Ernst & Young Report Questions Effectiveness of Cigarette Plain Packaging

Ernst & Young Report Questions Effectiveness of Cigarette Plain Packaging
SHARE
THIS



British American Tobacco (BAT) has released a report by Ernst & Young (EY) that assesses the impact of government policy on tobacco consumption over the last decade.

One of the key findings outlined by EY in the report is that they “found no evidence that plain packaging has reduced total consumption”.

Further, the report says that the introduction of plain packaging may have actually slightly increased cigarette consumption, although the analysis that EY has undertaken to date does not seek to predict any potential longer term impact of plain packaging.

The report is further evidence following figures released from both national and state government health departments’ which show a jump in youth smoking rates since the implementation of plain packaging.

BATA spokesperson Scott McIntyre said the EY report evaluates the key drivers of historical trends in Australian tobacco consumption particularly given recent policy developments. The report shows Australia as one of the most expensive and heavily regulated market in the world.

“The report found no evidence that since its introduction of plain packaging on 1 December 2012 tobacco consumption has reduced, after taking into consideration the increases in price. This was one of the main objectives of the former government’s policy,” said McIntyre.

“At the same time Australian Government Health Department figures show a 32 per cent increase in 12 to 17 year olds smoking following plain packaging being introduced.

“There’s also been a spike in youth smoking rates according NSW and SA Health Department statistics. Overall smoking rates in both states have risen as well.

“Not only does the report show there is no evidence that plain packaging is reducing tobacco consumption as intended, the rate of smokers quitting has not changed substantially over the last decade,” said McIntyre.

“This is in light of many key policies introduced by government such as Graphic Health Warnings, Retail Display Bans, public place and indoor smoking bans.

“BATA believes ad hoc excise increases in recent years have seen smokers look for cheaper legal and illegal tobacco products. We believe that these tax hikes are not working as the government intended.

“However due to large ad hoc tobacco tax increases the tobacco black market is at record levels while nearly 45 per cent of all legal cigarettes sold in Australia are between $12 and $15.”

The EY report also outlines that Australian Bureau of Statistic (ABS) consumption expenditure data does not provide the most appropriate basis for estimating the total number of cigarettes consumed in Australia, nor does it capture smoking rates for individuals.

“Industry data has been heavily debated in the past but at the end of the day it’s still the best evidence of total tobacco sales in the Australia,” said McIntyre.

“This EY report, the latest KPMG illegal tobacco report and government youth smoking rate figures should all be a key focus of the Australian Government’s Post-Implementation Review into plain packaging which is scheduled to begin on 1 December 2014.”

Please login with linkedin to comment

AXA CP Communications New Book

Latest News

Acast Adds New Brand Suitability Controls For Advertisers Via Comscore
  • Advertising
  • Media

Acast Adds New Brand Suitability Controls For Advertisers Via Comscore

Acast, the independent power source of podcasting has teamed up with Comscore to provide brand suitability controls for brands advertising through the Acast Marketplace. This new innovation is part of a global partnership with Comscore, and will be available to all advertisers working with Acast Australia and New Zealand. The brand suitability solutions offered by […]

Wavemaker Names Susie Si As New Vodafone Lead
  • Media

Wavemaker Names Susie Si As New Vodafone Lead

Media agency Wavemaker has appointed Susie Si as group business director – to lead the Vodafone account. Si joins from sister agency MediaCom, where she has spent the last 8 years. Most recently she was group client lead on News Corp. Si will report to Wavemaker Sydney managing director Ian Edwards, and replaces Emily Cook […]

Trade Indy Opens Sydney Office With Appointment Of NSW Commercial Director Ben Mulcahy
  • Marketing

Trade Indy Opens Sydney Office With Appointment Of NSW Commercial Director Ben Mulcahy

Headquartered in Melbourne, Trade Indy is expanding off the back of strong client retention and consistent growth through existing and new business. Founded in Melbourne in 2014, the team have since expanded the business through team members in Singapore, Indonesia, Tasmania and Queensland, and are pleased to announce the full-time employment of NSW commercial director […]

Outbrain Goes Public, Making Nasdaq Debut
  • Marketing

Outbrain Goes Public, Making Nasdaq Debut

Outbrain Inc. has announced the pricing of its initial public offering of 8,000,000 shares of common stock at a price to the public of US$20.00 per share. The gross proceeds to Outbrain from the offering, before deducting the underwriting discounts and commissions and offering expenses, are expected to be approximately $160 million. The shares began […]

HubSpot To Support The GO Foundation As Part Of World Certification Week
  • Technology

HubSpot To Support The GO Foundation As Part Of World Certification Week

HubSpot, the customer relationship management (CRM) platform for scaling companies, has announced that as part of its World Certification Week, it is supporting the GO Foundation with its mission to empower young Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people through education. As part of the support, HubSpot will donate $5 for every HubSpot Academy certification awarded […]

IntelligenceBank Secures $50M Investment From Five Elms Capital
  • Technology

IntelligenceBank Secures $50M Investment From Five Elms Capital

IntelligenceBank has today announced a strategic growth investment from Five Elms Capital. The $US37 million ($50 million) investment comes as brands and enterprises have realised that outdated technologies, disjointed data sources, and manual processes make it challenging to efficiently manage essential marketing workflows and ensure compliance across the organization. IntelligenceBank digitally transforms manual processes and […]

SCA Announces Ten New Dab Music Stations Via LiSTNR
  • Media

SCA Announces Ten New Dab Music Stations Via LiSTNR

Southern Cross Austero (SCA) announced today 10 all-new DAB+ music stations on LiSTNr. The introduction of the 10 new Dab stations takes the number of music stations to 25 and reinforces its commitment to growing exclusive music programs and content. The 10 new stations have been created to cater to a variety of moods and […]

SBS Launches Live Interpreting Of Daily NSW COVID-19 Conferences In Vietnamese And Arabic
  • Media

SBS Launches Live Interpreting Of Daily NSW COVID-19 Conferences In Vietnamese And Arabic

SBS has launched live interpreting of the daily NSW Government COVID-19 press conference in languages other than English, to provide communities with access to the latest information and critical health messages. The national-first initiative provides real-time interpreting of the press conferences in Arabic and Vietnamese, streamed live every day on the SBS Arabic24 and SBS Vietnamese Facebook pages, SBS […]

Linktree Chooses Snowflake To Support Intelligence And Analytics Activities
  • Technology

Linktree Chooses Snowflake To Support Intelligence And Analytics Activities

Snowflake, the Data Cloud company, today announced it has been chosen by market-leading linking platform, Linktree, to support the company’s business intelligence and analytics activities. Linktree enables creators, brands, artists, publishers, agencies, and businesses of all sizes to curate an online ecosystem and monetise their passion, instantly guiding their audience to the destinations they care […]

London, UK - August 01, 2018: The buttons of Snapchat, Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp on the screen of an iPhone.
  • Media

Snapchat Sees 116% Increase In Revenue

The last time B&T saw impressive increases the size of 116% was the swipe left rejections on our Tinder profile.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Woman hand using modern laptop computer to connect with live streaming video on social network
  • Technology

Xandr Sees 125% Lift In Video Spend

Xandr, AT&T’s data-enabled technology platform at the intersection of digital and TV, today shared results of premium video, Connected TV (CTV) and curated media spend on its platform for Q2 2021, which saw significant increases.

Taboola Acquires Connexity For $1 Billion
  • Technology

Taboola Acquires Connexity For $1 Billion

Taboola (Nasdaq: TBLA), a global leader in powering recommendations for the open web, helping people discover things they may like, announced today that it has entered into a definitive purchase agreement to acquire Connexity from Symphony Technology Group for approximately $US800 million. Connexity is one of the largest independent e-commerce media platforms in the open web, serving over 1,600 direct merchants, and 6,000 publishers.

How To Re-Engineer Your Event Mix With ON24
  • Partner Content

How To Re-Engineer Your Event Mix With ON24

Events are increasingly shifting online. You can't get loaded on booze & arancinis, but you'll save on dry cleaning

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Twitter Lifts Revenue 74% On The Back Of Advertising Boom
  • Technology

Twitter Lifts Revenue 74% On The Back Of Advertising Boom

Twitter has just experienced its fastest growth in revenue since 2014, with the social media platform benefiting from increased interest from advertisers. Revenue was up 74 per cent YoY, according to the company’s Q2 results, reaching $US1.19 billion ($1.6 billion) from $US683.4 million ($925 million) 12 months ago. The strong results came in the same […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine