Greenpeace V Shell Via Lego: The Building Blocks Of A Successful Campaign
In light of Lego cutting ties with Shell due to the Greenpeace campaign, Toby Miller from The Conversation looks at the way the marketing campaign forced the end of a decades long partnership.
October 9 2014 was a big day in eco-activism: Lego announced that it would not renew a product-placement deal with Shell, following concerted pressure from Greenpeace as part of a campaign to ban Arctic oil exploration by attacking firms associated with such activities.
It is a common tactic of major energy companies to engage in collaborations with companies such as Lego as part of their quest for what they call a “social license” to operate. That means winning local, national and international community support.
For its part, Lego benefits from the money that comes with product placement; as per a James Bond movie, the producers defray their costs well in advance of sales to customers by accepting funding from firms that want to be associated with a happy, friendly, trustworthy image.
In this case, the firm is Greenpeace’s sworn enemy, Shell. As a sub-plot, Lego has been boasting of its green credentials.
On July 1 2014, Lego said: “A co-promotion contract like the one with Shell is one of many ways we are able to bring Lego bricks into the hands of more children.” It went on:
The Greenpeace campaign focuses on how Shell operates in a specific part of the world. We firmly believe that this matter must be handled between Shell and Greenpeace. We are saddened when the Lego brand is used as a tool in any dispute between organisations.
Now, Lego’s tune differs:
We continuously consider many different ways of how to deliver on our promise of bringing creative play to more children. We want to clarify that as things currently stand we will not renew the co-promotion contract with Shell when the present contract ends.
We do not want to be part of Greenpeace’s campaign and we will not comment any further on the campaign. We will continue to deliver creative and inspiring Lego play experiences to children all over the world.
This is, surely, one of those moments when a big but pusillanimous multinational corporation withers in the face of critique from a gallant but small non-government organisation – when activism trumps business, ethics triumphs over size, and scale is helpless in the face of righteousness.
It has been hailed by Greenpeace true believers as “one of the most high-profile victories in its history” thanks to “guerrilla tactics”. The organisation itself immodestly announced in an email to its supporters that: “Today was a great day for the Arctic, and for people power.”
But was it? Perhaps this was a smart, sophisticated, well-heeled multinational marketing campaign, undertaken via a vast network, using the services of advertising agencies and borrowing trademarks and copyrights to make a political point?
Is this actually about what happens when multinationals fall out, when two vast companies (Shell and Lego) are separated by another powerful not-for-profit multinational (Greenpeace) revelling in the fantasy that it is David taking on Goliath? One version of these events might read: Greenpeace has not achieved very much in its critiques of Shell, so it went after a soft target. Lego caved in, the victim of a form of secondary boycott.
While the charity argues that its grassroots campaign and direct-action pranks were crucial, one might also say that “wot won it” was a couple of ingenious videos.
The first and most popular took music, words, images, and logos from one of the most successful films of the year, The Lego Movie, to create a post-modern pastiche aimed at the heartstrings. The second, artier and less direct, was targeted at parents.
The first, a brilliant video trope, worked magnificently and has become a case study for ad agencies. As the industry bible AdWeek put it, Greenpeace took “a page from Chipotle’s marketing playbook – haunting animation plus a distressing cover of a well-known song”.
Other actions, such as a few children building anti-oil Lego figures in central London, some adults climbing models at a theme park and fun Lego figures placed in protests across major world cities, were minor irritants at best, drawing predictably minimal press coverage but incarnating a grassroots legitimacy that appeals to donors and old-fashioned activists from pre-social media eras.
But even as the triumph occurred, Shell was luxuriating in Pele’s endorsement of it for providing “the world’s first player-powered community football pitch in the centre of Rio Di Janeiro’s favela”.
It will take more than a sophisticated stunt by vanguardist apparatchiks to answer Pele. And it won’t be the action of a brave wee David against a big nasty Goliath – more a contest between rivals for multinational space and control. Greenpeace is well-placed to participate, thanks to its vast resources and smart links to ad agencies. But is people power one more marketing tool in this admittedly worthy struggle?
Toby Miller is married to a Greenpeace campaigner and donates to the organization
This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.
Please login with linkedin to comment
Bauer Betting Brazil Clemenger BBDO Sydney storify walkley WAN-IFRA World Association of Newspapers and News PublishersLatest News
MINT Expands Technology Portfolio With The Addition Of Audio Brand Bang & Olufsen
Insight-led communications consultancy, The Mint Partners has expanded its technology portfolio with the addition of luxury audio lifestyle brand Bang & Olufsen. Founded in 1925 in Struer, Denmark, Bang & Olufsen has pushed the boundaries of audio technology for almost a century. The company continues to be at the forefront of acoustic innovation with its […]
WWF-Australia Appoints whiteGREY As Lead Agency
The tiger skin rug & taxidermied antelope quickly being removed from whiteGREY's reception after snaring WWF account.
Regulator Set To Clamp Down On Super Funds’ “Ridiculous Vain Advertising”
Most articles with "superannuation" in the headline can cause the eyes to glaze over. However, this one's rather catty.
The Body Shop Appoints Havas Melbourne As Media Agency
Are you friends with anyone from Havas Melbourne? Sadly, it'll be bath bombs & a pointless loofah for Christmas for you.
RAC Insurance Tells WA Locals “We See What You See” In New Spot Via Wunderman Thompson
WA car and home insurer, RAC has launched a new campaign to show locals that they understand the priceless relationship members have with their belongings. Created by Wunderman Thompson Perth, the campaign titled ‘We See What You See’ uses computer generated imagery (CGI) to depict the unique relationship a family has with their insured items – […]
Dave Grohl Opens Up About Caffeine Addiction In Hilarious Spoof Ad
Fear not, the person in the B&T office that asked, "Who's Dave Grohl?" has left the company with immediate effect.
Wednesday TV Wrap: Gruen Pips The Block By Just 25,000 Eyeballs
Gruen continues to shine a valuable light on the ad industry. Which begs the question: what the f@ck's B&T doing then?
PUMA & Athletics Australia Announce Four-Year Partnership
Can't run the 100-metres in under 15 minutes? Well, judging by this press photo it could be the drag from your elbows.
Australian Space Agency Appoints Indie Agency NATION
Apparently Australia has a space agency, with plans afoot to launch the first Jayco caravan into orbit.
TPG Telecom Appoints Paper Moose As Creative Agency For New Brand Felix
Paper Moose has created a campaign for the recently announced carbon-neutral telco brand, felix, due to go to market towards the end of the year. This is the first work from Paper Moose since winning a competitive pitch for the new TPG Telecom brand. The teaser campaign raises awareness of the nearly 1 million tonnes […]
UnLtd Launches Ambassadors Of Good Program
UnLtd launches its Ambassadors Of Good program. Which kinda sounds a bit like a Christian rock band at Hillsong.
Canva Launches New Products As Usage Surges 25%
Of all of Australia's tech billionaires, at least Canva's haven't decided they're also pseudo politicians.
Study: Consumers Want The Feel Good Factor In This Year’s Christmas Ads
B&T wants to see more realistic Chrissie ads - dry turkey, pissed relatives, possible fistfight & police intervention.
Why Apple Is Building Up Its Search Engine
Forget the shiny gadgets & skivvies, evidence is mounting that Apple could possibly be the Fourth Order Of The Sith.
All The Wholesome Pictures From The 2020 B&T Women In Media Awards!
It's your Women In Media picture gallery! The perfect way to have a bludge while pretending to do actual work.
Restoring Trust: How Supply Path Optimisation Is Driving Greater Transparency
Does your supply path optimisation resemble that kitchen drawer dedicated to junk? Spring clean via this essential read.
The Two Murrays Return To Weekends On 2GB And 4BC
Two of Australia’s favourite broadcasters are returning to radio with Murray Wilton and Murray Olds (aka The Two Murrays) set to deliver five hours of news, sport, entertainment, lifestyle and plenty of frivolity over summer weekends on 2GB and 4BC. Their new show launches this Saturday, October 31, and continues on weekends right through until the […]
Klarna Launches First Australian TVC Via Thinkerbell
Klarna is apparently a Swedish shopping app, arguably ideal for shoppers looking for a sauna or new mags for the Volvo.
The Brag Media To Exclusively Represent Australia & New Zealand Audiences Of Variety
The Brag Media, Australia’s number one music and entertainment publisher, has today announced it will exclusively represent Australia and New Zealand audiences for Variety. Variety is the most authoritative and trusted source of entertainment business news, reaching an audience of affluent influencers. For 115 years, influential producers, executives and talent in entertainment have turned to […]
Chello Picks Up ShopifyPlus And Four New Hires
Chello has announced three business wins across its business and four new hires to support recent growth. Joining the agency’s roster is ShopifyPlus APAC along with project work with ShopifyPlus North America, Shef, and Raine & Horne’s national brand. These wins complement the agency’s existing LIV by Mirvac and Qudos Bank accounts. ShopifyPlus APAC Marketing […]
New Campaign For MyDeal.Com.Au Urges Aussies To Bag Their Own Deal
MyDeal.com.au made a splash in the online retail sector last week with its successful IPO on the ASX. This week, however, the brand has made waves on television screens nationwide with the release of its lyrical 2020 Christmas campaign for the all-important December quarter, created in partnership with Cyclone Creative Agency. While COVID-19 has affected […]
Vollebak Prepares For Life On Mars In The Aussie Outback
Here's one for B&T's fashionista readership. So, it didn't really resonate with B&T's flannelette-clad staff.
Afterpay Taps TikTok For Fashion-Forward Fun In New Campaign
Afterpay is the cool and fun new way to get yourself into a lifetime of crippling debt.
Zenith Appoints Joshua Lee As National Head Of Digital & Data
Joshua Lee goes a little bit retro, a little bit Madame Tussauds for press photo following internal promotion.
QMS Showcases B&T Women In Media Winners
Women In Media winners not only receive industry esteem and a cheap looking trophy, but their own digi billboard too!
It’s Here! All The Incredible Winners From B&T’s Women In Media Awards 2020!
Chief sponsor Are Media congratulates all the Women In Media winners. Stops at offering tips on trophy polishing.
MEET YOUR 2020 WOMEN IN MEDIA WINNERS HERE
B&T’S Women in Media winners have been announced, here we profile in depth each and every one of the incredible winners.
We Need To Talk About B2B Events
This columnist asks is it the end for B2B events? And if so, where will B&T journalists take afternoon naps now?
Women In Media’s Nat Harvey: “Humans Need Other Humans To Thrive And Co-Create Happiness”
Seven's sales director Nat Harvey muses on the year that was AND doesn't use the words "bognogs" or "willy dribbler".
Women In Media’s Juliette Stead: “Playing It Safe Isn’t An Option For Me”
Juliette Stead declares, "Playing it safe isn’t an option for me." Top news if Juliette's your tennis doubles partner.
In light of Lego cutting ties with Shell due to the Greenpeace campaign, Toby Miller from The Conversation looks at the way the marketing campaign forced the end of a decades long partnership.