In his latest B&T column, industry recalcitrant and rabble rouser, Robert Strohfeldt, casts his eye over modern marketing buzzwords and says the old adage of “keep it simple stupid” still rings true…
I have often quoted or referred to article and papers by Professor Mark Ritson. But his latest column in Monday’s The Australian Media section has left me shaking my head.
“Evidence Based Marketing” is being portrayed as a 21st century concept. Mark stated, “There are the enlightened marketers who use evidence based and those who continue to build their campaigns around arcane myths of the 20th century”.
Mark has stated that 21st century marketers,
- Are evidence-based
- Still believe in mass marketing
- Use emotion in advertising to increase effectiveness
The term “legendary” is often thrown about, but a truly legendary marketer is Bob Miller, the former director of marketing for Toyota. If you have not heard of Bob, then your history of marketing and advertising in Australia is lacking.
We had a chat this morning after reading this article and both pissed ourselves laughing. Does he think we stuck a fucking finger in the air to see which way the wind blew and then spent $40,000,000 in advertising on guesses?
Today we live in a world of algorithms. Programmatic media planning is seen as the most effective method. How many people know what are the details of the algorithm and its accuracy? There is so much media “stock” out there to choose from, a person with a calculator cannot cope. But computer modelling was well established and used in media in the 1980s (and before). We are getting dumber and our computers are supposedly getting smarter. (But we don’t really know, as no one has a fucking clue about the algorithms on which they base their assumptions?)
I joined a market research firm in 1980, working for the mad genius George Kelly. “If you want your advertising to work, you need emotion,” he told every client.
The statistical analysis we did had far more rigour to it than much of the rubbish I see today. That attribution has gained such credibility is a testament to the lack of serious understanding of mathematics. Statistics is applied mathematics, particularly multi-dimensional calculus and linear algebra. A 12- month course in statistics to enable a person to become a data scientist, is akin to giving a 17- year old a bottle of bourbon, a joint and the keys to a turbo Porsche. It will end in tears.
Maslow’s hierarchy of needs was developed between 1943 to 1954. A bloody long time ago.
- Self- actualisation
- Self esteem
- Love and belonging
- Safety and security
- Physiological needs.
So, tell me, which of these do not involve emotion?
And then we have the promotion of mass marketing. Segmenting markets is a great way for media proprietors (traditional and particularly online) to get more money for the same amount of media. (Break your audience into segments and stick a loading on each.)
Too often, marketers and advertisers restrict their reach by targeting too finely. I saw this come out of research so many times.
Take cars as just one example. Respondents are asked a series of “behavioural” questions. The analysis will look for correlations (not causal) and say that Mercedes buyers have different views to people who buy BMW and Audi.
And so, they will buy media that can target this particular group of people. But there is no difference between Mercedes, BMW and Audi buyers. They are all the same sort of people but have bought a particular vehicle brand because they like how it looks or were offered a better deal. Not because of some pre-determined behavioural question stuck into the survey.
Of course, there are target segments. People with more money are going to buy more expensive cars. (Not all rich people buy expensive cars, but people without money don’t buy expensive ones). But today, with the ability to target way down to micro levels, many potential buyers are not reached.
Mass marketing gave way to segmented, tactical activities. They may raise sales in the short term but do nothing for the brand over the longer term. Brands are like big ships – they take a long time to change direction, but also a long time to turn back in the right direction.
Alan Morris from MoJo, (another pair who were legendary for their jingle- based campaigns) was asked who the target market for Toohey’s Draught was, “Anyone over 18 with a mouth”.
The biggest difference between the 20th and 21st centuries, is the fragmented media landscape. The creative execution has always had to be empathetic to the medium in which it appeared – e.g. radio “theatre of the mind”. To be successful requires integration, one medium alone will not cut it. There in is the challenge for creative – to ensure empathy across such a wide range of possible mediums, as integration is a must. No one medium can be relied upon. Though pre-digital, we had above and below the line, so marketers still had to be across both longer-term strategic brand building and short- term tactical activities.
And, of course, there is social media, the full effects of which are still occurring.
There is no doubting the marketing landscape is far more cluttered and complex, but the KISS principal still applies. It is so easy to be caught up in the complex. But cut through the bullshit and “keep it simple stupid”.
Please login with linkedin to commentRobert Strohfeldt
Pinterest reckons jellyfish & moody cowboys will be big in 2024. Refused to be drawn on the return of shoulder pads.
IAB Australia has launched ‘Evolution in Market Mix Modelling’, the fourth module in its Marketing Measurement Innovation Series, which has been developed by IAB Australia’s Ad Effectiveness Council. The module explores what is driving the increased use of MMM and how the technique is evolving with advances in computing power and machine learning to provide […]
Scope3, the collaborative sustainability platform leading the decarbonisation of media and advertising, announced the addition of digital out-of-home (DOOH) to its emissions measurement. With DOOH ad spending predicted to grow from $17B in 2023 to nearly $24B by 2028, measuring this channel brings us one step closer to understanding the total impact of digital advertising […]
NRF 2024: Retail’s Big Show Asia Pacific, is now open for online registrations for the main conference. Jointly organized by the National Retail Federation and Comexposium, Retail’s Big Show Asia Pacific will take place from 11 – 13 June, 2024 at the Sands Expo and Convention Centre in Singapore and is expected to draw thousands […]
Following a period of significant client growth, leading auto marketing agency, DBC2 has appointed Jason Fisher (lead image) to the newly created role of CEO. The appointment is part of DBC2’s long term growth strategy ahead of the agency announcing a brand refresh and expanded proposition in early-2024. As a new shareholder of the business, […]
Don’t treat regional media as a charity, but a real growth opportunity: That’s the message from Boomtown’s final masterclass of 2023, attended by almost 100 media industry representatives from across the nation. The masterclass was part of a series of educational sessions, delivered by Boomtown, the media collective championing advertising in regional Australia. The sessions […]