Imposing Gender Quotas at Work: Good Or Bad Move?

Imposing Gender Quotas at Work: Good Or Bad Move?
SHARE
THIS



Women remain divided over whether imposing quotas will fix or frustrate the gender diversity issue within creative agencies a debate held in New York City last week has shown.

Australia’s own Bec Brideson, Venus Comms, and Christina Gliha, Juniper Park\TBWA Canada, argued the case for quotas suggesting on current trends it will take 170 years for women to reach parity without it.  Emiliana Torrens CEO of Possible, Buenos Aires, and Jureeporn Thaidumrong, Grey Advertising Thailand, put forward an alternative view.

The debate unfolded at a special event at Google’s NYC headquarters leading up to the 3% Conference, held late last week and over the weekend Australian time. The 3% Conference, now five years old, was started in reaction to the shocking statistic that only 3% of creative directors were women. The number now hovers around 11%.

Moderated by Cecelia Wogan-Silva, global creative agency development director at Google, the views of these high profile ECDs varied greatly. Gliha provided some compelling data on the Nordic experience and the performance benefits of companies who initiated quotas to address the rebalance.

The World Economic Forum research and report on gender gaps conducted in collaboration with Harvard University and the University of California (2013) had Iceland, Finland, Norway and then Sweden come in the top 4.  New Zealand ranked seventh, and Australia ranked 24th, well behind other first world countries such as the UK, Canada and the US.

The report concludes countries and companies can be competitive only if they develop, attract and retain the best talent, both male and female. While governments have an important role to play in creating the right policy framework for improving women’s access and opportunities, it is also the imperative for companies to create workplaces where the best talent can flourish. Media and the advertising industry have important roles to play in both empowering women and engaging men in the process.

Brideson offered a holistic view of the systemic patterns needing to be addressed in addition to quotas. One such pattern is women and men’s contributions and behaviours in businesses are different and therefore need to be valued “equally but different” she says. Women bring the female lens and this brings deep knowledge and insight of the most dominant consumer, women.

Other commentators have told B&T that the work life balance required for the primary carer of young children (usually women) is a key stumbling block. Until brand CMOs stop demanding unrealistic turn around on briefs , requiring creatives to work around the clock, quotas alone will not address the issue.

While the room was divided, there was a definite skew towards the imposition of quotas. Notably, two of the panelists were against quotas. Instead they focused on merit in their debate and the notion they were given their roles to make up the numbers rather than on the merit of their work was considered a setback to the cause, in their view.

Vexing and heated at times, but always polite and diplomatic the jury was out with the audience, but not with this author.

The facts speak for themselves. Diversity and inclusion equals better performance. As Cindy Gallop mused in a later talk “you get a bunch of white blokes and you get Superman versus Batman, or you get a diverse group of talented people and you get Hamilton [Broadway’s latest breakthrough hip-hop stage show].”

Pictured above from left to right

  • Emiliana Torrens, CEO at POSSIBLE Buenos Aires, Argentina
  • Bec Brideson, ECD, Venus Communications, Australia
  • Christina Gliha, Group Creative Director, Juniper Park \ TBWA Toronto, Canada
  • Jureeporn Thaidumrong, Chief Creative Officer, Grey Advertising, Thailand
  • Cecelia Wogan-Silva, global creative agency development director at Google

Please login with linkedin to comment

3% Conference Advertising Standards Bureau american psychological association Dentsu Aegis Global ADMA Forum seven year switch

Latest News

In-Person Event! Hear From Ex-Monkey Justin Drape, BMF’s Christina Aventi, Dr. Karl Kruszelnicki (And All For Nix!)
  • Marketing

In-Person Event! Hear From Ex-Monkey Justin Drape, BMF’s Christina Aventi, Dr. Karl Kruszelnicki (And All For Nix!)

B&T’s sister publication Travel Weekly will be hosting its annual Travel Daze conference in Sydney on June the 9th and better still you’re invited and, even more fantastically, tickets are free! Yep, zilch, zero, nix! The full-day event will be staged at Paddington’s Chauvel Cinema in inner-Sydney and boasts an incredible and eclectic speaker line-up […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
VOLY Election Day Campaign, Developed By In-House Creative Team, Hits Aussies Right At The Feels
  • Campaigns

VOLY Election Day Campaign, Developed By In-House Creative Team, Hits Aussies Right At The Feels

On election day, instant grocery company VOLY, took to Sydney electorates to call out the wild and confusing things that make up our election process. The campaign featured a combination of walking billboards, social media and surprise ‘Democracy sausage’ deliveries to polling booths across Sydney. VOLY was able to cut through the noise and position […]

The headset on tablet for metaverse  or technology concept 3d rendering
  • Opinion
  • Technology

Is The Age Of The Metaverse Over Before It Officially Began?

Plummeting prices of cryptocurrencies, hacking and stealing of overpriced non-fungible tokens, an uncontrollable market that seems to operate on the moods of those who run it… All these are elements which are making marketers pull the breaks on their plans to invest within the world of digital real estate. But is all this coming to […]

Feeling Uncomfortable Is Your Biggest Opportunity For Growth
  • Opinion

Feeling Uncomfortable Is Your Biggest Opportunity For Growth

In this guest post, Stu Wragg (main photo), chief strategy officer at Herd MSL, says your best work so often happens when you’re well out of your comfort zone… There’s a lot to be said for feeling comfortable but when it comes to professional development, it’s uncomfortable experiences, not comfortable ones, that matter most. For […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Ecommerce Content, Product & Serves Site Youtime.Com Launches In Australia
  • Technology

Ecommerce Content, Product & Serves Site Youtime.Com Launches In Australia

Introducing youtime.com – a considered curation of content, products and services all designed to help enhance your ‘you time’. Unlike anything else in the Australian market, youtime is set to lead the way in a new-age breed of digital destinations; where editorial leads eCommerce, retail becomes a service, shopping meets experience, and everything is grounded […]

SBS Launches New Free-To-Air Multilingual Channel Titled SBS WorldWatch
  • Media

SBS Launches New Free-To-Air Multilingual Channel Titled SBS WorldWatch

SBS has today launched SBS WorldWatch, an all-new free-to-air multilingual news channel. The dedicated 24-hour channel features news bulletins from leading international broadcasters in more than 35 languages and is home to SBS’s Arabic and Mandarin television news bulletins – SBS عربي News and SBS 中文 News. The launch of the channel builds on SBS’ […]

Xandr Makes A Series Of Additions To Its Senior Team
  • Marketing

Xandr Makes A Series Of Additions To Its Senior Team

Xandr today announced three key senior appointments to the team, the first under new ANZ managing director, Nicole Prior, as the company eyes expansion. Mark Serhan is appointed to the newly created role of commercial director, Philip Coetzee becomes associate director – product management, and Archana Ganesh becomes associate director – APAC product support lead. […]

World-First Australian Fashion Trademark To Accelerate Demand for Australian Fashion Industry
  • Campaigns

World-First Australian Fashion Trademark To Accelerate Demand for Australian Fashion Industry

The Australian Fashion Council (AFC) – the peak body for the Australian fashion and textile industry – has launched Australian Fashion Trademark. The Australian Fashion™ and ‘Fashion Evolution: From Farm to Industry’ launched at Afterpay Australian Fashion Week. Over the next 10 years, the industry has the potential to deliver an additional $10.8 billion in […]

Elon Musk Was Accused Of Sexual Misconduct And SpaceX Paid Heavily To Cover It Up
  • Media

Elon Musk Was Accused Of Sexual Misconduct And SpaceX Paid Heavily To Cover It Up

According to reports, the SpaceX and Tesla owner, Elon Musk, asked a flight attendant for an “erotic massage” then proceeded to touch her inappropriately without her permission. He then gave her over $350,000 to keep her from talking about it. The report, which originally came from the Insider, cites a close friend of the flight […]