News Analysis: Cyber 'stalking'?

News Analysis: Cyber 'stalking'?
SHARE
THIS



With a large number of Australians saying targeted advertising feels "creepy", Alex Hayes asks what marketers can do to provide a more tailored experience without coming across all cyber stalker  

 

While advertisers are running as fast as they can to gather data on every person online, ostensibly to give them a more personal and targeted experience, a new Ipsos study suggests around half of Australians do not actually feel comfortable being targeted. 

The Mind and Mood report concluded that 46% of Australians do not want the ads targeted at them, with many describing the attempts as "clumsy", "creepy" and "insulting".

Women over the age of 40 were the main complainants, hitting out against "crudely stereotypical advertising". One study participant in in her 40s complained: "The advertising on Facebook changes depending on what you look at and like. For some reason I am getting lots of '53 year old mum looks 37' down the side, and neck exercises and dating for seniors. I look at them and think, harrumph, why am I getting that?"

A common complaint from many was the Big Brother-like quality of these adverts, making them feel as if they are being "stalked".

One respondent said: "It's so much harder to discover anything new these days. It's like you have this digital ghost of who you are hovering over you. It's horrifying."

Even former-US vice president-turned-futurist Al Gore decried it in his interview at South by SouthWest, stating: "There's a difference between scary and creepy. Creepy is not fear, it's pre-fear. Something's going on and you don't know what it is, so you need to be on your guard. That's the same as the digital world with this stalker economy."

The report's author, Laura Demasi, adds: "You'd be hard pressed to find anyone say something positive about the practice."

Despite this, if you ask any strategist, analyst or digital marketer, it is clear targeting is here to stay, so what can marketers do to make their advertising practices better?

"The trick is to not be creepy," is the advice of eBay's vice president of innovation Steve Yankovic.  He sees the shopping experience becoming increasingly personal, using mobile devices to advise on purchases, tell staff when a customer does not like to be approached and even hunt down a better deal locally. 

Yankovic states: "You need to do something useful. The trick is to use the data you have to allow people to opt in to the experience. 

"Eighteen-months ago, 75% of people said 'no' to using data to target content, now it's the other way around. If you change my life and delight me then you will do it."

Adobe's new marketing cloud has rolled together six existing tools – a content management system, analytics, media optimiser and a social media tool. 

And the final element? Adobe Target, a tool allowing marketers to not only customise their ads based on the data they have harnessed, and even test certain executions to portions of their audience to monitor responses. 

Kevin Lindsay, the director of product marketing for Adobe Target, says the important thing for marketers to understand is that there are "degrees of relevance" which need to be worked out on a customer-by-customer basis. 

He suggests: "There are different profiles, and the decision has to be what's appropriate and non-creepy for this anonymous person arriving to the site versus this authenticated person coming to the site because they are already a member and they are expecting a highly-relevant and personalised experience." 

Targeting, says Lindsay, has allowed marketers to finally do what they have always dreamed of – tailor their messages to each individual member of their audience. 

Nowadays many websites offer an experience tailored to customers in subtle ways. 

Lindsay says: "The other way to go is just to provide a relevant, elegant experience, and the person doesn't realise they're having it. But they would realise it if they weren't having it."

But, he acknowledges there is also a public education piece which needs to be performed, with more web browsers like Microsoft's Internet Explorer 10, Google Chrome and Firefox now offering people a "do not track" option, which blocks cookies.

Lindsay adds: "It's obviously a concern. I think that there's been so much fear-mongering about all this stuff that people may be justifiably concerned in some cases and in others it's just silliness. Most people enjoy having a great experience."

He points to Amazon as an exceptional version of personalisation and customisation, allowing consumers the option to tailor their experience right down to rating reviews, and removing them from their feeds. 

"That kind of transparency is a best practice. It's one that can certainly work, and might be a way to go," concludes Lindsay. 

But, with targeting comes a certain amount of demographic generalisations, based on age, gender, marital status, location and a myriad of other tiny details. 

Increasingly though, publishers and platforms are turning away from this broad-stroke approach, and turning instead to different ways to categorise their audiences.

While the century-old publisher Conde Nast may not be the first name you would think of to be pioneering this work, it has recently ripped up the rule book, and done a "deep dive" into its audience profiles, according to Chris Reynolds, its vice president of marketing and analytics.

He told an audience at the Adobe Summit conference in the US: "Publishers need to focus on who they can bring to the table. We're looking at who our core audience is, and doing a lot of online and offline data to identify who they are."

This involves fragmenting the audience into 10 categories, from 'Motor Maven' (luxury car experts) to 'Lovemark Mums' (mums who buy brand names rather than generic products), based on the behaviour of 450,000 readers from their "preferred user network" who have volunteered information, with the idea of being able to track them across multiple sites, as opposed to targeting just one title. 

The lesson seems to be, when you know who your users are, feel free to really tailor their advertising and web experiences.

But, until then, make small tweaks they will appreciate, and you will have them coming back for more – without realising you are really cyber stalking them.

 

Alex Hayes was a guest of Adobe at the Summit conference in Salt Lake City

This News Analysis was first published in the March 29 issue of B&T Magazine

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

The Diamond Concierge Gives Away $50K Ring In Campaign By McCann Queensland
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

The Diamond Concierge Gives Away $50K Ring In Campaign By McCann Queensland

McCann Queensland’s second instalment of ‘The 5th C’ campaign launched over the weekend for online diamond retailer The Diamond Concierge, which received over 47million views around the world in the first 48 hours of it being released. In this second phase of the campaign, The Diamond Concierge gave away an $85,000 diamond ring, with Gold […]

Group of young hipster friends playing with smartphone with mutual disinterest towards each other - Modern situation of technology interaction in alienated lifestyle - Internet wifi connection
  • Marketing

Study: Gen Zs Eschewing Sex, Booze & Their Driver’s Licence!

A new study has revealed something we all already know – the Gen Zs (those born after 2000) are addicted to social media. However, a more interesting finding of the study is they’re apparently delaying adult behaviours such as drugs, sex, alcohol and getting their driver’s licence. According to the study, by US psychologists Jean Twenge and Heejung Park, young […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Sparro Recruits Key Account Director Following Client Wins
  • Marketing

Sparro Recruits Key Account Director Following Client Wins

Digital marketing agency Sparro has announced the appointment of Hannah Jones (pictured above) as a key account director following a spate of client wins. Jones joins Sparro’s senior team alongside founders Cameron and Morris Bryant, overseeing a portfolio of accounts that includes Webjet, Domino’s Pizza, TAFE NSW, Temple & Webster, F45 Training and Bing Lee. […]

Women’s Health’s Jacqui Mooney On Driving A Women’s Brand In An Evolving Industry
  • Media

Women’s Health’s Jacqui Mooney On Driving A Women’s Brand In An Evolving Industry

In an industry facing change, Jacqui Mooney, editor of Women’s Health believes brands such as hers will continue to be a constant. Please note: this article was contributed by Magazine Networks. The magazine industry may be seeing substantial change but Jacqui Mooney has a goal that remains firm: to create happier, healthier lives for Australian women. […]

Talent Shortage? We’re Calling Bullsh*t!
  • Opinion

Talent Shortage? We’re Calling Bullsh*t!

In this guest post, Mike Hill, CEO and co-founder of Puffling, argues the reason women rarely rise to the top in the advertising industry isn’t from a shortage of suitable candidates… Two of the biggest issues plaguing the global advertising industry are a so-called talent shortage and abysmal gender diversity, particularly at the senior level. Just think… […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Survey: Bibles, Condoms & Turn-downs Top List Of Hotel Guest Gripes
  • Marketing

Survey: Bibles, Condoms & Turn-downs Top List Of Hotel Guest Gripes

A new study by New Zealand hotel chain Rees Hotels has identified the biggest likes and gripes of its paying guests. When it comes to the things hotel guests like the most, free Wi-Fi topped the survey’s list. Next was complimentary breakfast, car parking, a room with a view and daily housekeeping. The items and amenities […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Why Consumer Brands Are Failing Aussie Mums
  • Marketing
  • Opinion
  • Partner Content

Why Consumer Brands Are Failing Aussie Mums

Is your game chainsaws or large marlin wall-hangings? Can't seem to attract the mums? This couldn't come soon enough.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Network Ten Creditors Approve CBS Deal
  • Media

Network Ten Creditors Approve CBS Deal

It seems the fight for Ten between CBS and media moguls Lachlan Murdoch and Bruce Gordon may finally be over.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
MKTG Signs Exclusive Commercial Partnership With PlayersVoice
  • Marketing
  • Media

MKTG Signs Exclusive Commercial Partnership With PlayersVoice

MKTG has announced it has signed an exclusive commercial partnership with newly-launched sports storytelling site PlayersVoice.com.au – an agreement that will see the agency move into a new territory of sports marketing. The partnership between MKTG and PlayersVoice will see the business managing brand partnership opportunities for the new platform; working with clients to deliver […]

Domo Introduces New Data Security Software Solution
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Domo Introduces New Data Security Software Solution

Domo has announced it has introduced new cloud security technology for its Bring Your Own Key (BYOK) software, which includes unique capabilities like rolling generation of data encryption keys and a built-in kill switch. Domo BYOK is the first BYOK enterprise software solution for cloud analytics and business intelligence, and builds on the company’s existing security, compliance and […]

Shopper Media Group Grows Sydney & Melbourne Sales Teams
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Shopper Media Group Grows Sydney & Melbourne Sales Teams

Shopper Media Group (SMG) has continued to grow its Sydney and Melbourne sales teams to keep up with the demand for Smartlite Panels for shopping centres. Ashley Munro joins SMG as group sales manager for Sydney, having previously worked in a similar role at NOVA Entertainment. Laura Mason has been appointed as SMG’s business manager […]

RIO DE JANEIRO, BRAZIL - AUGUST 14:  Usain Bolt of Jamaica competes in the Men's 100 meter semifinal on Day 9 of the Rio 2016 Olympic Games at the Olympic Stadium on August 14, 2016 in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.  (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)
  • Advertising
  • Media

Olympics, Census Prove Tough Hurdles For Media Agencies: SMI

Australia’s media agency market has experienced another tough month in August, according to the latest data by Standard Media Index (SMI). SMI noted the softer demand this time around was primarily due to the Rio Olympics and Census providing abnormal bookings last year, resulting in demand for August 2017 so far being back 12.1 per […]

The Monkeys Takes Over From M&C Saatchi On NRMA’s Creative Account
  • Advertising

The Monkeys Takes Over From M&C Saatchi On NRMA’s Creative Account

Accenture-owned agency The Monkeys has bolstered its client ranks, having been chosen to handle the creative for the NRMA. The Monkeys CEO Paul Green confirmed to B&T that the agency had been appointed to the NRMA account by parent company IAG, which also includes brands CGU and Swann Insurance. M&C Saatchi was the incumbent creative […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
A waitress carries beer mugs in the Hofbraeuhaus tent after the opening of the famous Bavarian
  • Marketing

Study: Why No Or Low Alcohol Beers Are Fast Becoming Drinking’s “New Cool”

New research from global market intelligence agency Mintel reveals that over a quarter of consumers in France (28 per cent) and Germany (27 per cent ) agree that low (under 3.5 per cent) or no alcohol beer tastes just as good as full-strength beer. And while younger consumers may have been the most enthusiastic drinkers in previous generations, […]

Engine Group Encourages Queenslanders To ‘Go Local’ In New TVC For State Govt
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Engine Group Encourages Queenslanders To ‘Go Local’ In New TVC For State Govt

Brisbane creative agency Engine Group has launched an integrated campaign for the Queensland government promoting the benefits of buying locally and supporting local small businesses. The ‘Go Local, Grow Local’ social marketing campaign celebrates small businesses across Queensland and highlights that small businesses are the lifeblood to growth in local communities. Central to the new […]

Sam Weir, Editor - The Advertiser & AdelaideNow 
 Editorial 
 
 Picture: Turner Matt
  • Media

News Corp Appoints New Editor For The Courier-Mail

News Corp Australia has announced the appointment of Sam Weir (pictured above) as editor of Queensland’s The Courier-Mail. Weir is one of Australia’s most accomplished editors, having edited the Perth Sunday Times and for the last four-and-a-half years, The Advertiser in Adelaide. News Corp Australasia executive chairman Michael Miller said: “I am delighted Sam has […]

Is This The Creepiest Ice-Cream Ad Ever?
  • Campaigns

Is This The Creepiest Ice-Cream Ad Ever?

Look, a terrifying ice-cream ad! And by "terrifying" we really mean Tony Abbott in his sluggos kind of "terrifying".

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Creatives, Step Up To The CX Plate!
  • Marketing
  • Opinion

Creatives, Step Up To The CX Plate!

Aussie creatives urged to step up to the CX plate! That's the Adobe boss saying it; like B&T would never say try harder.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
InMobi’s Anne Frisbie On Ad Fraud
  • Advertising

InMobi’s Anne Frisbie On Ad Fraud

B&T sat down for a chinwag with InMobi’s Anne Frisbie who thought only half of our questions were poor & unresearched.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Facebook Provides More Clarity & Control For Brands
  • Advertising
  • Media

Facebook Provides More Clarity & Control For Brands

Facebook has announced it is taking action to provide more clarity and controls for advertisers. The updates include: Third-party verification Facebook is seeking accreditation from the Media Ratings Council and set a timeline of 18 months to audit, review and accredit Facebook measurement across three key areas: first-party served ad impression reporting; third-party viewability partner […]

Ogilvy Duo To lead Miami Ad School’s 2017 Social Media Boot Camp
  • Advertising

Ogilvy Duo To lead Miami Ad School’s 2017 Social Media Boot Camp

Miami Ad School has announced that Ogilvy’s Alex Watts (head of social) and Jennifer Ngai (lead social strategist), will lead its Social Media Boot Camp in the coming spring term. The 10-week boot camp is an intensive program where students work on live briefs to create fully-executed social media campaigns, and will run from Monday […]