Blaggers Guide to mobile payment

Blaggers Guide to mobile payment
SHARE
THIS


What best describes you?

Few technologies are as hotly contested right now as mobile payments. Financial institutions, telcos, retailers and even Google are all attempting to crack the market. Yet for now the technology is immature and adoption remains low. So who will win the race? And what will be the winning platform? Open or closed? While it’s far too early to call a winner, the platform discussion always attracts strong perspectives.

Why the future of mobile payments is open: ‘Scale for retailers AND consumers’.

By James Duthie

Here we go again: different technology, same debate… open vs closed. Of course, we’ve been here before, many times. Perhaps most famously between Mac and PC. Indeed, proponents of the closed approach will point towards Apple as the benchmark in closed technology success.

Yet when we cast our eyes past Apple, we see recent victories skew towards the open camp. Content management systems were once built upon proprietary technology, yet platforms such as WordPress, Magento and Umbraco are now prevalent (if not dominant). Firefox initially challenged Internet Explorer in the browser market with an open source product, only to be surpassed by Chrome (another open product). And despite Apple’s huge success, Android has won the market share battle.

Indeed, Apple’s own success in the mobile market was arguably driven by opening the development platform for iPhone. It was the App Store that truly unlocked the enhanced utility of the handset.

In each case, victory for the open platform has been driven by one key factor – scale. Scale of development resources (an open source development community) enabled each platform to rapidly scale functionality, and subsequent value, for end users.

At this early stage in its lifecycle, scale is precisely what the mobile payment industry is lacking. Simply put, there are too many solutions. From Kaching to Google Wallet to Visa (among others), market fragmentation is preventing mainstream adoption at both retailer and consumer level. And without scale at a retailer level, value for consumers is severely inhibited. Mobile payments can only succeed when they are as universal as cash and credit (at a minimum). Consumers won’t adopt payment method that is less convenient.

For their part, retailers have recognised the issue of scale. In particular, a band of mega American retailers recently formed MCX, an alliance that aims to pool resources to develop a retailer-friendly mobile payment solution. Yet unless retailers can move beyond traditional competitive rivalries, MCX is simply another fragmented solution in the market. Having invested funds into the MCX platform, will a company like Lowes allow Home Depot in to the party? Unlikely. And if they don’t, MCX isn’t the best solution for consumers.

Consumers crave simplicity. We have four main banks. We use Amex, Visa or Mastercard. And when mobile payments take off, we’ll want a handful of choices at most. Expecting consumers to use different solutions/applications for different retailers creates consumer inefficiency. It’s harder than cash or credit. It doesn’t scale. And to be honest, retailers have bigger problems to solve in reinventing retail, rather than attempting to reinvent the payment industry.

It is the solution that meets consumer needs AND retailer needs than will ultimately win the mobile payments battle. For now, retailers and financial institutes are primarily looking to protect their territory with closed solutions. Which is why solutions are fragmented and adoption remains low.

Universal accessibility is the key. And an open solution is most likely to achieve that. Which is why the winning solution will be open.

Why the future of mobile payments is closed: ‘Cutting out the middleman’.

By Athan Didaskalou

We use our mobile phones for just about everything – search, entertainment, shopping  and more.  However, the state of mobile payments across the globe can be described as a schmozzle. Why you may ask?

Simply, it’s due to a mix of legacy systems, regulations, and slow hardware uptake that has led to niche but fragmented solutions, none of which has reached mass adoption.

Mass adoption is arguably the biggest problem, and I believe that out of five possible groups that have the potential to successfully drive mobile payment uptake (banks and credit card companies; telcos; governments; technology companies like Apple and Google; and merchants), only one can do it best.

Merchants

Without boring you with an analysis of how each body can contribute to mass adoption of mobile payments from customers to merchants, I believe it boils down to one simple thing: a transaction only requires a customer and a merchant. No banks, no credit card companies, no carriers, no regulators, no start-ups: no middlemen. Just merchants.

Mobile payments are the next step for customers and merchants to create a cashless society via technology. And if there’s one thing technology has done well in the last 20 years, it’s cut out the middleman.

We’re living in a world turning to simplification and reductionism because technology and software have allowed us to alleviate reliance on additional parties and do the things we never knew how to, autonomously. Large merchants see the opportunity in taking ownership of their customers and forgoing the third-party reliance of yesteryear. 

Welcome to the era of closed-loop payments where merchants are simplifying the purchase user experience by offering their own system every time you transact with them, all without involving third-party financial institution intermediaries – the ultimate user experience.

The best part? You can leave the DeLorean in the garage, the future is already upon us. US-based MCX is a mobile payments platform team-up of some of the biggest retailers in the world who are developing a closed-loop merchant system because they realised that the only way to beat the middlemen is to band together in a closed platform. Your Apple ID for all those apps you download? Yep, closed loop. The convenience you get from Amazon 1-click purchases? Correct, that’s closed too. Ever buy a coffee from Starbucks with a gift card? Think of that. But on your phone. It’s closed, and it’s making them millions.

So why are these forward-thinking U.S. merchants throwing time and money into cutting out the middlemen and taking ownership of the payments process? They are the first of many because of the shift in retail forces. As Porter would tell you, business and people work in moving forces, and there are three main forces contributing to the shift towards closed-loop systems in mobile payment ownership from retailers:

1. Internal forces to minimise costs. There’s strong motivation by merchants to find lower-cost incentives to process payments, and anything that makes the margin fatter in a global retail market is a plus.

2. Competitive forces for information. The world runs on the value of data. A closed loop system means merchants have single ownership of customer data and experience; no dilution with third party entities.

3. Social forces for incentives. In exchange for loyalty, people want incentives from their merchants. A closed loop system ensures control and focus, with larger margins contributing to better rewards and subsidies.

These three forces are contributing to the push for merchants to stop relying on third parties and start laying the foundations of owning the entire experience.

The most innovative companies have already shifted to cut out the middlemen. The future of mobile payments is one of closed-loop systems because it’s the only system that benefits the two parties that matter the most: merchants and customers. Closed loop systems: customer experience focused, bottom line driven.

In summing up, closed loop platforms have the necessary incentive of driving better financial returns; whilst open source means that merchants can focus on what they do best: retailing.  

James Duthie is a senior strategist at DT and Athan Didaskalou is a strategist at DT.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Vomit, Gnomes & Sex! We’ve Found The Most Nuts Christmas Ad Of The Season!
  • Campaigns

Vomit, Gnomes & Sex! We’ve Found The Most Nuts Christmas Ad Of The Season!

We run a lot of Christmas ads on B&T at this time of a year. Firstly, there’s a lot of them about and, unsurprisingly, they’re often some of the best creatives we get to see all year. Typically, most go with a similar theme – families gathering for Christmas lunch, a blanket of snow outside and a slightly […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Marc Edward Agency Launches Communications Division, Names Founding Client
  • Marketing

Marc Edward Agency Launches Communications Division, Names Founding Client

Experiential marketing outfit Marc Edward Agency (MEA) has broadened its service offering with the launch of a communications division to service founding client YesTelco Australia.  MEA managing director Nigel Hickey (pictured above) said clients have increasingly looked to the agency to provide integrated creative solutions over the last 12 months.  “The team have achieved great success in developing strategic campaigns for clients which […]

Advertising Standards Bureau Unveils Its 10 Most Complained About Ads For 2017
  • Advertising

Advertising Standards Bureau Unveils Its 10 Most Complained About Ads For 2017

Community concern about wagering advertising as well as sex and language are highlighted in the Advertising Standards Bureau’s (ASB’s) list of most complained about advertisements for 2017. “This year the ASB has met the challenge of a record number of complaints being processed in a single year, with over 6,000 complaints about advertisements lodged in […]

Indy Ad Agency Ugly Wins Uno Home Loans Account
  • Advertising

Indy Ad Agency Ugly Wins Uno Home Loans Account

Ideas-based independent advertising agency Ugly has announced it has been appointed as the agency of record for online mortgage broker uno Home Loans, following a four-way pitch.  Ugly will lead all of uno’s brand advertising work, while incumbent agency Archibald Williams will remain working with uno on content creation.  Kirsty Davison, chief marketing and strategy officer at uno, said: “We were impressed with Ugly’s approach of using creativity […]

The Seven Trends That Will Shape Consumer Marketing In 2018
  • Opinion

The Seven Trends That Will Shape Consumer Marketing In 2018

In this festive guest piece, the co-founder and managing director of Seven Communications, Patrice Pandeleos (pictured below), shares her top consumer marketing trends for 2018… Customer experience will form the heart of consumer planning Brands and agencies will rush to find new ways to put their customer experience at the heart of what they do. Using […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Cummins&Partners Creates ‘The Most Interesting Job Interview’ For The Australian Secret Intelligence Service
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Cummins&Partners Creates ‘The Most Interesting Job Interview’ For The Australian Secret Intelligence Service

The Australian Secret Intelligence Service (ASIS) has launched a recruitment campaign aimed at attracting the nation’s next generation of intelligence officers via Cummins&Partners.  Featuring a series of mind-bending audio and visual challenges, ‘The Most Interesting Job Interview’ is an interactive interview that gives ordinary Aussies the chance to step into the shoes of an aspiring ASIS Intelligence Officer.  The federal government’s Minister […]

Bastion Reputation Management Appoints First-Ever Principal
  • Marketing
  • Media

Bastion Reputation Management Appoints First-Ever Principal

Issues management and strategic communications company Bastion Reputation Management has announced the appointment of Scott Thompson to the newly created role of principal.  Thompson will take on a lead role at Bastion Reputation Management, working with companies looking for proactive strategies to build trust and form stronger relationships with customers and the wider community.  He joins Bastion Reputation […]

AKQA & Monash Uni Bring To Life 3D-Printed Chrissy Decorations To Help Fund A Cure For Muscular Dystrophy
  • Campaigns
  • Marketing

AKQA & Monash Uni Bring To Life 3D-Printed Chrissy Decorations To Help Fund A Cure For Muscular Dystrophy

For the second year in a row, WPP-owned ideas and innovation agency AKQA has partnered with Monash University and Muscular Dystrophy Australia (MDA) to bring to life the imaginative Christmas ornaments of kids with muscular dystrophy. For most kids, making Christmas decorations is a simple, fun activity that’s taken for granted. Thousands of Aussie kids are affected by muscular dystrophy, and these simple […]

Four Questions About Connected TVs Everyone Is Asking – Answered
  • Opinion

Four Questions About Connected TVs Everyone Is Asking – Answered

In this guest post, the ANZ country manager for martceh firm dataxu, Matthew Joyce (pictured below), says almost half of Australians have a connected TV and he takes a look at what that means for brands and advertisers… Four in 10 of us have smart TVs at home, and of that, 70 per per cent are Connected TVs (CTV). […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
TV Production Firm Crocmedia Hires Nine’s Tim Cleary For New Venture
  • Media

TV Production Firm Crocmedia Hires Nine’s Tim Cleary For New Venture

Crocmedia has announced the launch of Rainmaker, a dedicated TV production services business to be headed by former Head of Programming and Production at Channel Nine, Tim Cleary. Cleary will draw on his 25 years in the industry to spearhead the creation of bespoke new shows for distribution both in Australia and overseas under the Rainmaker […]

The Advertising ID Consortium Welcomes New Platform Partners
  • Advertising

The Advertising ID Consortium Welcomes New Platform Partners

The Advertising ID Consortium – the open identity solution for the digital advertising ecosystem – has announced new platform partners. Since the Consortium’s announcement in May 2017, the founding members have established a governance framework and product specification that includes an open and standardised cookie and accessible people-based identifiers, delivered in a secure, privacy conscious […]

Marketing Melodies Partners With Spotify-Backed Soundtrack Your Brand
  • Marketing

Marketing Melodies Partners With Spotify-Backed Soundtrack Your Brand

Australian in-store music provider Marketing Melodies has announced an exclusive reseller agreement with Spotify-backed Soundtrack Your Brand for the Australia and New Zealand markets. Founded in Sweden in 2013, Soundtrack Your Brand was developed to kill bad background music. Its flagship solution, Soundtrack Business, is a music streaming platform licensed for commercial and public spaces. The […]

Social Garden Becomes First Bronze Snapchat Certified Partner In Australia
  • Advertising
  • Marketing

Social Garden Becomes First Bronze Snapchat Certified Partner In Australia

Customer acquisition firm Social Garden has become the first business in Australia to achieve Bronze status on Snapchat. Among the new benefits Social Garden will receive as a result of its Bronze status is access to beta versions of Snapchat data tools, such as the Snapchat Conversion Pixel, as well as being among the first […]

Hypetap Appoints Nuffnang’s Chris Morfis As GM
  • Marketing

Hypetap Appoints Nuffnang’s Chris Morfis As GM

Influencer marketing player Hypetap has made its second senior hire in less than a month, appointing Chris Morfis as the company’s general manager. Joining from influencer marketing provider Nuffnang Australia, Morfis will guide Hypetap’s growing team, providing strategic direction to accelerate the company’s growth, as well as leading operations and managing relationships with key partners. Morfis’ appointment will […]

On Air sign in a studio broadcasting via radio, podcast or wireless transmission.
  • Media

ARN Announces Departure Of Content Director & Radio Veteran

Australian Radio Network (ARN) has announced that Charlie Fox, content Director for WSFM and The Edge, and WSFM morning announcer Ron E Sparks, have departed. Fox has been with ARN since 2005, and Sparks joined WSFM in 2002. ARN national content director Duncan Campbell said the departure of Fox and Sparks are part of the […]

OMD Announces New MD For Melbourne
  • Media

OMD Announces New MD For Melbourne

OMD unveils new Melbourne MD, and it certainly wasn't among any of B&T's picks. Not that we were picking, mind you.

Sydney Festival Chooses Brightcove To Enhance Online Video Content
  • Media

Sydney Festival Chooses Brightcove To Enhance Online Video Content

Video cloud service Brightcove has announced that Sydney Festival has selected the platform to improve its user experience through online video content. Brightcove will do so by removing third-party branding and pre-roll ads, as well as adding autoplay functionality, ahead of the event in January. Leveraging the Brightcove video platform to host and publish video […]

Does Your Christmas Marketing Suck?
  • Opinion

Does Your Christmas Marketing Suck?

Remember the old Palmolive soap ad that asked, "Don't wait to be told"? This is sort of similar, albeit sans any suds.

Opinion

by Peter Harris

Peter Harris
Queensland Anti-Porn Crusaders Cop Ad Ban
  • Campaigns

Queensland Anti-Porn Crusaders Cop Ad Ban

We have a strident anti-pornography policy at B&T. Earphones must be worn at all times and strictly no little people.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine