DJ Dan Man & The Comrades after snaring Hottest 100 top 20.

The Rise And Rise Of The ‘As A Service’ Model
Here's a top piece on data as a service model. And as data's adland's "new gold", you could turn it into a new tooth.

Fitness First Unveils ‘Put Yourself First’ Campaign Via Thinkerbell
Reinvigorate your New Year goals with this new campaign. Unless those goals were to get more slovenly & take up smoking.

Carat Unveils Its Annual 2021 Trends Report
Looking for flying cars & self-styling hair helmets in Carat's 2021 Trends Report? Alas, no news, B&T's sad to report.

“We Don’t Respond To Threats”: Frydenberg Hits Back At Google
The mudslinging continues between the government & the tech giants. Expect Google's return sludge some time tomorrow.

Cristiano Ronaldo Turns Down $10M A Year To Be Face Of Saudi Tourism Over Human Rights Abuses
B&T's sure Saudi Arabia would be the perfect getaway for NRL end-of-season tours, bucks parties & even schoolies week.

Girls React To Kamala Harris Inauguration In Inspiring Spot Via Girl Up
All your colleagues bludged off on a four-day weekend while you're stuck in the office? Find some motivation here.

Cricket Australia Stands Firm On Decision To Remove ‘Australia Day’ From Marketing Campaign Despite PM’s Criticism
According to Wiki, other reasons to celebrate 26th of January include 1918's Finnish civil war and Ellen's birthday.

The Year Of Trust: Why 2021 Will Be Ruled By The Consumer
Columnist says 2021 will be ruled by the consumer. Probably not the consumer who wants an overseas holiday, however.

Joe Biden Fronts TIME Cover Depicting Mess Left By Trump Administration
One minute you're "person of the year", the next you're excrement on the sole of a shoe. As Trump's discovered here.

Cooks Urged To Help ‘Killjoy’ Vegans By Embracing Plant-Based, Via Mush-Boom
New campaign urges us all to embrace mushrooms. Presumably the button-type, not the magic variety.

Kayo Launches New Free Content Offering
Kayo launches new free content offering. Sadly, still no love for fans of elephant polo, frog racing or cheese rolling.

Seven Snares Former Nine Exec Clare Gill To Head Government Affairs
Undoubtedly the first rule of any government affairs role is having to lie about pretending to enjoy Canberra.

Bus Shelters Filled With Golf Balls In New Holey Moley Promo, Via Seven + QMS Media
You'd have to admit, if Holey Moley proves a fizzer it definitely won't be from marketing the absolute crap out of it.

Google Has “No Real Choice” But To Disable Search In Australia If Media Code Legislation Is Passed
If Google turns off search in Australia, B&T can no longer guarantee outright plagiarism of other media sites.

Cannes Lions Jury Has Highest Representation Of Women In Festival’s History
In arguably bad news for ladder, chainsaw and ute ads, Cannes now boasts it's biggest number of female judges.

Bush Heritage Honours Heroes Of Bush Conservation In Latest Campaign
Here's one of those nice stories B&T likes to run. Makes a refreshing change from our usual evil & gutter journalism.

Australian Open Controversy No Cause For Concern For Sponsors
Could Nick finally do the nation proud at this year's Oz Open? Or will he bow out early in a huffy tantrum as usual?

Get On The Beers: BrewDog To Gift Brewery To Mashd N Kutcher If They Chart In Triple J’s Hottest 100
As a warning, if you're unaware of the Mashd N Kutcher song then this story will make little to no sense.

TV Host Jimmy Kimmel Farewells Trump With Glorious Spoof Send-Off Video
Admit it, much like the Sizzler restaurant chain, Gangnam Style & chlamydia you're going to miss the Donald, aren't you?

Can’t Cook Pasta Al Dente? Barilla Now Has Spotify Playlists That’ll Help
With all due respect, surely the perfect tune to cook pasta al dente would have to be Joe Dolce's 'Shaddap Your Face'.

Outdoor Industry Launches First $3M Pro Bono Health Campaign For Department Of Health
B&T's always happy to report on the industry doing good. Except if it requires a financial donation on our part.

Facebook Launches Mardi Gras Parade Viewing Events Grants Program
It's mid-January & that means two things: abandoning all New Year resolutions & the start of Mardi Gras stories on B&T.

Zenith Appointed To SBS’ Performance Media Account
Surely this SBS news would be more appropriate in Flemish or Hungarian, yet, sadly, it's all in English, we're afraid.

IMG Wins Asian Television Award For NBL20 Grand Final Series
Admittedly, we're not huge basketball fans here at B&T. Although we always enjoyed OJ Simpson's movies.

Wunderman Thompson Launches Annual Future 100 Report
New report says immunity wellness, cloud gaming & micropreneurs are in & storming the Capital dressed as a viking's out.