Crowdsourcing, the pros and cons

Crowdsourcing, the pros and cons
SHARE
THIS



Crowdsourcing is “on fire” in Australia but use with caution is the advice from technology business consultancy LogicalTech.

Australia has become a “global hub for crowdsourcing” according to Cassidy Poon, national marketing manager for LogicalTech.

“In fact, crowdsourcing Down Under is on fire, with websites consistently punching above their weight and assuming market leadership in multiple crowdsourcing verticals.”

Alec Lynch, the founder and CEO of crowdsourcing platform DeisgnCrowd, says the practice has four key benefits including speed, price, and access to a large number of freelancers as well as reduced risk.

“When a business goes to an agency there is always a risk that they will get something that they don’t like,” Lynch told B&T.

“Whereas with crowdsourcing you can go back to the crowd and ask for more ideas…some crowdsourcing platforms, like ours, provide money back gurantees for clients.”

While there are positives, Poon told B&T it is important to keep in mind the downfalls of the growing crowdsourcing practice.

Those negatives include talent only being paid for the winning ideas, which Poon said undervalues freelancers.

“Does it hurt the designer who can’t get work because companies are using crowdsourcing websites to get their sites and logos made?

“Does it hurt participants of crowd sourced projects? Or does it hurt the companies or businesses that use a crowdsourcing model?

“The short answer is that it hurts everyone.”

Without the traditional client and designer interaction Poon believes a project is “just a jumbled, one-sided affair”.

“While good things can be produced from just the client’s brief, truly great things come from reciprocal relationships between a client and designer.”

The ability to tap into a large global pool of talent is a crowdsourcing drawcard, but Poon says there are risks businesses must be aware of.

“[There is] no verification that submissions are non-infringing, as a result costs/burdens associated with clearing infringement risk may be too high.”

Lynch described crowdsourcing as a new and “evolving” practice which will continue to improve.

DesignCrowd offers designers ‘participation payments’ of between $15 and $100 for taking part in projects when their work is not selected by the client.

Lynch also said a project’s budget is fixed.

“It’s not a bidding or undercutting process. We say to clients, tell us how much you can pay and we will find the best design the world has to pay for that budget. We encourage competition on creativity not cost.”

Crowdsourcing sites are also used by freelancers as business development tools for finding new clients to work with on an on-going basis, according to Lynch.

The platforms are also gaining popularity in developing economies where the fees paid for winning work and participation go a lot further than in developed.

Poon agreed that crowdsourcing could be of benefit to low-income workers in developing countries as the only criteria for employment is the ability to complete the task at hand.

“In addition, the working hours are completely flexible, allowing workers to earn money whenever they have extra time,” he said.

But he said as they are unlikely to have a computer at home they need to establish an alternative way to perform the work online.

Some crowdworking platforms have taken these issues to heart already Poon said.

“Many are starting to set minimum wages for its workers tied to the cost of living in the country they are working in.

“Each worker is assigned to a manager who watches their work and pushes suitable tasks their way, and there are opportunities to ascend the corporate ladder.”

Have you ever used a crowdsourcing platform, either as a freelancer or a client? Or do you simply have a point of view to share? Let us know by leaving a comment below. 

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Tourism Campaign: Self-Confessed “Boring” Nebraska Declares “It’s Not For Everyone”
  • Campaigns

Tourism Campaign: Self-Confessed “Boring” Nebraska Declares “It’s Not For Everyone”

How do you attract tourists when, let’s be honest, your home state’s just a bit boring? That was the dilemma facing US midwestern town Nebraska which, due to a lack of things to do, was facing a visitor shortage and had been voted the “least likely state” tourists planned on visiting. Hence, its new tourist catchphrase, “Honestly, […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
APN Outdoor Boss James Warburton To Exit
  • Media

APN Outdoor Boss James Warburton To Exit

After less than a year in the role, APN Outdoor CEO James Warburton will leave the business following the completion of its acquisition by JCDecaux. The Federal Court of Australia was the latest regulator to give the JCDecaux-APN Outdoor deal the green light, announcing its approval to APN shareholders yesterday. Warburton joined APN Outdoor in […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Six Tips To Getting Your Opinion Heard In Meetings
  • Opinion

Six Tips To Getting Your Opinion Heard In Meetings

Michelle Sales (pictured below) is a leadership speaker, coach and trainer and author of The Power of Real Confidence. In this book extract below, Sales offers her tips to make sure your voice gets heard at any meeting… It was Eleanor Roosevelt who once said, ‘You gain strength, courage and confidence by every experience in which […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
How To Foster A Culture Of Creativity
  • Opinion

How To Foster A Culture Of Creativity

Emma Bannister (pictured below) is the CEO of Presentation Studio and author of the book Visual Thinking: How to transform the way you think, communicate and influence with presentations. In this guest post, Bannister offers her top tips to get the creative juices flowing… Many of us wrongly assume that to be creative, means to […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Buxton Real Estate Appoints JPD As Strategic, Creative & Digital Agency
  • Advertising
  • Marketing

Buxton Real Estate Appoints JPD As Strategic, Creative & Digital Agency

Melbourne real estate group Buxton has appointed independent agency James Phillip Design (JDP) to handle strategic, creative and digital duties. JDP managing director James Peltekis said the agency was very excited about the appointment. “We’ve been collaborating with Buxton for a while now, working on their overall brand strategy and refreshing their brand. We’re delighted […]

Federal Court Finds APN Outdoor/JCDecaux Acquisition “Legally Effective”
  • Media

Federal Court Finds APN Outdoor/JCDecaux Acquisition “Legally Effective”

The Federal Court of Australia has given JCDecaux’s acquisition of APN Outdoor the green light. According to a release from APN Outdoor, the Federal Court of Australia has “approved the scheme of arrangement in relation to the JCDecaux transaction”. It adds: “APN Outdoor confirms that an office copy of the Court orders has been lodged with […]

Amazon Launches Prime Music Down Under
  • Media

Amazon Launches Prime Music Down Under

Amazon Australia has announced the launch of Prime Music, bringing a catalogue of more than two million songs and hundreds of hand-curated playlists and stations, ad-free and on-demand with unlimited skips, to Prime members. With music listening powered by Alexa, Prime Members can also experience music streaming through the ease of using voice to find […]

WPP Scores Panadol’s Global Media Business
  • Advertising
  • Media

WPP Scores Panadol’s Global Media Business

GSK Consumer Healthcare has appointed WPP to support its global Panadol business, following a competitive pitch process. WPP will be responsible for creating integrated creative campaigns and content across advertising, digital, shopper and expert marketing, PR and communications for the global Panadol brand. The work will be delivered by a bespoke team led by CEO […]

Michelle Guthrie (Managing Director, ABC) at Radio Alive 2017
  • Media

Michelle Guthrie To Sue ABC

Former ABC managing director Michelle Guthrie is taking her ex-employer to court, according to several media sources. As reported in The Australian, Guthrie lodged papers with the Fair Work Commission earlier this week, citing unfair dismissal. Guthrie was fired half-way through her five-year term as managing director of the public broadcaster. The move follows news last week communications […]